ACC 250 Topic 6 useful life comparison memo example

Financial Accounting Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This ACC 250 Topic 6 sample paper is a useful life comparison memo that sets two equipment makers' property notes side by side before comparing their earnings. It belongs to GCU ACC 250, Financial Accounting, the course listed as ACC-250 in the Grand Canyon University BS in Accounting. Both use straight-line depreciation, but one implies a 10-year average life and the other 7, and accumulated depreciation runs at 40 and 60 percent of cost. A stated-assumption exhibit recomputes the first company on seven years, adding about $1.03 million of expense and cutting its operating margin from 10.0 to 8.5 percent, which explains a little over half the gap. The memo says what can and cannot be concluded.

CourseACC 250 Financial Accounting
TopicTopic 6
Paper typeUseful life comparison memo
LengthAbout 760 words, 1 pages
FormatMemo with APA 7 references
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramBS in Accounting
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for ACC 250 Topic 6

1

Memorandum

To: Dana Whitfield, investor

From: [Author Name]

Date: [Date]

Re: How much of Tessera's higher operating margin comes from its depreciation policy

 

Your Question

You are comparing Tessera Instruments with its closest competitor, Brightline Analytical, and noticed that Tessera's operating margin is 10.0% against Brightline's 8.0%. Before crediting Tessera's management with the difference, it is worth reading both companies' property and equipment notes, because depreciation is an estimate, and two companies can depreciate similar machines over quite different lives. Both companies and all figures here are illustrative composites, in thousands of dollars.

What the Two Notes Disclose

Both companies use the straight-line method, which spreads an asset's cost evenly over its estimated useful life. Their disclosed lives for production and test equipment differ: Tessera uses 5 to 12 years, Brightline 3 to 8. Table 1 sets the equipment figures side by side.

Table 1

Equipment Disclosures, 2025

Equipment class, 2025, $ thousandsTessera InstrumentsBrightline Analytical
Depreciation methodStraight-lineStraight-line
Useful lives disclosed5 to 12 years3 to 8 years
Gross cost24,00026,000
Accumulated depreciation9,60015,600
Accumulated depreciation as a share of cost40%60%
Depreciation expense2,4003,700
Implied average life, cost divided by expense10.0 years7.0 years
Revenue70,00064,000
Operating income7,0005,100
Operating margin10.0%8.0%

Reading the Difference

Dividing gross cost by annual depreciation gives a rough implied average life: about 10 years for Tessera and 7 for Brightline. A longer life spreads the same cost over more years, so each year's expense is smaller and reported income is larger. Nothing in either note is improper. Useful life is an estimate management must make, and the standards allow a range; a company whose equipment is heavily maintained and lightly used may justify a longer life than one running machines around the clock (Kieso et al., 2019).

Accumulated depreciation as a share of cost gives a second, rough signal: about 40% for Tessera and 60% for Brightline. That could mean Tessera's equipment is newer, or that it is being depreciated more slowly. The two explanations cannot be separated from the notes alone.

Restating Tessera on Brightline's Life

To see how much of the margin gap the policy explains, Table 2 recomputes Tessera's equipment depreciation using Brightline's implied seven-year life. The assumptions are stated because the result depends on them: straight-line depreciation, no salvage value, the full cost as the depreciable base and an average life applied to the whole class. The result is an approximation, not a restatement Tessera would make.

Table 2

Tessera's Depreciation Recomputed on a Seven-Year Life

Restatement of Tessera, $ thousandsAmount
Equipment cost24,000
Assumed average life, Brightline's implied figure7 years
Restated depreciation, 24,000 รท 73,429
Reported depreciation2,400
Additional expense1,029
Reported operating income7,000
Restated operating income5,971
Restated operating margin8.5%

What the Restatement Shows

On a seven-year life, Tessera's depreciation would rise by about $1.03 million and its operating income would fall to about $5.97 million, a margin of about 8.5%. The reported gap in operating income between the two companies is $1.9 million; the difference in depreciation policy explains roughly $1.03 million of it, a little more than half. Measured by margin, Tessera's two-point lead shrinks to about half a point.

The remaining half point may reflect genuinely better operations at Tessera, differences in the two companies' product mix, or other policy differences this memo has not examined, such as how each capitalizes software or records warranty costs. The point is not that Tessera's figures are wrong. It is that comparing the two companies' operating income as though their depreciation assumptions were the same would credit Tessera's management with a difference that mostly comes from an estimate.

What You Can and Cannot Conclude

You can conclude that, on comparable depreciation assumptions, the two companies' operating margins are much closer than reported. You cannot conclude which life is right. That depends on how the equipment is actually used and when it will be replaced, facts that sit outside the statements. Researchers have studied why firms choose and change depreciation policies, including tax, earnings and investment considerations (Keating & Zimmerman, 1999), which is a reason to read these notes rather than assume the policies are neutral.

Two follow-up questions would help. Has either company changed its useful lives in recent years? A change is disclosed in the notes in the year it happens. And what do their capital spending plans imply about replacement: if Tessera plans to replace equipment well before ten years, its lives may be optimistic. The investor relations teams, the management discussion sections and the capital spending lines in the cash flow statements are the places to look (Franklin et al., 2019).

References

Franklin, M., Graybeal, P., & Cooper, D. (2019). Principles of accounting, volume 1: Financial accounting. OpenStax. https://openstax.org/details/books/principles-financial-accounting

Keating, A. S., & Zimmerman, J. L. (1999). Depreciation-policy changes: Tax, earnings management, and investment opportunity incentives. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 28(3), 359-389. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0165-4101(00)00004-5

Kieso, D. E., Weygandt, J. J., & Warfield, T. D. (2019). Intermediate accounting (17th ed.). Wiley.

Reading the GCU ACC 250 Topic 6 instructions

The Topic 6 instructions in ACC-250 ask students to compare how two companies account for long-lived assets. Weak submissions describe depreciation methods in general. The assignment rewards memos that read both companies' property notes, compare methods, useful lives and accumulated depreciation, and estimate how much of a difference in reported income the policy explains. Students should recompute one company's depreciation under the other's assumptions in a small exhibit with every assumption stated, label the result as an approximation, avoid treating a longer life as evidence of wrongdoing and say what information outside the statements would settle the question.

How the ACC-250 Topic 6 example is put together

The finished memo sets two property and equipment notes next to each other and reads what each discloses: the depreciation method, the range of useful lives, and the gross cost and accumulated depreciation by asset class. With illustrative figures, it shows that one company depreciates comparable equipment over a noticeably longer life, which lowers its annual expense and raises its reported income. It then recomputes that company's depreciation on the shorter life, in a small exhibit that states every assumption, and shows how much of the difference in operating income the policy explains. It also compares accumulated depreciation to gross cost for both, as a rough indicator of asset age. The memo ends by stating what the investor can conclude, and what would require information outside the statements, such as actual replacement plans.

Reading the ACC 250 Topic 6 rubric

Faculty grading the useful life memo reward reading the notes before ranking earnings. Excellent memos compute implied average lives and accumulated depreciation ratios for both companies. Credit goes to a restatement with stated assumptions that shows how much of the margin gap comes from the estimate. The rubric values recognizing that a longer life may be justified by how assets are used. The highest level lists follow-up questions, such as past changes in lives and replacement plans. Memos that present a restated figure as exact, or rank companies on reported operating income alone, usually lose marks.

Common ACC 250 Topic 6 mistakes, and how to avoid them

The loss that recurs on this topic is comparing two companies' earnings as though their depreciation assumptions were the same. A memo ranking companies on operating income, without reading either property note, has attributed a policy difference to management. Restatements with no stated assumptions cannot be checked and are marked as assertion. Treating a longer useful life as evidence of manipulation overstates what the disclosure shows, since the life may be justified by how the assets are actually used. Papers that describe straight-line and accelerated methods in general terms, with no company figures, repeat the introductory course rather than reading as an outside investor would. Many rubrics also look for the approximation to be labeled as one, and a restated figure presented as exact loses credit for precision it cannot have.

Get an ACC-250 Topic 6 example written to your instructions

Send the ACC-250 Topic 6 instructions, your rubric and the companies or asset data you were assigned. We write a custom example to them, with both property notes summarized, the useful life difference given a direction, one company's expense restated with assumptions shown and the limits of the comparison stated, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one costs nothing.

More ACC 250 papers and BS in Accounting samples

ACC 250 Topic 6 questions, answered

Why does useful life matter to an investor?

Because it sets how quickly the cost of an asset reaches the income statement. Spreading the same cost over more years lowers each year's expense and raises reported income, without any change in how the business operates. Two companies with identical equipment and different assumed lives will report different profits, and an investor comparing them needs to know how much of the gap that explains.

Can an outside reader tell whether a useful life is reasonable?

Only roughly. The note gives a range of lives by asset class, and a reader can compare it with peers and with how long the company's assets appear to last, using accumulated depreciation relative to cost. Frequent gains or losses on disposal can also suggest the lives are off. Anything firmer requires engineering or replacement information the statements do not carry.

Where does impairment fit in?

It is the separate adjustment made when an asset's carrying amount can no longer be recovered, recorded as a loss rather than through ordinary depreciation. For an outside reader, an impairment often signals that earlier depreciation assumptions were optimistic or that the asset's use has changed. The memo mentions impairment where a company reports one, because it can make a restated comparison of depreciation misleading.

Where can I find a free ACC 250 Topic 6 sample paper?

Everything is above: the question, what the two notes disclose, reading the difference, the seven-year restatement, what it shows and what can and cannot be concluded. Share the two companies for a free worked memo.

How much of the margin gap is policy in ACC 250 Topic 6?

About $1.03 million of the $1.9 million operating income gap, a little more than half, comes from the longer useful life; the margin lead shrinks from two points to about half a point.