| Course | ACC 260 Management Accounting |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 7 |
| Paper type | Make-or-buy decision analysis |
| Length | About 980 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 260 Topic 7
The $18 Bracket Really Costs $15 to Make: Correcting a Make-or-Buy Comparison at Canyon Ridge Trailer Works
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
ACC-260: Management Accounting
Topic 7 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
The $18 Bracket Really Costs $15 to Make: Correcting a Make-or-Buy Comparison at Canyon Ridge Trailer Works
The Obvious Comparison
Canyon Ridge Trailer Works, a composite trailer manufacturer, makes its own mounting brackets, about 10,000 a year. The cost system reports that a bracket costs $18 to make. A metal fabricator has offered to supply the same bracket for $16. The purchasing manager's first reading is simple: buying saves $2 a bracket, or $20,000 a year. This analysis breaks the $18 into its parts, separates the costs that would disappear if production stopped from those that would continue, and finds that the obvious comparison points the wrong way. All figures are illustrative.
What the $18 Contains
Table 1 lists each part of the reported cost and whether it would be avoided if Canyon Ridge stopped making the bracket.
Table 1
Reported and Relevant Cost to Make
| Cost per bracket, reported | Amount | Avoidable if production stops? |
|---|---|---|
| Direct materials: steel plate, bolts, powder coat | $8 | Yes |
| Direct labor | 4 | Yes |
| Variable overhead: power, consumables | 2 | Yes |
| Allocated fixed overhead: line supervisor's salary, $10,000 a year | 1 | Yes: the position would be eliminated |
| Allocated fixed overhead: plant rent, depreciation, plant manager | 3 | No: these continue |
| Reported cost to make | $18 | |
| Relevant cost to make | $15 |
Which Costs Disappear
Materials, labor and variable overhead, $14 in total, would all stop if production stopped. The $4 of allocated fixed overhead needs closer reading. The cost system spreads fixed factory costs over every product line, and the bracket's $4 share has two parts. One dollar is the salary of the supervisor who runs the bracket line, $10,000 a year; if production stops, the position is eliminated, so that cost is avoidable. The other $3 is the bracket line's share of plant rent, equipment depreciation and the plant manager's salary. Those costs continue whether or not brackets are made; they would simply be reallocated to the other product lines.
A cost is relevant to a decision only if it differs between the alternatives (Garrison et al., 2021). The relevant cost of making a bracket is therefore $15: $14 of variable cost and $1 of avoidable fixed cost.
Why the System Reported $18
The cost system is not wrong. It is built to value inventory and to set list prices, and for those purposes every product must carry a share of the plant's fixed costs. Canyon Ridge spreads fixed overhead by machine hours, and the bracket line uses about 8% of the plant's machine hours, so it carries 8% of the rent, depreciation and plant management. That share is a reasonable way to divide costs that all products use together. It is not a measure of what would be saved if one product were dropped, because shared costs do not shrink when one user leaves. The same $18 figure is therefore right for the balance sheet and wrong for this decision.
The Corrected Comparison
Table 2 compares the two options on relevant costs at current volume.
Table 2
Relevant Annual Cost of Making and Buying
| Annual comparison at 10,000 brackets | Make | Buy |
|---|---|---|
| Variable cost, $14 a bracket | $140,000 | |
| Supervisor's salary | 10,000 | |
| Purchase price, $16 a bracket | $160,000 | |
| Total relevant cost | $150,000 | $160,000 |
| Difference | Buying costs $10,000 more |
Reading the Result
At 10,000 brackets a year, buying would cost Canyon Ridge $10,000 more than making, not save $20,000. The $30,000 swing comes entirely from the $3 of unavoidable fixed overhead per bracket, $30,000 a year, which the reported cost counted as though it would disappear. If the company bought the brackets, that $30,000 would still be paid, now charged to other products, and total company profit would fall by $10,000.
Volume Decides the Answer
The supervisor's salary is fixed in total, so its cost per bracket falls as volume rises. Making costs $14 a bracket plus $10,000 a year; buying costs $16 a bracket. The two are equal where $2 a bracket times the volume equals $10,000, at 5,000 brackets a year. Below that, buying is cheaper; above it, making is. Table 3 shows the comparison at four volumes.
Table 3
Make or Buy at Different Volumes
| Annual volume | Make: $14 a bracket plus $10,000 | Buy: $16 a bracket | Cheaper |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3,000 | $52,000 | $48,000 | Buy |
| 5,000 | $80,000 | $80,000 | Indifferent |
| 10,000 | $150,000 | $160,000 | Make |
| 14,000 | $206,000 | $224,000 | Make |
Factors Outside the Numbers
Three considerations could change the answer even at 10,000 brackets. First, capacity: if the space and equipment freed by buying could produce something more profitable, the lost profit from that alternative is an opportunity cost of making, and it would join the analysis. Canyon Ridge's plant is not currently short of capacity, so no such cost applies now. Second, quality and delivery: a bracket failure on a customer's trailer is a safety issue, and the fabricator's record should be checked before any change. Third, the supplier's price may not hold; a low introductory price followed by increases after Canyon Ridge has dismantled its own line would leave it with little bargaining power (Datar & Rajan, 2021).
The recommendation is to keep making the brackets at the current volume of about 10,000 a year, and to revisit the decision if volume falls toward 5,000, if the plant needs the space for a more profitable product, or if the supplier offers a price below $15. The broader lesson for Canyon Ridge's managers is that the reported unit cost, useful for inventory valuation, includes allocated costs that do not change with this decision (Franklin et al., 2019).
What to Tell the Purchasing Manager
The purchasing manager's instinct to test the market was sound, and the fabricator's quote is useful. It sets a ceiling on what the bracket line should cost, and it gives Canyon Ridge a benchmark to watch. The corrected comparison should be shared with the reasoning in Table 1, so that the next quote is judged on relevant cost from the start. Keeping the quote on file also means that if the company's volume or plant use changes, the decision can be revisited quickly with a known alternative.
References
Datar, S. M., & Rajan, M. V. (2021). Horngren's cost accounting: A managerial emphasis (17th ed.). Pearson.
Franklin, M., Graybeal, P., & Cooper, D. (2019). Principles of accounting, volume 2: Managerial accounting. OpenStax. https://openstax.org/details/books/principles-managerial-accounting
Garrison, R. H., Noreen, E. W., & Brewer, P. C. (2021). Managerial accounting (17th ed.). McGraw Hill.
The ACC-260 Topic 7 assignment instructions
ACC-260 Topic 7 asks students to analyze a make-or-buy decision using relevant costs. Many submissions compare the reported unit cost with the supplier's price. The assignment rewards analyses that break the reported cost into its parts, identify which fixed costs are avoidable if production stops, and compare relevant costs at current volume. Students should explain why the cost system's figure is right for inventory but wrong for the decision, find the volume at which the answer changes, consider opportunity costs of capacity and qualitative factors, and make a recommendation with the conditions for revisiting it.
Inside the ACC 260 Topic 7 example
The finished analysis puts two numbers side by side and then corrects the obvious one. The accounting system reports that a bracket costs $18 to make, and a supplier offers it at $16, which appears to save $20,000 a year on the illustrative volume of 10,000. The example breaks the $18 down: $8 of materials, $4 of labor, $2 of variable overhead and $4 of allocated fixed overhead. Of that $4, only $1, a line supervisor's salary, disappears if production stops, and the remaining $3 covers plant costs that continue. The relevant cost of making is therefore $15, and buying would cost the company $10,000 a year rather than saving $20,000. The analysis names volume as the driver and states the annual quantity, 5,000 brackets, below which the answer would flip.
Where the marks sit in the ACC 260 Topic 7 rubric
Faculty grading the make-or-buy analysis reward separating avoidable from unavoidable costs. Excellent analyses show which part of allocated overhead disappears and which is merely reallocated. Credit goes to a corrected annual comparison and to an indifference volume computed from the avoidable fixed cost. The rubric values discussing capacity, supplier reliability and future price risk. The highest level explains why the reported cost exists and how to judge the next supplier quote. Analyses that treat all allocated overhead as saved by buying usually land in a middle band.
Common ACC 260 Topic 7 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Comparing the supplier's price with the full reported cost costs the most marks here, because it recommends buying on a saving that is not there. The allocated plant overhead is real money, but it is spent whether the bracket is made or bought, so charging it to the make option inflates that side. A subtler loss comes from removing every fixed cost at once, which throws out the supervisor's salary along with the rent and understates what making really costs. Analyses that compare per-item rates and never multiply by volume cannot find the threshold where the answer changes. Recommendations leading with reliability or quality, before the main comparison is even computed, have argued the soft factors first. Leaving the freed capacity unmentioned, when the scenario offers a use for it, drops an opportunity cost from the decision.
Get an ACC-260 Topic 7 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-260 Topic 7 instructions, your classroom rubric and the quote, volume and cost breakdown in the scenario. We prepare a custom example to those criteria, with avoidable costs separated from allocated ones, totals compared at the stated volume, the threshold solved and the recommendation argued, returned in 24 to 48 hours. We never charge for the first one.
More ACC 260 papers and BS in Accounting samples
- ACC 260 Topic 1: Reporting Audience Comparison
- ACC 260 Topic 2: Cost Behavior Classification
- ACC 260 Topic 3: Contribution Format Restatement
- ACC 260 Topic 4: Break-even Assumptions Memo
- ACC 260 Topic 5: Sunk Cost Discussion Post
- ACC 260 Topic 6: Linked Budget Schedules
- ACC 260 Topic 8: Keep or Drop Recommendation
- ACC 335 Topic 7: Control Weakness Finding
- ACC 250 Topic 7: Creditor Ratio Briefing
- ACC 337 Topic 7: Management Findings Brief
- ACC 240 Topic 7: Statement Assembly Problem
ACC 260 Topic 7 questions, answered
How do I know whether a fixed cost is avoidable?
Ask whether it would stop if the activity stopped. A supervisor who runs only this line, a machine lease that can be canceled or a dedicated inspection contract usually would. Plant rent, the controller's salary and depreciation on shared equipment usually would not. When the scenario is silent, state the assumption you made, because the recommendation can turn on that single sentence.
Does the freed space ever change the answer?
Yes, whenever it has another use. If stopping production lets the company rent the space out or make a more profitable part there, that forgone income is an opportunity cost of continuing to make the bracket and belongs on the make side of the comparison. When the scenario offers no alternative use, say so in one sentence rather than leaving the reader to wonder.
Should qualitative factors ever override the numbers?
They can, and the analysis should say when. A supplier with a history of late deliveries, or a part central to product quality, may justify making in-house at a modest cost premium. The recommendation should still state that premium in dollars, so the manager knows the price of the qualitative preference instead of treating it as free.
Where can I find a free ACC 260 Topic 7 sample paper?
This page holds the complete analysis: the obvious comparison, what the $18 contains, which costs disappear, why the system reported $18, the corrected comparison, volume, other factors and advice for purchasing. Share your make-or-buy case for a free worked analysis.
At what volume does buying win in ACC 260 Topic 7?
Below 5,000 brackets a year. Making costs $14 each plus a $10,000 supervisor, buying costs $16 each, and the two are equal where $2 times volume equals $10,000.