| Course | ACC 260 Management Accounting |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 8 |
| Paper type | Keep or drop recommendation |
| Length | About 760 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 260 Topic 8
Memorandum
To: Pat Delgado, store manager, Mesa Hardware
From: [Author Name]
Date: [Date]
Re: Whether to close the garden department
Recommendation
Keep the garden department. Its report shows a $10,000 loss, but the loss is created by $25,000 of store costs allocated to it that would not go away if it closed. The department itself earns $15,000 a year above the costs it causes, and closing it would lower the store's income by at least that amount. All figures are illustrative.
The Department Rebuilt in Layers
Table 1 rebuilds last year's department report in three layers: contribution margin, segment margin and the allocated costs below it.
Table 1
Garden Department Report in Layers
| Garden department, last year | Amount |
|---|---|
| Sales | $150,000 |
| Variable costs: plants, soil, tools at cost; card fees | 105,000 |
| Contribution margin | 45,000 |
| Traceable fixed costs: seasonal staff $21,000, fixture lease $9,000 | 30,000 |
| Segment margin | 15,000 |
| Allocated common costs: store rent, general advertising, store manager's salary | 25,000 |
| Reported department result | ($10,000) |
What Each Layer Means
Sales of $150,000 less $105,000 of variable costs leave $45,000 of contribution margin. From that, the department pays $30,000 of fixed costs that exist only because it exists: the seasonal staff hired each spring and the lease on the greenhouse shelving and display fixtures. Those would end if the department closed. What remains, $15,000, is the segment margin, the department's contribution to the store's shared costs and profit (Garrison et al., 2021).
The $25,000 below that line is the department's share of store rent, general advertising and your own salary, allocated by floor space. If the garden department closed, the rent would be unchanged, the general advertising would continue and your salary would not fall. The $25,000 would simply be reallocated to hardware, paint and housewares, making their results look worse. Hardware, for example, would absorb about half of it and would report roughly $12,000 less profit next year, although nothing about hardware's own performance had changed. Closing a department because of allocated costs tends to repeat itself, since each closure pushes the shared costs onto the departments that remain.
The Store With and Without the Department
Table 2 shows last year's store income both ways.
Table 2
Store Operating Income With and Without the Garden Department
| Whole store, last year | With garden department | Without garden department |
|---|---|---|
| Segment margin of other departments | $160,000 | $160,000 |
| Segment margin of garden department | 15,000 | 0 |
| Common fixed costs: rent, general advertising, store manager | (110,000) | (110,000) |
| Store operating income | $65,000 | $50,000 |
Reading the Comparison
With the garden department, the store earned $65,000. Without it, the store would have earned $50,000. The $15,000 difference is exactly the department's segment margin, because its segment margin is the part of its results that closing would actually remove. The reported $10,000 loss never appears in the comparison, because the allocated costs that produce it are the same in both columns.
The comparison probably understates the cost of closing. Customers who come in for spring plants often buy hoses, tools and fencing from the hardware aisles. If even $20,000 a year of other departments' sales depends on garden traffic, at their average contribution margin ratio of about a third, closing the garden department would cost roughly another $6,600 a year.
The Objection You Are Likely to Hear
The owner may say that the department has shown a loss on the monthly report for three years running, and that a department that never makes money should go. The answer is that the monthly report measures something different from what closing would change. It charges the department for costs it shares with the whole store. A better report would show segment margin as the department's result and show common costs once, at the store level, so that no department appears to lose money merely because of how rent is divided (Datar & Rajan, 2021).
What Would Change the Advice
Three kinds of evidence would change the recommendation. First, a better use of the space: if the garden area could house a department with a segment margin above $15,000 plus any lost cross-sales, for example an expanded outdoor power equipment line, the comparison would favor switching, and the lost garden margin would be the opportunity cost of that choice. Second, costs that are not really traceable: if the fixture lease runs another three years and cannot be canceled, part of the $30,000 would continue after closing, making the case for keeping the department stronger still. Third, a falling contribution margin: if big-box competition has been pushing plant prices down faster than costs, next year's segment margin may be much smaller than last year's, and the decision should be revisited with a current forecast rather than last year's results (Franklin et al., 2019).
References
Datar, S. M., & Rajan, M. V. (2021). Horngren's cost accounting: A managerial emphasis (17th ed.). Pearson.
Franklin, M., Graybeal, P., & Cooper, D. (2019). Principles of accounting, volume 2: Managerial accounting. OpenStax. https://openstax.org/details/books/principles-managerial-accounting
Garrison, R. H., Noreen, E. W., & Brewer, P. C. (2021). Managerial accounting (17th ed.). McGraw Hill.
The ACC-260 Topic 8 assignment instructions
The Topic 8 instructions in ACC-260 ask students to recommend whether to keep or drop a segment. Weak submissions accept the segment's reported profit or loss. The assignment rewards recommendations that state the answer first, rebuild the segment report into contribution margin, traceable fixed costs, segment margin and allocated common costs, and compare total company income with and without the segment. Students should consider effects on other segments' sales, answer the objection a manager is likely to raise and state what evidence, such as a better use of the space, would change the recommendation.
How the ACC-260 Topic 8 example is put together
The finished recommendation opens with its answer: keep the department. The supporting schedule rebuilds the department's report in three layers using illustrative figures. Sales of $150,000 less $105,000 of variable cost leave $45,000 of contribution margin; subtracting $30,000 of fixed costs that belong only to the department, its seasonal staff and fixture lease, leaves a segment margin of $15,000. The $25,000 of store rent, general advertising and the manager's own salary allocated below that line is what produces the reported loss, and none of it leaves with the department. The memo then shows the store's income with and without the garden department, side by side, so the manager sees the $15,000 difference directly. A closing paragraph takes up the objection the manager is likely to raise and names what evidence would change the advice.
Where the marks sit in the ACC 260 Topic 8 rubric
Faculty grading the keep or drop recommendation reward segment margin as the deciding figure. Excellent recommendations separate traceable fixed costs from allocated common costs and show that the latter remain after closing. Credit goes to a side-by-side comparison of company income in which the difference equals the segment margin. The rubric values estimating lost cross-sales and recommending a better report format. The highest level names specific evidence, such as a higher-margin use of the space, that would reverse the advice. Recommendations based on the reported loss usually lose marks.
ACC 260 Topic 8 help before you submit
Recommending the closure because the department report shows a loss is the classic mistake at this point, and marks disappear with it. The allocated costs producing that loss stay with the store, so the recommendation would lower profit while claiming to raise it. Papers that correctly remove allocated costs but also remove the department's traceable salaries overstate the benefit of keeping it. Showing only the department's figures, never the whole store under both options, leaves the manager to do the final comparison alone. Memos written to an instructor rather than to the manager open with definitions of segment margin and bury the advice in the fourth paragraph. Ignoring what garden customers buy elsewhere in the store understates the cost of closing, and a strong version at least names that effect even without a figure for it.
Get an ACC-260 Topic 8 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-260 Topic 8 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with the segment report or scenario you were given. The custom example is drafted to those criteria, advising the named manager, separating traceable from allocated costs, showing the whole company under both options and answering the likely objection, back to you in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More ACC 260 papers and BS in Accounting samples
- ACC 260 Topic 1: Reporting Audience Comparison
- ACC 260 Topic 2: Cost Behavior Classification
- ACC 260 Topic 3: Contribution Format Restatement
- ACC 260 Topic 4: Break-even Assumptions Memo
- ACC 260 Topic 5: Sunk Cost Discussion Post
- ACC 260 Topic 6: Linked Budget Schedules
- ACC 260 Topic 7: Make-or-buy Decision Analysis
- ACC 335 Topic 8: Compensating Control Plan
- ACC 250 Topic 8: Annual Report Evaluation
- ACC 337 Topic 8: Reproducible Analysis Workpaper
- ACC 240 Topic 8: Accounting Cycle Explainer
ACC 260 Topic 8 questions, answered
What makes a fixed cost traceable to a department?
It exists because the department exists and would end if the department closed. A department supervisor, a lease on equipment only that department uses or advertising that promotes only its products all qualify. Building rent divided by floor space does not, because the building stays. The test is what happens to the cost after the decision, not what the report calls it.
What if the segment margin were negative?
Then dropping the department would raise company profit, at least before other effects are counted, because it would not be covering even its own fixed costs. The memo should still check the complementary sales it supports and whether the freed space has a better use, since either one can reverse a result that looks decisive on the schedule alone.
How formal should the memo be?
As formal as a real manager would expect and no more. A heading, the advice, a compact schedule and a few paragraphs of reasoning usually suit an introductory course, unless the instructions call for APA style or a report format. Write every sentence for the person who will act, and keep the course terminology where it helps that person follow the figures.
Where can I find a free ACC 260 Topic 8 sample paper?
The full memo is above, with the recommendation, the department in layers, what each layer means, the store with and without it, the likely objection and what would change the advice. Tell us your segment for a free worked recommendation.
Why keep a department that reports a loss in ACC 260 Topic 8?
Its $15,000 segment margin covers part of store costs that would remain anyway, so closing it would cut store income from $65,000 to $50,000.