| Course | ACC 335 Accounting Information Systems |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 4 |
| Paper type | Incompatible duties matrix |
| Length | About 970 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 335 Topic 4
Who Takes the Cash, Who Voids the Visit: An Incompatible Duties Matrix for Bright Harbor Family Dental's Front Desk
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
ACC-335: Accounting Information Systems
Topic 4 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Who Takes the Cash, Who Voids the Visit: An Incompatible Duties Matrix for Bright Harbor Family Dental's Front Desk
The Practice and the Question
Bright Harbor Family Dental, a composite practice with two dentists and a staff of nine, handles about 45 patient visits a day. Three people touch patient payments: the office manager, the front desk lead and a part-time bookkeeper who works two days a week. The owner asked whether any one of them could take money and hide it. This matrix answers by listing the payment tasks, tagging each by function and recording who actually performs each task, as observed across one normal Tuesday rather than as the job descriptions say.
Segregation of duties rests on keeping three functions apart: authorizing transactions, recording them and having custody of the assets involved. When one person holds two of those functions, that person can both commit an error or fraud and conceal it in the normal course of work (Romney et al., 2021).
The Matrix
Table 1 lists each task, its function and who performed it on the observed day. Cells marked as conflicts are those where a person's tasks combine custody with recording or authorization.
Table 1
Payment Tasks by Person, Observed
| Task | Function | Office manager | Front desk lead | Part-time bookkeeper |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Take cash and card payments at checkout | Custody | Sometimes | Yes | |
| Enter visit charges in the practice system | Recording | Yes | ||
| Apply discounts, adjustments and voids | Authorization and recording | Yes | Yes, conflict | |
| Prepare the daily deposit | Custody | Yes, conflict | Sometimes, conflict | |
| Post deposits and adjustments to the ledger | Recording | Yes | ||
| Reconcile the bank account | Reconciliation | Yes, conflict |
How the Observed Day Differed From the Job Descriptions
The job descriptions assign voids and adjustments to the office manager alone and the deposit to the office manager alone. On the observed Tuesday, practice differed in two ways. The front desk lead applied three voids and two courtesy discounts without asking the office manager, because the practice system allows the front desk role to do so and the office manager was with a patient. And when the office manager left early, the front desk lead counted the cash drawer and prepared the deposit slip, which the office manager dropped at the bank the next morning without recounting.
Neither departure was concealed; staff described both as normal on busy days. But a matrix built from the job descriptions would have shown no conflict for the front desk lead at all. The conflicts that matter are the ones the system permissions and daily habits allow, which is why the matrix records what people actually did.
The Conflicts Written as Transactions
A shaded cell is only useful if it is translated into what someone could actually do. Table 2 writes out each conflict as the transaction it would allow, ranked by exposure.
Table 2
Conflicts Ranked by Exposure
| Rank | Conflict | Transaction it would allow | Exposure |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Front desk lead takes cash and can void visits | Takes a $180 cash payment, voids the visit so no charge exists, keeps the cash; nothing is left to reconcile | High: cash is common for cleanings, and the void erases the evidence |
| 2 | Office manager applies adjustments and prepares the deposit | Removes cash from the deposit and records an equal courtesy adjustment on a patient account | Moderate: adjustments appear on reports but are rarely reviewed |
| 3 | Bookkeeper posts to the ledger and reconciles the bank | Records a deposit that never reached the bank and forces the reconciliation with a false entry | Lower: the bookkeeper has no custody of cash, so this conceals errors more than it enables theft |
Why the First Conflict Ranks Highest
The front desk lead's conflict ranks first because it combines custody with the power to erase the record. When a patient pays cash for a cleaning, the lead receives the money. If the lead then voids the visit in the practice system, there is no charge on the patient's account, no receivable and no expected deposit. The daily deposit agrees with the day's recorded payments, the bank reconciliation agrees with the ledger, and the patient, who paid and left, has no reason to complain. The theft leaves a gap only between the appointment schedule and the charges, and no one currently compares them.
Frauds of this kind, in which cash is taken before it is recorded, are a recognized category of occupational fraud, and small organizations are especially exposed because they have fewer people to separate duties and fewer anti-fraud controls in place (Association of Certified Fraud Examiners, 2024).
What Cannot Be Separated
The matrix does not pretend every conflict can be removed. With three people and a part-time bookkeeper, full segregation is not possible. Someone at the front desk must accept payments, and the same people must sometimes correct charges when a patient's insurance changes. Segregation of duties problems are common enough that they have appeared among the internal control weaknesses public companies disclose (Ge & McVay, 2005), and in a practice this size they are a condition to manage rather than a defect to eliminate.
The ranking therefore guides where to act first. Conflict 1 can be narrowed directly: remove void permission from the front desk role in the practice system, so that voids require the office manager's login. Conflict 2 is harder to separate and calls for a review control, such as the owner reviewing a weekly report of adjustments and voids. Conflict 3 can be left in place if the owner reviews the bank statement directly each month, since the bookkeeper has no custody of cash.
A Check the Owner Can Run Now
While permissions are changed, one detective check can be run immediately: compare the appointment schedule for each day with the visits charged in the practice system. Every completed appointment should have a charge or a documented reason for none. Run for the past three months, this comparison would show whether conflict 1 has already been used.
References
Association of Certified Fraud Examiners. (2024). Occupational fraud 2024: A report to the nations. https://legacy.acfe.com/report-to-the-nations/2024/
Ge, W., & McVay, S. (2005). The disclosure of material weaknesses in internal control after the Sarbanes-Oxley Act. Accounting Horizons, 19(3), 137-158. https://doi.org/10.2308/acch.2005.19.3.137
Romney, M. B., Steinbart, P. J., Summers, S. L., & Wood, D. A. (2021). Accounting information systems (15th ed.). Pearson.
Reading the GCU ACC 335 Topic 4 instructions
The Topic 4 instructions in ACC-335 ask students to analyze segregation of duties in a small organization. Weak submissions list the three incompatible functions in general terms. The assignment rewards matrices that set people against specific tasks, tag each task by function, record who actually performs it and shade combinations of custody with recording or authorization. Students should write each conflict as the transaction it would allow, note how observed practice differs from job descriptions, rank conflicts by exposure, acknowledge those that cannot be separated in a small staff and propose narrowing or review controls.
Inside the ACC 335 Topic 4 example
The finished matrix is a grid with the office manager, the front desk lead and the part-time bookkeeper down the side and the payment tasks across the top: taking cash and card at checkout, entering charges in the practice system, applying discounts and voids, preparing the deposit, posting to the ledger and reconciling the bank account. Each task is tagged by function, so it is clear which ones are custody and which are recording. Cells show who does each task in practice, observed across a normal day. Conflicts are shaded, and each shaded cell is written out as the transaction it would allow: the desk lead takes a cash payment, voids the visit in the system and keeps the money, leaving no record to reconcile. The matrix does not pretend every conflict can be removed; it ranks them.
ACC 335 Topic 4 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Faculty grading the duties matrix reward conflicts written as transactions. Excellent matrices show how one person could take cash and void the record so nothing remains to reconcile. Credit goes to observing actual practice, including system permissions that allow more than job descriptions say. The rubric values ranking conflicts by exposure and admitting that full separation is impossible with three people. The highest level proposes a permission change for the top conflict and a detective check the owner can run immediately. Matrices built only from job descriptions usually lose marks.
ACC 335 Topic 4 help: mistakes that cost marks
Recommending full segregation to a three-person office is the recommendation markers see most often and credit least, because nobody could staff it. A matrix built from job descriptions reports the separation the clinic intended, not the one it operates, and the void permission usually proves the two differ. Grids that mark conflicts without saying what each one permits leave the reader to imagine the risk. Treating every overlap as equally serious misses the point of ranking: a receptionist who both schedules and confirms appointments is not in the position of one who holds cash and can erase the sale. Papers listing the four functions without applying them to specific tasks have defined segregation rather than tested it. Ending with no plan for the conflicts that remain leaves the office exposed exactly where it was.
Get an ACC-335 Topic 4 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-335 Topic 4 instructions, your classroom rubric and the department or staffing scenario the assignment describes. We return a custom example built to those criteria, with tasks tagged by function, the matrix filled from practice, each conflict written as a transaction and the remaining ones ranked, in 24 to 48 hours. Your first sample is free.
More ACC 335 papers and BS in Accounting samples
- ACC 335 Topic 1: Cycle Responsibility Map
- ACC 335 Topic 2: Expenditure Cycle Flowchart
- ACC 335 Topic 3: Design Versus Operation Memo
- ACC 335 Topic 5: Control Cost Discussion Post
- ACC 335 Topic 6: User Access Rights Review
- ACC 335 Topic 7: Control Weakness Finding
- ACC 335 Topic 8: Compensating Control Plan
- ACC 260 Topic 4: Break-even Assumptions Memo
- ACC 250 Topic 4: Allowance Estimate Review
- ACC 240 Topic 4: Closing Entry Sequence
ACC 335 Topic 4 questions, answered
Which duties must be kept apart?
The classic pairing to separate is custody of an asset from the recording of it, since one person holding both can take the asset and adjust the record. Authorization should also sit apart from both, and review should be performed by somebody who did none of the three. In a small office the realistic goal is to break the most dangerous pairing and cover the others by other means.
Does a system permission count as a duty?
Yes, and it is often the one that matters most. An employee who never voids a transaction in practice but holds the permission to do so can still do it, usually without anybody noticing. A matrix built only from observed behavior misses that, so a strong example checks the permissions list alongside what people actually do and marks both.
What if every conflict involves the owner?
That is common in small businesses, and it changes the question. An owner who holds cash and records it would be taking from their own business, so the concern shifts toward the other employees and toward honest errors rather than theft. The matrix should still show the owner's conflicts and note that the risk they carry is of a different kind.
Where can I find a free ACC 335 Topic 4 sample paper?
This page carries the complete matrix: the practice and question, the task table, how the observed day differed, conflicts written as transactions, why the first ranks highest, what cannot be separated and a check to run now. Tell us your office for a free worked matrix.
What is the highest-ranked conflict in ACC 335 Topic 4?
The front desk lead can take a cash payment and void the visit, so no charge, receivable or expected deposit exists and the theft leaves nothing to reconcile.