| Course | ACC 361 Intermediate Managerial Accounting |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 4 |
| Paper type | Materials and labor variance analysis |
| Length | About 950 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 361 Topic 4
A Cheaper Resin That Cost $1,620 More: Materials and Labor Variance Analysis for Pinecrest Garden Products' June Planters
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
ACC-361: Intermediate Managerial Accounting
Topic 4 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
A Cheaper Resin That Cost $1,620 More: Materials and Labor Variance Analysis for Pinecrest Garden Products' June Planters
The Standard
Pinecrest Garden Products, a composite maker of molded resin planters, uses standard costs to control materials and labor. Table 1 is the standard cost card for its most popular 18-inch planter. The standards were set from engineering tests and last year's actual results, and they are what a planter should cost when materials and labor are used and priced as planned. All figures are illustrative.
Table 1
Standard Cost Card
| Standard cost card, one planter | Quantity | Price | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Resin pellets | 2.0 pounds | $6.00 a pound | $12.00 |
| Molding and trimming labor | 0.5 hours | $20.00 an hour | 10.00 |
| Standard prime cost | $22.00 |
June's Results
In June, the plant made 1,000 planters. For the first time, purchasing bought a lower grade of recycled resin from a new supplier at $5.40 a pound instead of $6.00. Table 2 sets June's actual inputs against what the standard allows for 1,000 planters.
Table 2
Standard Allowed and Actual Inputs, June
| June, 1,000 planters | Standard allowed | Actual |
|---|---|---|
| Resin bought and used | 2,000 pounds at $6.00 | 2,300 pounds at $5.40 |
| Labor | 500 hours at $20.00 | 560 hours at $20.00 |
| Total materials and labor | $22,000 | $23,620 |
The Four Variances
Price and rate variances measure paying more or less than standard for what was used; quantity and efficiency variances measure using more or less than standard for the output produced. Table 3 computes each. The materials price variance is computed on the quantity bought; here all 2,300 pounds bought were used in June.
Table 3
Materials and Labor Variances, June
| Variance | Calculation | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Materials price | (Actual price − standard price) × actual quantity bought: ($5.40 − $6.00) × 2,300 | $1,380 F |
| Materials quantity | (Actual quantity − standard quantity) × standard price: (2,300 − 2,000) × $6.00 | $1,800 U |
| Labor rate | (Actual rate − standard rate) × actual hours: ($20.00 − $20.00) × 560 | $0 |
| Labor efficiency | (Actual hours − standard hours) × standard rate: (560 − 500) × $20.00 | $1,200 U |
| Total | $23,620 actual less $22,000 standard | $1,620 U |
Reading Each Variance Alone
Read alone, the materials price variance looks like good news: purchasing saved $1,380 by paying 60 cents a pound less. The materials quantity variance looks like a production problem: 300 more pounds than standard, costing $1,800. The labor efficiency variance also looks like a production problem: 60 hours over standard, $1,200. The labor rate variance is zero, since workers were paid the standard rate.
A report that sent each variance to its usual owner would praise purchasing and question the production supervisor. That would be wrong, because the three nonzero variances share a single cause, and treating them separately would hide it.
Is It Worth Investigating?
Pinecrest investigates any variance above 5% of standard cost or $1,000, whichever is lower. The net $1,620 is 7.4% of the $22,000 standard and clears both thresholds. More telling is the pattern: materials quantity is 15% over standard and labor 12% over, in the same month and on the same product, after months in which both ran within 2%. A simultaneous jump in two usage variances points to a common cause, and the obvious candidate is whatever changed that month.
The standard itself already includes a normal allowance for scrap. The 2.0 pounds per planter assumes that about one planter in twenty is rejected and reground, based on last year's experience with the standard resin. The June overrun is therefore not ordinary scrap, which the standard covers, but scrap well above the normal rate, which is exactly what a quantity variance is designed to flag.
Connecting the Pieces
The lower-grade resin contains more contaminants and melts less evenly. The molding operators reported more short shots, planters that did not fill the mold completely, and more flash to trim from the edges. Rejected planters were reground but lost material in the process, which explains most of the 300 extra pounds. The extra trimming and remolding explain the 60 extra hours. The production supervisor did not choose the resin and could not have avoided its effects. Operators slowed the molding cycle on the second day to reduce short shots, which helped but added machine time to every planter, and the log of rejected parts shows the reject rate falling only slightly after that adjustment.
Taken together, the switch saved $1,380 on price and cost $3,000 in extra material and labor, a net loss of $1,620 against the standard grade it replaced. The price saving was real, but it was more than consumed by the variances it caused downstream. Variances interact, and a favorable variance in one area can be the cause of unfavorable variances in another; evaluating them in isolation can reward the wrong decision (Datar & Rajan, 2021).
Who Should See the $1,620
The net cost belongs with the purchasing manager, whose decision produced it, not with the production supervisor, whose report it appears on. That is not a criticism of trying a cheaper supplier; testing lower-cost inputs is part of purchasing's job. The point is that purchasing should be judged on the total cost of its decision, including its effect on production. Many companies address this by reporting the materials price variance alongside the quantity and efficiency variances that follow a supplier change, so the full effect is visible in one place (Garrison et al., 2021).
Recommendation
Return to the standard resin grade for the 18-inch planter from next month. If the new supplier's price remains attractive, test its resin on a simpler product with thicker walls, where contaminants cause fewer defects, and measure scrap and labor for a full month before switching. Revise the standard cost card only after the test, so that a lower standard price is not built in before its effect on quantity and hours is known (Franklin et al., 2019).
References
Datar, S. M., & Rajan, M. V. (2021). Horngren's cost accounting: A managerial emphasis (17th ed.). Pearson.
Franklin, M., Graybeal, P., & Cooper, D. (2019). Principles of accounting, volume 2: Managerial accounting. OpenStax. https://openstax.org/details/books/principles-managerial-accounting
Garrison, R. H., Noreen, E. W., & Brewer, P. C. (2021). Managerial accounting (17th ed.). McGraw Hill.
The ACC-361 Topic 4 assignment instructions
The Topic 4 instructions in ACC-361 ask students to compute and interpret materials and labor variances. Weak submissions compute each variance and assign it to its usual owner. The assignment rewards analyses that present the standard cost card, compute price, quantity, rate and efficiency variances with formulas shown, and then look for connections among them. Students should explain whether the variances are large enough to investigate, identify a common cause where one exists, assign the net effect to the manager whose decision produced it and recommend what to do before revising standards.
How the ACC-361 Topic 4 example is put together
Opening the example, a reader finds the standard cost card: two pounds of material at $6.00 a pound and half an hour of labor at $20.00 for each finished item. One month's output of 1,000 items is set against it, with every figure illustrative. The materials price variance, computed on the 2,300 pounds bought at $5.40, comes out $1,380 favorable. Usage tells the other half: 300 pounds over standard is $1,800 unfavorable, and labor needed 60 extra hours, a $1,200 unfavorable efficiency variance, while the labor rate matched standard. The analysis then connects the pieces. The cheaper grade saved on price and cost more in waste and handling, so the switch lost $1,620 against the standard grade it replaced, a figure the purchasing manager rather than the floor has to answer for.
Where the marks sit in the ACC 361 Topic 4 rubric
Faculty grading the variance analysis reward variances connected to a cause. Excellent analyses show that a favorable price variance on cheaper material caused unfavorable quantity and efficiency variances downstream. Credit goes to computing the net effect and assigning it to the purchasing decision. The rubric values applying an investigation threshold and recognizing that standards already include normal scrap. The highest level recommends a controlled test before changing suppliers or standards. Analyses that praise purchasing for the price saving and separately blame production for the overruns usually lose marks with graders.
ACC 361 Topic 4 help: mistakes that cost marks
Deductions in this topic are mostly arithmetic, and markers find them quickly. A price variance computed on the quantity used, when the rubric expects the quantity purchased, gives the right total with the wrong split and loses credit for the split. Quantity variances valued at actual rather than standard price blend two effects the analysis is supposed to hold apart. Getting the sign wrong on a favorable variance, and then interpreting it, turns a correct calculation into an incorrect conclusion. The heavier reasoning loss is reporting four variances as four unrelated events, so the waste appears to be the production supervisor's problem when the material decision caused it. Analyses that stop at the figures without pricing the cheaper grade against the standard one never answer whether the switch was worth making.
Get an ACC-361 Topic 4 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-361 Topic 4 instructions, the rubric and the standard cost card and actual results your section provided. We write a custom example to them, with each variance formula shown, price and usage separated for materials and labor, the variances connected to their cause and the underlying decision priced, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More ACC 361 papers and BS in Accounting samples
- ACC 361 Topic 1: Mixed Cost Estimation Memo
- ACC 361 Topic 2: Cash Budget Shortfall Analysis
- ACC 361 Topic 3: Flexible Budget Performance Report
- ACC 361 Topic 5: Variance Ownership Discussion Post
- ACC 361 Topic 6: Segment Margin Report
- ACC 361 Topic 7: Residual Income Comparison
- ACC 361 Topic 8: Control System Incentive Review
- ACC 360 Topic 4: Overhead Base Selection Memo
- ACC 337 Topic 4: Rule-based Anomaly Screen
- ACC 335 Topic 4: Incompatible Duties Matrix
ACC 361 Topic 4 questions, answered
Why compute the price variance on the quantity purchased?
Because it reports the buying decision when it happens. If the variance waits until the material is used, a purchase made this month may not show up for several months, by which time nobody can act on it. Some sections compute it on quantity used for simplicity, and the example follows whichever basis the instructions name, stating it in the analysis.
Can a favorable variance cause an unfavorable one?
Often, and this topic is built around the case. Cheaper material, less experienced labor paid a lower rate, or a skipped maintenance visit can each produce a favorable figure on one line and a larger unfavorable figure elsewhere. Reading the variances together, and asking what single decision would explain several of them, is what turns a set of calculations into an analysis.
What should the standards be based on?
Engineering studies, past performance adjusted for known changes and current supplier prices are the usual sources. Standards set at ideal levels produce unfavorable variances every month and teach people to ignore them; standards set too loosely hide real problems. The example states where its standards came from and treats them as attainable, which is the assumption most intermediate coursework uses.
Where can I find a free ACC 361 Topic 4 sample paper?
This page carries the complete analysis: the standard, June's results, the four variances, reading each alone, whether to investigate, connecting the pieces, who should see the $1,620 and the recommendation. Share your standard cost data for a free worked analysis.
Who owns the $1,620 in ACC 361 Topic 4?
The purchasing manager, whose switch to cheaper resin saved $1,380 on price but caused $3,000 of extra material and labor in production.