ACC 361 Topic 7 residual income comparison example

Intermediate Managerial Accounting Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This ACC 361 Topic 7 sample paper compares return on investment and residual income on one division earning 20 percent and one project earning 15 percent against a 12 percent minimum. It was prepared for GCU ACC 361, Intermediate Managerial Accounting, catalog code ACC-361, in the Grand Canyon University BS in Accounting program. Accepting the $500,000 project would cut ROI to 19 percent, so a manager paid on ROI rationally rejects it, while residual income rises by $15,000 a year. The paper breaks ROI into margin and turnover, discusses the capital charge rate, shows aging assets lifting ROI from 20 to 25 percent with no improvement and names what each measure rewards.

CourseACC 361 Intermediate Managerial Accounting
TopicTopic 7
Paper typeResidual income comparison
LengthAbout 970 words, 2 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramBS in Accounting
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for ACC 361 Topic 7

1

A 15 Percent Project Under a 12 Percent Hurdle: Why ROI Tells the Division to Refuse It and Residual Income Does Not

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

ACC-361: Intermediate Managerial Accounting

Topic 7 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title sets out the conflict between the two measures in one case, which is the comparison the paper works through. The division and all figures are illustrative composites.
2

A 15 Percent Project Under a 12 Percent Hurdle: Why ROI Tells the Division to Refuse It and Residual Income Does Not

The Division and the Project

The Precision Components Division of a composite industrial company has $2,000,000 of operating assets earning $400,000 a year, a return on investment of 20%. The company requires every investment to earn at least 12%, its estimate of the cost of the capital it provides. The division manager has been offered a $500,000 project, a new machining cell for an aerospace customer, that would earn $75,000 a year, a 15% return. The division manager's bonus is based on return on investment. All figures are illustrative.

Table 1

The Project Under Both Measures

Division nowProjectDivision with project
Operating assets$2,000,000$500,000$2,500,000
Operating income$400,000$75,000$475,000
Return on investment20.0%15.0%19.0%
Minimum required return, 12%$240,000$60,000$300,000
Residual income$160,000$15,000$175,000

Why a Manager Paid on ROI Rejects It

Accepting the project would lower the division's return on investment from 20% to 19%, because the project earns less than the division's current average. A manager whose bonus rises and falls with return on investment is being paid to reject it, and doing so is rational given the measure. The company, however, loses. The project earns 15% on capital that costs 12%, so every year it is refused, the company forgoes returns above its cost of capital.

This is the best-known weakness of return on investment as a performance measure: it encourages managers of high-return divisions to reject investments that are profitable for the company but below the division's current average, and it can encourage managers of low-return divisions to accept investments that are above their average but below the cost of capital (Garrison et al., 2021).

What Residual Income Says

Residual income charges each division for the capital it uses at the minimum required return and measures what it earns above that charge. The division's residual income is $400,000 less 12% of $2,000,000, or $160,000. The project's is $75,000 less 12% of $500,000, or $15,000. Accepting it raises the division's residual income to $175,000. A manager paid on residual income would accept the project, which is also what the company wants. The $15,000 is the amount the company loses each year the project stays rejected. Residual income as a divisional measure was set out by Solomons (1965) for precisely this reason: it aligns the manager's measure with the company's interest in any project that earns more than the cost of capital.

Choosing the Capital Charge

Residual income is only as good as its capital charge. At 12%, the project adds $15,000 a year. If the aerospace work is riskier than the division's usual business, because it depends on one customer's program, the company might reasonably charge 14% on that project's assets, and the residual income would fall to $5,000. At 15%, it would be zero. The charge rate is therefore a policy decision that headquarters, not the division manager, should set, and it should reflect the risk of the investment rather than a single rate for everything. Setting it too low encourages overinvestment, and setting it too high reproduces the underinvestment problem that return on investment creates.

Margin and Turnover

Return on investment can be broken into margin, income as a share of sales, and turnover, sales per dollar of assets. The breakdown shows why the project lowers the average.

Table 2

Return on Investment as Margin Times Turnover

Return on investment = margin × turnoverDivision nowProjectWith project
Sales$5,000,000$600,000$5,600,000
Margin: income ÷ sales8.0%12.5%8.5%
Turnover: sales ÷ assets2.501.202.24
Return on investment20.0%15.0%19.0%

Reading the Breakdown

The project has a higher margin than the division, 12.5% against 8.0%, because aerospace parts command premium prices. But it needs a lot of equipment for its sales, so its turnover is only 1.2 against the division's 2.5. The combined effect is a lower return on investment. The breakdown tells the manager where the project differs, and it shows that a lower return on investment does not mean lower profitability per sale.

How Aging Assets Flatter Both Measures

Both measures use the net book value of assets, cost less accumulated depreciation. If the division made no new investments, its assets would shrink each year as they depreciated, and its measured performance would improve without any change in operations.

Table 3

Measured Performance With an Aging Asset Base

No new investment, assets depreciate $200,000 a yearYear 1Year 2Year 3
Net book value of assets$2,000,000$1,800,000$1,600,000
Operating income, unchanged$400,000$400,000$400,000
Return on investment20.0%22.2%25.0%
Residual income at 12%$160,000$184,000$208,000

What Each Measure Rewards

Return on investment rises from 20% to 25% in two years with no improvement at all, and residual income rises too, though less sharply. A manager evaluated on either measure has a reason to delay replacing old equipment, since new assets would raise the asset base and lower the measure. Return on investment is the more sensitive of the two, because the shrinking base appears in the denominator.

Each measure therefore rewards different behavior. Return on investment rewards keeping the asset base small and rejecting investments below the division's own average. Residual income rewards accepting any investment above the required return, but it favors large divisions, since a larger division can earn more dollars above the charge; comparisons across divisions should be made against each division's own target rather than in raw dollars. Both reward delaying replacement of aging assets unless assets are measured at gross cost or replacement cost (Merchant & Van der Stede, 2017).

For the Precision Components Division, the recommendation is to evaluate the manager on residual income, or at least to approve projects above 12% centrally so that the manager's bonus does not decide them, and to review capital spending over several years so that deferred replacement is visible.

References

Garrison, R. H., Noreen, E. W., & Brewer, P. C. (2021). Managerial accounting (17th ed.). McGraw Hill.

Merchant, K. A., & Van der Stede, W. A. (2017). Management control systems: Performance measurement, evaluation and incentives (4th ed.). Pearson.

Solomons, D. (1965). Divisional performance: Measurement and control. Financial Executives Research Foundation.

ACC 361 Topic 7 instructions, in plain terms

ACC-361 Topic 7 asks students to compare performance measures for investment centers. Many papers define ROI and residual income without applying them to a decision. The assignment rewards comparisons that apply both measures to one division and one proposed investment, show how each would guide the manager, and explain why the measures can disagree. Students should break ROI into margin and turnover, discuss how the capital charge is set, show how net book value makes aging assets look better, name the behaviors each measure encourages and recommend how the company should evaluate the manager.

How the ACC-361 Topic 7 example is put together

The comparison starts from one division's figures, all illustrative: $2,000,000 of operating assets earning $400,000, a 20 percent return. A $500,000 project promises $75,000 a year, 15 percent, against a company minimum of 12 percent. Under ROI the division would fall to 19 percent if it accepted, so a manager paid on ROI rejects it, and the example shows that choice is rational given the measure. Residual income tells the other story. Charging 12 percent on the new assets leaves $15,000 a year of residual income, the amount the company loses each year the project stays rejected. The example then breaks ROI into margin and turnover, shows how net book value makes an aging asset base look steadily better, and names the behavior each measure rewards. It ends by proposing which measure the division should report.

Where the marks sit in the ACC 361 Topic 7 rubric

Faculty grading the residual income comparison reward a worked conflict between measures. Excellent comparisons show the ROI decline that leads a manager to reject a project above the cost of capital. Credit goes to computing the project's residual income and explaining what the company loses by rejecting it. The rubric values margin and turnover analysis and a table showing aging assets flattering both measures. The highest level addresses the choice of capital charge and the bias of residual income toward large divisions. Comparisons without a numerical case usually lose marks.

ACC 361 Topic 7 help: mistakes that cost marks

Here the measure itself is under examination, and a paper earns its credit by saying what that measure does to a manager. Computing ROI and residual income correctly and then declaring one superior, with no decision run through both, shows arithmetic and no grasp of behavior. Treating the manager who rejects a profitable project as irrational misses the point, since the measure made rejection sensible. A paper that notes the conflict without pricing it leaves the company unsure what the measure is costing. Residual income recommended without any mention of its bias toward large divisions presents a trade-off as a free improvement. Where the rubric asks about the asset base, overlooking how net book value inflates ROI in older divisions omits the most common way the ratio misleads a head office reading it.

Get an ACC-361 Topic 7 example written to your instructions

Send the ACC-361 Topic 7 instructions, the rubric and the division or project figures your section supplied. We write a custom example to them, with one decision run through ROI and residual income, the rejected project priced, the ratio split into margin and turnover and each measure's incentive named, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More ACC 361 papers and BS in Accounting samples

ACC 361 Topic 7 questions, answered

Why would a manager reject a project that beats the required rate?

Because the measure rewards the average, not the addition. A division already earning 20 percent lowers its ROI by accepting anything below 20 percent, even when the project clears the company's 12 percent minimum comfortably. A manager paid on ROI is acting rationally by refusing, and the example accordingly treats the problem as one of measure design rather than of judgment.

Is residual income always the better measure?

Not always. It removes the incentive to refuse projects above the required rate, but it favors larger divisions, since a bigger asset base can produce a bigger residual figure at the same underlying performance. Comparing divisions of different sizes on raw residual income is misleading, and many designs compare each division's result with its own target instead.

Where does economic value added fit in?

It is a refinement of residual income, usually applying the company's weighted average cost of capital to an adjusted measure of invested capital and after-tax operating profit. Some sections introduce it alongside residual income. The example mentions it where the instructions do, but the central comparison stays with ROI and residual income, since that is where the behavioral conflict is clearest.

Where can I find a free ACC 361 Topic 7 sample paper?

This page holds the complete comparison: the division and project, why ROI rejects it, what residual income says, the capital charge, margin and turnover, aging assets and what each measure rewards. Tell us your division figures for a free worked comparison.

Why would a manager reject the project in ACC 361 Topic 7?

It earns 15 percent, below the division's 20 percent, so accepting would lower ROI to 19 percent and the manager's bonus, even though it beats the 12 percent hurdle.