| Course | ACC 370 Intermediate Accounting I |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 5 |
| Paper type | Capitalize or expense discussion post |
| Length | About 460 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Discussion post, APA 7 citations |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 370 Topic 5
Topic 5 DQ 1: Initial Post and Reply
Beyond the Original Estimate or Back to It? Capitalizing a $14,000 Engine Overhaul and Expensing a $600 Tune-Up on the Same Invoice
Initial Post
My answer: spending on an existing asset is capitalized when it gives the asset service potential beyond what the original estimate assumed, and expensed when it keeps the asset performing as that estimate assumed.
Here is the case, with illustrative figures. A distributor bought a delivery truck for $48,000, estimated an eight-year life and no residual value, and depreciates it at $6,000 a year. After five years its book value is $18,000 and it has three years left. The shop then rebuilds the engine for $14,000, and the fleet manager expects the truck to run five more years instead of three. The same invoice includes a $600 tune-up: new spark plugs, filters and an oil change.
The overhaul extends the truck's life by two years beyond the original estimate. That is service potential the original estimate did not include, so the $14,000 is capitalized. The truck's book value becomes $32,000, spread over the new remaining life of five years, or $6,400 a year. Expenditures that extend useful life, increase capacity or improve efficiency beyond the original expectation are added to the asset, while ordinary repairs and maintenance that maintain it in its expected operating condition are expensed (Kieso et al., 2019).
The tune-up restores nothing beyond expected condition. The original eight-year estimate assumed the truck would receive routine maintenance like this every year, so the $600 is an expense of the current period (Weygandt et al., 2021).
One fact would reverse the overhaul's treatment. If the original eight-year estimate had assumed an engine rebuild at about year five, as some fleet estimates do for heavy trucks, then the overhaul would only keep the truck on its expected path, and it would be a major repair within the original estimate. In that case, there would be a reasonable argument to expense it or, more precisely, to have treated the engine as a separate component from the start, depreciated over five years and replaced when rebuilt.
Question for classmates: how would you decide, from the documents you would actually have, whether an overhaul extends life or only keeps an asset on its expected path?
Reply to Jordan
Jordan, you suggested capitalizing anything over $5,000 as a practical rule. A threshold is useful for small items, and many companies expense everything below one. But a size threshold alone would have capitalized a $6,000 repair that merely restores a truck damaged in an accident, which extends nothing beyond the original estimate, and it would have expensed a $4,000 upgrade that adds refrigeration capacity. Would you combine your threshold with the life-and-capacity test, so the threshold decides only whether an item is worth analyzing at all?
References
Kieso, D. E., Weygandt, J. J., & Warfield, T. D. (2019). Intermediate accounting (17th ed.). Wiley.
Weygandt, J. J., Kimmel, P. D., & Mitchell, J. E. (2021). Accounting principles (14th ed.). Wiley.
ACC 370 Topic 5 instructions, in plain terms
ACC-370 Topic 5 asks students to discuss when spending on existing assets should be capitalized. Many posts list categories such as repairs, additions and improvements. The prompt rewards posts that state a test, apply it to a numerical case with more than one item, and show the revised depreciation after any capitalized amount. Students should identify a fact that would reverse their conclusion, such as an original estimate that assumed the overhaul, ask classmates a question about applying the test in practice and reply to a classmate by testing their proposed rule.
How the ACC-370 Topic 5 example is put together
Its answer arrives in the first sentence: spending is capitalized when it gives the asset service potential beyond the original estimate, and expensed when it keeps the asset performing as that estimate assumed. The case follows, with illustrative figures. A $48,000 delivery truck on an eight-year life, no residual value, has three years left and an $18,000 book value; a $14,000 engine overhaul lets it run five more. Two extra years is a benefit the original estimate lacked, so the overhaul is capitalized and the new $32,000 book value is spread at $6,400 a year. The $600 tune-up on the same invoice restores nothing beyond expected condition and is expensed. The post names the fact that would reverse the overhaul's treatment and asks how a classmate's employer, with its own capitalization threshold, would handle a similar bill.
Where the marks sit in the ACC 370 Topic 5 rubric
GCU's rubric for this discussion rewards a test applied to figures. Excellent posts capitalize an overhaul that extends life beyond the original estimate and recompute depreciation on the new book value. Credit goes to expensing routine maintenance on the same invoice. The rubric values naming what would reverse the treatment, including component depreciation. The strongest replies show how a dollar threshold alone would misclassify both a repair and an upgrade. Posts that decide by amount alone, without reference to the original estimate, tend to earn partial credit.
ACC 370 Topic 5 help before you submit
Discussion credit on this question tracks whether the criterion is applied to a specific expenditure. A post listing the textbook categories, additions, improvements, replacements and repairs, but never placing a real cost in any of them, repeats the chapter without using it. Concluding that the overhaul should be capitalized because it was expensive treats size as the test and ignores what the work did to the asset. Posts that capitalize an expenditure and never adjust future depreciation leave the consequence of the decision unstated. Where a classmate's case is answered with agreement rather than a second expenditure, the reply adds little to the thread. Many sections expect one citation to the course text for the treatment, and a post claiming the answer is obvious offers no source anyone could check.
Get an ACC-370 Topic 5 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-370 Topic 5 discussion question, the participation rubric and any expenditure your section wants worked. We write a custom example to those, with the criterion stated first, one contested cost walked through it, a contrasting cost treated the other way, revised depreciation shown and a reply prompt ready, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More ACC 370 papers and BS in Accounting samples
- ACC 370 Topic 1: Conceptual Framework Case Memo
- ACC 370 Topic 2: Receivables and Revenue Recognition Problem
- ACC 370 Topic 3: Cost Flow and Write-down Problem
- ACC 370 Topic 4: Acquisition Cost Build-up Schedule
- ACC 370 Topic 6: Depreciation Estimate Change Problem
- ACC 370 Topic 7: Impairment Trigger Analysis
- ACC 370 Topic 8: Asset Judgment Research Memo
- ACC 361 Topic 5: Variance Ownership Discussion Post
- ACC 360 Topic 5: Allocation Distortion Dq Post
- ACC 337 Topic 5: Pattern Versus Evidence Dq Post
ACC 370 Topic 5 questions, answered
Where does a capitalized overhaul get recorded?
Textbooks differ. Some add an expenditure that extends useful life to the asset account; others debit accumulated depreciation, on the reasoning that the work recovers service potential already written off. Either way, the book value rises by the same amount and future depreciation is recalculated over the new remaining life. Follow the approach your course text uses and name it in the post.
What is a capitalization threshold?
A company policy setting a dollar amount below which expenditures are expensed even if they technically qualify as assets, because tracking and depreciating very small items costs more than the information is worth. It rests on materiality. A threshold does not change the criterion for larger items; it removes small ones from the analysis, and companies document the amount they use.
Does replacing a component change the answer?
It adds a step. When a major component is replaced, the new cost is capitalized and the old component's cost and accumulated depreciation are removed if they can be identified, with any remaining book value recognized as a loss. The truck in this post had its engine overhauled rather than replaced, so no component is removed, and the post says why.
Where can I find a free ACC 370 Topic 5 sample paper?
You will find the post with one reply above, covering the test, the truck and overhaul, revised depreciation, the tune-up, the fact that would reverse the answer and a reply on thresholds. Send us your prompt for a free example.
Why is the overhaul capitalized in ACC 370 Topic 5?
It extends the truck's life by two years beyond the original eight-year estimate, adding service potential that estimate did not include.