ACC 371 Topic 5 contingency recognition dq example

Intermediate Accounting II Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This ACC 371 Topic 5 sample discussion post argues that a loss is accrued only when it is probable and reasonably estimable, whatever anyone feels about the case. It was written for GCU ACC 371, Intermediate Accounting II, catalog code ACC-371, in the Grand Canyon University BS in Accounting. A probable product injury suit with a $300,000 to $900,000 range and no best estimate is accrued at the $300,000 minimum with the possible $600,000 more disclosed. A reasonably possible patent claim estimated at $2,000,000 is disclosed only. The post explains why the smaller claim reaches the balance sheet, names the development that would change that and replies to a classmate's midpoint.

CourseACC 371 Intermediate Accounting II
TopicTopic 5
Paper typeContingency recognition discussion post
LengthAbout 430 words, 1 pages
FormatDiscussion post, APA 7 citations
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramBS in Accounting
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for ACC 371 Topic 5

1

Topic 5 DQ 1: Initial Post and Reply

Accrue the Smaller Claim, Disclose the Larger One: Two Lawsuits and the Two Conditions a Loss Must Meet

Initial Post

My position: a loss contingency is accrued only when a loss is probable and its amount can be reasonably estimated, and a strong feeling about a case satisfies neither condition (Financial Accounting Standards Board, 1975).

Two illustrative claims against the same appliance maker make the point. In the first, a customer sued after a space heater overheated and caused burns. Outside counsel judges an unfavorable outcome probable. Counsel estimates the loss at between $300,000 and $900,000, and says no amount within that range is a better estimate than any other. Both conditions are met: the loss is probable, and a range is a reasonable estimate. When no amount in a range is more likely than another, the minimum of the range is accrued (Financial Accounting Standards Board, 1976). The company records a $300,000 loss and liability and discloses that the loss could be as much as $600,000 more.

In the second, a competitor claims one of the company's thermostats infringes its patent. Counsel calls the chance of losing reasonably possible, not probable, and estimates that if the company lost, damages would be about $2,000,000. That amount is larger and easier to state than the first claim's range, but the first condition fails. A reasonably possible loss is disclosed, with the estimate, and nothing is recorded.

So the smaller claim reaches the balance sheet and the larger one appears only in the notes. That can look backwards, but it follows from what each condition protects. Probability keeps speculative losses out of the accounts; estimability keeps recorded amounts from being guesses.

The development that would change the patent claim's treatment is a change in counsel's assessment. If a court ruled against the company on a key motion, and counsel then judged a loss probable, the company would accrue its best estimate at that point, in that period, not restate the earlier one.

Question for classmates: how should a controller respond when management's view of a case is more optimistic than counsel's?

Reply to Morgan

Morgan, you suggested accruing the midpoint of the heater claim's range, $600,000, because it seems most realistic. I see the appeal, but counsel specifically said no amount in the range is more likely than another, and in that situation the guidance points to the minimum, with the rest disclosed. If counsel had said $500,000 was the most likely outcome, that amount would be accrued instead. Would you change your answer if the midpoint had no more support from counsel than the minimum?

References

Financial Accounting Standards Board. (1975). Accounting for contingencies (Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 5). FASB.

Financial Accounting Standards Board. (1976). Reasonable estimation of the amount of a loss: An interpretation of FASB Statement No. 5 (FASB Interpretation No. 14). FASB.

The ACC-371 Topic 5 assignment instructions

ACC-371 Topic 5 asks students to discuss when loss contingencies should be recognized or disclosed. Many posts recite the probability categories without applying them. The prompt rewards posts that state the two conditions for accrual and apply them to specific claims with counsel's assessments and amounts. Students should explain how a range with no best estimate is handled, why a larger but only reasonably possible loss is disclosed rather than accrued, what later development would change the treatment and how it would be accounted for, and answer a classmate by asking what would justify a different amount.

How the ACC-371 Topic 5 example is put together

The post takes its position in the first line: a loss is accrued only when it is probable and reasonably estimable, and a strong feeling about a case satisfies neither condition. Two illustrative claims carry the argument. In the first, a product injury suit, counsel judges an unfavorable outcome probable and puts the loss between $300,000 and $900,000 with no figure in that range more likely than another, so the post accrues the $300,000 minimum and discloses the possible $600,000 more. In the second, a patent claim, counsel calls the chance of losing reasonably possible and offers an estimate of $2,000,000. The post discloses it and records nothing, even though that amount is larger and easier to state. It then identifies the development that would move the patent case onto the books, and a question to classmates closes it.

Reading the ACC 371 Topic 5 rubric

GCU's rubric for this discussion rewards both conditions applied to facts. Excellent posts accrue the minimum of a range when no amount is more likely and disclose the possible excess. Credit goes to disclosing a reasonably possible loss without recording it, even when it is larger. The rubric values explaining that a change in counsel's assessment is recognized in the period it occurs, without restatement. The strongest replies explain when a midpoint or best estimate would be appropriate instead. Posts that accrue every claim management expects to lose tend to earn partial credit.

ACC 371 Topic 5 help before you submit

In the thread, posts most often give up credit by treating the size of a claim as though it were its probability. Accruing the $2,000,000 patent claim because the number is large and specific records a loss that is only reasonably possible, the classic recognition error here. Booking the midpoint of the $300,000 to $900,000 range, when nothing makes the midpoint more likely, borrows a measurement rule from international standards that has no place under US GAAP. A post that accrues the minimum and omits disclosure of the further exposure has done half of what the guidance asks. Answers asserting a case is probable, without saying who assessed it, never apply the test. Replies that simply agree with a classmate add nothing, and many rubrics reward a reply that brings a different claim to the same two conditions.

Get an ACC-371 Topic 5 example written to your instructions

Send the ACC-371 Topic 5 discussion question, the participation rubric and any contingency case your section posted. We write a custom example to those, with both recognition conditions stated first, each claim tested against them, the accrual or disclosure decided and a reply prompt that moves the thread forward, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More ACC 371 papers and BS in Accounting samples

ACC 371 Topic 5 questions, answered

What does probable mean for a loss contingency?

Under US GAAP, likely to occur, which is a higher threshold than more likely than not. Reasonably possible covers the middle ground, more than remote but less than likely, and remote means slight. The categories come from the judgment of counsel and management about the specific claim, so a post has to say whose assessment it relies on. Only the probable category, with an estimable amount, leads to an accrual.

Why accrue the minimum instead of the midpoint?

Because US GAAP calls for it when no amount within a range is a better estimate than any other. The minimum is recorded and the additional possible loss is disclosed. If one amount in the range is more likely, that amount is accrued instead. International standards use the midpoint in the equal-likelihood case, which is why posts drawing on IFRS material sometimes reach a different figure from the same facts.

Does a remote claim need any disclosure?

Generally not, for litigation. A claim whose chance of loss is slight is usually left out of the notes entirely, since disclosing every remote suit would bury the ones that matter. Guarantees are the familiar exception, disclosed even when a loss is remote. A post that finds a claim remote should still say why, because the classification is itself a judgment that a reader may question.

Where can I find a free ACC 371 Topic 5 sample paper?

The post with one reply appears above: the position, the injury suit, the patent claim, why the smaller claim is recorded, what would change it and a reply on the midpoint. Share the discussion prompt with us for a free worked example.

Why accrue $300,000 in ACC 371 Topic 5?

The loss is probable, the range is $300,000 to $900,000 and counsel sees no amount as more likely, so the minimum is accrued and the extra $600,000 is disclosed.