| Course | ACC 371 Intermediate Accounting II |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 8 |
| Paper type | Debt or equity research memo |
| Length | About 760 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 371 Topic 8
Memorandum
To: Controller, Blue Mesa Health Products
From: [Author Name], technical accounting
Date: [Date]
Re: Balance sheet classification of the Series A and Series B preferred shares
Question
The company plans to issue two series of preferred shares to fund a new production facility. You asked whether both can be reported as equity. This memo answers for each series separately, applying the guidance for instruments with characteristics of both liabilities and equity, and then states what the answer does to the debt-to-equity covenant in the company's bank loan. All figures are illustrative.
Facts
Series A: $5,000,000 of 8% preferred shares, which the company must redeem at $100 a share, their issue price, at the end of year seven. Dividends of $400,000 a year are cumulative. Series B: $3,000,000 of 7% preferred shares, which the holders may require the company to redeem at $100 a share at any time after year five; the company has no obligation to redeem unless a holder asks. The bank loan agreement limits total liabilities to 1.50 times stockholders' equity, and the company is now exactly at that limit.
Guidance
ASC 480, from FASB Statement No. 150, requires a mandatorily redeemable financial instrument to be classified as a liability. A financial instrument is mandatorily redeemable if it embodies an unconditional obligation requiring the issuer to redeem it by transferring assets at a specified or determinable date or upon an event certain to occur. Shares that are redeemable only at the holder's option are not mandatorily redeemable until the option is exercised or becomes certain (Financial Accounting Standards Board, 2003). This follows the conceptual framework, under which a liability is a present obligation of the entity to transfer an economic benefit (Financial Accounting Standards Board, 2021).
Analysis: Series A
The company must pay $5,000,000 to Series A holders on a fixed date, and nothing within its control can avoid that payment. The obligation is unconditional. Calling the instrument preferred stock does not change its substance, which is a seven-year borrowing. Series A is a liability under ASC 480. Its $400,000 annual dividend is reported as interest cost in the income statement, not as a distribution of retained earnings, and the shares are presented among the company's liabilities, measured at the amount payable at redemption (Kieso et al., 2019).
Analysis: Series B
The company must redeem Series B only if a holder chooses to require it, and until a holder does, the company has no unconditional obligation. Series B is not mandatorily redeemable and is classified in stockholders' equity. If the company's shares were publicly registered, securities regulators would require shares redeemable outside the company's control to be presented between liabilities and equity, as temporary equity; for this privately held company that presentation does not apply, but the redemption feature must be disclosed. If a holder later gives notice of redemption, the amount becomes a liability at that point.
The Consequence for the Covenant
Table 1 shows the debt-to-equity ratio before and after the financing.
Table 1
Debt to Equity Before and After the Financing
| $ millions | Before financing | After, as the standard requires | After, if both series were equity |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total liabilities | 12.0 | 17.0 | 12.0 |
| Total stockholders' equity | 8.0 | 11.0 | 16.0 |
| Debt to equity | 1.50 | 1.55 | 0.75 |
| Covenant maximum | 1.50 | 1.50 | 1.50 |
| Within covenant? | At the limit | No | Yes |
Reading the Table
If both series were equity, the ratio would fall to 0.75, well within the covenant. But Series A is a liability. After the financing, liabilities rise to $17.0 million and equity to $11.0 million, and debt to equity rises to about 1.55, above the 1.50 maximum. Issuing Series A as designed would breach the loan covenant on the day it is issued.
Classification cannot be chosen to avoid this result. The accounting follows the instrument's terms. What can change is the terms or the covenant. Three options follow. First, negotiate an amendment or waiver with the bank before issuing Series A, ideally one that treats the Series A in a way the bank finds acceptable. Second, restructure Series A so that redemption is at the holders' option or at the company's option, which would make it equity, although investors may demand a higher dividend for giving up the fixed redemption date. Third, change the mix, issuing more Series B and less Series A. Before any of these, the loan agreement's own definition of liabilities should be read closely, since some agreements define debt differently from the balance sheet.
Conclusion
Classify Series A as a liability and Series B as equity. Do not issue Series A on its current terms until the covenant question is resolved with the bank or the terms are revised.
References
Financial Accounting Standards Board. (2003). Accounting for certain financial instruments with characteristics of both liabilities and equity (Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 150). FASB.
Financial Accounting Standards Board. (2021). Conceptual framework for financial reporting: Chapter 4, elements of financial statements (Statement of Financial Accounting Concepts No. 8). FASB.
Kieso, D. E., Weygandt, J. J., & Warfield, T. D. (2019). Intermediate accounting (17th ed.). Wiley.
The ACC-371 Topic 8 assignment instructions
The Topic 8 instructions in ACC-371 ask students to research whether financial instruments are liabilities or equity. Weak submissions classify by the instrument's name. The assignment rewards memos that set out the terms of each instrument, cite the guidance on mandatorily redeemable instruments and apply it to each series separately. Students should explain how classification affects the income statement treatment of dividends, compute the effect on ratios such as debt to equity, identify any covenant consequence and describe responses that change the terms or the agreement rather than the accounting.
Inside the ACC 371 Topic 8 example
The finished memo answers one question for a controller who would prefer both series reported as equity: where does each instrument belong on the balance sheet? Series A, $5,000,000 of 8 percent preferred that must be redeemed at $100 a share in seven years, is an unconditional obligation to transfer cash on a fixed date, so it is classified as a liability whatever the shares are called, and its $400,000 annual dividend is reported as interest cost. Series B, redeemable only at the holders' option, stays in equity until a holder gives notice. A table then computes debt to equity before the financing, under the required classification and under the classification the controller hoped for, and the memo closes with three responses: a covenant amendment, revised redemption terms or a different mix of the two series.
Where the marks sit in the ACC 371 Topic 8 rubric
GCU's rubric for the debt or equity memo rewards substance over labels. Excellent memos classify shares with a fixed redemption date as liabilities and holder-redeemable shares as equity until exercise. Credit goes to reporting the liability series' dividends as interest and noting temporary equity for public companies. The rubric values computing debt to equity under the required classification. The highest level recognizes that accounting cannot be chosen to avoid a covenant breach and proposes changes to terms or the agreement. Memos that call all preferred shares equity, or that stop before the covenant effect, usually lose marks.
ACC 371 Topic 8 help before you submit
Most lost marks on this topic come from classifying instruments by their names. A memo that calls both series preferred stock, and therefore equity, has missed the guidance on mandatorily redeemable instruments entirely. Some drafts classify Series B as a liability because it can be redeemed, overlooking that redemption is at the holders' option and not yet exercised. Others classify correctly but leave the Series A dividend in retained earnings rather than interest cost. A frequent gap is stopping at classification without computing what it does to debt to equity, which is the reason the controller asked. Suggesting that the accounting be chosen to avoid a covenant breach, rather than changing the terms or the agreement, misunderstands what classification is for.
Get an ACC-371 Topic 8 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-371 Topic 8 instructions, the rubric and the financing documents or case facts your section assigned. We write a custom example to them, with each instrument's terms stated, the governing Codification topic cited, every term walked against the classification requirement and the effect on debt ratios and covenants shown, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one costs nothing.
More ACC 371 papers and BS in Accounting samples
- ACC 371 Topic 1: Liability Definition Test Memo
- ACC 371 Topic 2: Year-end Accrual Schedule
- ACC 371 Topic 3: Effective Interest Amortization Schedule
- ACC 371 Topic 4: Lessee Lease Classification Memo
- ACC 371 Topic 5: Contingency Recognition Dq
- ACC 371 Topic 6: Stockholders Equity Rollforward
- ACC 371 Topic 7: Diluted Eps Computation
- ACC 370 Topic 8: Asset Judgment Research Memo
- ACC 361 Topic 8: Control System Incentive Review
- ACC 360 Topic 8: Quote Cost Basis Memo
- ACC 240 Topic 8: Accounting Cycle Explainer
ACC 371 Topic 8 questions, answered
Why can shares be reported as a liability?
Because classification follows the obligation, not the legal form. A share the issuer must buy back for cash on a fixed or determinable date commits the company to transfer assets just as a bond does, and ASC 480 requires it to be reported among liabilities. Dividends on those shares are then presented as interest cost. The legal name of the instrument does not change what the company owes.
What happens to Series B if holders give notice of redemption?
Once the holders exercise their option, or redemption otherwise becomes certain, the shares become mandatorily redeemable and are reclassified to liabilities, measured at fair value with equity reduced by that amount and no gain or loss recognized. Until then the series remains in equity. Public companies face an extra step, since SEC staff guidance generally places shares redeemable outside the issuer's control between liabilities and equity.
Do lenders use the same classification in a covenant?
Not necessarily. A loan agreement defines its own terms, and some define debt to include or exclude particular instruments regardless of how GAAP presents them. The memo therefore separates the two questions: GAAP decides where Series A appears on the balance sheet, and the covenant language decides whether the ratio has been breached. Reading the agreement's definitions is part of the analysis, and the example says so.
Where can I find a free ACC 371 Topic 8 sample paper?
Read the full memo above: the question, the facts, the guidance, Series A, Series B, the covenant consequence, reading the table and the conclusion. Share your instrument terms for a free worked memo.
Why is Series A a liability in ACC 371 Topic 8?
The company must redeem it at a fixed price on a fixed date, an unconditional obligation to transfer cash, so ASC 480 requires liability classification whatever it is called.