| Course | ACC 425 Ethics in Accounting |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 2 |
| Paper type | Independence arrangements review |
| Length | About 860 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 425 Topic 2
Memorandum
To: Managing partner
From: [Author Name], quality control
Date: [Date]
Re: Independence review of the Cedar Creek Distributors audit before the engagement letter is renewed
Approach
This review looks at the firm's relationships with Cedar Creek Distributors, a composite wholesale client, from the position of a reasonable and informed third party. It does not question anyone's integrity. Independence has two parts: independence of mind, the state that permits an opinion without being affected by influences that compromise judgment, and independence in appearance, the avoidance of circumstances that would lead an informed third party to conclude that the firm's objectivity had been compromised (American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, 2014). The second is the one an outsider can observe, and it is the one this review can test. For each arrangement, it identifies the threat under the Code's conceptual framework, judges its significance and asks whether a safeguard reduces it to an acceptable level. Where the Code has a specific rule, the rule governs. All figures are illustrative.
The Arrangements
Table 1 sets out the five arrangements.
Table 1
Independence Threats and Safeguards
| Arrangement | Threat category | Significance | Safeguard | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Audit and other fees equal 22% of the office's revenue | Self-interest | Significant: losing the client would hurt the office | Engagement quality review by a partner from another office | Acceptable with the safeguard |
| Firm prepares the financial statements and runs payroll | Self-review; management participation | Significant | Management must take responsibility, through an overseer with suitable skill, knowledge and experience | Not met: the designated overseer is a sales manager without accounting background |
| Engagement partner has led the audit for 14 years | Familiarity | Significant | Second-partner review of key judgments, or rotation | Acceptable only with rotation or review |
| Last year's fees of $38,000, billed 14 months ago, remain unpaid | Self-interest | Impairs independence under the Code's specific rule | Collect before the current report is issued | Must be resolved before issuance |
| A staff auditor's spouse works as an accounts payable clerk at the client | Familiarity | Low: not a key position | Assign the staff auditor away from payables testing | Acceptable with the safeguard |
Fees
Cedar Creek's audit, tax and advisory fees together make up 22% of the office's revenue. The office's partners know that losing the client would mean staff reductions, and that knowledge creates a self-interest threat: an incentive, conscious or not, to avoid conclusions the client would dislike. The threat is significant but can be reduced. An engagement quality review by a partner from another office, whose own revenue does not depend on Cedar Creek, provides an objective check on the significant judgments before the report is released.
Statement Preparation and Payroll
The firm prepares Cedar Creek's financial statements and runs its payroll. These nonattest services are permitted for an audit client only if management takes responsibility for them, which the Code makes concrete: the client must designate an individual with suitable skill, knowledge or experience to oversee the services, evaluate their adequacy and accept responsibility for the results. Cedar Creek has designated its sales manager, who has no accounting training and told the engagement team that the firm's drafts are signed as prepared, without review. That designation does not meet the requirement. Unless Cedar Creek names someone qualified, such as its new controller, the firm would be performing management's function and auditing its own work, and independence would be impaired. The firm should not continue both services on the current basis.
Partner Tenure
The engagement partner has led the audit for 14 years. Rotation is not required for a private company, but long association creates a familiarity threat: a partner who has watched management make reasonable judgments for years may stop questioning new ones. Research on auditor bias describes how familiarity and repeated interaction can shift judgment gradually, in ways the auditor does not notice (Bazerman et al., 2002). A second partner's review of the key estimates, or rotation of the lead partner, would reduce the threat.
Unpaid Fees
Last year's fees of $38,000, billed 14 months ago, are still unpaid. Here the Code does not leave the question to judgment: independence is impaired if fees for services provided more than one year before the current report date remain unpaid when the report is issued. The firm is, in effect, a creditor of its client, with an interest in the client's ability to pay. The fees must be collected before the current year's report is released.
The Staff Auditor's Spouse
A staff auditor's spouse works as an accounts payable clerk at Cedar Creek. The position is not a key position able to influence the financial statements, so the Code's specific prohibition does not apply. A familiarity threat remains for any work touching payables. Assigning the staff auditor to other areas is a simple and sufficient safeguard.
Recommendations
Before renewing the engagement letter: collect the unpaid fees; require Cedar Creek to designate a qualified overseer for statement preparation and payroll, or stop providing them; arrange an engagement quality review from another office; add a second-partner review of key estimates or rotate the lead partner; and reassign the staff auditor. Independence failures rarely come from a single decision. They accumulate through arrangements like these, each reasonable on its own, which is why reviewing them together matters (Moore et al., 2006).
References
American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. (2014). AICPA code of professional conduct. AICPA.
Bazerman, M. H., Loewenstein, G., & Moore, D. A. (2002). Why good accountants do bad audits. Harvard Business Review, 80(11), 96-102.
Moore, D. A., Tetlock, P. E., Tanlu, L., & Bazerman, M. H. (2006). Conflicts of interest and the case of auditor independence: Moral seduction and strategic issue cycling. Academy of Management Review, 31(1), 10-29. https://doi.org/10.5465/amr.2006.19379621
Reading the GCU ACC 425 Topic 2 instructions
The Topic 2 instructions in ACC-425 ask students to evaluate independence using the AICPA conceptual framework. Weak submissions judge independence by whether people seem honest. The assignment rewards reviews that list each relationship, name the threat category it creates, judge its significance and identify a safeguard that reduces it to an acceptable level, while recognizing where the Code imposes a specific rule instead. Students should address independence in appearance, apply the requirements for nonattest services, explain which arrangements must change before the next report and connect the analysis to research on auditor bias.
Inside the ACC 425 Topic 2 example
Written to the firm's managing partner, the review treats independence as something an outsider could observe, not as a statement about anyone's honesty. Each arrangement gets a row: what it is, the threat category it creates under the AICPA conceptual framework, how significant the threat is and which safeguard, if any, reduces it to an acceptable level. The client's fees, an illustrative 22 percent of the office's revenue, create a self-interest threat that a review by a partner outside the office can address. The statement preparation and payroll services are permitted only if management takes responsibility for them, and the client's designated overseer, a sales manager with no accounting background, cannot. Fourteen years of partner tenure raise familiarity. The spouse holds a non-key clerical role. The review concludes that one arrangement must change before the next report is signed.
ACC 425 Topic 2 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Faculty grading the independence review reward threats matched to safeguards. Excellent reviews identify self-interest, self-review, management participation and familiarity threats correctly. Credit goes to applying the requirement that a client designate an overseer with suitable skill, knowledge or experience for nonattest services. The rubric values recognizing that unpaid fees older than a year impair independence by rule. The highest level explains how individually reasonable arrangements accumulate into a problem and sets out actions before renewal. Reviews that assume independence holds because the partner is honest usually lose marks.
ACC 425 Topic 2 help: mistakes that cost marks
Independence reviews forfeit credit fastest by treating independence as a question of character. A paper concluding that the partner is independent because the partner is honest has answered a question the standards do not ask, since the public cannot inspect anyone's integrity but can inspect a fee concentration. Arrangements listed without a threat category leave the reader unable to judge whether the proposed safeguard fits. The nonattest services draw the most specific deductions: accepting them because the client signed an engagement letter, with no look at whether its designated overseer is actually qualified, lets a rule citation stand in for the analysis. Reviews that clear each arrangement separately and never weigh them together miss the aggregate evaluation the framework calls for. Recommending that the firm resign the client, when a narrower change would restore independence, overshoots the facts.
Get an ACC-425 Topic 2 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-425 Topic 2 instructions, your rubric and the engagement facts or case your section provided. We write a custom example to them, with every arrangement registered, its threat named and weighed, safeguards matched to threats, the aggregate judged and the required change stated, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one costs nothing.
More ACC 425 papers and BS in Accounting samples
- ACC 425 Topic 1: Public Interest Obligation Essay
- ACC 425 Topic 3: Subordination of Judgment Case
- ACC 425 Topic 4: Estimate Bias Decision Case
- ACC 425 Topic 5: Withdrawal Threshold Dq
- ACC 425 Topic 6: Confidentiality Conflict Analysis
- ACC 425 Topic 7: Disagreement Documentation Memo
- ACC 425 Topic 8: Personal Ethics Commitment Paper
- ACC 371 Topic 2: Year-end Accrual Schedule
- ACC 370 Topic 2: Receivables and Revenue Recognition Problem
- ACC 361 Topic 2: Cash Budget Shortfall Analysis
- ACC 240 Topic 2: Journal to Trial Balance Trace
ACC 425 Topic 2 questions, answered
What is the conceptual framework approach to independence?
It is the method the AICPA Code uses where no specific rule settles a situation. The member identifies threats to independence, evaluates how significant each is, and applies safeguards that eliminate the threat or reduce it to an acceptable level. If no safeguard is adequate, the member declines or ends the engagement. Specific prohibitions, such as a direct financial interest in an attest client, apply regardless of safeguards.
Can a firm audit a client and also prepare its financial statements?
For private company clients under the AICPA Code, generally yes, provided the firm does not assume management responsibilities and the client designates an individual with suitable skill, knowledge and experience to oversee the services and accept responsibility for the results. Public company auditors face much stricter limits, since federal law prohibits many nonaudit services outright. The example turns on the designated individual, which is where these arrangements usually fail.
Does long partner tenure impair independence?
It creates a familiarity threat that the firm has to evaluate and, where the threat is significant, address. For public company audits, federal rules require the lead partner to rotate on a fixed schedule. For a private company client, the firm weighs the threat under the conceptual framework, and rotating the partner or adding a second partner's review are common responses. The review weighs tenure alongside the fee concentration rather than on its own.
Where can I find a free ACC 425 Topic 2 sample paper?
The complete review sits above, with the approach, the arrangements table, fees, statement preparation and payroll, partner tenure, unpaid fees, the staff auditor's spouse and recommendations. Share your client arrangements for a free worked review.
Why is the nonattest service a problem in ACC 425 Topic 2?
The client designated a sales manager with no accounting background to oversee it, so management cannot take responsibility for the work as the Code requires.