ACC 425 Topic 7 disagreement documentation memo example

Ethics in Accounting Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This ACC 425 Topic 7 sample paper is a disagreement documentation memo, dated and addressed to the engagement file, on whether a client's reserve for incurred but unreported health claims is understated. It was prepared for GCU ACC 425, Ethics in Accounting, catalog code ACC-425, in the Grand Canyon University BS in Accounting program. The actuary's $900,000 estimate is set beside the senior's $1,150,000 recalculation from the client's own claims lag data. Both positions appear in their strongest form, the consultation with a second partner is recorded with dates, and the resolution, a $100,000 adjustment and a note on remaining uncertainty, closes with the senior's own view and follow-up for next year.

CourseACC 425 Ethics in Accounting
TopicTopic 7
Paper typeDisagreement documentation memo
LengthAbout 770 words, 1 pages
FormatMemo with APA 7 references
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramBS in Accounting
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for ACC 425 Topic 7

1

Memorandum

To: Engagement file, Northgate Manufacturing audit, year ended December 31

From: [Author Name], audit senior

Date: February 18

Re: Difference of opinion on the reserve for incurred but unreported health claims

 

Issue

Whether Northgate Manufacturing's reserve for incurred but unreported health claims under its self-insured employee health plan, recorded at $900,000 based on its actuary's estimate, is understated. All figures are illustrative.

Facts

Northgate self-insures employee health benefits and records a reserve for claims incurred by year end but not yet reported or paid. The company's consulting actuary estimated the reserve at $900,000, using industry lag factors applied to the last three months of paid claims.

I recalculated the reserve using Northgate's own claims lag data, the history of how long its claims take to be paid after the service date, for the past 36 months. Northgate's claims have been paid more slowly than the industry factors assume since the plan changed third-party administrators in March. Applying Northgate's own lag pattern to the same paid claims gives a reserve of $1,150,000. The difference is $250,000, against overall materiality of $600,000 and a clearly trivial threshold of $30,000.

Positions

My position: the reserve should reflect Northgate's own claims experience, which is the most relevant evidence available. The administrator change has slowed payment, and industry factors that assume faster payment understate the claims still outstanding at year end. Auditing standards require the auditor to evaluate whether the methods, assumptions and data management used are appropriate in the context of the entity's circumstances (American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, 2020).

The engagement manager's position, stated as the manager would state it: the actuary is a qualified specialist, the industry method is widely used and was applied consistently with prior years, and nine months of data after an administrator change may reflect a temporary backlog rather than a lasting pattern. The difference is below materiality. The manager did not dispute my calculation, only whether Northgate's recent lag was the right basis.

Consultation

On February 12 the engagement partner referred the matter to a second partner, Dana Whitfield, who has no role on the engagement and heads the firm's employee benefits practice. Whitfield reviewed the actuary's report, my recalculation and the administrator's processing reports on February 14. The conclusion, discussed with the engagement team on February 15: Northgate's lag has lengthened but was improving by the fourth quarter as the new administrator cleared its backlog; the appropriate estimate lies between the two figures; and the actuary should be asked to reflect Northgate's own recent experience, weighted toward the fourth quarter. The firm's policy requires differences of opinion to be resolved through consultation and documented, and the report not to be dated until they are (American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, 2022).

Resolution

The actuary revised the estimate on February 17 to $1,000,000, using Northgate's fourth-quarter lag experience. Management accepted a $100,000 adjustment, increasing the reserve and employee benefits expense. The revised estimate is within a range the team considers reasonable. Some uncertainty remains: if the slower lag persists, actual claims may exceed the reserve by up to about $150,000, which the team will evaluate as a subsequent event if claims paid before the report date indicate a larger shortfall, and which management has agreed to describe in the notes as an estimate subject to change.

Follow-Up for Next Year

Next year's team should obtain the claims paid in the first quarter after year end and compare them with this reserve, which will show whether the lag pattern held. It should also ask the actuary, at the planning stage, to use Northgate's own claims history as the primary basis and industry factors only where Northgate's data is thin, and to explain any difference between the two. If the administrator's processing times have returned to normal, the difference between methods should narrow, and a repeat of this disagreement becomes unlikely.

My View of the Resolution

I agree that $1,000,000 is within a reasonable range and that the consultation addressed the question I raised. My original estimate of $1,150,000 remains, in my view, the better point estimate, but I accept that the fourth-quarter improvement is evidence I weighted too lightly, and the difference that remains, $150,000, is below materiality and is not the result of an unsupported assumption. I am prepared to sign the workpaper for this area. This memo is placed in the file so that a reviewer can see the issue, both positions, the consultation and the resolution in one place, and so that next year's team starts with this year's evidence on the lag pattern. Documenting a disagreement fully, rather than only its outcome, is part of exercising professional skepticism rather than simply deferring to seniority (Nelson, 2009).

References

American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. (2020). Auditing accounting estimates and related disclosures (Statement on Auditing Standards No. 143). AICPA.

American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. (2022). Quality management for an engagement conducted in accordance with generally accepted auditing standards (Statement on Auditing Standards No. 146). AICPA.

Nelson, M. W. (2009). A model and literature review of professional skepticism in auditing. Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory, 28(2), 1-34. https://doi.org/10.2308/aud.2009.28.2.1

Reading the GCU ACC 425 Topic 7 instructions

ACC-425 Topic 7 asks students to document a professional disagreement. Many memos record only the outcome. The assignment rewards memos addressed to the engagement file that state the issue in one sentence, set out the facts with figures, present each position in its strongest form and record any consultation with its date and conclusion. Students should describe the resolution and the uncertainty that remains, state their own view of the resolution honestly, note follow-up for the next period and explain why complete documentation supports professional skepticism.

Inside the ACC 425 Topic 7 example

The memo is short, dated the day it was written, and addressed to the engagement file rather than to a person. It states the issue in one sentence: whether the client's reserve for incurred but unreported health claims is understated. The facts follow, figures illustrative: the actuary's estimate of $900,000, the senior's recalculation of $1,150,000 from the client's own claims lag data, and the $250,000 between them. Each position is then set out in its strongest form, including the manager's reasons for accepting the actuary. The consultation with a second partner is recorded with its date and its conclusion. The resolution, a $100,000 adjustment the client accepted and a note on remaining uncertainty, closes the substance. A final paragraph records the senior's view that the adjustment was too small, stated without comment on anyone's motives.

ACC 425 Topic 7 rubric: what Excellent looks like

GCU's rubric for the disagreement memo rewards a record a reviewer could rely on. Excellent memos state both positions fairly, including the reasons for the view the writer did not hold. Credit goes to dating the consultation and recording its reasoning, not only its outcome. The rubric values describing remaining uncertainty and how it will be monitored. The highest level closes with the writer's own view of the resolution and practical follow-up for next year. Memos that record only the final adjustment usually land in a middle band.

ACC 425 Topic 7 help before you submit

Documentation memos lose credit for what they leave out and for what they put in. Omitting the consultation date, the documents reviewed or the name of the partner consulted leaves a record a later reviewer cannot use, and audit documentation standards expect an experienced auditor with no prior connection to the engagement to follow it. Memos written as advocacy, with the manager's reasons summarized dismissively, read as grievance and lose the credibility the record exists to provide. Speculating about the manager's motives is a common and costly addition. Papers that treat documentation as a formality, written after the decision and separate from it, miss the topic's argument that writing the record is itself a decision. A memo backdated to the day of the meeting, or edited after the file closed without a dated note, turns a record into a problem.

Get an ACC-425 Topic 7 example written to your instructions

Send the ACC-425 Topic 7 instructions, the rubric from your classroom and the case your section is working. We write a custom example to them, with the issue stated in one sentence, every figure tied to its source, both positions recorded fairly, the consultation reconstructable and any remaining dissent preserved, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More ACC 425 papers and BS in Accounting samples

ACC 425 Topic 7 questions, answered

Why write down a disagreement that has been resolved?

Because the resolution is only as defensible as the record behind it. A reviewer, a regulator or a court looking at the file years later sees only what was written at the time. A resolved dispute with no record looks like a dispute that never happened, and one recorded after the fact looks like a story assembled for an audience. The memo protects the client and the firm as much as the senior.

Can the memo be changed after the file is closed?

Audit documentation standards generally prohibit deleting or discarding documentation after the file is assembled, and they require any later addition to record when it was made, by whom and why. Federal law adopted after the corporate scandals of the early 2000s also makes destroying or altering records to obstruct an investigation a serious crime. The example includes its own dating convention for exactly this reason.

Should the memo say what the senior thinks of the manager's judgment?

Only in professional terms, and only about the judgment. The memo records that the senior considers the adjustment too small and why, citing the recalculation. It does not describe the manager as careless, pressured or conflicted, because those are claims about a person the memo cannot support, and they make the whole record look partisan. A reader should finish the memo knowing the disagreement, not the office politics.

Where can I find a free ACC 425 Topic 7 sample paper?

This page holds the complete memo: the issue, facts, positions, consultation, resolution, follow-up for next year and the senior's view of the resolution. Tell us your disagreement for a free worked memo.

How was the disagreement resolved in ACC 425 Topic 7?

After consultation, the actuary revised the estimate to $1,000,000 using the client's fourth-quarter lag experience, and management accepted a $100,000 adjustment.