| Course | ACC 460 Taxation |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 1 |
| Paper type | Tax authority ranking memo |
| Length | About 880 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 460 Topic 1
Memorandum
To: Tax manager
From: [Author Name], tax associate
Date: [Date]
Re: Ranking the authorities in the file on the section 183 issue for the Reyes return
The Issue
The client, a composite taxpayer, has operated an alpaca-breeding activity for five years and reported a loss each year. The question is whether the activity is engaged in for profit, so that its losses may offset other income, or is an activity not engaged in for profit under section 183, in which case the losses are limited. The file contains seven sources gathered by the preparer last year. Before analyzing the issue, this memo ranks them, because the conclusion can rest only on sources that carry authority.
The Sources Ranked
Table 1 lists each source, who issued it, its level in the hierarchy of tax authority and whom it binds.
Table 1
Sources in the File, by Authority
| Source in the file | Issued by | Level | Binds |
|---|---|---|---|
| Section 183 of the Internal Revenue Code | Congress | Statute: primary authority | Everyone: the IRS, the taxpayer and the courts |
| Treasury Regulation § 1.183-2, listing nine profit-motive factors | Treasury Department | Final regulation: primary authority | The IRS and taxpayers; courts apply it unless it conflicts with the statute |
| A revenue ruling on a horse-breeding activity | IRS | Administrative guidance | The IRS, for taxpayers with substantially the same facts; not courts |
| Dreicer v. Commissioner | U.S. Tax Court | Judicial: primary authority | Precedent in the Tax Court |
| Nickerson v. Commissioner | Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals | Judicial: primary authority | Courts within the Seventh Circuit |
| IRS Publication 525 | IRS | Informal guidance | No one: not authority |
| A tax blog post on hobby losses | Private author | None | No one |
The Statute Controls
Section 183 is the starting point and the final word on what the law requires. It limits deductions for an activity not engaged in for profit and creates a presumption that an activity is engaged in for profit if it produces a profit in at least three of five consecutive years, or two of seven for activities that consist mainly of breeding, training, showing or racing horses (Activities Not Engaged in for Profit, 2018). The client's activity has produced no profitable years, so the presumption does not help, and the question must be answered on the facts.
The Regulation Supplies the Test
The Treasury regulation under section 183 lists nine factors used to determine whether an activity is engaged in for profit, including the manner in which the taxpayer carries on the activity, the expertise of the taxpayer or advisers, the time and effort expended, the history of income or losses and the taxpayer's financial status (Activities Not Engaged in for Profit, 2024). A final regulation has the force of law and binds the IRS and taxpayers. Courts apply it unless it departs from the statute, and since the Supreme Court's 2024 decision ending judicial deference to agency interpretations of ambiguous statutes, courts decide for themselves what a statute means rather than deferring to the agency's reading (Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo, 2024). That change does not unsettle this regulation, which has been applied for decades without challenge, but it is the reason the statute, not the regulation, sits at the top.
Revenue Ruling and Court Decisions
The revenue ruling in the file concerns a horse-breeding activity. Revenue rulings bind the IRS in cases with substantially the same facts and may be relied on by taxpayers in that position, but they do not bind courts, and a ruling on horses applies to alpacas only by analogy. It is useful for understanding the IRS's view, not decisive.
Court decisions are primary authority, but their weight depends on the forum. Dreicer v. Commissioner, a Tax Court decision, holds that the test is whether the taxpayer had an actual and honest objective of making a profit, not whether the expectation was reasonable (Dreicer v. Commissioner, 1982). Nickerson v. Commissioner, from the Seventh Circuit, reversed a finding against taxpayers who were restoring a dairy farm, emphasizing that a start-up period of losses does not show the absence of a profit motive (Nickerson v. Commissioner, 1983). The Tax Court follows the decisions of the court of appeals to which a case would be appealed (Golsen v. Commissioner, 1970). The client lives in Ohio, within the Sixth Circuit, so Nickerson is persuasive but not binding on the Tax Court in the client's case.
Publication and Blog Post
IRS Publication 525 explains how hobby income is reported and is helpful for understanding current treatment. It is not authority; the IRS is not bound by its publications, and a taxpayer who relies on one has no defense if it is wrong. The blog post has no authority at all. It argues that alpaca breeders almost always win section 183 cases, citing no decisions, and it should be removed from the file so that no one relies on it.
What This Means for the Analysis
The analysis should apply the nine factors from the regulation to the client's facts, drawing on Dreicer for the standard and on Nickerson and other decisions for how courts weigh start-up losses, and noting the Sixth Circuit's position if it has addressed the issue. The revenue ruling can be cited as the IRS's view. The publication may be mentioned for reporting mechanics. The conclusion must rest on the statute, the regulation and the case law, and the memo should say so.
References
Activities Not Engaged in for Profit, 26 C.F.R. § 1.183-2 (2024).
Activities Not Engaged in for Profit, 26 U.S.C. § 183 (2018).
Dreicer v. Commissioner, 78 T.C. 642 (1982).
Golsen v. Commissioner, 54 T.C. 742 (1970).
Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo, 603 U.S. 369 (2024).
Nickerson v. Commissioner, 700 F.2d 402 (7th Cir. 1983).
The ACC-460 Topic 1 assignment instructions
ACC-460 opens with Topic 1, where students evaluate sources of tax authority. Many papers list the sources without ranking them. The assignment rewards memos that identify who issued each source, where it sits in the hierarchy of primary and secondary authority and whom it binds: the IRS, the taxpayer or a court. Students should explain why the statute controls, what force regulations and revenue rulings carry, how the weight of a court decision depends on its forum and the taxpayer's circuit, and which informal sources a preparer may read but must not rely on.
How the ACC-460 Topic 1 example is put together
The finished memo is addressed to a tax manager and runs to about two pages. Its first table lists the six sources already in the file: section 183 of the Internal Revenue Code, the Treasury regulation under it that sets out nine profit-motive factors, a revenue ruling, two court decisions from different forums, an IRS publication and a tax blog post. Each row gives the issuing body, the level it sits at and whether it binds the IRS, the taxpayer or a court. The memo then explains the ordering in prose: the statute controls, a final regulation carries the force of law unless it departs from the statute, and a publication is guidance a preparer may read but cannot rely on. The blog post survives only as a pointer to primary sources. The hobby question itself is left open.
ACC 460 Topic 1 rubric: what Excellent looks like
GCU's rubric for the authority memo rewards binding force explained. Excellent memos place the statute at the top, explain that final regulations have the force of law and note how courts interpret statutes independently. Credit goes to recognizing that revenue rulings bind the IRS but not courts, and that the Tax Court follows the taxpayer's circuit. The rubric values excluding publications and commentary as authority. The highest level shows how the ranking shapes the analysis that follows. Memos that treat an IRS publication or a blog as authority usually lose marks.
ACC 460 Topic 1 help: mistakes that cost marks
Treating every source in the file as equally weighty is what sinks most versions of this memo. A paper that quotes an IRS publication as though it settled the question has cited a document the IRS itself does not treat as binding. Placing a revenue ruling above the regulation inverts the order the course expects, and explaining why the ruling might still matter on its facts usually separates the stronger papers. Court decisions listed without their forum lose marks, since a Tax Court memorandum decision and a circuit opinion differ in reach. Memos that answer the hobby question instead of ranking the sources have done a later topic's work and skipped this one. Inconsistent citation form also costs credit in many sections, since a table mixing section numbers with page titles cannot be checked quickly.
Get an ACC-460 Topic 1 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-460 Topic 1 instructions, the rubric from your classroom and the research question or source list your section assigned. We write a custom example to them, with each source placed by issuer and weight and the ordering explained in prose, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free, and it is coursework support rather than tax advice.
More ACC 460 papers and BS in Accounting samples
- ACC 460 Topic 2: Gross Income Inclusion Schedule
- ACC 460 Topic 3: Exclusion Eligibility Analysis
- ACC 460 Topic 4: Deduction Test Analysis
- ACC 460 Topic 5: Avoidance and Evasion Dq Post
- ACC 460 Topic 6: Basis and Gain Computation
- ACC 460 Topic 7: Individual Return Workpaper
- ACC 460 Topic 8: Return Position Research Memo
- ACC 425 Topic 1: Public Interest Obligation Essay
- ACC 371 Topic 1: Liability Definition Test Memo
- ACC 370 Topic 1: Conceptual Framework Case Memo
- ACC 240 Topic 1: Transaction Analysis Worksheet
ACC 460 Topic 1 questions, answered
Is an IRS publication a source of authority?
Not in the sense a return position needs. Publications explain the IRS's reading of the law in plain language and are useful for orientation, but the IRS does not treat them as binding on itself, and courts have declined to treat them as authority. A memo can mention one as a starting point and then cite the Code section, regulation or ruling that actually supports the treatment.
Why does the forum of a court decision matter?
Because reach differs. A Supreme Court decision binds every court. A circuit court's decision binds the courts within that circuit. The Tax Court hears cases from taxpayers everywhere and follows the precedent of the circuit to which a particular case would be appealed, so the same issue can come out differently for taxpayers in different places. A ranking memo notes the forum of each decision before relying on it.
Should the memo answer the hobby question too?
Usually not at this stage. The point of an opening topic in many sections is to establish which sources may be cited and in what order, so the eventual answer rests on the right foundation. If the assignment does ask for a preliminary view, keep it short, label it tentative and tie it to the section 183 factors rather than to the blog post.
Where can I find a free ACC 460 Topic 1 sample paper?
Scroll up for the complete memo: the issue, the ranked sources, the statute, the regulation, the revenue ruling and court decisions, the publication and blog post, and what it means for the analysis. Describe your tax issue for a free worked memo.
Why is the Seventh Circuit case not binding in ACC 460 Topic 1?
The client lives in the Sixth Circuit, and the Tax Court follows the court of appeals to which the case would be appealed, so the Seventh Circuit decision is only persuasive.