| Course | ACC 460 Taxation |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 3 |
| Paper type | Exclusion eligibility analysis |
| Length | About 960 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 460 Topic 3
Five Receipts, Five Tests: Which of Riley Park's $223,200 Escapes Gross Income, Condition by Condition
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
ACC-460: Taxation
Topic 3 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Five Receipts, Five Tests: Which of Riley Park's $223,200 Escapes Gross Income, Condition by Condition
The Starting Point
Gross income includes every accession to wealth unless a specific provision excludes it. An exclusion is therefore something a taxpayer must qualify for, one condition at a time. Riley Park, a composite taxpayer and graduate student, received five items during the year that might be excluded. This analysis pairs each receipt with the section that might exclude it, lists that section's conditions and checks them. All amounts are illustrative.
The Analysis
Table 1 summarizes each receipt, the section tested, the conditions and the result.
Table 1
Exclusion Eligibility
| Receipt | Amount | Section tested | Conditions checked | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Life insurance paid on a parent's death | $150,000 | 101(a) | Paid under a life insurance contract; paid by reason of death; no transfer for value | Excluded |
| Settlement for injuries in a car accident | 40,000 | 104(a)(2) | Damages received on account of personal physical injuries | Excluded |
| Settlement of an employment dispute, emotional distress only | 12,000 | 104(a)(2) | No physical injury or physical sickness | Included |
| Scholarship, tuition and required fees | 9,500 | 117(a) and (b) | Degree candidate; used for qualified tuition and related expenses | Excluded |
| Scholarship, room and board | 4,500 | 117(b) | Room and board are not qualified tuition and related expenses | Included |
| Employer-paid health coverage premiums | 7,200 | 106(a) | Employer-provided coverage under an accident or health plan | Excluded |
| Totals | $206,700 excluded; $16,500 included |
Life Insurance
Riley received $150,000 as beneficiary of a life insurance policy on a parent. Section 101(a) excludes amounts received under a life insurance contract if paid by reason of the death of the insured (Certain Death Benefits, 2018). Both conditions are met. One further condition matters: the exclusion is limited if the policy was transferred for valuable consideration, the transfer-for-value rule. Riley was named beneficiary when the parent bought the policy and did not buy it, so the rule does not apply, and the full $150,000 is excluded. Any interest paid on the proceeds after death, had the insurer held them, would be taxable.
The Two Settlements
Section 104(a)(2) excludes damages received on account of personal physical injuries or physical sickness (Compensation for Injuries or Sickness, 2018). Riley received $40,000 in settlement of claims for a broken wrist and back injuries from a car accident. The damages were received on account of physical injuries, so they are excluded, including the portion attributable to pain and suffering, because it flows from the physical injury.
The $12,000 settlement of an employment dispute is different. Riley claimed only emotional distress from a supervisor's treatment; there was no physical injury or physical sickness. The statute states that emotional distress is not treated as a physical injury or physical sickness, except for amounts paid for medical care attributable to it. Riley had no such medical expenses, so the full $12,000 is included. The Supreme Court had already narrowed the exclusion before the word physical was added, holding that damages must be received on account of personal injury to qualify (Commissioner v. Schleier, 1995); the later amendment narrowed it further.
The Scholarship
Riley's university awarded a $14,000 scholarship. Section 117 excludes a qualified scholarship received by a degree candidate, but only to the extent it is used for qualified tuition and related expenses: tuition, fees and books, supplies and equipment required for courses (Qualified Scholarships, 2018). The scholarship paid $9,500 of tuition and required fees, which is excluded. The remaining $4,500 paid for room and board, which are not qualified expenses, so that amount is included in gross income. The scholarship did not require Riley to teach or do research in return; if it had, the portion representing payment for services would be taxable regardless of use.
Employer Health Coverage
Riley's part-time employer paid $7,200 of premiums for Riley's health coverage. Section 106(a) excludes employer-provided coverage under an accident or health plan from the employee's gross income (Contributions by Employer to Accident and Health Plans, 2018). The premiums are excluded, and so are benefits Riley receives from the plan for medical care.
Facts That Would Change a Result
Several variations would change the answers, and a preparer should ask about each. If the car accident settlement had included punitive damages, that portion would be taxable, because punitive damages are not received on account of the injury itself but to punish the defendant. If it had included an amount for lost wages, that amount would still be excluded, since it is received on account of the physical injury. If the life insurance had been paid in installments rather than a lump sum, the portion of each payment representing interest would be taxable. If the employment settlement had included reimbursement for therapy costs, that portion would be excluded as medical care attributable to emotional distress.
For the health coverage, it does not matter whether the employer pays the premiums directly or Riley pays part of them through a cafeteria plan with pretax salary reductions; in both cases the coverage is excluded. It would matter if Riley bought individual coverage and the employer simply reimbursed the premiums outside a qualifying arrangement, which could make the reimbursement taxable.
Result
Of $223,200 received, $206,700 is excluded and $16,500, the employment settlement and the room and board portion of the scholarship, is included in gross income. The two receipts that fail do so on a single condition each: the absence of physical injury and the use of scholarship funds for living costs. Riley's records should include the settlement agreements, which describe the claims settled, and the university's statement showing how the scholarship was applied, since both determinations rest on those documents.
The label on a receipt is never the test. A settlement is excluded or included according to the claim it resolves, and a scholarship according to what it pays for. That is why the analysis lists conditions rather than categories.
References
Certain Death Benefits, 26 U.S.C. § 101 (2018).
Commissioner v. Schleier, 515 U.S. 323 (1995).
Compensation for Injuries or Sickness, 26 U.S.C. § 104 (2018).
Contributions by Employer to Accident and Health Plans, 26 U.S.C. § 106 (2018).
Qualified Scholarships, 26 U.S.C. § 117 (2018).
Reading the GCU ACC 460 Topic 3 instructions
ACC-460 Topic 3 asks students to determine whether receipts qualify for exclusion from gross income. Many papers exclude items by category. The assignment rewards analyses that pair each receipt with the section that might exclude it, list that section's conditions and check each against the facts. Students should distinguish physical injury settlements from emotional distress settlements, split scholarships between qualified expenses and living costs, address rules such as transfer for value and explain how different facts, such as punitive damages or installment payments, would change the results.
How this ACC 460 Topic 3 example is built
The finished analysis takes one illustrative taxpayer and five receipts: $150,000 of life insurance paid on a parent's death, a $40,000 settlement for injuries suffered in a car accident, a $12,000 settlement of an employment dispute for emotional distress alone, a $14,000 scholarship, and $7,200 of health coverage premiums the employer paid. Each receipt is paired with the section that might exclude it, and that section's conditions are listed and checked one at a time. Life insurance, health coverage and the accident settlement pass. The employment settlement fails, because section 104(a)(2) reaches physical injury and physical sickness only. The scholarship splits: $9,500 of tuition and required fees is excluded under section 117, while the $4,500 housing allowance is included. A final table separates $206,700 excluded from $16,500 included.
ACC 460 Topic 3 rubric: what Excellent looks like
GCU's rubric for the exclusion analysis rewards conditions checked one at a time. Excellent analyses exclude life insurance and physical injury settlements and explain why emotional distress alone does not qualify. Credit goes to splitting a scholarship between tuition and room and board. The rubric values addressing related rules, such as the medical care exception and the transfer-for-value rule, and citing case law on the injury requirement. The highest level shows which facts would change each result and which documents support them. Analyses that exclude every settlement as personal injury usually lose marks.
Common ACC 460 Topic 3 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Losing marks here usually starts with treating every receipt that feels like a windfall as excludable. Papers that exclude the emotional distress settlement because it resolved a genuine harm have skipped the physical injury condition, and that condition is the entire test. The scholarship is the second trap: excluding the full $14,000 ignores that section 117 covers tuition and required fees only, while including all of it ignores that the exclusion applies at all. Life insurance excluded without a citation to section 101 earns less than it should, since the conclusion is right and the authority is missing. Policy explanations that praise an exclusion without tying its purpose to its boundary add length and no analysis. Tables that list excluded items without the conditions checked give a marker nothing to verify, even when the totals are correct.
Get an ACC-460 Topic 3 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-460 Topic 3 instructions with your rubric and the receipts or scenario your section was given. The custom example is written to them: each item tested against the conditions of the provision that might exclude it, split items shown on both sides, and the policy behind each exclusion explained, in 24 to 48 hours. First one free.
More ACC 460 papers and BS in Accounting samples
- ACC 460 Topic 1: Tax Authority Ranking Memo
- ACC 460 Topic 2: Gross Income Inclusion Schedule
- ACC 460 Topic 4: Deduction Test Analysis
- ACC 460 Topic 5: Avoidance and Evasion Dq Post
- ACC 460 Topic 6: Basis and Gain Computation
- ACC 460 Topic 7: Individual Return Workpaper
- ACC 460 Topic 8: Return Position Research Memo
- ACC 425 Topic 3: Subordination of Judgment Case
- ACC 371 Topic 3: Effective Interest Amortization Schedule
- ACC 370 Topic 3: Cost Flow and Write-down Problem
- ACC 240 Topic 3: Accrual Adjustment Schedule
ACC 460 Topic 3 questions, answered
Why is an emotional distress settlement usually taxable?
Because section 104(a)(2) excludes damages received on account of personal physical injuries or physical sickness, and emotional distress alone is not treated as either. Amounts paid for medical care attributable to emotional distress receive separate treatment, which a paper would note if the facts supplied them. The origin of the claim decides the result, so the analysis reads the settlement's purpose rather than its label.
Is employer-paid health coverage really not income?
Correct, when it is coverage under an employer's accident or health plan. Section 106 excludes the premiums the employer pays, even though they are plainly part of what the employee receives for working. The exclusion reflects a long-standing policy of encouraging coverage through employment. Cash paid instead of coverage is a different matter and is generally wages, which the analysis would treat separately.
Should a paper explain the policy behind each exclusion?
Where the assignment asks, yes, and briefly. The value of the policy explanation is that it accounts for the boundary: knowing that the scholarship exclusion supports the cost of education explains why it stops short of housing. A paragraph praising an exclusion without that link rarely earns credit. The citation and the conditions still carry most of the marks in current classrooms.
Where can I find a free ACC 460 Topic 3 sample paper?
The whole analysis appears here, with the starting point, the summary table, life insurance, the two settlements, the scholarship, employer health coverage, facts that would change a result and the result. Send your receipts for a free worked analysis.
Why is the employment settlement taxable in ACC 460 Topic 3?
It compensated emotional distress only, and section 104(a)(2) excludes damages only for physical injury or physical sickness, apart from amounts for related medical care.