| Course | ACC 465 Taxation II |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 1 |
| Paper type | Entity income flow comparison |
| Length | About 960 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 465 Topic 1
One $200,000 Profit Through Three Entity Forms: Where the Tax Falls, and When
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
ACC-465: Taxation II
Topic 1 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
One $200,000 Profit Through Three Entity Forms: Where the Tax Falls, and When
Assumptions
A composite equipment rental business earns $200,000 of taxable profit a year and has two equal owners. The comparison uses labeled assumptions throughout: each owner pays an illustrative 24% on ordinary income and 15% on qualified dividends; the corporate rate is the flat 21% in section 11 (Tax Imposed, 2018); and the qualified business income deduction available to some owners of pass-through businesses is set aside so that the difference between forms can be seen clearly. Payroll and self-employment taxes are noted but not added to the totals, because they depend on salary decisions examined separately. Two panels follow: one where all profit is distributed, and one where it stays in the business.
Panel 1: Profit Distributed
Table 1
Income Tax When All Profit Is Distributed
| Profit distributed in full, $200,000 | Partnership | S corporation | C corporation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Entity-level income tax | $0: section 701 | $0: section 1366 passes income through | $42,000 at 21%: section 11 |
| Income reported by the two owners | $200,000 as distributive shares | $200,000 as pass-through income | $158,000 as qualified dividends |
| Owner-level income tax | $48,000 at 24% | $48,000 at 24% | $23,700 at 15% |
| Total income tax | $48,000 | $48,000 | $65,700 |
| Where the forms differ further | Self-employment tax on each partner's share | Payroll tax on reasonable salaries only | Payroll tax on any salaries paid |
Reading Panel 1
A partnership is not subject to income tax; its partners are taxed on their distributive shares of its income, whether or not it is distributed (Partners, Not Partnership, Subject to Tax, 2018). Each owner reports $100,000, and at 24% the two owners pay $48,000 in total.
An S corporation reaches the same income tax result by a different path. Section 1366 passes its income through to shareholders, who report their pro rata shares (Pass-Thru of Items to Shareholders, 2018). Each owner again reports $100,000, and the total is again $48,000. The difference between the two flow-through forms lies outside income tax: partners generally owe self-employment tax on their share of trade or business income, while S corporation shareholders who work in the business owe payroll tax only on reasonable salaries, not on the rest of the profit.
A C corporation is a separate taxpayer. It pays $42,000 at 21%, leaving $158,000. When that is distributed, the owners report it as qualified dividends and pay 15%, $23,700. Total income tax is $65,700, $17,700 more than the flow-through forms. The same profit is taxed twice, once at each level (Tax Imposed, 2018).
Panel 2: Profit Retained
Table 2
Income Tax When Profit Is Kept in the Business
| Profit retained in the business, $200,000 | Partnership | S corporation | C corporation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tax this year | $48,000, owners taxed whether or not cash is distributed | $48,000, same | $42,000 at the corporate level only |
| Cash left in the business after tax | $152,000 if owners pay their tax from it | $152,000 | $158,000 |
| Tax when the retained profit is later distributed | None: already taxed | None: already taxed | $23,700 as dividends, deferred |
Reading Panel 2
If the business keeps its profit to buy equipment, the ranking changes for the current year. Partners and S corporation shareholders are taxed on their shares whether or not they receive cash, so they owe $48,000 and must find the cash to pay it, often by drawing that much from the business. The C corporation pays only its $42,000. It keeps $158,000 to reinvest, $6,000 more than the flow-through forms keep after owners' taxes are paid.
The second layer of tax is deferred, not avoided. If the retained profit is distributed later, the owners will owe the $23,700. The longer the deferral and the higher the return on reinvested profit, the smaller that deferred tax becomes in present value. For a business that expects to reinvest for many years and eventually be sold, a C corporation's lower entity rate can outweigh the second tax; for one that distributes most of its profit, the flow-through forms are cheaper every year.
What the Comparison Leaves Out
Three factors could change the ranking and should be analyzed before any choice. The qualified business income deduction, where it applies, reduces the flow-through owners' effective rate and widens their advantage. Payroll and self-employment taxes, set aside here, favor the S corporation when owners take moderate salaries. And state taxes differ across forms, with some states taxing S corporations or partnerships at the entity level. The comparison isolates the federal income tax structure; a recommendation must add these back.
When the Business Loses Money
The panels assume a profit. In a loss year the forms diverge even more. A partnership's or S corporation's loss passes through to the owners, who can deduct it against other income to the extent of their basis and subject to the at-risk and passive activity limits. A C corporation's loss stays inside the corporation as a net operating loss carryforward, usable only against the corporation's own future profits, and gives the owners no current benefit. For a new business expecting early losses, that difference often outweighs everything in the two panels.
Why the Choice Is Rarely Made on Income Tax Alone
Owners choose a form for more than its tax. A limited liability company can be taxed as a partnership or elect S corporation status while giving its owners the same liability protection as a corporation, so liability is seldom the deciding factor today. Ownership flexibility often is: an S corporation may have only one class of stock and a limited number and type of shareholders, which can rule it out for a business that plans to raise outside capital. Exit plans matter too, because buyers of a business often prefer to buy assets, and the tax cost of an asset sale differs sharply between a C corporation and a flow-through entity. The income tax comparison above is the starting point for the decision, not the whole of it.
References
Partners, Not Partnership, Subject to Tax, 26 U.S.C. § 701 (2018).
Pass-Thru of Items to Shareholders, 26 U.S.C. § 1366 (2018).
Tax Imposed, 26 U.S.C. § 11 (2018).
What the ACC 465 Topic 1 instructions ask for
ACC-465 opens with Topic 1, where students compare how business entities are taxed. Many papers describe each form's rules without computing anything. The assignment rewards comparisons that fix one profit and one set of labeled assumptions, run the income through each form and show the tax at the entity and owner levels. Students should cite the provisions that make partnerships and S corporations flow-through and C corporations separate taxpayers, show how retention changes the result, address losses and state which factors, such as payroll taxes and the qualified business income deduction, the comparison sets aside.
How this ACC 465 Topic 1 example is built
The finished comparison runs on one set of labeled assumptions: $200,000 of taxable profit, two equal owners, an illustrative 24 percent owner rate on ordinary income and 15 percent on qualified dividends. Under a partnership, section 701 puts no tax on the entity and each owner reports a $100,000 share, $48,000 of tax in total. An S corporation reaches the same $48,000 through section 1366, with the difference sitting in payroll and self-employment tax. The C corporation pays $42,000 at the flat 21 percent rate in section 11, then distributes $158,000 that costs the owners a further $23,700, or $65,700 in all. A second panel assumes the profit stays in the business: the corporation's $42,000 now undercuts the $48,000 the flow-through owners owe whether or not any cash reaches them.
Reading the ACC 465 Topic 1 rubric
GCU's rubric for the entity comparison rewards the same facts through every form. Excellent comparisons compute entity-level and owner-level tax and show the double tax on distributed C corporation profit. Credit goes to a second panel showing that retaining profit defers the second tax rather than avoiding it. The rubric values noting how losses pass through only in flow-through forms. The highest level lists what the comparison leaves out and why the choice is rarely made on income tax alone. Comparisons with no stated assumptions usually land in a middle band.
ACC 465 Topic 1 help before you submit
Comparisons that list features, single taxation here and limited liability there, without computing anything are where this assignment most often slips. A marker wants the consequence of each feature traced to the owners' figures, and a table of adjectives cannot show that. Papers that compute the corporate tax and forget the second layer on distribution understate the corporate cost by $23,700 on these assumptions. Treating the S corporation as identical to the partnership misses the payroll and self-employment difference that usually drives the choice between them. Unstated assumptions make every figure unverifiable, and rates presented as current law without a year are marked as unsupported. Papers that stop at full distribution never reach the retention case, the most instructive result the facts allow. Limited liability comes from state law, and presenting it as a tax difference confuses two separate questions.
Get an ACC-465 Topic 1 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-465 Topic 1 instructions, your section's rubric and the business facts you were given. We write a custom example to them, following the same profit to the owners under each form with labeled assumptions, entity and owner layers computed, and the conditions that would change the ranking stated, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More ACC 465 papers and BS in Accounting samples
- ACC 465 Topic 2: Formation Basis Schedule
- ACC 465 Topic 3: Distribution Taxability Analysis
- ACC 465 Topic 4: Related Party Transaction Review
- ACC 465 Topic 5: Entity Stage Choice Dq Post
- ACC 465 Topic 6: Deferral Qualification Analysis
- ACC 465 Topic 7: Entity Recommendation Memo
- ACC 465 Topic 8: Loss Limitation Position Memo
- ACC 460 Topic 1: Tax Authority Ranking Memo
- ACC 425 Topic 1: Public Interest Obligation Essay
- ACC 240 Topic 1: Transaction Analysis Worksheet
- ACC 371 Topic 1: Liability Definition Test Memo
ACC 465 Topic 1 questions, answered
Why does the C corporation cost more in one panel and less in the other?
Because its second layer of tax arrives only when profit is distributed. With full distribution, the corporation's flat 21 percent plus the owners' dividend tax exceeds a single layer at owner rates. With profit retained, only the corporate layer applies, while partners and S shareholders are taxed on their shares either way. The example shows both panels so the effect of the distribution decision is visible.
Why are the owner rates labeled illustrative?
Individual brackets are indexed each year and depend on each owner's other income and filing status, so no single current rate applies to every reader. The example picks round rates, labels them and applies them consistently, so the mechanism stays in view. The corporate rate is different: section 11 sets it at a flat 21 percent, so the example states it as law.
Is this comparison a recommendation for a real business?
No. It is a coursework example on simplified facts, leaving out state taxes and several federal layers on purpose. A real entity choice turns on the owners' full circumstances, their plans for the business and current law, and belongs with a qualified adviser. What the example offers is a picture of a finished comparison that computes consequences rather than listing features.
Where can I find a free ACC 465 Topic 1 sample paper?
The full comparison is on this page: the assumptions, both panels and how to read them, what the comparison leaves out, loss years and why the choice is rarely made on income tax alone. Describe your business for a free worked comparison.
Why is the C corporation total higher in ACC 465 Topic 1?
Its profit is taxed at 21 percent when earned and again at 15 percent when distributed as dividends, so the same $200,000 bears $65,700 instead of $48,000.