| Course | ACC 465 Taxation II |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 7 |
| Paper type | Entity recommendation memo |
| Length | About 760 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 465 Topic 7
Memorandum
To: Morgan Lee, owner, Lee Engineering Consulting LLC
From: [Author Name]
Date: [Date]
Re: Whether to elect S corporation status for the LLC
Recommendation
Elect to have your LLC taxed as an S corporation beginning next tax year, pay yourself a salary of about $80,000 supported by comparable pay data, and take the remaining profit as distributions. At your current profit of $150,000, this should save about $6,454 a year in employment taxes after the added costs of running payroll and filing a separate return. The saving depends on the salary being defensible, and it disappears if profit falls to about $104,000. Figures are illustrative and use current rates; the wage base is indexed and is assumed not to limit the tax at these amounts.
Today: Self-Employment Tax
As a single-member LLC, you report the business on Schedule C and pay self-employment tax on your net earnings from self-employment, which are 92.35% of your net profit (Definitions, 2018). The tax rate is 15.3%, combining social security and Medicare (Rate of Tax, 2018). On $150,000 of profit, the tax is $21,194. Half of it is deductible in computing income tax, which the comparison sets aside because a similar deduction exists for the employer's share of payroll tax under an S corporation.
Under an S Corporation
An S corporation pays you wages, on which you and the corporation together pay payroll taxes at the same combined 15.3% rate, and distributes the remaining profit, which is not subject to employment tax. The saving comes from the part of the profit taken as distributions. Table 1 compares the two.
Table 1
Employment Tax, Sole Proprietorship and S Corporation
| Annual comparison at $150,000 of profit | Sole proprietorship | S corporation |
|---|---|---|
| Earnings subject to employment tax | $138,525: 92.35% of net earnings | $80,000 salary |
| Employment tax at 15.3% | $21,194 | $12,240 |
| Difference | $8,954 lower | |
| Added costs: payroll service, separate return, state fees | ($2,500) | |
| Net annual saving | $6,454 |
The Salary Is the Condition
The $80,000 salary is an assumption, and it is the part of this recommendation most likely to be challenged. The IRS expects S corporation officers who perform substantial services to be paid reasonable compensation before taking distributions (Internal Revenue Service, 2008). When owners have paid themselves too little, judges have sided with the IRS in treating part of the distributions as wages. In Watson v. United States, a shareholder who took a small salary and large distributions had a substantial part of the distributions treated as wages, based on what comparable professionals earned (Watson v. United States, 2012).
You perform all the engineering work and manage the business. The $80,000 should be supported by pay data for engineers with similar experience in your region, documented at the start of each year. Useful sources include salary surveys from professional engineering societies, government wage data for civil engineers in your metropolitan area and what you would have to pay to hire an engineer to do your work. Keep the sources with the payroll records. If the data points to a higher figure, the saving shrinks: at a salary of about $122,000, it disappears entirely.
Where the Saving Disappears
Table 2
Break-Even Points
| Where the saving disappears | Figure |
|---|---|
| Profit at which the saving is zero, with an $80,000 salary | About $104,300 |
| Salary at which the saving is zero, with $150,000 of profit | About $122,200 |
The election makes sense only while profit comfortably exceeds a reasonable salary plus the added costs. If your profit fell to about $104,000 with an $80,000 salary, the employment tax saving would just equal the $2,500 of added costs. Below that, the election would cost you money.
Why Not a C Corporation
A C corporation was considered and set aside. You draw most of the profit to live on. In a C corporation, profit paid out as dividends would be taxed first at the corporate rate and again to you, and paying it all as salary to avoid that would bring back the employment tax the S corporation avoids. A C corporation suits a business that retains most of its profit, which yours does not.
Other Effects to Weigh
Two further effects run the other way and should be reviewed with your tax preparer. Your salary will reduce the profit eligible for the qualified business income deduction, if you qualify for it, which can offset part of the saving. And paying less social security tax will reduce the earnings credited toward your future social security benefit. Neither changes the recommendation at your current profit, but both are reasons to revisit it each year. The election is made by filing Form 2553 within the first two months and fifteen days of the tax year for which it is to take effect.
References
Definitions, 26 U.S.C. § 1402 (2018).
Internal Revenue Service. (2008). Wage compensation for S corporation officers (Fact Sheet FS-2008-25). U.S. Department of the Treasury.
Rate of Tax, 26 U.S.C. § 1401 (2018).
Watson v. United States, 668 F.3d 1008 (8th Cir. 2012).
What the ACC 465 Topic 7 instructions ask for
ACC-465 Topic 7 asks students to recommend an entity form for a client. Many memos describe each form without reaching a recommendation. Strong memos state the recommendation up front, compute the tax effect under the current and proposed forms with labeled assumptions, and net the added costs of the new form. Students should explain the reasonable compensation condition and its support, solve for the profit and salary at which the benefit disappears, explain why other forms were set aside and note effects that run the other way.
How the ACC-465 Topic 7 example is put together
Its recommendation arrives in the memo's first paragraph, and the rest earns it. Self-employment tax on the current $150,000 profit is computed at the statutory 15.3 percent on 92.35 percent of net earnings, $21,194, with a note that the wage base is indexed and assumed not to bind. Under an S corporation, the memo assumes an $80,000 salary, labeled as an assumption to be supported by the owner's duties, and computes $12,240 of combined payroll tax. The difference, $8,954, is reduced by an illustrative $2,500 of added payroll and return costs to $6,454 a year. A C corporation is considered and set aside because the owner draws most of the profit to live on. The memo then solves for the profit at which savings equal costs, about $104,300 on the same assumptions.
Where the marks sit in the ACC 465 Topic 7 rubric
Faculty grading the recommendation memo reward a conclusion priced and conditioned. Excellent memos compute self-employment tax correctly and compare it with payroll tax on a defensible salary. Credit goes to treating the salary as an assumption supported by comparable pay, with guidance and case law. The rubric values break-even calculations and netting of added costs. The highest level addresses offsetting effects, such as the qualified business income deduction and future social security benefits, and the election mechanics. Memos that set salary at zero or ignore added costs usually land in a middle band.
ACC 465 Topic 7 help: mistakes that cost marks
Memos that recommend an S corporation because it saves payroll tax, and stop there, lose marks for describing a consequence instead of pricing it. The salary assumption is the next point of loss: papers that set wages unrealistically low to maximize the saving present a figure that reasonable compensation guidance would not support, and markers in many sections notice. Leaving out compliance costs overstates the benefit by the full cost of running payroll and filing a separate return. Papers that ignore the C corporation entirely give the owner no reason the alternative was rejected. A recommendation without a break-even point treats a result that depends on profit as permanent. Stating the Social Security wage base as a current figure with no year attached is marked as unsupported, and the 92.35 percent adjustment is often missed, which overstates self-employment tax.
Get an ACC-465 Topic 7 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-465 Topic 7 instructions, your rubric and the business and owner facts your section provided. We write a custom example to them, with the recommendation stated first, current and proposed structures priced row by row, assumptions labeled, the alternative rejected on figures and a break-even profit solved, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.
More ACC 465 papers and BS in Accounting samples
- ACC 465 Topic 1: Entity Income Flow Comparison
- ACC 465 Topic 2: Formation Basis Schedule
- ACC 465 Topic 3: Distribution Taxability Analysis
- ACC 465 Topic 4: Related Party Transaction Review
- ACC 465 Topic 5: Entity Stage Choice Dq Post
- ACC 465 Topic 6: Deferral Qualification Analysis
- ACC 465 Topic 8: Loss Limitation Position Memo
- ACC 460 Topic 7: Individual Return Workpaper
- ACC 425 Topic 7: Disagreement Documentation Memo
- ACC 240 Topic 7: Statement Assembly Problem
- ACC 371 Topic 7: Diluted Eps Computation
ACC 465 Topic 7 questions, answered
Where does the S corporation saving come from?
From the difference in employment taxes. A sole proprietor pays self-employment tax on essentially all net earnings from the business. An S corporation owner who works in the business pays payroll tax on wages but not on distributions of the remaining profit. The saving therefore depends on how much of the profit is paid as salary, which is why the salary assumption carries so much weight.
Why not choose the lowest possible salary?
Because an S corporation owner who performs services must be paid reasonable compensation for them, and IRS guidance and court decisions allow wages that are too low to be recharacterized, with the saving reversed and penalties possible. The memo labels its salary as an assumption to be supported by the owner's actual duties and time rather than chosen to produce the largest saving.
Why compute a break-even profit?
Because the recommendation depends on profit staying high enough to cover the election's fixed costs. The break-even figure tells the owner when the answer changes, which makes the recommendation useful beyond the year it was written. On the example's assumptions it is about $104,300; a different salary or cost estimate moves it, and the memo shows the formula, letting the owner measure the shift.
Where can I find a free ACC 465 Topic 7 sample paper?
This page holds the complete memo: the recommendation, today's self-employment tax, the S corporation comparison, the salary condition, break-even points, why not a C corporation and other effects. Tell us your business for a free worked memo.
When does the S corporation stop saving in ACC 465 Topic 7?
With an $80,000 salary, the employment tax saving just covers the $2,500 of added costs at about $104,300 of profit; below that it costs money.