| Course | ACC 465 Taxation II |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 8 |
| Paper type | Loss limitation position memo |
| Length | About 820 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 465 Topic 8
Memorandum
To: Dana Kim, shareholder, Kim Precision Tooling, Inc.
From: [Author Name]
Date: [Date]
Re: How much of the corporation's loss you can deduct this year
Your Position
Kim Precision Tooling, an S corporation you own entirely, will report a $90,000 loss this year after a slow period and new equipment costs. Your position is that the full $90,000 should be deductible on your return, because in addition to your $30,000 of stock basis you personally guaranteed the corporation's $100,000 bank loan. This memo tests that position against the limits in the order the Code applies them: basis, then amount at risk, then the passive activity rules. All figures are illustrative.
Basis Comes First
A shareholder may deduct pass-through losses only up to the sum of the shareholder's stock basis and the basis of any debt the corporation owes to the shareholder; losses beyond that are suspended and carried forward to future years (Pass-Thru of Items to Shareholders, 2018). Your stock basis is $30,000.
The guarantee does not add debt basis. The regulations provide that a shareholder obtains basis in debt only for bona fide indebtedness of the corporation that runs directly to the shareholder, and that a shareholder does not obtain basis merely by guaranteeing a loan or acting as a surety (Limitations on Deduction of Pass-Through Items to Shareholders, 2024). The bank loan is owed by the corporation to the bank, not to you. Courts reached the same conclusion before the regulation, holding that a guarantor has made no economic outlay until called on to pay (Estate of Leavitt v. Commissioner, 1989). If the bank ever collected from you under the guarantee, you would then acquire debt basis in the amount paid.
As proposed, therefore, $30,000 of the loss is deductible this year and $60,000 is suspended.
An Alternative That Changes the Answer
If you borrow $60,000 personally from your own bank, on your own credit, and lend it to the corporation under a written note with stated interest and a repayment schedule, the corporation will owe that debt directly to you. It creates $60,000 of debt basis. Table 1 applies the limits under both approaches.
Table 1
Loss Limits Applied in Order
| Limit, applied in order | As proposed | With a $60,000 shareholder loan |
|---|---|---|
| Loss allocated to the shareholder | $90,000 | $90,000 |
| Stock basis | 30,000 | 30,000 |
| Debt basis | 0: the guarantee creates none | 60,000 |
| Allowed by basis, section 1366(d) | 30,000 | 90,000 |
| Amount at risk, section 465 | 30,000 | 90,000 |
| Passive activity limit, section 469 | Not limited: material participation | Not limited |
| Deductible this year | $30,000 | $90,000 |
| Suspended and carried forward | $60,000 | $0 |
The Other Limits
Amount at risk: section 465 separately limits losses to the amount a taxpayer has at risk in the activity, generally money and property contributed and amounts borrowed for which the taxpayer is personally liable (Deductions Limited to Amount at Risk, 2018). As proposed, your at-risk amount is your $30,000 of stock basis. Under the alternative, the $60,000 you borrowed personally and lent to the corporation adds to your amount at risk, because you are personally liable on the borrowing, so both limits rise together.
Passive activity: section 469 limits losses from activities in which the taxpayer does not materially participate (Passive Activity Losses and Credits Limited, 2018). You work in the business full time, well over the hours the material participation tests require, so the loss is not passive under either approach.
The excess business loss rule, which limits the amount of business losses an individual may deduct against other income, applies only above a threshold far higher than $90,000, so it does not affect you this year.
Timing and Form
The loan must be made before the end of the tax year to create basis for this year's loss. The note should be signed, state an interest rate at least equal to the applicable federal rate, and set a repayment schedule, and the corporation should record it as a liability and pay interest when due. A transfer recorded as a contribution would add stock basis instead, which would also permit the deduction but would lose the ability to repay the amount without it being treated as a distribution. An undocumented advance invites the argument that no debt exists.
A Consequence to Plan For
Once the loss reduces your debt basis, repayments of the loan by the corporation will produce gain to the extent they exceed your reduced basis in the note. If the corporation repays the $60,000 next year before its income restores the basis, part of each payment will be taxable. The loan should be repaid only after the corporation's income has rebuilt the debt basis, or the gain should be expected and planned for.
Conclusion
Your position that the guarantee supports the full $90,000 is not supportable; as things stand, $30,000 is deductible and $60,000 is suspended. If you lend $60,000 to the corporation directly before year end, properly documented, the full loss is deductible this year.
References
Deductions Limited to Amount at Risk, 26 U.S.C. § 465 (2018).
Estate of Leavitt v. Commissioner, 875 F.2d 420 (4th Cir. 1989).
Limitations on Deduction of Pass-Through Items to Shareholders, 26 C.F.R. § 1.1366-2 (2024).
Passive Activity Losses and Credits Limited, 26 U.S.C. § 469 (2018).
Pass-Thru of Items to Shareholders, 26 U.S.C. § 1366 (2018).
ACC 465 Topic 8 instructions, in plain terms
The Topic 8 instructions in ACC-465 ask students to evaluate how much of a pass-through loss an owner may deduct. Weak submissions allow the loss because the owner is liable on entity debt. The assignment rewards memos that apply the limits in order, basis, amount at risk, passive activity and excess business loss, and explain why a guarantee does not create debt basis. Students should compute the deductible and suspended amounts, evaluate an alternative that changes the result, set out its timing and documentation requirements and describe consequences, such as gain on later loan repayment.
Inside the ACC 465 Topic 8 example
The finished memo sets out the owner's position and then tests it in the order the Code applies the limits. Basis comes first: her stock basis is $30,000, and a guarantee of the corporation's $100,000 bank loan adds no debt basis, because under section 1366(d) and the regulations only debt the corporation owes directly to the shareholder counts. As proposed, $30,000 is deductible and $60,000 is suspended and carried forward. The memo then prices an alternative: if she borrows $60,000 personally and lends it to the corporation on a documented note, her debt basis and her amount at risk under section 465 both rise, and the full loss clears both limits. Material participation keeps it outside the passive rules of section 469. The excess business loss limit in section 461(l) is noted as indexed.
Reading the ACC 465 Topic 8 rubric
GCU's rubric for the loss limitation memo rewards limits applied in order. Excellent memos deny debt basis for a guarantee, citing the regulation and case law, and suspend the excess loss. Credit goes to showing how a direct shareholder loan raises both debt basis and the at-risk amount. The rubric values addressing material participation and the excess business loss threshold. The highest level explains documentation, year-end timing and the gain that arises if the loan is repaid before basis is restored. Memos that treat a guarantee as debt basis usually lose marks.
ACC 465 Topic 8 help: mistakes that cost marks
Positions defended only against the limit a paper happens to know fail here, since the rubric expects every applicable limit to be tested. A memo that allows the full $90,000 because the owner is personally liable to the bank has treated a guarantee as debt basis, which is the error this fact pattern is written around. Testing passive activity before basis reverses the statutory order and can report a loss as allowed that basis already blocked. Papers that call the $60,000 permanently lost misread the carryforward. Restructuring offered without the conditions a shareholder loan must meet, a real note, interest and repayment terms, recommends something a reviewer could collapse. Ignoring the income that later repayment triggers presents a timing benefit as a permanent one. Citing no section for any limit leaves a planning position with nothing to stand on.
Get an ACC-465 Topic 8 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-465 Topic 8 instructions, the rubric and the owner and entity facts your section supplied. A custom example is written to them, with the proposed position stated, each limit applied in order, any restructuring tested against the same rules and the surviving position defended with its citations, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free. Coursework support only.
More ACC 465 papers and BS in Accounting samples
- ACC 465 Topic 1: Entity Income Flow Comparison
- ACC 465 Topic 2: Formation Basis Schedule
- ACC 465 Topic 3: Distribution Taxability Analysis
- ACC 465 Topic 4: Related Party Transaction Review
- ACC 465 Topic 5: Entity Stage Choice Dq Post
- ACC 465 Topic 6: Deferral Qualification Analysis
- ACC 465 Topic 7: Entity Recommendation Memo
- ACC 460 Topic 8: Return Position Research Memo
- ACC 425 Topic 8: Personal Ethics Commitment Paper
- ACC 240 Topic 8: Accounting Cycle Explainer
- ACC 371 Topic 8: Debt or Equity Research Memo
ACC 465 Topic 8 questions, answered
Why does a guarantee not create basis for an S corporation owner?
Because the regulations on S corporation debt basis look for bona fide indebtedness of the corporation that runs directly to the shareholder. A guarantee leaves the corporation owing the bank, and the owner is only contingently liable. If she later pays the bank under the guarantee, the answer changes from that point. Partnerships follow different rules for liabilities, which is one reason entity form matters here.
What happens to a loss suspended by the basis limit?
It carries forward and can be deducted in a later year when the owner has enough basis to absorb it, for example after the corporation earns income or she contributes capital or lends money directly. The memo records the $60,000 as suspended so it is not forgotten. An owner who sells the stock before restoring basis generally loses the benefit of the suspended amount.
Is the restructured loan a recommendation to borrow?
No. It is a coursework illustration of how the limits respond to different facts, and a real decision to borrow involves risks and circumstances the example leaves out. The memo tests the restructured loan against each limit to show that a planning position is defended by rules rather than by resemblance to familiar planning. Anyone considering such a step needs a qualified adviser applying current law.
Where can I find a free ACC 465 Topic 8 sample paper?
Read the full memo above: the position, basis first, the alternative, the other limits, timing and form, a consequence to plan for and the conclusion. Describe the owner's situation and we will write the memo free.
Why does the guarantee add no basis in ACC 465 Topic 8?
Debt basis requires debt the corporation owes directly to the shareholder, and a guarantee creates none unless the shareholder actually pays the lender.