| Course | ACC 486 Financial Statement Analysis |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 5 |
| Paper type | Flattering ratio discussion post |
| Length | About 460 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Discussion post, APA 7 citations |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 486 Topic 5
Topic 5 DQ 1: Initial Post and Reply
Return on Equity Rose From 14 to 18 Percent While the Business Got Worse: What the DuPont Breakdown Shows
Initial Post
My claim: return on equity can improve while the business underneath gets worse, and the DuPont breakdown shows exactly how.
Here is one illustrative company. The DuPont breakdown writes return on equity as the product of three ratios: net profit margin, asset turnover and the equity multiplier, which is total assets divided by equity. In year one the company earned a 7% net margin, turned its assets over 1.0 times and had an equity multiplier of 2.0, so return on equity was 7% times 1.0 times 2.0, or 14%.
In year two its net margin slipped to 6%, as costs rose faster than prices. Asset turnover held at 1.0. But during the year the company borrowed heavily to fund a large share buyback, which reduced equity while leaving assets unchanged, and the equity multiplier jumped to 3.0. Return on equity became 6% times 1.0 times 3.0, or 18%.
A shareholder looking only at return on equity sees a four-point improvement. The breakdown shows that the operating business did worse: return on assets, margin times turnover, fell from 7% to 6%. Every dollar of assets earned less. The entire improvement in return on equity came from financing, from spreading a smaller profit over a smaller equity base.
What does the higher multiplier mean for shareholders? In good years, more return, because each dollar of equity controls three dollars of assets instead of two. In bad years, more loss for the same reason, and a higher chance of trouble: the company now carries more interest cost against a thinner margin, and a further fall in profit would hit equity harder. Research on ratio analysis separates operating profitability from the effect of financing precisely because the two have different implications for value and risk (Nissim & Penman, 2001). A return on equity driven by borrowing is not the same quality as one driven by operations (Penman, 2013).
Question for classmates: if you were a lender to this company rather than a shareholder, which of the three ratios would you watch most closely next year, and why?
Reply to Jamie
Jamie, you argued that the buyback was a good decision because return on equity rose. It may have been, if the company's shares were cheap and its borrowing cost is below its return on assets, since then each borrowed dollar earns more than it costs. At a 6% return on assets, that requires borrowing below about 6% after tax, which may be true now. But the margin is already falling. What would you want to know about the debt's interest rate and maturity before calling the buyback a success?
References
Nissim, D., & Penman, S. H. (2001). Ratio analysis and equity valuation: From research to practice. Review of Accounting Studies, 6(1), 109-154. https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1011338221623
Penman, S. H. (2013). Financial statement analysis and security valuation (5th ed.). McGraw-Hill.
What the ACC 486 Topic 5 instructions ask for
ACC-486 Topic 5 asks students to discuss how ratios can improve for the wrong reasons. Many posts define return on equity and leave it there. Good posts commit to a claim, break a ratio into its components with numbers for two periods, and show which component drove the change. Students should explain what a higher equity multiplier means for shareholders in good and bad years, distinguish returns from operations from returns created by borrowing, pose a question from a lender's perspective and answer a classmate with the figures their view would need.
How the ACC-486 Topic 5 example is put together
The post leads with its claim: return on equity can improve while the business underneath gets worse, and the DuPont breakdown shows how. One illustrative company carries the case. In year one it earns a 7 percent net margin on asset turnover of 1.0 with an equity multiplier of 2.0, for a 14 percent return on equity. In year two margin slips to 6 percent, turnover holds at 1.0 and the multiplier jumps to 3.0 after borrowing funded a large buyback, so return on equity reaches 18 percent. Return on assets fell from 7 to 6 percent over the same year. The post explains what the higher multiplier means for shareholders, more return in good years and more exposure in bad ones, and names times interest earned as the ratio to check beside it. A question for classmates ends it.
Where the marks sit in the ACC 486 Topic 5 rubric
GCU's rubric for this discussion rewards a ratio broken down with figures. Excellent posts show margin, turnover and multiplier for both years and identify borrowing as the source of the higher return. Credit goes to computing return on assets to show the operating decline. The rubric values explaining how a higher multiplier magnifies both gains and losses. The strongest replies ask what the debt's cost and maturity must be for the buyback to pay off. Posts that praise a higher return on equity without decomposing it tend to earn partial credit.
ACC 486 Topic 5 help: mistakes that cost marks
Posts lose most on this topic when they report the higher return on equity and stop. Without the three components, a reader cannot tell whether the business improved or the capital structure changed. Some drafts compute the components but never compare return on assets across the two years, which is the figure that exposes the operating decline. Others treat borrowing as simply bad, which ignores that debt can raise returns when it costs less than the assets earn. A post that never mentions the added risk of a thinner equity base misses half the argument. Replies that agree without adding a figure or a question earn little in most sections, since the exchange is part of what is graded.
Get an ACC-486 Topic 5 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-486 Topic 5 discussion question, the participation rubric and the company your section is following. We write a custom example to those, with the claim stated first, the ratio decomposed for two years, the moving component tied to a decision, a check ratio set beside it and a reply prompt for classmates, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More ACC 486 papers and BS in Accounting samples
- ACC 486 Topic 1: Comparability Adjustment Schedule
- ACC 486 Topic 2: Profit to Cash Gap Analysis
- ACC 486 Topic 3: Normalized Earnings Worksheet
- ACC 486 Topic 4: Common Size Trend Analysis
- ACC 486 Topic 6: Driver Based Revenue Forecast
- ACC 486 Topic 7: Pro Forma Forecast with Assumptions
- ACC 486 Topic 8: Valuation Sensitivity Table
- ACC 465 Topic 5: Entity Stage Choice Dq Post
- ACC 240 Topic 5: Undetected Error Discussion Post
- ACC 460 Topic 5: Avoidance and Evasion Dq Post
- ACC 250 Topic 5: Note Disclosure Discussion Post
ACC 486 Topic 5 questions, answered
What does the DuPont breakdown show?
That return on equity is the product of three things: net profit margin, asset turnover and the equity multiplier, which measures how much of the asset base each dollar of equity supports. Multiplying the three gives the headline figure. Separating them shows whether a change came from pricing and cost control, from using assets more intensively, or from financing more of the business with debt.
Which other ratios can improve for the wrong reason?
Several. Asset turnover can rise because old equipment is heavily depreciated and not being replaced, which shrinks the asset base while capacity ages. Inventory turnover can improve because stock ran short and sales were lost. A falling collection period can reflect receivables sold to a factor. Each needs the same treatment as the example: find the component that moved and the decision behind it.
Where can I find a free ACC 486 Topic 5 sample paper?
The post with one reply is on this page: the claim, year one and year two, what return on assets shows, what the higher multiplier means and a reply on the buyback. Send the discussion question and a worked post comes back free.
Why did return on equity rise in ACC 486 Topic 5?
The equity multiplier rose from 2.0 to 3.0 after a debt-funded buyback, more than offsetting a fall in net margin from 7 to 6 percent.
Is more debt always bad in ACC 486 Topic 5?
No. Borrowing raises returns to shareholders when the debt costs less than the assets earn, but it also magnifies losses and raises the risk of distress if profits fall.