| Course | ACC 491 Auditing |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 5 |
| Paper type | Evidence sufficiency discussion post |
| Length | About 420 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Discussion post, APA 7 citations |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 491 Topic 5
Topic 5 DQ 1: Initial Post and Reply
Sixty Confirmations Prove the Customers Owe the Money, Not That They Will Pay It: Evidence Is Sufficient Only for Something
Initial Post
My position: evidence is sufficient only for a particular assertion, and a large pile of evidence aimed at the wrong assertion is not more evidence.
Here is the illustrative case. An audit team sent positive confirmation requests to 60 customers of a medical equipment distributor, together covering about 70% of the $6.2 million receivables balance. All 60 replied, and every reply agreed with the recorded balance. That is strong evidence. It comes directly from independent third parties outside the company, in writing, which makes it more reliable than anything the company could produce itself, and it speaks directly to existence: the customers exist and acknowledge that they owe the amounts recorded (American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, 2020).
What the same 60 letters cannot establish is whether the customers will pay. A hospital that is months behind on its bills can confirm a debt it has no ability to pay. The confirmations say nothing about the valuation of receivables, meaning whether the allowance for doubtful accounts is adequate. For that, the team needs different evidence: cash received from customers after year end, which shows which balances have actually been collected, and an aging of overdue accounts, which shows where the collection risk sits. A reviewer who saw 60 clean confirmations and concluded that receivables were fairly stated would have tested one assertion and signed off on two.
Sufficiency also depends on risk. If the team had assessed a higher risk of material misstatement for receivables, for example because the client's largest customer was in financial difficulty, it would need more evidence, more persuasive evidence or both, such as a larger sample of subsequent receipts and a direct review of that customer's financial condition (Arens et al., 2020). The quantity needed is set by the risk, not by how much evidence is convenient to collect.
Question for classmates: which assertion for inventory do you think is most often tested with evidence that actually speaks to a different assertion?
Reply to Sam
Sam, you suggested that because all 60 confirmations agreed, the team could reduce its other receivables work. For existence, I agree that the clean replies justify less additional testing. But the reduction cannot carry over to valuation, because the confirmations never touched it. Would you reduce the subsequent receipts test as well, and if so, what evidence would you rely on for the allowance?
References
American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. (2020). Audit evidence (Statement on Auditing Standards No. 142). AICPA.
Arens, A. A., Elder, R. J., Beasley, M. S., & Hogan, C. E. (2020). Auditing and assurance services (17th ed.). Pearson.
The ACC-491 Topic 5 assignment instructions
ACC-491 Topic 5 asks students to discuss the sufficiency and appropriateness of audit evidence. Many posts equate more evidence with better evidence. The prompt rewards posts that tie evidence to specific assertions, explain what a type of evidence establishes and what it cannot, and identify the evidence needed for the assertion left untested. Students should explain why external evidence is more reliable, relate the quantity of evidence to assessed risk, pose a question applying the idea to another account and answer a classmate who wants to cut testing by asking which assertion the cut would leave unsupported.
Inside the ACC 491 Topic 5 example
Its opening line carries the position: evidence is sufficient only for something, and a pile of it aimed at the wrong assertion is not more evidence. The case is an illustrative receivables balance. Sixty positive confirmations come back agreeing with the recorded amounts, strong support that the customers exist and owe the balances, since the replies come straight from outside the company. What those same letters cannot establish comes next: a customer can confirm a debt it has no ability to pay. Valuation needs different evidence, cash received after year end and an aging of overdue accounts. The post adds that higher assessed risk calls for more persuasive evidence as well as more of it, cites the course text's ordering of evidence reliability, and closes by asking classmates for an assertion confirmations would support poorly.
ACC 491 Topic 5 rubric: what Excellent looks like
GCU's rubric for this discussion rewards evidence matched to assertions. Excellent posts show that confirmations support existence strongly but say nothing about collectibility. Credit goes to naming subsequent receipts and aging as valuation evidence. The rubric values linking sufficiency to assessed risk and explaining the reliability of external evidence. The strongest replies accept a reduction for existence while refusing to carry it to valuation. Posts that treat a large number of confirmations as proof that the whole receivables balance is fairly stated tend to earn partial credit.
ACC 491 Topic 5 help: mistakes that cost marks
Posts on sufficiency commonly lose credit by answering with a number. A contribution suggesting that some percentage of a balance, or some count of items, makes evidence sufficient has replaced the judgment the question asks about with a rule nobody issued. Posts that call confirmations the strongest evidence available, without saying for which assertion, overstate them in exactly the way the topic warns about. Discussing sufficiency and never appropriateness separates two ideas the standards treat together. Cases that stay abstract, naming evidence types in general, give classmates nothing to challenge. Replies earn little when they agree that auditors need enough evidence, and they earn more when they bring a second assertion and show the original evidence falling short of it, which is where participation marks usually go.
Get an ACC-491 Topic 5 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-491 Topic 5 discussion question, the participation rubric and any account or scenario your instructor attached. We write a custom example to those, with sufficiency tied to a named assertion, one case worked for and against it, risk connected to evidence quality and a closing question for the thread, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one costs nothing.
More ACC 491 papers and BS in Accounting samples
- ACC 491 Topic 1: Audit Opinion Scope Memo
- ACC 491 Topic 2: Covered Member Interest Analysis
- ACC 491 Topic 3: Assertion Level Risk Matrix
- ACC 491 Topic 4: Control Reliance Decision Memo
- ACC 491 Topic 6: Attribute Sampling Evaluation
- ACC 491 Topic 7: Receivables Confirmation Working Paper
- ACC 491 Topic 8: Opinion Selection Memo
- ACC 240 Topic 5: Undetected Error Discussion Post
- ACC 486 Topic 5: Flattering Ratio Discussion Post
- ACC 250 Topic 5: Note Disclosure Discussion Post
- ACC 465 Topic 5: Entity Stage Choice Dq Post
ACC 491 Topic 5 questions, answered
What is the difference between sufficient and appropriate evidence?
Sufficiency is about quantity, enough evidence given the risk. Appropriateness is about quality: whether the evidence is relevant to the assertion being tested and reliable given its source and nature. The two work together, since a large volume of irrelevant evidence is not sufficient for anything, and a small amount of highly reliable, relevant evidence may be enough where the risk is low.
Which kinds of evidence are most reliable?
Course texts generally rank evidence from independent outside sources above evidence generated inside the company, evidence the auditor obtains directly above evidence obtained indirectly, documents above oral statements, and originals above copies. Evidence from inside the company is more reliable when its controls are effective. The ranking guides judgment rather than settling it, since relevance to the assertion still decides whether any of it counts.
Can confirmations support completeness?
Poorly, when they are sent to customers already in the records, because a customer the company never recorded will never receive a letter. Completeness is tested by starting from evidence outside the recorded balance, such as shipping records traced forward to invoices and the ledger. That is the point the post leaves for classmates, since it shows the same procedure strong for one assertion and weak for another.
Where can I find a free ACC 491 Topic 5 sample paper?
Above you will find the initial post and one reply: the position, sixty confirmations, what they cannot establish, how risk sets sufficiency, a closing question and a response on cutting later work. Send your DQ prompt for a free worked post.
What can confirmations not prove in ACC 491 Topic 5?
That customers will pay. A customer can confirm owing a balance it cannot pay, so valuation needs subsequent receipts and an aging review.