| Course | ACC 491 Auditing |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 6 |
| Paper type | Attribute sampling evaluation |
| Length | About 980 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 491 Topic 6
One Deviation in Sixty, and Why That Is Too Many: An Attribute Sampling Evaluation of Cascade Foodservice's Three-Way Match
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
ACC-491: Auditing
Topic 6 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
One Deviation in Sixty, and Why That Is Too Many: An Attribute Sampling Evaluation of Cascade Foodservice's Three-Way Match
Parameters First
The audit team planned to rely on Cascade Foodservice's three-way match, a composite client's control requiring that a payment be released only after the purchase order, receiving report and supplier invoice are matched and initialed. Relying on the control would reduce the substantive testing of payables and expenses. To support that reliance, the team tested the control with attribute sampling. Every parameter was set before any voucher was examined, so that the results could not shape the test. All figures are illustrative.
Table 1
Sampling Parameters
| Parameter, set before testing | Value |
|---|---|
| Control tested | Three-way match of purchase order, receiving report and invoice, initialed before payment |
| Population | 4,800 vouchers paid during the year, numbered V-10001 to V-14800 |
| Deviation | Any voucher paid without all three documents matched and initialed |
| Tolerable deviation rate | 5% |
| Risk of overreliance | 10% |
| Sample size | 60 |
| Selection | Random numbers matched to the voucher sequence |
Why These Parameters
The tolerable deviation rate, 5%, is the highest rate of control failure the team could accept and still rely on the control at the planned level. The risk of overreliance, 10%, is the risk the team accepts of concluding the control works when its true deviation rate exceeds the tolerable rate; it is set low because the reliance substantially reduces other testing. Defining a deviation in advance, a payment without all three documents matched and initialed, prevents a borderline case from being argued away after it is found. Random selection matched to the voucher sequence gives every voucher an equal chance of selection, which is what allows the results to be projected to the population (American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, 2011).
The Result
Fifty-nine vouchers had all three documents matched and initialed. One did not. Voucher V-12418, a $7,860 payment for produce, was paid on a rush basis after a phone call from the warehouse manager confirming delivery; there was no receiving report in the file, and the match initials were missing.
Table 2
Sample Results and Evaluation
| Result | Value |
|---|---|
| Deviations found | 1 |
| Sample deviation rate: 1 รท 60 | 1.7% |
| Upper deviation limit at 10% risk, from the attribute sampling table | About 6.4% |
| Tolerable deviation rate | 5% |
| Conclusion | Upper limit exceeds tolerable rate: the control does not support the planned reliance |
Reading the Evaluation
The sample deviation rate is 1.7%, well under the 5% tolerable rate. It would be tempting to conclude that the control works. That conclusion ignores sampling risk: 60 vouchers are a small part of 4,800, and the true rate in the population could be higher than the sample shows. The evaluation therefore uses the upper deviation limit, the highest rate the population could have at the chosen risk of overreliance given one deviation in 60. From the standard attribute sampling table at 10% risk, that limit is about 6.4% (Arens et al., 2020).
The upper limit exceeds the 5% tolerable rate. At the planned level of assurance, the team cannot conclude that the control fails less often than it can accept. The control does not support the planned reliance. It is the upper limit, not the sample rate, that is compared with the tolerable rate; comparing the sample rate would claim more assurance than 60 vouchers can give.
The Nature of the Deviation
The quantitative result is enough to withdraw reliance, but the deviation itself also matters. A payment released on a phone call, without a receiving report, is exactly the kind of failure the control exists to prevent: it allows payment for goods that were never received, or received short. It also suggests a practice, rush payments bypassing the match, that may be more common than one voucher shows. The team asked the payables supervisor, who confirmed that rush payments are occasionally approved by phone during peak season. That is a design gap, not just an operating lapse, and it is communicated to management in writing.
The Response
Because the control cannot be relied on as planned, the team restores the substantive testing it had planned to reduce. It extends the search for payments without receiving reports to all vouchers above $5,000 paid in the peak season, tests a larger sample of payables and expenses for the existence of the goods and services paid for, and compares warehouse receiving logs with payments for the produce vendors most often paid on a rush basis. If that testing finds payments for goods not received, the amounts will be evaluated as misstatements and, depending on the pattern, as possible fraud. Assessments of control risk must reflect the evidence obtained, so the risk for payables and expenses is reassessed from moderate to high in the planning file (American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, 2021).
What Would Have Changed the Answer
With zero deviations in 60, the upper limit at 10% risk would have been about 3.8%, below the tolerable rate, and reliance would have been supported. With a larger sample, one deviation would have produced a lower upper limit. The team could have chosen a larger sample from the start if it expected occasional deviations; choosing 60 assumed the control rarely fails, and the one deviation showed that assumption was optimistic.
What the Working Paper Records
The working paper for this test records the parameters and their rationale as set before testing, the random number seed and the list of 60 vouchers selected, the result for each voucher, a description of voucher V-12418 with copies of its documents, the evaluation using the upper deviation limit, the conclusion on reliance and the resulting change to the audit plan. A reviewer should be able to reperform the selection from the seed, see that the deviation was defined before it was found and follow the chain from one missing receiving report to the expanded substantive tests. That chain, not the deviation count alone, is what supports the change in approach.
References
American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. (2011). Clarification and recodification (Statement on Auditing Standards No. 122). AICPA.
American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. (2021). Understanding the entity and its environment and assessing the risks of material misstatement (Statement on Auditing Standards No. 145). AICPA.
Arens, A. A., Elder, R. J., Beasley, M. S., & Hogan, C. E. (2020). Auditing and assurance services (17th ed.). Pearson.
The ACC-491 Topic 6 assignment instructions
The Topic 6 instructions in ACC-491 ask students to plan and evaluate an attribute sample for a test of controls. Weak submissions compare the sample deviation rate with the tolerable rate. The assignment rewards evaluations that set and justify parameters before testing, define a deviation in advance, select randomly and evaluate the result using the upper deviation limit at the chosen risk. Students should consider the nature of any deviation as well as the count, state the effect on reliance and control risk, describe the substantive response and document the test so a reviewer can reperform it.
How this ACC 491 Topic 6 example is built
Parameters come before results, all illustrative: a population of 4,800 vouchers paid during the year, a tolerable deviation rate of 5 percent, a 10 percent risk of overreliance and a sample of 60 selected by random numbers matched to the voucher sequence. A deviation is defined in advance as a payment released without a purchase order, receiving report and invoice all matched and initialed. One voucher fails, a rush invoice paid on a phone call from the warehouse with no receiving report. The sample rate is 1.7 percent, but the evaluation reports the upper deviation limit, about 6.4 percent from the standard attribute table, as the figure that speaks for the population. Because that limit exceeds 5 percent, the planned reliance is withdrawn, the deviation is examined for its cause, and substantive testing of payables is extended.
Where the marks sit in the ACC 491 Topic 6 rubric
Faculty grading the sampling evaluation reward the upper limit compared with tolerance. Excellent evaluations show why a 1.7 percent sample rate can still fail a 5 percent tolerable rate once sampling risk is considered. Credit goes to parameters and deviation definitions fixed before testing and random selection. The rubric values analyzing the deviation's nature as a possible design gap. The highest level reassesses control risk, restores substantive procedures and explains what would have changed the answer. Evaluations that conclude from the sample rate alone usually lose marks.
ACC 491 Topic 6 help before you submit
Sampling papers lose credit most often at the evaluation, after the arithmetic is finished. Concluding that the control works because only 1.7 percent of the sample deviated states a fact about sixty vouchers and treats it as a fact about 4,800, ignoring the sampling risk the upper limit exists to capture. Deviations defined after the results are known invite reclassification, and markers notice a failure relabeled as an exception. Samples drawn from a single month cannot support conclusions about the year. Papers that compute the upper limit correctly, find it above tolerance and then rely on the control anyway have performed the test and disregarded its result. Treating the deviation only as a number, with no look at why the rush payment happened, misses the qualitative evaluation that many rubrics expect beside the quantitative one.
Get an ACC-491 Topic 6 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-491 Topic 6 instructions, your rubric and the sampling case or control your section assigned. We write a custom example to them, with the deviation defined in advance, parameters justified, the sample rate projected to an upper limit, the result compared with tolerance and the deviation's cause examined, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More ACC 491 papers and BS in Accounting samples
- ACC 491 Topic 1: Audit Opinion Scope Memo
- ACC 491 Topic 2: Covered Member Interest Analysis
- ACC 491 Topic 3: Assertion Level Risk Matrix
- ACC 491 Topic 4: Control Reliance Decision Memo
- ACC 491 Topic 5: Evidence Sufficiency Discussion Post
- ACC 491 Topic 7: Receivables Confirmation Working Paper
- ACC 491 Topic 8: Opinion Selection Memo
- ACC 240 Topic 6: Merchandising Entry Set
- ACC 486 Topic 6: Driver Based Revenue Forecast
- ACC 250 Topic 6: Useful Life Comparison Memo
- ACC 465 Topic 6: Deferral Qualification Analysis
ACC 491 Topic 6 questions, answered
Why not rely on the sample deviation rate?
Because a sample can by chance contain fewer deviations than the population holds. The upper deviation limit adds an allowance for that sampling risk, giving the highest rate the population could plausibly have at the chosen risk of overreliance. Comparing that limit with the tolerable rate is how the sample supports a statement about the whole population rather than about the vouchers actually examined.
What is the risk of overreliance?
The risk that the sample suggests a control is working well enough when, in the full population, it is not. An auditor who overrelies on a control reduces substantive testing below what the true control risk would justify. Setting that risk low requires larger samples. The example uses 10 percent, labeled illustrative, and explains the choice in terms of how heavily the audit plan depends on the control.
Is statistical sampling required?
No. Auditing standards permit statistical and nonstatistical sampling, and both require the sample to be representative and the results projected to the population. Statistical methods measure sampling risk mathematically, which makes the upper limit calculation possible. Nonstatistical approaches rely on judgment for that allowance. The example uses attribute tables because many sections ask for them, and it notes the nonstatistical alternative.
Where can I find a free ACC 491 Topic 6 sample paper?
Everything is above: parameters first, why these parameters, the result, reading the evaluation, the nature of the deviation, the response, what would have changed the answer and what the working paper records. Share your test for a free worked evaluation.
Why does one deviation fail in ACC 491 Topic 6?
With one deviation in 60, the upper deviation limit at 10 percent risk is about 6.4 percent, above the 5 percent tolerable rate, so the planned reliance is not supported.