| Course | ACC 491 Auditing |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 7 |
| Paper type | Receivables confirmation working paper |
| Length | About 950 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 491 Topic 7
Working Paper C-3: Confirming $4.31 Million of Summit Medical Distributors' Receivables, With Every Reply and Nonreply Accounted For
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
ACC-491: Auditing
Topic 7 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Working Paper C-3: Confirming $4.31 Million of Summit Medical Distributors' Receivables, With Every Reply and Nonreply Accounted For
Header
Table 1
Working Paper Header
| Working paper | C-3 |
|---|---|
| Client | Summit Medical Distributors, Inc. |
| Year end | December 31 |
| Prepared by | [Staff initials], January 18 |
| Reviewed by | [Senior initials], January 24 |
| Purpose | Test the existence of trade receivables of $6.2 million by positive confirmation |
The header identifies the paper for any reviewer, so it can be found, cited from other papers and signed off: which client, which year, who prepared and reviewed it and when, and the assertion it tests. Confirmations provide evidence mainly about existence, so that is the purpose stated; valuation of the receivables is tested separately at C-4. All figures are illustrative.
Selection
Table 2
Selection of Accounts
| Selection | Accounts | Recorded balance |
|---|---|---|
| All accounts over $100,000 | 22 | $3,900,000 |
| Random selection from the remaining accounts, 30 of 412 | 30 | 410,000 |
| Total selected | 52 | $4,310,000 |
| Coverage of the $6.2 million balance | 69.5% |
Every account over $100,000 was selected, because large balances carry the most risk of material misstatement individually. The remaining 412 accounts were sampled at random using the audit software's random selection, seed recorded at C-3.1. The confirmation requests were prepared from the client's aged listing, reconciled to the general ledger at C-1, and mailed by the audit team directly to addresses verified against customer websites, so that the client could not intercept or alter them (American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, 2011).
Why Positive Confirmations, and How They Were Controlled
Positive requests, which ask every customer to reply whether or not it agrees, were used rather than negative requests, which ask for a reply only if the customer disagrees. The receivables balance is material, several large hospital accounts make up much of it and the risk assessment at A-3 rated existence as moderate, so the team wanted evidence from every selected customer, not silence that could mean agreement or inattention.
The process was controlled from start to finish. The team prepared the requests, verified mailing addresses against sources outside the company, mailed them itself and had replies sent directly to the firm's office. Two replies received by email were checked by calling the customers at numbers from their websites to confirm that the replies came from them. The client's staff never handled a request or a reply, which is what makes a confirmation more reliable than a document the client provides.
Results
Table 3
Confirmation Results
| Result | Accounts | Balance |
|---|---|---|
| Replies agreeing | 41 | $3,120,000 |
| Replies with differences, resolved below | 3 | $640,000 |
| No reply, cleared by alternative procedures | 8 | $550,000 |
| Total | 52 | $4,310,000 |
Of 52 requests, 44 came back. Forty-one agreed with the recorded balance. Three reported differences, investigated below. Eight did not reply after a second request sent three weeks after the first, and a follow-up call to each customer's accounts payable department produced no written reply in time for the fieldwork deadline.
Differences
Table 4
Differences Investigated
| Difference | Customer's reply | Resolution | Misstatement |
|---|---|---|---|
| Riverside Clinic | Paid $48,200 on December 30 | Payment in transit; deposited January 3 per bank statement | None |
| Lakeview Surgical | Paid $22,700 on December 31 | Payment in transit; deposited January 4 | None |
| Mercy West Hospital | Claims $18,500 credit for equipment returned December 20 | Receiving log shows return on December 21; credit memo issued January 9 | $18,500 overstatement of receivables and sales |
Two differences are payments customers mailed at year end that the company received and deposited in early January; the bank statements confirm the deposits, so the recorded balances were correct at year end. The third is a misstatement. Mercy West Hospital returned $18,500 of equipment on December 20; the company's receiving log shows it arrived on December 21, but the credit memo was not issued until January 9. At year end, receivables and sales were overstated by $18,500, and inventory was understated by the cost of the returned equipment.
Nonreplies
For each of the eight nonreplies, alternative procedures were performed (American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, 2020). For six accounts, totaling $470,000, cash received in January was matched to the specific invoices making up the year-end balance; all six were fully collected by January 17. For the other two, totaling $80,000, neither has paid yet, so the team examined the customers' signed purchase orders and the carrier's delivery confirmations for each invoice. All eight balances are supported as existing at year end. The alternative procedures are documented account by account at C-3.3, with the January deposit or delivery confirmation referenced for each invoice.
Evaluation and Conclusion
The only misstatement found is the $18,500 Mercy West return, in an account over $100,000 that was examined in full, so it is not projected to the untested accounts. It is posted to the summary of misstatements at A-5 with its inventory effect. The team also asked management whether other returns received in late December were credited in January; management identified two more totaling $6,200, which were verified to receiving logs and added to the summary. The return cutoff issue is referred to C-4 and to the inventory team, since it suggests a process gap rather than a single error.
Conclusion: except for the returns noted, which total $24,700, are well below materiality and are accumulated on the summary of misstatements, the confirmation evidence supports the existence of trade receivables at December 31. Tickmarks used on the individual confirmation schedule are explained in the legend at C-3.2 (Arens et al., 2020).
What This Paper Does Not Test
Confirmations show that customers acknowledge owing the balances; they do not show that the balances will be collected, which is tested at C-4 through the aging and subsequent receipts, and they do not test that all receivables are recorded, which the revenue cutoff tests at R-2 address. A reviewer reading C-3 alone should not conclude that receivables are fairly stated in every respect, only that they exist.
References
American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. (2011). Clarification and recodification (Statement on Auditing Standards No. 122). AICPA.
American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. (2020). Audit evidence (Statement on Auditing Standards No. 142). AICPA.
Arens, A. A., Elder, R. J., Beasley, M. S., & Hogan, C. E. (2020). Auditing and assurance services (17th ed.). Pearson.
Reading the GCU ACC 491 Topic 7 instructions
ACC-491 Topic 7 asks students to prepare an audit working paper for a substantive test. Many submissions present results without the header, cross-references and resolution of every request that a reviewer needs. The assignment rewards working papers with a complete header and purpose, a selection method explained and recorded, controlled confirmation procedures, results that account for every request, and investigation of each difference and nonreply. Students should distinguish timing differences from misstatements, apply alternative procedures, decide whether misstatements are projected, follow up on patterns and state a conclusion limited to the assertion tested.
How this ACC 491 Topic 7 example is built
The working paper carries the header a reviewer expects: client, year end, reference C-3, preparer and reviewer with dates, and a purpose line naming existence as the assertion tested. Selection comes next, all figures illustrative. Every account over $100,000 is confirmed, 22 accounts totaling $3.9 million, plus 30 accounts drawn at random from the remaining $2.3 million, for coverage of $4.31 million. Of 52 requests, 44 come back. The eight nonresponses are cleared by alternative procedures, January cash receipts matched to specific invoices and shipping documents for the rest. Three replies disagree: two are payments in transit that cleared in early January, and one is a pricing dispute of $18,000 that the client concedes. Projected across the untested remainder, that error becomes about $101,000. Tickmarks tie each figure to the aging schedule.
ACC 491 Topic 7 rubric: what Excellent looks like
GCU's rubric for the confirmation working paper rewards every request accounted for. Excellent papers select all large balances plus a random sample and control mailing and replies. Credit goes to resolving payments in transit with bank evidence and clearing nonreplies with subsequent receipts or shipping documents. The rubric values identifying a cutoff misstatement, asking about similar items and posting them to the summary. The highest level limits the conclusion to existence and cross-references valuation and completeness work. Papers with unresolved nonreplies or no header usually land in a middle band.
Common ACC 491 Topic 7 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Working papers are marked as documents another auditor will use, and the common failures are the ones that leave that auditor stranded. A paper describing the confirmation work in paragraphs, with no log of requests and results, makes the reviewer rebuild the work to check it. Missing the purpose line, or naming valuation as the assertion confirmations test, points the whole paper at the wrong target. Nonresponses left unresolved, or cleared with a note that the client considers the balances collectible, rest on management's word where outside evidence was available. Reporting the $18,000 dispute and never projecting it treats a sample result as the whole finding. Conclusions without a cross-reference to where the misstatement was carried, or without a reviewer's sign-off field, break the chain a file review depends on.
Get an ACC-491 Topic 7 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-491 Topic 7 instructions, the rubric and the balance, aging or case your section supplied. We write a custom example to them, with a purpose naming the assertion, a repeatable selection, a confirmation log, resolved exceptions, alternative procedures, a projection against tolerable misstatement and a cross-referenced conclusion, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one costs nothing.
More ACC 491 papers and BS in Accounting samples
- ACC 491 Topic 1: Audit Opinion Scope Memo
- ACC 491 Topic 2: Covered Member Interest Analysis
- ACC 491 Topic 3: Assertion Level Risk Matrix
- ACC 491 Topic 4: Control Reliance Decision Memo
- ACC 491 Topic 5: Evidence Sufficiency Discussion Post
- ACC 491 Topic 6: Attribute Sampling Evaluation
- ACC 491 Topic 8: Opinion Selection Memo
- ACC 240 Topic 7: Statement Assembly Problem
- ACC 486 Topic 7: Pro Forma Forecast with Assumptions
- ACC 250 Topic 7: Creditor Ratio Briefing
- ACC 465 Topic 7: Entity Recommendation Memo
ACC 491 Topic 7 questions, answered
Why confirm large accounts and sample the rest?
Because the large accounts carry most of the balance and most of the risk of a material error, so confirming all of them covers a large share of the balance with certainty. The remainder is made of many small accounts where sampling is efficient. Documenting both parts, and projecting any error found in the sample only to the part it represents, keeps the conclusion accurate for each.
What if a customer never replies?
The request is followed up, and if no reply comes, the auditor performs alternative procedures to obtain evidence of existence another way. Cash received after year end that pays the specific invoices in the balance is strong evidence, since it comes from the customer. For balances still unpaid, shipping documents and signed delivery records show the sale occurred. A nonresponse is never treated as agreement.
Is a timing difference a misstatement?
Usually not. A customer who paid on December 30 may report a zero balance while the company, correctly, shows the amount outstanding until the cash arrives. The working paper confirms the explanation by tracing the payment to its January receipt. A difference the company cannot support that way, such as the pricing dispute, is treated as a misstatement and evaluated with the others.
Where can I find a free ACC 491 Topic 7 sample paper?
This page holds the complete working paper: header, selection, why positive confirmations and how they were controlled, results, differences, nonreplies, evaluation and what the paper does not test. Tell us your balance for a free worked paper.
Which difference is a misstatement in ACC 491 Topic 7?
The $18,500 return received December 21 but credited January 9, which overstated year-end receivables and sales; the other two are payments in transit.