| Course | ACC 491 Auditing |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 8 |
| Paper type | Opinion selection memo |
| Length | About 760 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 491 Topic 8
Memorandum
To: Engagement partner, Westbrook Outdoor Products audit
From: [Author Name], audit manager
Date: [Date]
Re: Form of opinion given management's refusal to record the inventory write-down
The Uncorrected Misstatements
Management of Westbrook Outdoor Products, a composite maker of camping gear, has declined to record a $520,000 write-down of obsolete inventory that the audit team proposed. Table 1 summarizes all uncorrected misstatements. Figures are illustrative.
Table 1
Summary of Uncorrected Misstatements
| Summary of uncorrected misstatements | Pretax income effect |
|---|---|
| Inventory obsolescence write-down management declined to record | $(520,000) |
| Accrued vacation understated | (38,000) |
| Sales cutoff: December shipments recorded twice | (31,000) |
| Other items below the clearly trivial threshold, accumulated | (21,000) |
| Total uncorrected | $(610,000) |
| Overall materiality | $400,000 |
| Reported pretax income | $450,000 |
| Pretax income if corrected | $(160,000) |
The Evidence and Management's Position
The write-down concerns 2,100 units of last year's tent and sleeping bag models, carried at $610,000. The file's listing of slow-moving stock shows no sales of those models in the last nine months, the sales history shows the current models replacing them in every channel, and the only offer received, from a liquidator in February, was $90,000 for the lot. Net realizable value is therefore about $90,000, and the required write-down is $520,000.
Management's reasons are recorded fairly. Management believes the old models can be sold through a new outlet store planned for next spring, at prices near cost, and notes that outdoor gear is seasonal and slow periods are normal. The team considered this. The outlet store has no lease, budget or opening date, the models have not sold at any price in nine months including two discount promotions, and the liquidator's offer is the only market evidence available. A plan without evidence of feasibility does not support carrying the inventory at cost.
Question 1: Is the Misstatement Material?
Yes, on two grounds. Quantitatively, $610,000 exceeds overall materiality of $400,000. Qualitatively, recording it would turn reported pretax income of $450,000 into a loss of $160,000, and a misstatement that changes a profit into a loss is material to users whatever its size relative to a benchmark. The auditor must evaluate uncorrected misstatements individually and in total, considering both their size and nature (American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, 2011); on either test, these are material.
Question 2: Is It Pervasive?
No. A misstatement is pervasive if its effects are not confined to specific elements, accounts or items of the financial statements, or, if confined, represent a substantial proportion of the statements, or relate to disclosures fundamental to users' understanding (American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, 2019). The misstatement here is confined to inventory and cost of sales, and to the related tax effects. It can be measured precisely. It does not affect revenue, receivables, liabilities other than taxes, or the company's cash position, and it does not call into question the reliability of the rest of the statements. Users can understand the effect from a description and adjust for it.
The Opinion
A material but not pervasive misstatement calls for a qualified opinion: the statements are presented fairly in all material respects except for the effects of the matter described. An adverse opinion, stating that the statements are not presented fairly, would be required only if the misstatement were both material and pervasive. The distinction is not a technicality; an adverse opinion tells users the statements as a whole cannot be relied on, which would overstate the problem here.
The report will include a basis for qualified opinion paragraph stating that inventory is carried at $610,000 for obsolete models whose net realizable value is about $90,000, that generally accepted accounting principles require inventory to be written down when its cost exceeds what it can be sold for less the costs of selling it, and that had the write-down been recorded, inventory and net income would each have been reduced by $520,000, before tax, turning the reported pretax profit into a loss (Arens et al., 2020).
Before the Report Is Issued
The partner should discuss the qualification with the audit committee before the report is dated, since management may choose to record the write-down once it understands the consequence; if it does, the opinion will be unmodified. The management representation letter should include management's representation on the inventory's recoverability, and the team should consider whether management's refusal, alongside the other uncorrected items, all of which overstate income, indicates bias that bears on other estimates. The summary of misstatements and this memo are filed at A-5. If management does record the write-down, the remaining $90,000 of uncorrected items would fall below materiality, and the team would reassess them only for their qualitative effects before issuing an unmodified opinion.
References
American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. (2011). Clarification and recodification (Statement on Auditing Standards No. 122). AICPA.
American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. (2019). Auditor reporting and amendments, including amendments addressing disclosures in the audit of financial statements (Statement on Auditing Standards No. 134). AICPA.
Arens, A. A., Elder, R. J., Beasley, M. S., & Hogan, C. E. (2020). Auditing and assurance services (17th ed.). Pearson.
ACC 491 Topic 8 instructions, in plain terms
The Topic 8 instructions in ACC-491 ask students to determine the appropriate form of audit opinion. Weak submissions choose an opinion without working through the criteria. The assignment rewards memos that summarize uncorrected misstatements, present the evidence and management's position fairly, and answer separately whether the misstatement is material and whether it is pervasive. Students should apply quantitative and qualitative materiality, explain why a confined, measurable misstatement is not pervasive, select and draft the basis for the opinion and describe communications and representations before the report is issued.
Inside the ACC 491 Topic 8 example
First in the memo is the summary of uncorrected misstatements, all figures illustrative: the $520,000 obsolescence write-down management refused, supported by the file's listing of slow-moving stock and the sales history behind it, plus $90,000 of smaller items, for $610,000 against materiality of $400,000. Management's reasons for declining are recorded fairly. The memo then works the two questions that decide the opinion. The misstatement is material, on amount and because recording it would turn a reported profit into a loss. It is not pervasive, since it is confined to inventory and cost of sales, can be measured precisely and leaves the rest of the statements reliable. That combination points to a qualified opinion rather than an adverse one, and because the evidence was obtained, a disclaimer does not apply. The draft basis paragraph states the effect on each affected line.
Reading the ACC 491 Topic 8 rubric
Faculty grading the opinion memo reward the two questions answered separately. Excellent memos find materiality both in amount and in turning a profit into a loss. Credit goes to explaining why a misstatement confined to inventory and cost of sales is not pervasive. The rubric values recording management's reasons and the evidence against them fairly and drafting the basis for qualified opinion. The highest level addresses audit committee communication, representations and possible bias. Memos that choose an adverse opinion for a confined misstatement usually lose marks.
ACC 491 Topic 8 help: mistakes that cost marks
Opinion papers at the end of the course are judged on whether the report follows from the file. A memo that moves to a disclaimer because management refused the adjustment has confused a disagreement about accounting with an inability to obtain evidence, and markers catch the mix-up. Choosing an adverse opinion for a misstatement confined to one account overstates its reach, while an unmodified opinion with the $520,000 left in treats a material error as tolerable. Papers that test materiality on amount alone miss the change from profit to loss, the qualitative factor that makes this case clear. Memos without cross-references to the working papers ask the reviewer to take the totals on trust. The last loss is draft wording that names the departure and omits its effect on the affected lines, which the basis paragraph exists to state.
Get an ACC-491 Topic 8 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-491 Topic 8 instructions, the rubric from your classroom and the case facts or misstatement summary your section assigned. We write a custom example to them, with uncorrected misstatements summarized and cross-referenced, materiality and pervasiveness weighed separately, the rejected opinions ruled out and the report wording drafted, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More ACC 491 papers and BS in Accounting samples
- ACC 491 Topic 1: Audit Opinion Scope Memo
- ACC 491 Topic 2: Covered Member Interest Analysis
- ACC 491 Topic 3: Assertion Level Risk Matrix
- ACC 491 Topic 4: Control Reliance Decision Memo
- ACC 491 Topic 5: Evidence Sufficiency Discussion Post
- ACC 491 Topic 6: Attribute Sampling Evaluation
- ACC 491 Topic 7: Receivables Confirmation Working Paper
- ACC 240 Topic 8: Accounting Cycle Explainer
- ACC 486 Topic 8: Valuation Sensitivity Table
- ACC 250 Topic 8: Annual Report Evaluation
- ACC 465 Topic 8: Loss Limitation Position Memo
ACC 491 Topic 8 questions, answered
What is the difference between a qualified and an adverse opinion?
Reach. Both respond to material misstatement, but a qualified opinion says the statements are presented fairly except for the effects of a specific matter, while an adverse opinion says they are not presented fairly at all, because the effects are pervasive. A misstatement confined to one or two accounts and measurable usually leads to a qualification; one that distorts the statements as a whole leads to an adverse opinion.
When is a disclaimer the right choice?
When the auditor cannot obtain sufficient appropriate evidence on which to base an opinion and the possible effects of what went unexamined could be both material and pervasive. It is a statement that no opinion can be given, not a finding that the statements are wrong. Refusing to record a known adjustment is a disagreement about the accounting, which the evidence can measure, so it does not produce a disclaimer.
Does the auditor tell anyone before issuing the qualified report?
Yes. Uncorrected misstatements are reported to management and to the owners, who hold governance responsibility at a private company like this one, together with their effect on the opinion, and the auditor asks for them to be corrected. The memo records those communications with their dates. If management records the write-down after all, the matter falls away and the memo is revised to support an unmodified opinion.
Where can I find a free ACC 491 Topic 8 sample paper?
Read the full memo above: the uncorrected misstatements, evidence and management's position, whether they are material, whether they are pervasive, the opinion and steps before issuance. Share your misstatement summary for a free worked memo.
Why qualified rather than adverse in ACC 491 Topic 8?
The misstatement is material but not pervasive: it is confined to inventory and cost of sales, measurable and does not undermine the rest of the statements.