| Course | ACC 502 Accounting Practices |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 4 |
| Paper type | Inventory method analysis |
| Length | About 960 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 502 Topic 4
Same Bicycles, Three Profits: Running One Quarter's Inventory Through FIFO, LIFO and Average Cost, and Choosing on the Business's Own Terms
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
ACC-502: Accounting Practices
Topic 4 Inventory Method Analysis
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Same Bicycles, Three Profits: Running One Quarter's Inventory Through FIFO, LIFO and Average Cost, and Choosing on the Business's Own Terms
The Question
A business that buys identical goods at different prices has to choose which purchase prices flow to the goods sold and which stay with the goods still on hand. The physical bicycles are the same whichever assumption is chosen, but the reported profit is not. This analysis runs one quarter of a composite bicycle shop's purchases and sales of a single commuter model through three cost flow assumptions, first-in first-out, last-in first-out and weighted average, and reports what changes. It then chooses one, on grounds a reader can evaluate. All figures are illustrative.
The Quarter's Data
The shop began the quarter with 20 bicycles costing 500 dollars each, 10,000 dollars in total. It bought 30 more at 540 dollars and later 25 more at 580 dollars as the manufacturer raised prices. It had 75 bicycles available at a total cost of 40,700 dollars. It sold 55 of them at 900 dollars each, 49,500 dollars in revenue, and ended the quarter with 20 on hand.
Three Assumptions
Under first-in first-out, the earliest costs go to the bicycles sold. Cost of goods sold is the 20 at 500, the 30 at 540 and 5 of the 580 bicycles, 29,100 dollars, and the 20 left on hand are carried at the latest cost of 580, or 11,600 dollars.
Under last-in first-out, applied here at period end, the latest costs go to the bicycles sold: the 25 at 580 and the 30 at 540, 30,700 dollars. The 20 on hand are carried at the oldest cost of 500, or 10,000 dollars.
Under weighted average, every bicycle carries the average cost of all those available, 40,700 divided by 75, about 542.67 dollars. Cost of goods sold is about 29,847 dollars and ending inventory about 10,853.
Table 1
One Quarter Under Three Cost Flow Assumptions, Dollars
| Measure | FIFO | LIFO | Weighted average |
|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue | 49,500 | 49,500 | 49,500 |
| Cost of goods sold | 29,100 | 30,700 | About 29,847 |
| Gross profit | 20,400 | 18,800 | About 19,653 |
| Ending inventory | 11,600 | 10,000 | About 10,853 |
Why the Results Differ
Identical physical activity produces gross profit ranging from 18,800 to 20,400 dollars. The direction of the difference comes from the price movement in the data, not from a rule about the methods. Prices rose during the quarter, so the method that assigns the latest, highest costs to goods sold, LIFO, reports the lowest profit, and the method that assigns the earliest, lowest costs, FIFO, reports the highest. If prices had fallen, the order would reverse: LIFO would report the highest profit. Kieso et al. (2019) stress this dependence on price trends, which is why memorizing which method gives higher profit, without asking which way prices moved, leads to wrong answers.
The Tax Consequence
LIFO's lower reported profit when prices rise also means lower taxable income. At a 21 percent tax rate, the 1,600-dollar difference in gross profit between FIFO and LIFO would save the shop about 336 dollars of tax this quarter. The saving is real but comes with a condition: under the federal LIFO conformity rule, a business electing LIFO on its tax return is required to report on the same basis in the statements it gives to owners and lenders (Last-in, First-out Inventories, 2018). The shop cannot report the higher FIFO profit to its bank while paying tax on the lower LIFO profit.
What the Methods Do Not Change
The methods change how cost is divided between the income statement and the balance sheet; they do not change the total. Under every assumption, cost of goods sold plus ending inventory equals the 40,700 dollars the shop spent on bicycles available for sale. Nor do the methods change cash: the shop paid the same amounts to the manufacturer whichever assumption it uses, apart from the tax effect under LIFO. A reader comparing two shops that use different methods should therefore adjust for the method before comparing their margins, or one shop will look more profitable for reasons unconnected to how well it is run. That is why the method appears in the notes accompanying the statements.
The Choice
The analysis recommends FIFO for the shop. Its bicycles are sold roughly in the order they arrive, so FIFO matches the physical flow. FIFO carries ending inventory at recent costs, so the balance sheet shows what the stock would cost to replace, which matters to the bank that lends against it. The tax saving from LIFO, about 336 dollars a quarter at current price increases, is modest for a business of this size, and adopting LIFO would require reporting the lower LIFO profit to the bank under the conformity rule. Weighted average is a reasonable middle course, but it offers neither FIFO's match to physical flow nor LIFO's tax advantage.
Consistency and Disclosure
A method, once adopted, is applied the same way every period and disclosed in the financial statements. A business that switched methods whenever one produced a more convenient profit would make its results meaningless over time, which is the abuse the accounting rules on changes in method exist to prevent. A change is permitted only when the new method is preferable, and its effect must be applied retrospectively and explained (Financial Accounting Standards Board, 2005).
Conclusion
The same 55 bicycles produce three different profits depending on a cost flow assumption, because prices rose during the quarter. FIFO suits the shop's physical flow and its lender's needs, LIFO's tax saving is small and comes with the conformity requirement, and whichever method is chosen must be kept and disclosed. The owners should revisit the choice only if the business's inventory or tax position changes materially, and disclose any change when it is made. Either way, the choice should be written into the shop's accounting policies.
References
Financial Accounting Standards Board. (2005). Accounting changes and error corrections (Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 154). FASB.
Kieso, D. E., Weygandt, J. J., & Warfield, T. D. (2019). Intermediate accounting (17th ed.). Wiley.
Last-in, First-out Inventories, 26 U.S.C. ยง 472 (2018).
The ACC-502 Topic 4 assignment instructions
In Topic 4, ACC-502 asks MBA students to compare inventory cost flow methods and choose one. Strong analyses run the same purchases and sales through each method, report cost of goods sold, ending inventory and profit side by side, and explain the direction of the differences from the price trend rather than a memorized rule. Students should address the tax consequence and the LIFO conformity rule, state what the methods do not change, defend a choice on the business's own circumstances and explain consistency and disclosure requirements. Students should also compare cost of goods sold, ending inventory and taxes under each method on the same purchase data.
Inside the ACC 502 Topic 4 example
The finished example runs one set of purchases and sales through each method and reports what changes. Cost of goods sold, ending inventory and reported profit are shown for each assumption, so the reader sees that a choice about paperwork produces a different profit from identical physical activity. The direction of the difference is explained by the price movement in the data rather than memorized as a rule, since the relationship reverses when prices fall. The example then chooses, defending the selection on what the business actually is, and it addresses the tax consequence honestly. Consistency and disclosure requirements appear, because a method chosen and then changed for convenience is the abuse the rules exist to prevent.
Where the marks sit in the ACC 502 Topic 4 rubric
Faculty reward an analysis that explains differences from the data. An Excellent paper computes all three methods for 55 bikes sold and shows the totals tying to 40,700 dollars. Credit goes to explaining that rising prices make LIFO report the lowest profit and that falling prices would reverse it, following Kieso, Weygandt and Warfield. The rubric values the tax saving of about 336 dollars and the conformity rule in section 472. Strong papers choose FIFO for physical flow and the lender. Top marks go to consistency under FASB rules on accounting changes. Papers that tie the method choice to the shop's tax position and its lender's view of the balance sheet show judgment beyond the calculation.
ACC 502 Topic 4 help before you submit
Computing one method and describing the others is the shortfall this topic is built to expose, since the comparison is the assignment. A second weakness is stating which method reports higher income as a fixed rule, because the answer inverts when prices fall and a paper that has memorized it will be wrong on the falling case. Papers lose marks for confusing physical flow with cost flow, which produces claims about which goods actually left the warehouse that the accounting does not make. Choosing a method because it produces a better looking result, without addressing consistency, misses the ethical dimension the rubric usually includes. Arithmetic errors carry directly here. Inventory figures reported without stating the method used cannot be compared with anything.
Get an ACC-502 Topic 4 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-502 Topic 4 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with the purchase and sale data your section supplied. We write a custom example to those criteria, with each method computed in full, the results compared side by side, the direction explained by price movement and a choice defended, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.
More ACC 502 papers and MBA samples
- ACC 502 Topic 1: Accounting Equation Write-up
- ACC 502 Topic 2: Accounting Cycle Problem Set
- ACC 502 Topic 3: Adjusting Entries Exercise
- ACC 502 Topic 5: Depreciation Method Analysis
- ACC 502 Topic 6: Financing and Equity Analysis
- ACC 502 Topic 7: Cash Flow Statement Build
- ACC 502 Topic 8: Ratio and Control Analysis
- ACC 650 Topic 4: Contribution Margin Analysis
- UNV 504 Topic 4: Short Argument Paper
- BUS 635 Topic 4: Media Rights Cycle Analysis
- SYM 506 Topic 4: Normal Distribution Application
ACC 502 Topic 4 questions, answered
Does the cost flow assumption have to match the physical flow?
No, and that surprises people. A shop may sell its oldest stock first while costing inventory on an entirely different assumption, because the assumption concerns how costs move through the accounts rather than how goods move through the door. Some methods happen to match common physical practice, which is why the two get conflated, but the accounting does not require it.
Which method reports the higher income?
It depends on which way prices moved, which is why memorizing the answer fails. When costs are rising, a method that charges older cheaper costs to expense leaves higher income and higher inventory value; when costs fall, the relationship reverses. Work it from the data in front of you rather than reciting the rising price case, which is the only one most students have practiced.
Can a company change its method?
Yes, but not casually, and the constraint is the point of the consistency principle. A change requires justification, disclosure and usually restatement of comparatives, precisely so that a company cannot improve its reported results by switching methods when convenient. Mentioning that requirement in the paper shows you understand why the choice matters beyond the arithmetic.
Where can I find a free ACC 502 Topic 4 sample paper?
The inventory analysis is shown here complete: the question, the quarter's data, three assumptions, why results differ, the tax consequence, what the methods do not change, the choice, consistency and disclosure and the conclusion. Bring your inventory records and we will run the methods free.
Why does LIFO report less profit in ACC 502 Topic 4?
Prices rose during the quarter, so assigning the latest, highest costs to bikes sold raises cost of goods sold. If prices fell, LIFO would report the most profit instead.