| Course | ACC 502 Accounting Practices |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 6 |
| Paper type | Financing and equity analysis |
| Length | About 980 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 502 Topic 6
The Same 200,000 Dollars Raised Twice: Following a Shop's Expansion Through Debt and Through Equity, and the Obligations a Balance Sheet Can Hide
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
ACC-502: Accounting Practices
Topic 6 Financing and Equity Analysis
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
The Same 200,000 Dollars Raised Twice: Following a Shop's Expansion Through Debt and Through Equity, and the Obligations a Balance Sheet Can Hide
The Decision
A composite bicycle shop needs 200,000 dollars to open a second location. It can borrow the money as a five-year bank loan at 7 percent interest, or it can sell a 25 percent ownership stake to a new investor for the same amount. The cash received is identical. This analysis follows both choices through the financial statements and shows that the statements look entirely different afterward. It then turns to obligations that do not appear on the face of the balance sheet at all. Figures are illustrative.
Raising the Money as Debt
Under debt, the shop receives 200,000 dollars in cash and records a liability of the same amount. Entry: debit Cash 200,000; credit Notes Payable 200,000. Each year, interest of 14,000 dollars becomes an expense that reduces reported income, and the loan must be repaid whatever happens to the business. The original owners keep all of the ownership and all of the profit after interest.
Raising the Money as Equity
Under equity, the shop receives the same 200,000 dollars in cash, but no liability appears. Entry: debit Cash 200,000; credit Contributed Capital 200,000. There is no interest expense and no repayment obligation. Instead, the new investor owns a quarter of the business and is entitled to a quarter of its profits and a voice in its decisions. The cost of equity is dilution, which does not appear as an expense on the income statement.
The Statements Compared
Suppose the expanded shop earns 60,000 dollars a year before interest and tax, and pays tax at 21 percent. Under debt, interest of 14,000 reduces pretax income to 46,000, tax is 9,660 and net income is 36,340 dollars, all belonging to the original owners. Under equity, there is no interest, pretax income is 60,000, tax is 12,600 and net income is 47,400 dollars, of which the original owners' 75 percent share is 35,550.
Table 1
Debt and Equity Compared for the Same 200,000 Dollars, Illustrative
| Measure | Debt | Equity |
|---|---|---|
| Cash received | 200,000 | 200,000 |
| New liability on the balance sheet | 200,000 | None |
| New contributed capital | None | 200,000 |
| Annual interest expense | 14,000 | None |
| Net income | 36,340 | 47,400 |
| Original owners' share of net income | 36,340 (100%) | 35,550 (75%) |
| Repayment required | Yes, over five years | No |
Reading the Comparison
Equity reports higher net income, because interest is an expense and payments to owners are not. But the original owners' share of income is slightly lower under equity, because they now share all profits with the investor. A reader comparing net income alone would think equity was the better choice; the owners' own return tells a different story. The balance sheet differs too: under debt, liabilities rise by 200,000 and the shop looks more heavily indebted to a future lender; under equity, it looks stronger, but the original owners control less of it. If the new location struggles, debt still has to be repaid, while equity investors simply share a smaller profit.
Which the Owners Should Choose
The accounting comparison informs the decision without making it. If the owners are confident the new location will earn at least 60,000 dollars a year, debt keeps them in full control and leaves them with slightly more income, and the interest is tax-deductible. If the new location's results are uncertain, equity shares the risk: in a bad year, the shop owes the investor nothing, whereas the bank must still be paid. The owners also give up a quarter of every future year's profit under equity, a cost that grows if the business does well. The statements show these consequences; the owners must weigh them.
Obligations Not on the Face of the Balance Sheet
A reader who looks only at the balance sheet will miss obligations that matter. The shop is negotiating a ten-year lease for the new location. Under current lease accounting, a lease of more than twelve months appears on the balance sheet as both an asset for the right to use the item and a liability for the payments (Financial Accounting Standards Board, 2016), so the lease will appear once signed, but the commitments under leases not yet commenced appear only in the notes. The shop also faces a claim from a customer injured on a demonstration bike. A loss contingency is recorded only if a loss is probable and can be reasonably estimated; if it is only reasonably possible, it is disclosed in the notes instead (Financial Accounting Standards Board, 1975). The shop's lawyer judges the claim reasonably possible, so it will appear in the notes and not on the balance sheet. A lender who skipped the notes would miss both.
Equity Transactions and Retained Earnings
Under the equity option, the investor's 200,000 dollars goes to contributed capital. Profits the business keeps accumulate in retained earnings, and dividends paid to owners reduce it. If the shop earns 47,400 dollars and pays 12,000 in dividends, retained earnings rise by 35,400. Retained earnings is often misread as a fund of cash the business can draw on. It is not: it is the cumulative profit the owners have left in the business over its life, and the cash those profits produced has long since been spent on inventory, equipment and the new location. A business can have large retained earnings and little cash (Weygandt et al., 2021).
Conclusion
Raising 200,000 dollars as debt or as equity brings in the same cash but produces different statements: a liability and interest expense under debt, contributed capital and dilution under equity. Net income alone favors equity, while the owners' return favors debt slightly in this case, and the risk of repayment favors equity. Lease commitments and contingencies may sit in the notes rather than on the balance sheet, and retained earnings records accumulated profit, not available cash. A reader needs all of this to judge the shop's financial position.
References
Financial Accounting Standards Board. (1975). Accounting for contingencies (Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 5). FASB.
Financial Accounting Standards Board. (2016). Leases (Topic 842) (Accounting Standards Update No. 2016-02). FASB.
Weygandt, J. J., Kimmel, P. D., & Mitchell, J. E. (2021). Accounting principles (14th ed.). Wiley.
What the ACC 502 Topic 6 instructions ask for
The Topic 6 brief in ACC-502 asks MBA students to analyze how financing choices are reported. Strong analyses record the same amount raised as debt and as equity, show the resulting balance sheets and income statements, and explain why net income and the owners' return can point in different directions. Students should explain obligations that may appear only in the notes, such as lease commitments and loss contingencies, show how equity transactions affect retained earnings, and explain why retained earnings is not a fund of cash. Students should also explain how retained earnings differ from cash and how lease obligations now appear on the balance sheet.
How this ACC 502 Topic 6 example is built
The finished example raises the same sum two ways and reports both. Under debt, a liability appears, interest becomes an expense that reduces reported income, and a repayment obligation exists whatever happens to the business. Under equity, no liability appears, no interest expense arises, and ownership is diluted instead. The example shows both sets of entries and both resulting balance sheet positions. Contingent and long term obligations are handled carefully, including the ones that appear in notes rather than on the face of the statements, since a reader who looks only at the balance sheet will miss them. Equity transactions are worked through, and retained earnings is explained as an accumulation rather than as a fund.
Reading the ACC 502 Topic 6 rubric
Faculty reward an analysis that works both financing routes fully. An Excellent paper journalizes the loan and the share issue and tables their statement effects. Credit goes to showing net income higher under equity while the owners' share is higher under debt. The rubric values lease recognition under ASC 842 and contingencies disclosed under FASB Statement No. 5 when only reasonably possible. Strong papers explain retained earnings as an accumulation, not a fund. Top marks go to weighing control, risk and dilution in the choice. Papers that compare the owners' control and risk under each financing choice, not only the statements, show the decision weighed as the owners would weigh it.
Common ACC 502 Topic 6 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Describing debt and equity in general terms is the shortfall, since the topic asks how each appears in the statements and a discussion of financing philosophy does not answer it. A second weakness is treating retained earnings as cash available for distribution, which is the misconception the topic exists to correct and which faculty check for directly. Papers lose marks for omitting the note disclosures, because a company's real obligations frequently exceed what the balance sheet shows and a reader who stops at the face of it is misled. Missing the interest effect on income leaves the comparison incomplete. Entries recorded without the resulting position defeat the purpose of working both routes.
Get an ACC-502 Topic 6 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-502 Topic 6 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with the financing scenario your section supplied. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the same sum raised both ways, entries and resulting positions shown for each, note obligations included and retained earnings explained accurately, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.
More ACC 502 papers and MBA samples
- ACC 502 Topic 1: Accounting Equation Write-up
- ACC 502 Topic 2: Accounting Cycle Problem Set
- ACC 502 Topic 3: Adjusting Entries Exercise
- ACC 502 Topic 4: Inventory Method Analysis
- ACC 502 Topic 5: Depreciation Method Analysis
- ACC 502 Topic 7: Cash Flow Statement Build
- ACC 502 Topic 8: Ratio and Control Analysis
- ACC 650 Topic 6: Master Budget Build
- UNV 504 Topic 6: Ethical Lens Analysis
- BUS 635 Topic 6: Merchandise Margin Analysis
- SYM 506 Topic 6: Confidence Interval Report
ACC 502 Topic 6 questions, answered
Is retained earnings the same as cash?
No, and the confusion is worth clearing early. Retained earnings records the cumulative profit a company has not distributed, but that profit was long since converted into inventory, equipment, receivables or anything else the business bought. A company can hold a large retained earnings balance and almost no cash, which is why a dividend decision depends on the cash position rather than on that figure.
Why does debt look worse on the balance sheet than equity?
Because it creates an obligation the company must meet regardless of performance, and that appears as a liability. Equity carries no such requirement, so nothing is recorded as owed. That does not make equity cheaper; it dilutes ownership and existing owners give up a share of future results permanently, which is a real cost the statements do not show as one.
What obligations are not on the balance sheet?
Several kinds, disclosed in the notes rather than on the face. Operating commitments, guarantees, pending litigation and contingent liabilities that are possible but not probable all sit there. A reader confined to the balance sheet can substantially understate what a company owes, which is why financial analysis always reads the notes and why the topic includes them.
Where can I find a free ACC 502 Topic 6 sample paper?
The financing analysis appears here complete: the decision, debt, equity, the statements compared, reading the comparison, which to choose, off-balance-sheet obligations, equity and retained earnings and the conclusion. Outline the financing choice in your case and an analysis follows free.
Why does equity show higher net income in ACC 502 Topic 6?
Interest on debt is an expense, while payments to owners are not. Net income is 47,400 under equity against 36,340 under debt, though the original owners keep less under equity.