ACC 650 Topic 3 activity based costing analysis example

Managerial Accounting Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This ACC 650 Topic 3 sample paper costs a composite furniture maker's chairs, benches and teak dining sets under a 20-dollar plantwide labor-hour rate and under four activity pools. It was prepared for GCU ACC 650, Managerial Accounting, catalog code ACC-650, an MBA course at Grand Canyon University. Setups at 400 dollars each, design at 60 an hour, handling at 52.50 a move and machining at 12 an hour shift the teak sets' overhead from 500 to 1,150 dollars, turning a 400-dollar profit into a 250-dollar loss at a 4,800 price. The paper checks the drivers and weighs the method's upkeep.

CourseACC 650 Managerial Accounting
TopicTopic 3
Paper typeActivity-based costing analysis
LengthAbout 1,030 words, 2 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMBA
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for ACC 650 Topic 3

1

The Teak Set Was Losing Money All Along: Costing Three Products Under a Plantwide Rate and Under Activity Drivers

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

ACC-650: Managerial Accounting

Topic 3 Activity-Based Costing Analysis

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the reversal the analysis demonstrates. The furniture maker and every figure are a composite; the sources are real.
2

The Teak Set Was Losing Money All Along: Costing Three Products Under a Plantwide Rate and Under Activity Drivers

The Question

A composite outdoor furniture maker sells three products: simple Adirondack chairs in high volume, about 20,000 a year; benches, about 3,000 a year; and complex custom teak dining sets, about 200 a year. It assigns its 480,000 dollars of annual manufacturing overhead using one plantwide rate of 20 dollars per direct labor hour. This analysis costs the same three products under that rate and then under activity-based costing, which assigns overhead through the activities that cause it, and shows that the product that looked profitable is not. Figures are illustrative.

The Plantwide Rate

Under the plantwide rate, overhead follows direct labor hours. A chair takes 0.8 labor hours and receives 16 dollars of overhead; a bench takes 1 hour and receives 20 dollars; an average teak set takes 25 hours and receives 500 dollars. Added to prime costs, direct materials and labor, of about 50.40, 68 and 3,900 dollars, the full costs are 66.40 dollars for a chair, 88 for a bench and 4,400 for a teak set. At prices of 95, 120 and 4,800 dollars, all three products appear profitable, with the teak set earning about 400 dollars each.

Activity Pools and Their Drivers

Activity-based costing groups overhead into pools by activity and assigns each pool using a driver that causes its cost (Cooper & Kaplan, 1988). A driver must cause the cost, not merely move with volume. The maker identifies four pools.

Machine setups cost 120,000 dollars a year. The driver is the number of setups: changing a machine for a new job takes the same effort whether the run is ten chairs or one dining set. There were 300 setups, so each costs 400 dollars. Design and engineering cost 96,000 dollars, driven by design hours, 1,600 in the year, or 60 dollars an hour. Materials handling costs 84,000 dollars, driven by material moves, 1,600 in the year, or 52.50 dollars a move. Machine operations cost 180,000 dollars, driven by machine hours, 15,000 in the year, or 12 dollars an hour.

Table 1

Activity Pools, Drivers and Rates

PoolCost, dollarsDriverChairsBenchesTeak setsRate
Setups120,000Setups4060200400 per setup
Design and engineering96,000Design hours1001001,40060 per hour
Materials handling84,000Moves60020080052.50 per move
Machine operations180,000Machine hours12,0001,0002,00012 per hour

The Reversal

Assigning each pool by its driver gives very different overhead per unit. Chairs absorb 197,500 dollars of overhead across 20,000 units, about 9.88 dollars each, instead of 16. Benches absorb 52,500 across 3,000 units, 17.50 each, instead of 20. Teak sets absorb 230,000 dollars across only 200 units, 1,150 dollars each, instead of 500. Each teak set requires its own setup and many design hours and material moves, costs the plantwide rate spread across all products by labor hours.

With activity-based overhead, a teak set costs about 5,050 dollars to make against a price of 4,800, a loss of about 250 dollars on each set. Chairs earn about 34.72 dollars each rather than 28.60. The low-volume, complex product had been subsidized by the high-volume, simple one, which is the pattern activity-based costing exists to reveal.

Table 2

Unit Cost and Margin Under Two Methods, Dollars

ProductPlantwide costActivity-based costPricePlantwide marginActivity-based margin
Chair66.40About 60.289528.60About 34.72
Bench88.0085.5012032.0034.50
Teak set4,4005,0504,800400Minus 250

Checking the Drivers

Before acting, the maker should check that each driver truly causes its pool's cost. Setups are a sound driver: the time to change a machine is roughly the same for any run. Design hours are directly logged by the designers. Materials handling is less certain, because a move of heavy teak slabs takes longer than a move of chair parts; weighting moves by time would refine the teak sets' share. If the teak sets' handling cost were halved by such a refinement, their activity-based cost would still exceed their price, so the conclusion survives the check. That is the test any activity analysis should pass before it drives a pricing decision.

Decision Consequences

The analysis changes three decisions. On pricing, the teak sets are underpriced by at least 250 dollars each; the maker should raise prices for complex designs or charge separately for design work. On product mix, the maker should reconsider pursuing more teak orders at current prices, since each additional set loses money, while chairs are more profitable than believed. On cost reduction, the activity view shows where to look: standardizing teak designs to cut design hours and setups would reduce the sets' cost far more than cutting labor hours, which the plantwide rate would have pointed to.

The Cost of the Method

Activity-based costing takes real effort to maintain. Someone must track setups, design hours and material moves, and keep the drivers and rates current as the business changes. It is not worth it everywhere: a business with similar products that use activities in similar proportions gains little over a plantwide rate. Kaplan and Anderson (2004) proposed a time-driven version, which estimates the time each activity takes and the cost of capacity per minute, to reduce the effort of maintaining the system. For this maker, whose products differ sharply in complexity, the effort pays for itself in the teak set decision alone.

What the Plantwide Rate Assumed

A single plantwide rate assumes that every product draws on overhead in proportion to one measure, usually labor or machine hours (Garrison et al., 2021). That assumption holds when products are made in similar ways. It fails here because the teak set is made in small, complex batches that need frequent setups, special finishing and extra inspection, while the chairs run in long, simple batches. The rate therefore spread the teak set's support costs across the chairs, flattering the set and burdening the line that was actually profitable.

Conclusion

Under a plantwide rate, all three products appeared profitable. Assigning overhead by the activities that cause it shows the teak sets losing about 250 dollars each and the chairs earning more than believed. The reversal changes pricing, product mix and where the maker should look to cut costs.

References

Cooper, R., & Kaplan, R. S. (1988). Measure costs right: Make the right decisions. Harvard Business Review, 66(5), 96-103.

Garrison, R. H., Noreen, E. W., & Brewer, P. C. (2021). Managerial accounting (17th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.

Kaplan, R. S., & Anderson, S. R. (2004). Time-driven activity-based costing. Harvard Business Review, 82(11), 131-138.

The ACC-650 Topic 3 assignment instructions

Topic 3 of ACC-650 asks MBA students to compare traditional and activity-based costing. Strong analyses cost the same products both ways, define activity pools with drivers that cause their costs, and show any reversal in product profitability that results. Students should check that drivers cause rather than merely correlate with cost, weigh the method's cost of maintenance, and draw consequences for pricing, product mix and cost reduction. A table of pools, drivers and rates should make each assignment traceable, and the reversal should be tested against a refinement of the weakest driver. Students should also explain what the plantwide rate assumed about how products consume support activities, and why that assumption failed here.

Inside the ACC 650 Topic 3 example

The finished example produces a reversal rather than describing one. The same product set is costed under a plantwide rate and then under activity pools with drivers, and the low volume complex product turns out to have been subsidized by the high volume simple one, which is the pattern the method exists to reveal. Each activity pool is named with the driver that causes its cost, and the example is careful that a driver has to cause the cost rather than merely correlate with volume. The implementation cost is addressed honestly, since activity costing takes real effort to maintain and is not worth it everywhere. The decision consequences are drawn: pricing, product mix and where to look for cost reduction.

ACC 650 Topic 3 rubric: what Excellent looks like

Faculty reward an analysis that produces the reversal and tests it. An Excellent paper sets four pools and their rates in a table and shows the teak sets moving from a 400-dollar profit to a 250-dollar loss. Credit goes to Cooper and Kaplan on measuring costs right and to checking that handling moves truly drive cost. The rubric values consequences for pricing design work, product mix and standardizing designs. Strong papers weigh the method's upkeep with Kaplan and Anderson's time-driven version. Top marks go to showing the conclusion survives a driver refinement. Papers that identify which product was subsidizing which, and what the furniture maker should do about the teak set's price or design, carry the costing through to a decision.

Common ACC 650 Topic 3 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Describing activity costing without recosting anything defeats the assignment, since the entire argument depends on showing that the numbers actually move. A second weakness is drivers chosen that are really volume in disguise, which reproduces the plantwide result and demonstrates nothing. Papers lose marks for recommending adoption without weighing the maintenance burden, because the method is expensive to run and is genuinely not worth it in a single product operation. Failing to identify which product subsidized which leaves the analysis short of its finding. Recosting products and then drawing no pricing or mix consequences ends the paper before the decisions the numbers were computed for. Pools built without naming the activity that consumes them cannot be defended to anybody.

Get an ACC-650 Topic 3 example written to your instructions

Send the ACC-650 Topic 3 problems and the rubric your classroom posts, with the product and overhead data your section supplied. We write a custom example to those criteria, with both costings tabulated together, drivers that cause rather than correlate, the cross subsidy named and the maintenance cost weighed, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.

More ACC 650 papers and MBA samples

ACC 650 Topic 3 questions, answered

What makes a good cost driver?

Something that causes the cost to be incurred. Number of setups drives setup cost because each setup consumes the resource; number of units does not, because a thousand unit run and a ten unit run need one setup each. Testing whether the driver causes rather than merely accompanies the cost is what separates a real activity system from a relabeled volume allocation.

Why do low volume products come out more expensive?

Because they consume activities disproportionately to their volume. A product made in small batches needs as many setups, inspections and orders as one made in large batches, so it absorbs those costs on far fewer units. A volume based rate spreads them evenly and hides it, which is why the high volume product appears to cost more than it does and subsidizes the other.

Is activity based costing always worth adopting?

No, and saying so demonstrates judgment. It requires identifying activities, measuring drivers and maintaining the data, which is ongoing work. In a firm with one product, or where overhead is a small share of total cost, the plantwide rate is close enough and the effort is wasted. The case for adoption strengthens with product diversity and with overhead as a proportion of cost.

Where can I find a free ACC 650 Topic 3 sample paper?

The activity-based costing analysis is printed here in full: the question, the plantwide rate, activity pools and drivers, the reversal, checking the drivers, decision consequences, the method's cost and the conclusion. Share your products and overhead data and we will cost them at no charge.

Why do teak sets absorb more overhead in ACC 650 Topic 3?

Each set needs its own setup and many design hours and material moves. The plantwide rate spread those costs by labor hours across all products, hiding about 650 dollars per set.