| Course | ACC 650 Managerial Accounting |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 5 |
| Paper type | Variable and absorption comparison |
| Length | About 1,020 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 650 Topic 5
Two Incomes From One Year: Absorption and Variable Costing for the Chair Line, Reconciled to the Dollar
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
ACC-650: Managerial Accounting
Topic 5 Variable and Absorption Comparison
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Two Incomes From One Year: Absorption and Variable Costing for the Chair Line, Reconciled to the Dollar
The Data
A composite outdoor furniture maker's chair line produced 22,000 Adirondack chairs this year and sold 20,000 at 95 dollars each, leaving 2,000 in ending inventory; there was no beginning inventory. Variable manufacturing costs are 54 dollars a chair, and variable selling costs, mainly commissions, are 4 dollars per chair sold. Fixed manufacturing overhead for the chair line is 330,000 dollars, and fixed selling and administrative costs are 120,000. This paper prepares the year's income statement under absorption costing and under variable costing, shows the two incomes disagreeing, and reconciles the difference exactly. Figures are illustrative.
Absorption Costing
Absorption costing, required for external reporting, treats fixed manufacturing overhead as a product cost. Each chair absorbs a share of it: 330,000 divided by 22,000 chairs produced, or 15 dollars. The unit product cost is 54 plus 15, or 69 dollars.
Table 1
Absorption Costing Income Statement
| Absorption costing income statement | Dollars |
|---|---|
| Sales (20,000 at 95) | 1,900,000 |
| Cost of goods sold (20,000 at 69) | (1,380,000) |
| Gross margin | 520,000 |
| Variable selling costs (20,000 at 4) | (80,000) |
| Fixed selling and administrative costs | (120,000) |
| Net operating income | 320,000 |
Variable Costing
Variable costing treats fixed manufacturing overhead as a period cost, expensed in full in the year incurred, so only variable manufacturing costs attach to units (Garrison et al., 2021). The statement is organized by behavior rather than function, showing contribution margin.
Table 2
Variable Costing Income Statement
| Variable costing income statement | Dollars |
|---|---|
| Sales (20,000 at 95) | 1,900,000 |
| Variable cost of goods sold (20,000 at 54) | (1,080,000) |
| Variable selling costs (20,000 at 4) | (80,000) |
| Contribution margin | 740,000 |
| Fixed manufacturing overhead | (330,000) |
| Fixed selling and administrative costs | (120,000) |
| Net operating income | 290,000 |
The Reconciliation
Absorption costing reports 320,000 dollars of income and variable costing 290,000, a difference of 30,000. The difference is not a difference in performance; the same chairs were made and sold at the same prices and costs. It sits in inventory. Under absorption costing, the 2,000 chairs in ending inventory each carry 15 dollars of fixed overhead, 30,000 dollars in all, which is on the balance sheet rather than expensed this year. Under variable costing, all 330,000 dollars of fixed overhead was expensed. The difference equals the fixed overhead in the change in inventory: 2,000 chairs times 15 dollars, exactly 30,000. When production exceeds sales, absorption income is higher; when sales exceed production and inventory falls, the deferred overhead is released and absorption income is lower.
The Following Year: The Difference Reverses
The deferral is temporary. Suppose that next year the line produces 18,000 chairs and sells 20,000, drawing the 2,000 chairs from inventory, with prices and costs unchanged. Variable costing income is again 290,000 dollars, because sales and costs are the same. Absorption income falls to 260,000. The 2,000 chairs carried over each bring 15 dollars of last year's fixed overhead into this year's cost of goods sold, and the smaller production run raises this year's fixed overhead per chair to about 18.33 dollars. Over the two years together, both methods report the same total income, 580,000 dollars under variable costing and 320,000 plus 260,000 under absorption, because all fixed overhead is eventually expensed. Absorption costing only moves it between years according to inventory changes. A manager judged one year at a time can benefit from that movement; a manager judged over the full cycle cannot, which is another argument for evaluating plant managers over longer periods.
Why Low-Inventory Operations Narrow the Gap
A business that holds little inventory sees little difference between the two methods, because the fixed overhead deferred in inventory is small. Firms that produce closely to orders, keeping finished goods to a minimum, therefore find that absorption and variable income track each other, and the incentive to overproduce weakens. For the chair line, which builds ahead of the spring season, the gap will always be largest at year end, when stock is highest.
The Incentive
The reconciliation exposes an incentive. A plant manager rewarded on absorption income can raise it by producing more chairs than customers ordered. Every extra chair produced lowers fixed overhead per unit and moves part of the 330,000 dollars from this year's income statement into inventory on the balance sheet. Had the manager produced 30,000 chairs and still sold 20,000, fixed overhead per chair would have fallen to 11 dollars, and 110,000 dollars of fixed overhead would have been parked in 10,000 unsold chairs, raising absorption income by 80,000 dollars more than variable income, with nothing to show for it but a warehouse full of chairs and the storage costs that come with them. Datar and Rajan (2021) describe this incentive as a central reason managers are evaluated on variable costing results, or with penalties for building inventory, inside many firms.
Which to Use, and When
Absorption costing is required for external financial statements and for tax, so the maker must prepare it. For internal decisions and performance evaluation, variable costing is often more useful: its income moves with sales, not production, and it separates the contribution of each unit from the fixed costs of capacity, which supports the decisions examined elsewhere in the course. The maker should evaluate its plant managers on variable costing income, or add a charge for inventory held, so that producing to stock is not rewarded.
Why the Two Methods Coexist
Absorption costing is required for external reporting because it matches all production costs, including fixed overhead, to the goods sold. Variable costing is more useful inside the business because profit then moves with sales rather than with production. Johnson and Kaplan (1987) traced how external reporting requirements came to shape internal cost systems, often at the expense of the information managers needed; keeping both statements, as this analysis recommends, avoids that trap at little cost.
Conclusion
One year of chair production and sales yields 320,000 dollars of income under absorption costing and 290,000 under variable costing. The 30,000-dollar gap is fixed overhead carried in 2,000 unsold chairs, and the reconciliation ties exactly. Because absorption income can be raised by producing inventory nobody ordered, internal evaluation should rest on variable costing.
References
Datar, S. M., & Rajan, M. V. (2021). Horngren's cost accounting: A managerial emphasis (17th ed.). Pearson.
Garrison, R. H., Noreen, E. W., & Brewer, P. C. (2021). Managerial accounting (17th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.
Johnson, H. T., & Kaplan, R. S. (1987). Relevance lost: The rise and fall of management accounting. Harvard Business School Press.
Reading the GCU ACC 650 Topic 5 instructions
The Topic 5 brief in ACC-650 asks MBA students to compare variable and absorption costing. Strong submissions prepare both income statements in full from the same data, reconcile the difference to the fixed overhead in the change in inventory, and show how the difference reverses when inventory falls. Students should explain why low-inventory operations narrow the gap, name the incentive absorption costing creates for managers to produce inventory nobody ordered, and recommend which method to use for which purpose. Both statements should be shown in full rather than summarized. Students should also explain the incentive absorption costing creates to overproduce and say which method managers should use for internal decisions.
How the ACC-650 Topic 5 example is put together
The finished example prepares both statements from the same data and then explains the gap. Under absorption costing, fixed manufacturing overhead attaches to units and travels into inventory, so producing more than is sold moves cost onto the balance sheet and raises reported income. Under variable costing it is expensed as incurred and income tracks sales. The example reconciles the two figures exactly, showing that the difference equals the fixed overhead in the change in inventory. It then names the incentive plainly: a manager rewarded on absorption income can improve it by producing inventory nobody ordered, which is the reason the comparison is taught. Both statements are laid out in full rather than summarized into a comparison table.
Reading the ACC 650 Topic 5 rubric
Faculty reward a reconciliation that ties to the dollar. An Excellent paper lays out both statements and explains the 30,000-dollar gap as 2,000 chairs times 15 dollars of fixed overhead. Credit goes to a following year in which absorption income falls to 260,000 while variable income stays at 290,000. The rubric values naming the incentive to build stock and pricing what 30,000 chairs would do. Strong papers explain why little inventory narrows the gap, with Datar and Rajan. Top marks go to recommending variable costing for evaluating managers. Papers that reconcile the two incomes to the dollar through the fixed overhead held in inventory, and then show the difference reversing the following year, earn the most credit.
Common ACC 650 Topic 5 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Preparing one statement and describing the other is the standard shortfall, since the comparison is the assignment and a single correct statement does not make it. A second failure is a reconciliation that does not tie, which usually means fixed overhead was applied at the wrong rate and which the exact arithmetic is designed to catch. Papers lose marks for attributing the income difference to performance, when the entire gap is cost moving between the income statement and inventory. Omitting the incentive discussion misses the reason the topic exists, since the accounting difference matters mainly because of what it encourages managers to do. Treating absorption costing as simply wrong ignores that external reporting requires it.
Get an ACC-650 Topic 5 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-650 Topic 5 problems and the rubric posted in your classroom, with the production, sales and cost data your section supplied. We write a custom example to those criteria, with both statements prepared from the same figures, the reconciliation tied exactly and the incentive named, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.
More ACC 650 papers and MBA samples
- ACC 650 Topic 1: Internal Reporting Comparison
- ACC 650 Topic 2: Product Costing Problem Set
- ACC 650 Topic 3: Activity Based Costing Analysis
- ACC 650 Topic 4: Contribution Margin Analysis
- ACC 650 Topic 6: Master Budget Build
- ACC 650 Topic 7: Standard Cost Variance Report
- ACC 650 Topic 8: Relevant Cost Decision
- BUS 635 Topic 5: Losing Season Dq Post
- ACC 502 Topic 5: Depreciation Method Analysis
- BUS 655 Topic 5: Promotion Attribution Dq Post
ACC 650 Topic 5 questions, answered
Why do the two methods report different income?
Because they treat fixed manufacturing overhead differently. Absorption costing attaches it to units, so any of it sitting in unsold inventory has not yet reached the income statement. Variable costing expenses it in the period incurred. When production exceeds sales, absorption reports higher income by exactly the fixed overhead held in the inventory increase, which is why the reconciliation ties precisely.
Which method should a company use?
Both, for different purposes. External reporting requires absorption, so there is no choice there. Internally, variable costing gives managers a figure that moves with sales rather than with production decisions, which makes it better for evaluating performance and for the contribution analysis the course is built around. Most firms maintain both and reconcile between them.
What is the incentive problem?
A manager evaluated on absorption income can improve the number by producing more than the firm can sell, since the extra fixed overhead goes into inventory instead of expense. The company is worse off, holding stock it did not need and tying up cash, while the reported figure rises. That is the practical reason this comparison is taught rather than a technical curiosity.
Where can I find a free ACC 650 Topic 5 sample paper?
The comparison is printed here in full: the data, absorption costing, variable costing, the reconciliation, the following year, low-inventory operations, the incentive, which to use and the conclusion. Bring your period data and we will prepare both statements free.
Why is absorption income higher in ACC 650 Topic 5?
Fixed overhead of 15 dollars per chair travels into the 2,000 unsold chairs, so 30,000 dollars sits on the balance sheet instead of being expensed this year.