ACC 650 Topic 8 relevant cost decision example

Managerial Accounting Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This ACC 650 Topic 8 sample paper works three relevant cost decisions for a composite outdoor furniture maker and writes down every cost it excludes. It closes GCU ACC 650, Managerial Accounting, catalog code ACC-650, an MBA course at Grand Canyon University. Buying 8,000 cushions saves 14,000 dollars once freed space worth 30,000 is counted. A 600-chair hotel order at 80.75 dollars loses 6,150 in a full April but adds 16,050 in July. Dropping the bench line would cost 92,000, because its allocated overhead continues. The qualitative factors that could reverse each answer close the paper. Each excluded cost is written down with the reason.

CourseACC 650 Managerial Accounting
TopicTopic 8
Paper typeRelevant cost decision
LengthAbout 1,060 words, 2 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMBA
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for ACC 650 Topic 8

1

Only What Changes: Three Relevant Cost Decisions for an Outdoor Furniture Maker, With Every Exclusion Written Down

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

ACC-650: Managerial Accounting

Topic 8 Relevant Cost Decisions

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the principle applied and the discipline it requires. The furniture maker and every figure are a composite; the sources are real.
2

Only What Changes: Three Relevant Cost Decisions for an Outdoor Furniture Maker, With Every Exclusion Written Down

The Principle

A cost matters to a decision only when it lies in the future and changes with the alternative chosen (Garrison et al., 2021). Sunk costs, already incurred, cannot be changed by any decision; costs that will be the same whichever alternative is chosen cannot affect the choice. Opportunity costs, the benefit given up by choosing one alternative over another, are relevant even though no invoice records them. This paper works three decisions for a composite outdoor furniture maker, a make-or-buy question, a special order and a keep-or-drop question, and in each starts by naming what it excludes. Figures are illustrative.

Decision One: Make or Buy Chair Cushions

The maker sews 8,000 seat cushions a year for its chairs. Its cost report shows 22 dollars per cushion: 9 of fabric and foam, 6 of labor, 2 of variable overhead and 5 of allocated fixed overhead. A supplier offers identical cushions for 19 dollars.

Excluded: the 5 dollars of allocated fixed overhead, because the factory's rent, supervision and depreciation will continue whether or not the maker sews cushions. Included: the 17 dollars of variable cost, which would be avoided by buying. Included as well: an opportunity cost. If the sewing area were freed, the maker could use it to assemble 1,000 more benches a year, contributing about 30,000 dollars.

Making costs 8,000 times 17, or 136,000 dollars. Buying costs 8,000 times 19, or 152,000, less the 30,000 the freed space would earn, a net 122,000. Buying is cheaper by 14,000 dollars. Without the opportunity cost, making would have looked 16,000 dollars cheaper, and with the allocated overhead included, buying would have looked cheaper by 24,000 for the wrong reason.

Decision Two: A Special Order

A hotel chain offers to buy 600 chairs at 80.75 dollars each, 15 percent below the usual price, for delivery in April. The chairs' variable cost is 54 dollars, since no sales commission would be paid on a direct order.

Excluded: fixed overhead and fixed selling costs, which will not change. Included: the contribution of 26.75 dollars a chair, 16,050 dollars in total, and the condition the whole calculation rests on, whether capacity is spare. In April the line runs at full capacity for garden-center orders. Accepting the hotel order would displace 600 regular chairs, each contributing 37 dollars, an opportunity cost of 22,200 dollars. In April the order would lose 6,150 dollars. The analysis recommends offering the hotel July delivery, when the line has idle capacity and the order would add the full 16,050.

Decision Three: Keep or Drop the Bench Line

The bench line's product statement shows a loss: revenue of 360,000 dollars, variable costs of 228,000, traceable fixed costs of 40,000 for its dedicated jigs and part-time assembler, and 110,000 of allocated company overhead, a reported loss of 18,000 dollars. A manager proposes dropping it. Last year the maker also spent 25,000 dollars on bench molds.

Excluded: the 25,000 dollars spent on molds, a sunk cost that dropping the line cannot recover; and the 110,000 dollars of allocated overhead, which would continue and be spread over the remaining products. Included: the 132,000 dollars of contribution the line earns and the 40,000 of traceable fixed costs that dropping it would save.

Dropping the benches would lose 132,000 dollars of contribution and save 40,000, leaving the company 92,000 dollars worse off, even though the bench statement shows a loss. The line contributes 92,000 toward the very overhead its statement charges it with.

Table 1

Three Decisions and Their Exclusions, Dollars

DecisionExcluded and whyRelevant comparisonResult
Make or buy cushionsAllocated fixed overhead, unavoidableMake 136,000 against buy 152,000 less 30,000 opportunityBuy, saving 14,000
Hotel special order in AprilFixed costs, unchangedContribution 16,050 against 22,200 displacedReject April; offer July
Drop benchesMolds, sunk; allocated overhead, continuesLose 132,000 contribution, save 40,000Keep, worth 92,000

Where Such Analyses Usually Go Wrong

The three decisions show the errors relevant cost analysis exists to prevent. Including allocated fixed costs in the bench decision produces a recommendation to drop a product that was helping to pay for those very costs; after the benches were gone, the 110,000 dollars would be charged to chairs and teak sets, and one of them might then show a loss and be proposed for dropping in turn. Omitting opportunity cost in the special order would have accepted an April order that quietly displaced more profitable regular business. And counting the 25,000 dollars spent on molds, in either direction, would let a past decision distort a future one. Each error is avoided only by stating what was excluded and why.

What the Arithmetic Cannot Capture

Each decision has qualitative factors that could reverse it. Buying cushions makes the maker dependent on a supplier's quality and delivery in its busiest season; a contract with delivery guarantees and a fallback supplier should be in place first. Offering the hotel July delivery may lose the order entirely if the hotel needs chairs for a spring opening, though it may also open a relationship worth more than one order. Keeping the benches is supported by the numbers, but if the bench assembler's space could be used for a more profitable product, the comparison should be redone with that opportunity cost. Datar and Rajan (2021) emphasize that relevant cost analysis informs decisions rather than making them, and these factors belong in the recommendation.

Costs That Look Fixed but Are Not

Some costs that appear fixed change when a product line is dropped or a part is bought instead of made, and those must be counted. Cooper and Kaplan (1988) argued that support costs such as purchasing, scheduling and inspection are driven by the variety and complexity of products, so dropping a complex line can release more cost than a traditional cost report suggests. The analysis therefore asked of each overhead item whether it would actually disappear, not whether it was labeled variable.

Conclusion

In each decision, the right answer depends on excluding costs that cannot change and including costs that leave no invoice. Buying cushions saves 14,000 dollars once the freed space is valued; the hotel order makes sense in July but not April; and the bench line, despite its reported loss, is worth 92,000 dollars a year to the company. Writing down every exclusion is what makes the analysis checkable.

References

Cooper, R., & Kaplan, R. S. (1988). Measure costs right: Make the right decisions. Harvard Business Review, 66(5), 96-103.

Datar, S. M., & Rajan, M. V. (2021). Horngren's cost accounting: A managerial emphasis (17th ed.). Pearson.

Garrison, R. H., Noreen, E. W., & Brewer, P. C. (2021). Managerial accounting (17th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.

ACC 650 Topic 8 instructions, in plain terms

ACC-650 ends with Topic 8, where MBA students make make-or-buy, special order and keep-or-drop decisions using relevant costs. Strong analyses name the costs excluded in each decision, such as sunk costs and unavoidable fixed costs, and why, include opportunity costs that have no invoice, and check whether capacity is truly spare before accepting a special order. Students should show the common errors the method prevents and close each decision with the qualitative factors that could reverse it. A summary table of exclusions, comparisons and results helps the reader check each decision. Students should also identify costs that look fixed but would change, and qualitative factors the arithmetic cannot capture.

How the ACC-650 Topic 8 example is put together

The finished example builds each decision from only what changes. Sunk costs are excluded and named as excluded, since the discipline is visible only when the paper says what it left out. Unavoidable fixed costs are treated the same way, which is what makes a keep or drop decision counterintuitive: dropping a product with a positive contribution makes the firm worse off even though the product statement shows a loss, because the allocated fixed costs continue. Opportunity cost is included even though no invoice exists for it, particularly the alternative use of capacity in a special order. Each decision closes with the qualitative factors that the arithmetic cannot capture but that could reverse it.

Where the marks sit in the ACC 650 Topic 8 rubric

Faculty reward analyses that write down every exclusion. An Excellent paper excludes allocated overhead from the cushion decision and adds the freed space's 30,000-dollar contribution. Credit goes to rejecting the April hotel order because it displaces chairs worth 37 dollars each. The rubric values keeping the benches, which contribute 92,000 dollars despite a reported loss, and excluding the sunk mold cost. Strong papers table all three decisions, following Garrison, Noreen and Brewer. Top marks go to qualitative factors such as supplier reliability and the hotel's timing. Papers that write down every excluded cost with its reason, including allocated overhead that would continue after dropping the bench line, show the discipline that relevant costing requires.

Common ACC 650 Topic 8 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Including allocated fixed costs in a decision analysis is precisely what this closing topic sets out to stop, and it produces the recommendation to drop a product that was contributing toward those very costs. A second failure is omitting opportunity cost, most often in a special order that quietly displaces regular business at full price. Papers lose marks for excluding costs without saying so, since the exclusions are the analysis and an unexplained figure looks like an omission. Accepting a special order without checking whether capacity is genuinely spare ignores the condition the whole calculation rests on. Reaching a recommendation with no qualitative discussion treats a business decision as purely arithmetic, which few of these actually are.

Get an ACC-650 Topic 8 example written to your instructions

Send the ACC-650 Topic 8 problems and the rubric from your classroom, with the decision data your section supplied. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the relevance test applied throughout, every exclusion written down, opportunity cost included and the qualitative factors named, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.

More ACC 650 papers and MBA samples

ACC 650 Topic 8 questions, answered

Why can dropping a loss making product make things worse?

Because the product statement usually charges it with allocated fixed costs that will continue after it goes. If the product generates positive contribution, that contribution was helping to cover costs the firm still has, and removing it leaves the same fixed costs spread across fewer products. The relevant question is whether contribution is positive, not whether the allocated statement shows a profit.

When is a special order worth accepting?

When the price exceeds the incremental cost of producing it and the capacity is genuinely spare. Both conditions matter. If accepting the order displaces regular sales at full price, the lost contribution is an opportunity cost that belongs in the calculation and frequently reverses the answer. Orders accepted on incremental cost alone, with capacity assumed free, are the standard trap.

How do I handle factors I cannot put a number on?

Name them alongside the arithmetic rather than inside it. Becoming dependent on a single supplier, damaging a long standing customer relationship or losing an internal capability are real considerations that no figure captures. State the quantitative answer, then state which qualitative factors could reverse it and how large they would have to be. That reads as judgment rather than as hedging.

Where can I find a free ACC 650 Topic 8 sample paper?

The relevant cost decisions are printed here complete: the principle, make or buy, the special order, keep or drop, where analyses go wrong, what the arithmetic cannot capture and the conclusion. Bring your decision data and we will work it at no charge.

Why keep the bench line in ACC 650 Topic 8?

Dropping it loses 132,000 dollars of contribution and saves only 40,000 of traceable fixed costs. The 110,000 of allocated overhead continues, so the company is 92,000 worse off.