ACC 656 Topic 1 consolidation scope memo example

Advanced Accounting Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This ACC 656 Topic 1 sample paper is a consolidation scope memo to a controller deciding how three investees belong in the year-end statements. It was written for GCU ACC 656, Advanced Accounting, catalog code ACC-656, in the Grand Canyon University MS in Accounting. A warehouse entity the company owns no shares in is tested first under the variable interest model and consolidated, because the company guarantees its $6.4 million of bank debt and directs how the building is used. A 60 percent holding stays on the equity method because the founding family approves the budget and can remove the chief executive. A 30 percent distributor with two of seven seats gets significant influence only.

CourseACC 656 Advanced Accounting
TopicTopic 1
Paper typeConsolidation scope memo
LengthAbout 950 words, 1 pages
FormatMemo with APA 7 references
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMS in Accounting
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for ACC 656 Topic 1

1

Memorandum

To: Controller, Westfield Industrial Group

From: [Author Name], technical accounting

Date: [Date]

Re: Consolidation scope for three investees at December 31

 

Purpose and Short Answer

Westfield Industrial Group, a composite manufacturer, has interests in three entities: Summit Warehouse LLC, in which it owns no shares; Ridgeline Castings, in which it owns 60% of the voting stock; and Coastal Distribution, in which it owns 30%. This memo sets out how each should be reported in the December 31 statements. Ownership percentage will not settle any of them. Summit is consolidated although Westfield owns none of it, Ridgeline is accounted for by the equity method although Westfield owns a majority, and Coastal is accounted for by the equity method as its percentage suggests. The reasons follow the order the consolidation guidance requires.

Table 1

Three Investees and the Model That Decides Each

InvesteeOwnership and rightsModel appliedConclusion
Summit Warehouse LLCNo shares; Westfield guarantees its bank debt and directs how the building is usedVariable interest entity; Westfield is the primary beneficiaryConsolidate
Ridgeline Castings60% of voting shares; the family holding 40% approves the operating budget and can remove the chief executiveVoting interest; the family's rights are participatingEquity method
Coastal Distribution30% of voting shares; two of seven board seatsVoting interest; significant influence onlyEquity method

Step One: Is Any Investee a Variable Interest Entity?

The variable interest model is applied before the voting interest model, because counting votes is meaningless for an entity whose equity holders do not carry its risks (Financial Accounting Standards Board, 2009). An entity is a variable interest entity if, among other conditions, its equity at risk is insufficient to finance its activities without additional subordinated financial support, or its equity holders as a group lack the power to direct the activities that most significantly affect its economic performance (Financial Accounting Standards Board, 2015).

Ridgeline and Coastal are operating companies financed by their own equity and ordinary bank lines, and their shareholders direct them through their boards. Neither is a variable interest entity. Summit is different. It owns the distribution warehouse Westfield occupies, its members contributed $250,000 of equity against a building financed with $6.4 million of bank debt, and the bank lent only because Westfield guaranteed the loan. Summit's equity at risk cannot finance its activities without Westfield's support, so Summit is a variable interest entity, and Westfield's guarantee and lease are variable interests in it.

Step Two: Who Is Summit's Primary Beneficiary?

A variable interest entity is consolidated by its primary beneficiary, the party that has both the power to direct the activities that most significantly affect the entity's economic performance and the obligation to absorb losses or the right to receive benefits that could be significant to it (Financial Accounting Standards Board, 2009). Summit's performance depends on how the building is used, maintained and let. Under the lease and a services agreement, Westfield decides all three. Through the guarantee, Westfield also absorbs Summit's losses if the building's income cannot service the debt. Westfield has both elements and is the primary beneficiary. It consolidates Summit, presents Summit's members' equity as noncontrolling interest and eliminates the intercompany lease.

Step Three: The Voting Interest Model for Ridgeline and Coastal

Under the voting interest model, a majority voting interest is presumed to give control, but the presumption is overcome when noncontrolling shareholders hold substantive participating rights: rights to block or participate in the significant financial and operating decisions made in the ordinary course of business (Financial Accounting Standards Board, 2015). Protective rights, which guard a minority against fundamental changes such as a sale of the company, an amendment of its charter or a large borrowing, do not overcome it.

The founding family that holds Ridgeline's other 40% has two rights, and each is classified separately. Approval of the annual operating budget reaches the pricing, staffing and spending decisions that run the business every month, so it is participating. The power to remove the chief executive reaches who makes those decisions, so it is also participating. Neither is protective. Westfield cannot direct Ridgeline's operations without the family's agreement, the presumption is overcome, and Westfield does not control Ridgeline.

Coastal needs less analysis. Westfield's 30% holding elects two of seven directors, and the other five are elected by holders Westfield does not control. Westfield can influence Coastal's policies but cannot direct them.

Step Four: Equity Method for Both

Ownership of 20% to 50% of the voting stock is presumed to give significant influence, and Westfield's position in each company meets that test on the facts as well as the percentage: board seats in both, and a 60% vote in Ridgeline that cannot be outvoted on any matter the family does not block (Accounting Principles Board, 1971). Both are reported by the equity method. Westfield records its share of each company's income, 60% of Ridgeline's and 30% of Coastal's, reduces each investment by dividends received and amortizes any excess of cost over its share of book value that is attributable to depreciable assets (Hoyle et al., 2021). Sales between Westfield and either company leave Westfield's share of any unrealized profit deferred until the goods are sold to outsiders.

What Would Change These Conclusions

Each conclusion rests on a specific right or risk, and each should be reassessed when that fact changes, at least at every quarter end.

Table 2

Reassessment Triggers

EventEffect
The family's budget approval right lapses or is waivedRidgeline's presumption of control is restored; Westfield consolidates from that date
Westfield's guarantee of Summit's debt is releasedSummit is re-examined; Westfield may no longer absorb its losses
Summit's members add enough equity to finance the buildingSummit may no longer be a variable interest entity
Westfield gains a fourth seat on Coastal's boardCoastal is re-examined for control

References

Accounting Principles Board. (1971). The equity method of accounting for investments in common stock (APB Opinion No. 18). American Institute of Certified Public Accountants.

Financial Accounting Standards Board. (2009). Amendments to FASB Interpretation No. 46(R) (Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 167). FASB.

Financial Accounting Standards Board. (2015). Consolidation (Topic 810): Amendments to the consolidation analysis (Accounting Standards Update No. 2015-02). FASB.

Hoyle, J. B., Schaefer, T. F., & Doupnik, T. S. (2021). Advanced accounting (14th ed.). McGraw Hill.

Reading the GCU ACC 656 Topic 1 instructions

ACC-656 opens with Topic 1, where students decide which investees a company must consolidate. Many papers read control off the ownership percentage. The assignment rewards memos that apply the variable interest model before the voting interest model, identify a primary beneficiary by power and exposure to losses, and classify each minority right as participating or protective. Students should reach a conclusion for every investee, explain the equity method treatment where control is absent and list the events that would require each conclusion to be reassessed.

How this ACC 656 Topic 1 example is built

Each investee is taken on its own facts, in a memo to the controller. The 60 percent holding looks like a subsidiary, but the founding family holding the other 40 percent must approve the annual operating budget and can remove the chief executive. Those are participating rights over ordinary operating decisions, not protective ones, so under ASC 810 they overcome the presumption that a majority owner consolidates, and the memo applies the equity method instead. The 30 percent distributor, with two of seven board seats, gives significant influence and no more, leaving it under ASC 323. The warehouse entity is the surprise: its equity cannot finance the building without the company's guarantee of its bank debt, making it a variable interest entity whose primary beneficiary is the company, which directs the warehouse's use and absorbs its losses.

ACC 656 Topic 1 rubric: what Excellent looks like

Faculty grading the consolidation scope memo reward conclusions drawn from rights and risks. Excellent memos consolidate an entity with no shares held because its equity cannot carry its debt without a guarantee. Credit goes to testing both elements of the primary beneficiary definition. The rubric values sorting budget approval and removal of management into participating rights over ordinary decisions. The highest level separates control from significant influence cleanly and closes with reassessment triggers. Memos that consolidate every majority holding by default usually land in a middle band.

ACC 656 Topic 1 help: mistakes that cost marks

The deciding error on this topic is reading control off the share register. A memo that consolidates the 60 percent holding because it is a majority, without examining the family's rights, has applied a presumption the facts rebut. Treating budget approval as a protective right, when it governs ordinary operations, lands on the wrong side of that line and is marked wrong, not weak. Papers that skip the warehouse entity because the company holds no shares miss the variable interest model entirely, which in most sections is the largest single loss. Identifying a primary beneficiary on one criterion, the guarantee or the power, without both, leaves the conclusion half argued. Some memos stop at the scope decision and never say how the unconsolidated investees are accounted for, leaving two of the three holdings with no treatment.

Get an ACC-656 Topic 1 example written to your instructions

Send the ACC-656 Topic 1 instructions, your rubric and the investee facts or ownership structure your section assigned. We write a custom example to them, with each entity tested under the right model, rights classified as participating or protective, any primary beneficiary identified on both criteria and the unconsolidated holdings given their treatment, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More ACC 656 papers and MS in Accounting samples

ACC 656 Topic 1 questions, answered

Does owning more than half the voting shares always mean control?

Usually, but not always. A majority voting interest creates a presumption of control, and substantive participating rights held by other owners, such as approving the operating budget or appointing senior management, can overcome it. Protective rights, such as approving a sale of the company or changes to its charter, do not. The distinction turns on whether the rights reach decisions made in the ordinary course of business.

How can a company consolidate an entity it owns no shares in?

Through the variable interest model. When an entity's equity is too small to finance its activities without outside support, or its equity holders lack the usual rights and risks, control is judged by who holds power over its most significant activities and who absorbs its losses or receives its benefits. A guarantee, a loan or a lease can be the variable interest that makes a company the primary beneficiary.

What happens to an investee that is not consolidated?

It depends on the influence the company holds. Significant influence, often but not only through a holding of 20 to 50 percent or board representation, leads to the equity method, where the investment is adjusted for the company's share of the investee's income. Without significant influence, the investment is generally measured at fair value. The memo applies the equity method to both unconsolidated holdings and says why.

Where can I find a free ACC 656 Topic 1 sample paper?

The memo is on this page in full: the purpose and short answer, the variable interest test, the primary beneficiary, the voting interest model, the equity method for both holdings and what would change the conclusions. Tell us your investees for a free worked memo.

Why is the 60 percent holding not consolidated in ACC 656 Topic 1?

The family holding the other 40 percent approves the operating budget and can remove the chief executive, participating rights that overcome the presumption of control.