ACC 656 Topic 5 intercompany profit DQ post example

Advanced Accounting Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This ACC 656 Topic 5 sample discussion post argues that a group earns nothing by selling to itself, so internal profit waits for an outside buyer. It was written for GCU ACC 656, Advanced Accounting, catalog code ACC-656, in the Grand Canyon University MS in Accounting. A parent sells goods costing $160,000 to its 80 percent subsidiary for $200,000, and 30 percent remain unsold at year end. The post removes the $200,000 of sales and cost of sales and defers $12,000 of profit, returning inventory to its $48,000 cost. An upstream variation shows the noncontrolling interest bearing $2,400, and a reply weighs pricing internal sales at cost.

CourseACC 656 Advanced Accounting
TopicTopic 5
Paper typeIntercompany profit discussion post
LengthAbout 520 words, 1 pages
FormatDiscussion post, APA 7 citations
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMS in Accounting
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for ACC 656 Topic 5

1

Topic 5 DQ 1: Initial Post and Reply

A Group Earns Nothing by Selling to Itself: Deferring $12,000 of Profit Until an Outside Customer Buys

Initial Post

A consolidated group earns profit only when it sells to someone outside the group, so profit on a sale between a parent and its subsidiary does not exist for the group until an outside customer buys the goods. Everything below follows from that single-entity view.

Here is one shipment. The parent made goods at a cost of $160,000 and sold them to its 80 percent owned subsidiary for $200,000, earning a 20 percent gross margin on its own books. By year end the subsidiary had sold 70 percent of the goods to its customers and still held the other 30 percent, carried at the $60,000 it paid.

Two eliminations follow. First, remove $200,000 from both sales and cost of sales. Without this, the group reports the same goods as sold twice, once by the parent and once by the subsidiary, and revenue is overstated by the full transfer. Second, defer the profit still sitting in inventory. The $60,000 held at year end includes the parent's 20 percent margin, or $12,000, so debit cost of sales $12,000 and credit inventory $12,000. Consolidated inventory returns to $48,000, what the group actually paid to make those goods. The consolidation standard requires exactly this: intercompany profit on assets remaining within the group is eliminated (Committee on Accounting Procedure, 1959).

Only the $12,000 is deferred, not the whole $40,000 margin, because 70 percent of the goods have already reached outside buyers and that part of the profit is earned.

Now reverse the direction. If the subsidiary had sold the goods upstream to the parent, the unrealized profit would sit in the subsidiary's income, and the subsidiary has outside owners. The same $12,000 deferral would reduce the subsidiary's income before it is shared, so the noncontrolling interest would bear 20 percent of it, or $2,400, and the parent's share would fall by $9,600. In the downstream case above, the profit belongs to the parent, which has no outside owners within the group, so the parent bears all of it (Hoyle et al., 2021).

The deferral does not erase the profit. It moves it. Next year, when the subsidiary sells the remaining goods to outside customers, the $12,000 is recognized in consolidated income through an entry that reverses this year's deferral against opening retained earnings.

A question for the thread: if the eliminations were skipped, what could a parent do to its reported income in the last week of a weak quarter by shipping goods to a subsidiary that has no customer waiting for them?

Reply to Priya

Priya, you suggested the parent could avoid the deferral by pricing internal sales at cost. It would, since no profit would sit in inventory, but the eliminations of sales and cost of sales would still be needed, and a cost-based price can shift taxable income between jurisdictions, which tax authorities test under transfer pricing rules. The consolidated figures come out the same either way; only the separate books change. What would pricing at cost do to the subsidiary manager's measured performance?

References

Committee on Accounting Procedure. (1959). Consolidated financial statements (Accounting Research Bulletin No. 51). American Institute of Certified Public Accountants.

Hoyle, J. B., Schaefer, T. F., & Doupnik, T. S. (2021). Advanced accounting (14th ed.). McGraw Hill.

ACC 656 Topic 5 instructions, in plain terms

ACC-656 Topic 5 asks students to discuss the elimination of intercompany profit. Many posts state the rule without explaining it. Strong posts here commit to the single-entity view, work one shipment with its cost, transfer price and unsold share, and compute the unrealized profit from the margin. Students should give both eliminations with their purposes, show how the direction of the sale decides whether the noncontrolling interest shares the deferral, trace the profit into the following year and respond to a classmate's alternative with a question.

How the ACC-656 Topic 5 example is put together

The post's first sentence states its answer: a group earns nothing by selling to itself, so profit on an internal sale exists only once an outsider buys the goods. Figures are illustrative. The parent sold goods costing $160,000 to its 80 percent subsidiary for $200,000, and at year end the subsidiary still holds 30 percent of them, $60,000 at the transfer price. That inventory contains $12,000 of the parent's profit. The post removes the $200,000 of sales and cost of sales, then defers the $12,000 so consolidated inventory returns to its $48,000 original cost. It then reverses the direction. Had the subsidiary sold to the parent, the deferral would reduce the subsidiary's income and the noncontrolling interest would bear $2,400 of it. A closing question asks what year-end shipments could do to income if nothing were eliminated.

Reading the ACC 656 Topic 5 rubric

GCU's rubric for this discussion rewards reasoning over recitation. Excellent posts defer only the profit in goods still on hand, not the whole margin. Credit goes to separating the elimination of sales from the deferral against inventory. The rubric values showing that an upstream sale spreads the deferral to outside owners of the subsidiary. The strongest replies answer a classmate's pricing idea with its tax and performance effects. Posts that remove the sales but leave the profit in inventory, or treat upstream and downstream sales alike, usually land in a middle band.

ACC 656 Topic 5 help before you submit

Posts on this question lose most when they assert the elimination rule and never explain it. Quoting the consolidation requirement answers what the rule is, which the question already assumes, and leaves the reasoning the thread exists for untouched. A post that removes the intercompany sales but leaves the $12,000 in inventory overstates both group income and group assets, and this is the arithmetic markers check first. Eliminating the full $40,000 of profit, when 70 percent of the goods have already been sold to outsiders, defers profit the group has earned. Treating upstream and downstream sales identically ignores the noncontrolling interest's share in one of them. Replies that simply restate the rule add little, and in many sections a reply that tests a classmate's figures or direction earns considerably more.

Get an ACC-656 Topic 5 example written to your instructions

Send the ACC-656 Topic 5 discussion question, the participation rubric and any intercompany figures your section is using. We write a custom example to those, with the single-entity reason stated first, unrealized profit computed from the facts, both eliminations explained, the upstream case distinguished and a reply prompt ready, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More ACC 656 papers and MS in Accounting samples

ACC 656 Topic 5 questions, answered

Is the profit lost, or only delayed?

Delayed. The $12,000 is removed this year because the goods are still inside the group, and it is recognized in consolidated income in the period when the subsidiary sells them to an outside customer. Over the life of the goods, total consolidated profit is the same as if the internal sale had never happened. Elimination moves profit to the period in which the group actually earned it.

Why does the direction of the sale matter?

Because the profit sits in the seller's books. On a downstream sale the parent earned it, so the deferral reduces the parent's share of income and the noncontrolling interest is unaffected. On an upstream sale the subsidiary earned it, and since outside shareholders own part of the subsidiary, they bear their percentage of the deferral. Many rubrics test this distinction specifically.

Does this apply to sales of equipment as well as inventory?

Yes, with one difference. A gain on equipment sold within the group is deferred and then recognized gradually over the asset's remaining life, through the lower depreciation the group records compared with the buyer's books. Inventory profit is usually recognized in one step when the goods leave the group. Later topics often take up equipment transfers, and the reasoning is the same.

Where can I find a free ACC 656 Topic 5 sample paper?

This page holds the initial post and a reply to a classmate, covering the single-entity view, the shipment, both eliminations, the upstream case and when the profit is recognized. Send the discussion prompt and we will draft a sample post at no cost.

How much profit is deferred in ACC 656 Topic 5?

$12,000, the 20 percent margin on the $60,000 of goods still held, while profit on the 70 percent already sold to outsiders stays earned.