| Course | ACC 656 Advanced Accounting |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 8 |
| Paper type | Group results explanation memo |
| Length | About 860 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 656 Topic 8
Memorandum
To: Dana Whitfield, Board of Directors, Carrow Group
From: [Author Name], Corporate Controller
Date: [Date]
Re: Your two questions on this year's consolidated results
Your Questions and the Short Answers
You asked why the group's revenue grew only 3.9 percent when Carrow's own revenue grew 11 percent, and why the group's equity grew by less than its profit for the year.
On the first: most of the parent's growth came from selling more to our own distribution subsidiary, and sales inside the group are removed when the results are combined, because the group as a whole sold nothing to anyone in those transactions. On the second: the Canadian dollar weakened during the year, which reduced the US dollar value of our Canadian subsidiary's net assets, and the accounting rules record that reduction directly in equity rather than in profit.
The detail follows for each.
From the Parent's 11 Percent to the Group's 3.9 Percent
Carrow's own revenue rose from $30.0 million to $33.3 million. Of that $3.3 million increase, $3.0 million was additional sales to Carrow Distribution, the subsidiary that sells our products to retailers. Those sales rose from $1.2 million last year to $4.2 million this year because Carrow Distribution took over the western accounts that Carrow previously served directly. The goods moved from one group company to another; the group's customers are the retailers, and those sales are counted when Carrow Distribution makes them.
Table 1
Bridge From Parent Revenue to Group Revenue
| Last year | This year | Change | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Carrow's own revenue | $30.0 million | $33.3 million | $3.3 million |
| Less sales to Carrow Distribution | ($1.2 million) | ($4.2 million) | ($3.0 million) |
| Plus other group members' outside sales | $17.4 million | $18.9 million | $1.5 million |
| Consolidated revenue | $46.2 million | $48.0 million | $1.8 million |
Why Internal Sales Are Removed
A group is reported as if it were a single company, and a single company does not earn revenue by moving goods between its own warehouses (Committee on Accounting Procedure, 1959). If internal sales were counted, the group could report any revenue it liked by shipping goods between its members, so they are removed and only the sales to outside customers remain.
On that basis the group's real growth is the $1.8 million in the last line of the table. Of it, $0.3 million came from Carrow's outside customers and $1.5 million from our other companies, chiefly the distributor's new western accounts.
Why Equity Grew Less Than Profit
Carrow Canada keeps its books in Canadian dollars, and the Canadian dollar is its functional currency, the currency of the economy in which it mainly operates. To combine its results with ours, its statements are translated into US dollars: assets and liabilities at the year-end exchange rate and income at the average rate for the year (Financial Accounting Standards Board, 1981).
Table 2
Carrow Canada Translated to US Dollars
| Canadian dollars | Rate | US dollars | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Net assets at the start of the year | C$15.0 million | 0.75 | $11.250 million |
| Net income for the year | C$2.0 million | 0.73 average | $1.460 million |
| Net assets at the end of the year | C$17.0 million | 0.71 | $12.070 million |
| Translation adjustment | ($0.640 million) |
During the year the Canadian dollar fell from 75 US cents to 71. Carrow Canada's net assets were worth fewer US dollars at the end of the year than their Canadian dollar amounts had been worth at the start, even though in Canada nothing was lost.
Where the $640,000 Goes
The $0.640 million translation loss does not pass through net income. It is reported in other comprehensive income and accumulates in a separate component of equity, where it stays until Carrow Canada is sold or liquidated (Financial Accounting Standards Board, 1997). This year the group earned $3.2 million and paid $1.2 million in dividends; after the $0.640 million translation loss, equity grew by $1.360 million. That is the gap you noticed.
The treatment reflects the fact that the loss is unrealized and may reverse. Carrow Canada earns and spends in Canadian dollars, and its value to us changes with the exchange rate only if we bring the money home. If the Canadian dollar recovers next year, the adjustment will move the other way.
The Alternative We Did Not Use
Had Carrow Canada's functional currency been the US dollar, for instance if it bought and sold mostly in US dollars, its statements would instead have been remeasured, with inventory and equipment at the historical rates when they were acquired, and the resulting exchange differences would have been reported in net income (Hoyle et al., 2021). The choice of functional currency is based on the facts of the subsidiary's operations and is not elective. Because Carrow Canada operates in Canada, in Canadian dollars, translation applies, and net income is not affected by the currency's movement.
What to Watch Next Year
Two figures will tell you most about next year's results. The first is the share of Carrow's own revenue sold to Carrow Distribution, now about 13 percent, which will make the parent's growth look stronger than the group's for as long as the distributor keeps expanding. The second is the Canadian dollar exchange rate, since each cent of movement changes the US dollar value of Carrow Canada's net assets by about $170,000, all of it recorded in equity.
References
Committee on Accounting Procedure. (1959). Consolidated financial statements (Accounting Research Bulletin No. 51). American Institute of Certified Public Accountants.
Financial Accounting Standards Board. (1981). Foreign currency translation (Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 52). FASB.
Financial Accounting Standards Board. (1997). Reporting comprehensive income (Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 130). FASB.
Hoyle, J. B., Schaefer, T. F., & Doupnik, T. S. (2021). Advanced accounting (14th ed.). McGraw Hill.
The ACC-656 Topic 8 assignment instructions
The Topic 8 instructions in ACC-656 ask students to explain consolidated results to a nonaccountant. Weak submissions answer with worksheet entries and elimination columns, which explain the accounting to the wrong audience. The assignment rewards memos that restate the reader's questions, answer each in a sentence before any figure and bridge the parent's growth to the group's. Students should explain in plain terms why sales between members are removed, show how translating a foreign subsidiary's net assets produces an adjustment in other comprehensive income, contrast translation with remeasurement and tell the reader which two figures to watch next year.
How the ACC-656 Topic 8 example is put together
Addressed to a board member, the memo answers both questions in its opening paragraph. A three-line bridge takes the parent's revenue, removes $4.2 million of sales to the distributor and adds $18.9 million of other members' outside sales, reaching the group's $48.0 million. Two sentences explain why internal sales are removed. A small table translates the Canadian subsidiary's net assets from C$15.0 million at 0.75 to C$17.0 million at 0.71, with income at the 0.73 average, and isolates the $640,000 loss. The memo shows it bypassing net income, then states what remeasurement would have done had the subsidiary's functional currency been the US dollar, and closes on the intercompany share of parent sales and the exchange rate.
Reading the ACC 656 Topic 8 rubric
Faculty grading the explanation memo reward answers the reader can use. Excellent memos identify intercompany sales as the cause of the growth gap, not just the size of it. Credit goes to translation at closing and average rates, shown in a small table. The rubric values placing the loss in other comprehensive income and explaining why it may reverse. The highest level states when remeasurement would apply and why the choice is not elective. Memos that call the translation loss an operating loss, or imply it reduced net income, tend to earn partial credit.
Common ACC 656 Topic 8 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Explanations lose credit here when they are accurate and unreadable for the person who asked. A memo that answers the board member with elimination entries and worksheet columns explains the accounting to the wrong audience and leaves both questions formally answered and practically open. Reconciling the parent's growth to the group's without identifying the intercompany sales as the cause restates the gap without accounting for it. Treating the translation loss as an operating loss, or implying it reduced net income, misstates where ASC 830 sends it and is marked as an error, not a simplification. Papers that never distinguish translation from remeasurement miss the determination that decided the answer. A memo with no forward-looking line, on what to watch in the next set of statements, leaves the reader as dependent on the preparer as before.
Get an ACC-656 Topic 8 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-656 Topic 8 instructions, your rubric and the consolidated statements or group data your section assigned. We write a custom example to them for the reader your case names, with each question answered first, separate and consolidated figures bridged, any currency effect traced to where it lands and a next step stated, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More ACC 656 papers and MS in Accounting samples
- ACC 656 Topic 1: Consolidation Scope Memo
- ACC 656 Topic 2: Acquisition Date Fair Value Schedule
- ACC 656 Topic 3: Goodwill and Bargain Purchase Problem
- ACC 656 Topic 4: Elimination Entry Worksheet
- ACC 656 Topic 5: Intercompany Profit DQ Post
- ACC 656 Topic 6: Noncontrolling Interest Measurement Problem
- ACC 656 Topic 7: Consolidated Statement Preparation
- ACC 657 Topic 8: Champion Model Defense Memo
- ACC 653 Topic 8: Costing System Fitness Review
- ACC 658 Topic 8: Board Liquidity Briefing
- ACC 685 Topic 8: Earnout Integration Report
ACC 656 Topic 8 questions, answered
What is the difference between translation and remeasurement?
Translation applies when a foreign subsidiary's functional currency is its local currency: its statements are converted into the reporting currency, and the resulting adjustment goes to other comprehensive income. Remeasurement applies when the books are kept in a currency other than the functional currency, as with a subsidiary operating essentially as an extension of the parent, and exchange differences then go to net income. ASC 830 sets out both.
How is a subsidiary's functional currency determined?
By the economic environment in which it primarily generates and spends cash. Indicators include the currency of its sales prices, its costs, its financing and the extent of its transactions with the parent. A subsidiary that sells locally, pays local costs and finances itself locally usually has the local currency as its functional currency. The determination is a judgment, and a case often turns on it.
Why write for a reader who sees only the consolidated statements?
Because that is who most readers are. Lenders, investors and many directors never see the parent's separate books or the worksheet, and the consolidated figures can look inconsistent with announcements made about individual companies. Explaining the difference in the reader's terms, without the elimination entries, is a skill many rubrics in this course reward, and it tests whether the preparer understands what the consolidation actually did.
Where can I find a free ACC 656 Topic 8 sample paper?
The memo appears here in full: the questions and short answers, the revenue bridge, why internal sales are removed, why equity grew less than profit, where the loss goes, the alternative not used and what to watch. Share the board's questions for a free worked memo.
Why did equity grow less than profit in ACC 656 Topic 8?
A weaker Canadian dollar cut the subsidiary's translated net assets, and the $640,000 loss went to other comprehensive income, so equity grew $1.36 million on $3.2 million of profit.