| Course | ACC 657 Advanced Data Analytics |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 1 |
| Paper type | Sampling versus scoring memo |
| Length | About 810 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 657 Topic 1
Memorandum
To: Chief Audit Executive, Meridian Health Services
From: [Author Name], audit analytics
Date: [Date]
Re: How we select employee expense claims for review
Recommendation
I recommend that we replace our annual random sample of expense claims with a score that ranks every claim by its likelihood of being improper, on one condition: before we adopt it, the score must find more improper claims than our current rule screen when both are tested on a year of claims neither was built on. I also recommend that we keep a random draw of 150 unflagged claims a year. The reasons follow, beginning with what each kind of mistake costs us.
What Full-Population Access Changes
Our statistical sample was designed when pulling every claim was impractical. It answers one question well: what is the error rate across all claims, within a stated margin. We now extract all 60,000 claims a year from the expense system, and every claim can be tested by a query or scored by a model (American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, 2017). Sampling risk, the chance that the claims we happened to draw misrepresent the rest, is no longer the binding limit. The limit is how many claims a person can examine. Our four reviewers, with their other duties, can open about 1,500 claims a year. The question is which 1,500.
The Cost of Each Kind of Error
Two errors are possible. Opening a claim that turns out to be proper wastes time: audit timesheets for the last three years show a review takes about 40 minutes, or roughly $45 of loaded staff cost. Leaving an improper claim unopened costs what it would have recovered and the behavior it lets continue: prior recoveries average $620 per improper claim, the figure I use here.
The gap between $45 and $620 settles the design. A missed improper claim costs almost fourteen times as much as a wasted review, so the best method is the one that fills our 1,500 reviews with as many improper claims as possible. Prior reviews found about 1.5 percent of claims improper, or roughly 900 a year.
The Three Options Compared
The table sets out each option at our capacity. The rule screen and score figures come from applying each to last year's claims, where outcomes are known from prior reviews.
Table 1
Three Ways to Choose Which Claims to Review
| Option | Claims reviewed | Improper found | Wasted review cost | Improper missed, at $620 | Annual cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Random sample, current | 240 | 4 | $10,620 | $555,520 | $566,140 |
| Rule screen, 1,500 of 3,100 flags | 1,500 | 120 | $62,100 | $483,600 | $545,700 |
| Score, top 1,500 plus 150 random | 1,650 | 332 | $59,310 | $352,160 | $411,470 |
Reading the Table
The random sample finds about four improper claims a year, because it was never built to find cases; it was built to measure a rate. The rule screen, which flags claims over policy limits, weekend meals and duplicate amounts, flagged 9,300 claims over the past three years, about 3,100 a year. That is twice what we can open, so reviewers pick among the flags without any ordering, and about 8 percent of the flags they open prove improper.
The score ranks all 60,000 claims and sends the top 1,500 to review. On last year's claims, those 1,500 contained 330 improper ones, and the random draw of 150 unflagged claims would be expected to find two more. Its annual cost is about $134,000 lower than the rule screen's (Provost & Fawcett, 2013).
Why the Random Draw Stays
A ranking only tells us about the claims it sends to review. If it steadily passes over a kind of improper claim, for instance a new pattern it was never trained on, nothing in the reviewed claims will show it, and the model's own results will look fine (Bolton & Hand, 2002). A random draw from the claims the score did not flag is the only unbiased measure of what it misses. At 150 claims it costs under $7,000 a year, and it also preserves the error-rate estimate our annual report to the audit committee has always included.
The Validation Condition
The score's advantage in the table is measured on the year it was developed with, and a model can look better on familiar data than on new claims. Before adoption, the score and the rule screen should each rank the claims of the most recent completed year, which was held out of development, and each should be judged on how many improper claims fall in its top 1,500. If the score does not clearly beat the rules there, we keep the rules and order the flags by amount. Tests of this kind are what the audit analytics research recommends before an algorithm replaces an established procedure (Appelbaum et al., 2017).
Decision Requested
I ask for approval to run the held-out comparison, with results to you by March 31. If the score passes, it would select claims from the second quarter, with the 150-claim random draw running alongside it all year.
References
American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. (2017). Guide to audit data analytics. AICPA.
Appelbaum, D., Kogan, A., & Vasarhelyi, M. A. (2017). Big data and analytics in the modern audit engagement: Research needs. Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory, 36(4), 1-27. https://doi.org/10.2308/ajpt-51684
Bolton, R. J., & Hand, D. J. (2002). Statistical fraud detection: A review. Statistical Science, 17(3), 235-255. https://doi.org/10.1214/ss/1042727940
Provost, F., & Fawcett, T. (2013). Data science for business: What you need to know about data mining and data-analytic thinking. O'Reilly Media.
Reading the GCU ACC 657 Topic 1 instructions
ACC-657 opens with Topic 1, where students weigh statistical sampling against full-population analytics. Many papers praise analytics without pricing the choice. The assignment rewards memos that set the cost of each kind of error before naming a technique, identify review capacity as the real limit and compare options on claims reviewed, cases found and annual cost. Students should explain what the rejected sample still does well, attach a validation condition to any model and close with a clear decision request.
How the ACC-657 Topic 1 example is put together
The finished memo puts a price on being wrong before it names any technique. In the illustrative records, reviewing a claim that proves proper costs about 40 minutes of auditor time, roughly $45, while an improper claim left unreviewed costs $620 on average. Capacity is the other fixed fact: the team can examine about 1,500 claims a year. Three options follow. The current sample of 240 claims a year estimates an error rate well and was never built to find cases. A rule screen flags 9,300 claims over the three years, about 3,100 a year, twice what the team can open. A score ranking every claim by its likelihood of being improper fills the 1,500 slots with the claims most worth opening. The memo recommends the score, conditionally, and keeps a random draw of 150 unflagged claims a year.
Where the marks sit in the ACC 657 Topic 1 rubric
Faculty grading the sampling memo reward a recommendation built on error costs. Excellent memos show that full-population access removes sampling risk and leaves reviewer hours as the constraint. Credit goes to one table comparing all three options on the same terms. The rubric values keeping a random draw because a ranking cannot measure what it passes over. The highest level makes adoption conditional on beating the rules on a held-out year. Memos that recommend a model on its development results alone usually land in a middle band.
ACC 657 Topic 1 help before you submit
Memos lose ground fastest when they announce that testing everything removes risk and stop there, because what disappears is sampling risk and what arrives is a queue nobody can clear. Leaving the two error costs unpriced makes every option look equally reasonable, since the comparison has no common unit. Papers often favor the rule screen because it covers every claim, without noticing that 3,100 flags against 1,500 reviews leaves half unopened in whatever order they arrived. Proposing a model with no test on claims it never learned from promises a ranking nobody has checked. Dropping the random draw altogether removes the only estimate of what the ranking misses, so a falling count of findings becomes impossible to read. A memo with no decision requested and no date for the comparison gives the audit executive an essay to file.
Get an ACC-657 Topic 1 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-657 Topic 1 instructions, the rubric in your classroom and the description of the population your section works with. The custom example is written to those criteria, with error costs priced, review capacity stated, the options compared in one table and the rejected approach given its proper role, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More ACC 657 papers and MS in Accounting samples
- ACC 657 Topic 2: Feature Leakage Review
- ACC 657 Topic 3: Rule Baseline Benchmark
- ACC 657 Topic 4: Logistic Model Assumption Check
- ACC 657 Topic 5: Overfit Accuracy Dq Post
- ACC 657 Topic 6: Model Drift Monitoring Plan
- ACC 657 Topic 7: Model Rerun Specification
- ACC 657 Topic 8: Champion Model Defense Memo
- ACC 658 Topic 1: Government Report User Analysis
- ACC 656 Topic 1: Consolidation Scope Memo
- ACC 660 Topic 1: Dual-framework Impairment Comparison
- ACC 653 Topic 1: Cost Commitment Timing Memo
ACC 657 Topic 1 questions, answered
If every claim can be tested, why keep any sample?
Because detection and measurement are different jobs. A ranking sends reviewers to the claims most likely to be improper, which is efficient and also biased by design, so it cannot say how many improper claims sit in the rest of the population. A modest random draw from the unflagged claims answers that. Without it, a falling count of findings could mean the problem shrank or that the ranking stopped seeing it.
Where do the error costs come from?
From the organization's own records wherever possible. Review time can be read from audit timesheets and multiplied by a loaded hourly rate. The cost of a missed improper claim is harder, and prior recoveries give a floor rather than a full figure, since deterrence and reputation sit outside them. Label both as estimates, give their source, and show whether the recommendation survives if either one is halved or doubled.
Does this topic expect a model to be built yet?
Usually not. In many sections the opening topic asks what changes once the whole population is available and which approach suits the question, with the model built in later topics. A memo that runs a full classifier here has skipped the decision being examined. Naming the model's job, ranking claims into 1,500 review slots, and the test it must pass before adoption is the right depth for an opening paper.
Where can I find a free ACC 657 Topic 1 sample paper?
You can read every part of the memo here: the recommendation, what population access changes, the cost of each error, three options compared, why the random draw stays, the validation condition and the decision requested. Describe your review program for a free worked memo.
Why keep a random draw in ACC 657 Topic 1?
Only a random sample of unflagged claims gives an unbiased view of what the score misses, and 150 claims cost under $7,000 a year.