ACC 660 Topic 1 dual-framework impairment comparison example

Advanced Financial Accounting Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This ACC 660 Topic 1 sample paper runs one packaging line through the US GAAP and IFRS impairment tests. It was written for GCU ACC 660, Advanced Financial Accounting, catalog code ACC-660, in the Grand Canyon University MS in Accounting. The line carries $5,000,000 and should produce $900,000 a year for six years. Under ASC 360 the undiscounted $5,400,000 recovers the carrying amount, so no loss is recorded. Under IAS 36, value in use at 8 percent is $4,160,592, above fair value less disposal costs of $3,900,000, giving an $839,408 loss. A forecast of $820,000 a year moves the GAAP loss to $1,000,000 and the IFRS loss to $1,100,000.

CourseACC 660 Advanced Financial Accounting
TopicTopic 1
Paper typeDual-framework impairment comparison
LengthAbout 1,110 words, 2 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMS in Accounting
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for ACC 660 Topic 1

1

One Packaging Line, Two Impairment Tests: Why US GAAP Records Nothing and IFRS Records $839,408, and How a Small Forecast Change Flips the Result

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

ACC-660: Advanced Financial Accounting

Topic 1 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the two results the same facts produce and the sensitivity the paper exposes. The company and figures are illustrative composites; the standards and sources are real.
2

One Packaging Line, Two Impairment Tests: Why US GAAP Records Nothing and IFRS Records $839,408, and How a Small Forecast Change Flips the Result

The Asset and the Unit

Corwin Packaging, a composite manufacturer, operates a thermoforming line that makes food trays. The line's machines, molds and dedicated conveyor produce cash flows that are largely independent of the company's other lines, because the trays are sold under their own contracts. A customer's decision to switch to paper trays has cut expected volumes, which is an indicator that the line may be impaired under both frameworks.

US GAAP tests long-lived assets held and used at the level of the asset group, the smallest grouping whose cash flows can be identified separately from those of the company's other assets (Financial Accounting Standards Board, 2001). IFRS tests at the level of the cash-generating unit, the smallest group of assets that generates largely independent cash inflows (International Accounting Standards Board, 2004). On these facts the two definitions capture the same assets, with a carrying amount of $5,000,000, so any difference in the results comes from the tests themselves, not from what is being tested.

The Forecast and the Discount Rate

The plant's approved budget, revised after the customer's decision, projects net cash flows from the line of $900,000 a year for the six years of its remaining useful life, with no significant residual value. Both frameworks require forecasts based on reasonable and supportable assumptions, and the approved budget is the best evidence available.

Table 1

Base Forecast Under Each Framework

ItemFactsUS GAAP, ASC 360IFRS, IAS 36
Carrying amount$5,000,000$5,000,000$5,000,000
TestUndiscounted flows versus carrying amountRecoverable amount versus carrying amount
Undiscounted flows, 6 years at $900,000$5,400,000$5,400,000Not used
Fair value less costs of disposal$3,900,000Used only if recoverability fails$3,900,000
Value in use at 8 percent$4,160,592Not used$4,160,592
Impairment lossNone$839,408

The line's fair value, from a broker's quote for similar used equipment, is $4,000,000, and dismantling and selling it would cost $100,000. For value in use under IFRS, the flows are discounted at 8 percent, a pretax rate reflecting the time value of money and the risks of the line's cash flows, derived from Corwin's weighted average cost of capital adjusted for tax.

US GAAP: The Recoverability Step

ASC 360 works in two steps, and the second is reached only if the first fails. The first step asks whether the carrying amount is recoverable from the undiscounted cash flows expected from the use and eventual disposal of the asset group. Six years at $900,000 is $5,400,000, which exceeds the carrying amount of $5,000,000. The carrying amount is recoverable, and the analysis stops. No impairment loss is recognized, even though the line's fair value is $1,000,000 below its carrying amount (Hoyle et al., 2021).

This outcome is deliberate. The undiscounted test is designed to avoid recognizing losses from fluctuations in fair value when the asset is still expected to return its cost through use. The company should, however, reconsider the line's remaining useful life and depreciation method, since the same indicator that prompted the test may mean the depreciation pattern is no longer appropriate.

IFRS: Recoverable Amount

IAS 36 has no recoverability screen. The carrying amount is compared directly with recoverable amount, which is whichever is greater: value in use, or fair value after deducting the costs of disposal. Fair value less costs of disposal is $3,900,000. Value in use, six payments of $900,000 discounted at 8 percent, is $4,160,592. The higher of the two is value in use, so recoverable amount is $4,160,592, and the impairment loss is $5,000,000 less $4,160,592, or $839,408, recognized in profit or loss and reducing the line's carrying amount (International Accounting Standards Board, 2004).

The difference between the frameworks is the time value of money. US GAAP asks whether the asset will eventually return its carrying amount in nominal dollars; IFRS asks whether it is worth its carrying amount today.

The Lower Forecast

Suppose the budget is revised again and the line is expected to produce $820,000 a year instead of $900,000, a reduction of under 9 percent. Undiscounted flows fall to $4,920,000, below the carrying amount, so the recoverability test now fails. The GAAP loss is then the amount by which the carrying amount exceeds fair value, $5,000,000 less $4,000,000, or $1,000,000. Costs of disposal are not deducted, because the line is held and used, not held for sale. Under IFRS, value in use falls to $3,790,761, now below fair value less costs of disposal, so recoverable amount becomes $3,900,000 and the loss $1,100,000.

Table 2

Losses Under Two Forecasts

ForecastUS GAAP lossIFRS loss
$900,000 a yearNone$839,408
$820,000 a year$1,000,000$1,100,000

Reading the Cliff

A reduction of $80,000 a year in the forecast moves the IFRS loss by $260,592, a proportionate response. It moves the GAAP loss from nothing to $1,000,000 in a single step. The undiscounted test creates a threshold: above it, no loss regardless of how far fair value has fallen; below it, the full gap to fair value at once. Because the threshold depends on a forecast, the GAAP result is very sensitive to management's estimates near the line, and auditors examine forecasts that land just above it with particular care.

If the Forecast Recovers

If the lost customer returns next year and the forecast rises, the frameworks part again. US GAAP prohibits reversing an impairment loss on an asset held and used; the reduced carrying amount becomes the new cost basis and is depreciated over the remaining life. IAS 36 requires a reversal when there has been a change in the estimates used to determine recoverable amount, up to the carrying amount the line would have had, net of depreciation, if no loss had been recognized. Goodwill is the exception under IFRS: its impairments are never reversed.

What a Reader Needs to See

Under US GAAP on the base forecast, no loss is recognized and no impairment disclosure is required, but a reader would benefit from knowing that the recoverability test passed by only $400,000 of undiscounted flows. Under IFRS, Corwin must disclose the loss, the events that led to it, whether recoverable amount is value in use or fair value less costs of disposal, and the discount rate used. When a reasonably possible change in a key assumption would change the result, as the second forecast shows, a statement of how far the assumption would have to move is useful. IAS 36 requires that sensitivity only for units carrying goodwill or indefinite-lived intangibles, so for this line Corwin would give it voluntarily, but doing so gives a reader the sensitivity that the GAAP statements would leave hidden.

References

Financial Accounting Standards Board. (2001). Accounting for the impairment or disposal of long-lived assets (Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 144). FASB.

Hoyle, J. B., Schaefer, T. F., & Doupnik, T. S. (2021). Advanced accounting (14th ed.). McGraw Hill.

International Accounting Standards Board. (2004). Impairment of assets (IAS 36, revised 2004). IFRS Foundation.

ACC 660 Topic 1 instructions, in plain terms

ACC-660 opens with Topic 1, where students compare long-lived asset impairment under US GAAP and IFRS. Many papers describe the two standards without running them. The assignment rewards comparisons that confirm the asset group and cash-generating unit hold the same assets, state the forecast and discount rate with their sources, and run the recoverability step and the recoverable amount test on one set of facts. Students should rerun both on a lower forecast, explain the reversal rules and set out the disclosures each framework requires of the preparer.

How the ACC-660 Topic 1 example is put together

The finished comparison works one set of facts twice, every figure illustrative. A packaging line forming a single asset group carries $5,000,000 and is expected to produce net cash flows of $900,000 a year for six more years; its fair value is $4,000,000, less $100,000 of disposal costs. Under ASC 360 the first step asks only whether undiscounted flows of $5,400,000 recover the carrying amount, and they do, so no loss is recognized. IAS 36 compares the carrying amount with recoverable amount, the higher of fair value less costs of disposal, $3,900,000, and value in use, the same flows discounted at 8 percent, $4,160,592. The IFRS loss is $839,408. A second forecast of $820,000 a year then moves the GAAP loss from nothing to $1,000,000 and the IFRS loss to $1,100,000.

ACC 660 Topic 1 rubric: what Excellent looks like

Faculty grading the impairment comparison reward one set of facts run through both tests. Excellent comparisons stop the GAAP analysis when recoverability passes and explain why the undiscounted test is designed that way. Credit goes to using the higher of the two IFRS measures. The rubric values a second forecast that exposes the cliff in the GAAP test. The highest level contrasts reversal rules and the sensitivity a reader needs. Comparisons that measure the GAAP loss when recoverability has passed, or that discount the flows in the GAAP recoverability step, usually lose marks.

Common ACC 660 Topic 1 mistakes, and how to avoid them

The weakest comparisons describe the two impairment models side by side and never run either one on the facts. A comparison that states the GAAP test uses undiscounted flows, without setting $5,400,000 against $5,000,000, recites the standard and leaves the point unshown. Measuring the GAAP loss against value in use, or the IFRS loss against undiscounted flows, mixes the frameworks, and many sections mark that as an error rather than a simplification. Writers who pick one forecast and report one number miss what the topic is asking, since the sensitivity is the finding. Calling the GAAP result more conservative misreads the cliff, which cuts in either direction depending on where the forecast sits. A paper silent on reversal leaves out the difference that shapes depreciation and income in each later year.

Get an ACC-660 Topic 1 example written to your instructions

Send the ACC-660 Topic 1 instructions, the rubric your classroom posts and the asset or cash flow facts your section assigned. We write a custom example to them, with each framework run on the same facts, both recoverable measures computed, the forecast tested for sensitivity and reversal addressed, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More ACC 660 papers and MS in Accounting samples

ACC 660 Topic 1 questions, answered

Why does US GAAP use undiscounted cash flows in the first step?

The recoverability step asks a narrow question: will the asset group's carrying amount come back at all through use and eventual disposal. Undiscounted flows answer that question and nothing else, and only a failed test leads to measuring the loss at fair value. The effect is fewer recognized losses and a sharp threshold between none and a large one, which the example exposes with its second forecast.

Can an impairment loss be reversed?

Under IFRS, yes, for assets other than goodwill: if the estimates behind recoverable amount improve, the loss is reversed, capped at the carrying amount the asset would have had with no impairment. Under US GAAP, a loss on an asset held and used establishes a new cost basis and cannot be reversed. Coursework comparisons often turn on this point, because it changes depreciation and income for years.

Which discount rate does value in use require?

IAS 36 calls for a pre-tax rate reflecting current market assessments of the time value of money and the risks specific to the asset that the cash flow estimates have not already absorbed. Cases usually supply one. The example states its 8 percent rate and the basis for it in one line, because a rate chosen without support can move value in use as much as the forecast does.

Where can I find a free ACC 660 Topic 1 sample paper?

The whole comparison is above: the asset and the unit, the forecast and discount rate, the recoverability step, recoverable amount, the lower forecast, the cliff, a recovering forecast and what a reader needs. Share your asset's facts for a free worked comparison.

Why does US GAAP record no loss in ACC 660 Topic 1?

Six years of $900,000 in undiscounted flows total $5,400,000, which recovers the $5,000,000 carrying amount, so the analysis stops before fair value is used.