| Course | ACC 661 Flow-Through Entities and Planning |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 3 |
| Paper type | Special allocation validity test |
| Length | About 1,080 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 661 Topic 3
Does a 90 Percent Depreciation Allocation Stand? Testing Economic Effect Year by Year Until the Investor's Capital Account Runs Out
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
ACC-661: Flow-Through Entities and Planning
Topic 3 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Does a 90 Percent Depreciation Allocation Stand? Testing Economic Effect Year by Year Until the Investor's Capital Account Runs Out
The Agreement's Words
Kestrel Capital LLC, an investor, and Tamsin Equipment LLC, an operator, form Harlan Leasing LLC, taxed as a partnership. Each contributes $200,000, and the partnership buys $400,000 of equipment that it leases to contractors. Depreciation is $100,000 a year for four years, straight-line for simplicity. Kestrel wants the deductions; Tamsin has little taxable income to use them against. The operating agreement allocates 90 percent of depreciation to Kestrel and 10 percent to Tamsin, and all other items equally.
An allocation in the agreement is respected only if it has substantial economic effect; otherwise the item is allocated according to the partners' interests in the partnership (Partner's Distributive Share, 2018). The test is applied to the agreement's words, not to what the partners intended, so the three relevant clauses are quoted first.
Clause 4.2: "Capital accounts shall be maintained in accordance with Treasury Regulations section 1.704-1(b)(2)(iv)." Clause 9.3: "Upon liquidation, distributions shall be made to the Members in accordance with their positive Capital Account balances." Clause 4.6: "If any Member unexpectedly receives an adjustment, allocation or distribution that creates a deficit in the Member's Capital Account, items of income and gain shall be allocated to that Member to eliminate the deficit as quickly as possible." The agreement contains no obligation for any member to restore a deficit capital account.
Economic Effect First
Economic effect is tested first, because an allocation that lacks it never reaches the question of substantiality. The basic test requires three things: capital accounts maintained under the regulations, liquidating distributions made according to positive capital accounts, and an unconditional obligation to restore any deficit. Harlan's agreement meets the first two but not the third.
The alternate test applies instead. An agreement that meets the first two requirements and contains a qualified income offset, which clause 4.6 is, satisfies the alternate test for any allocation that does not cause or increase a deficit in the partner's capital account beyond any amount the partner is obligated to restore (Partner's Distributive Share, 2024). Kestrel has no restoration obligation, so each allocation stands only to the extent Kestrel's capital account stays at or above zero.
The principle predates the current regulations. In a well-known case, a special allocation of depreciation to one pair of partners was disregarded because it would not have changed what either pair received if the partnership's property were sold, so its only effect was to shift tax (Orrisch v. Commissioner, 1970). The capital account rules turn that reasoning into a mechanical test.
The Capital Account Roll
Both capital accounts are rolled forward year by year, with depreciation the only item for simplicity. Kestrel starts at $200,000.
Table 1
Capital Accounts Under the Alternate Test
| Year | Depreciation | Agreement allocates to Kestrel, 90% | Valid under alternate test | Reallocated to Tamsin | Kestrel capital, end | Tamsin capital, end |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $100,000 | $90,000 | $90,000 | $0 | $110,000 | $190,000 |
| 2 | $100,000 | $90,000 | $90,000 | $0 | $20,000 | $180,000 |
| 3 | $100,000 | $90,000 | $20,000 | $70,000 | $0 | $100,000 |
| 4 | $100,000 | $90,000 | $0 | $90,000 | $0 | $0 |
Where the Allocation Fails
In year one, Kestrel's $90,000 allocation reduces its capital account from $200,000 to $110,000, and in year two to $20,000. Both allocations have economic effect: if the partnership liquidated at book value at the end of either year, Kestrel would receive less because of the depreciation it was allocated, which is exactly the economic burden the allocation claims.
In year three, a full $90,000 allocation would push Kestrel's account to $70,000 below zero. Because Kestrel is not obligated to restore that deficit, the part of the allocation that creates it has no economic effect. If the partnership liquidated, Kestrel would receive nothing and pay nothing, and the $70,000 of lost equipment value would fall on Tamsin. Only $20,000 of the year-three allocation, the amount that brings Kestrel's account to zero, is valid. In year four, none of Kestrel's $90,000 is valid.
The failed portion totals $160,000: $70,000 in year three and $90,000 in year four.
Substantiality
The valid portions must also be substantial: they must have a reasonable possibility of affecting the dollar amounts the partners receive, independent of tax consequences. One concern is a transitory allocation, one that is likely to be offset by a later allocation, such as a gain chargeback on sale of the equipment. If the equipment is later sold at a gain, a chargeback would allocate that gain first to Kestrel to reverse its extra depreciation, and the partners would end up where they started, having shifted only tax.
The regulations resolve this with a presumption: the value of property is presumed to equal its book value, so it is not presumed that the equipment will be sold at a gain that offsets the depreciation (Partner's Distributive Share, 2024). A chargeback clause does not by itself defeat the allocation. Leased construction equipment usually loses value roughly as it is depreciated, so the valid portions of the allocation are substantial.
Reallocating the Failed Portion
The $160,000 that fails is reallocated according to the partners' interests in the partnership, determined by who actually bears the economic burden of the depreciation. Once Kestrel's account reaches zero, further decline in the equipment's value reduces only Tamsin's capital account, and on liquidation Tamsin would receive less. Tamsin bears the burden, so the $160,000 is allocated to Tamsin. Over four years Kestrel receives $200,000 of depreciation, not the $360,000 the agreement called for.
The Planning Choice
Two responses are available. The first is to cap the allocation in the agreement: allocate 90 percent of depreciation to Kestrel only to the extent it does not create a deficit, and the rest to Tamsin. That writes the alternate test into the agreement, avoids any dispute on audit and gives Kestrel $200,000 of deductions with certainty.
The second is for Kestrel to accept a deficit restoration obligation of $160,000, an unconditional promise to contribute that amount on liquidation if its capital account is negative. The full allocation would then have economic effect, and Kestrel would receive $360,000 of depreciation. But the obligation is real. If the equipment were worth nothing at the end, Kestrel would owe the partnership $160,000, which would go to Tamsin. At a 35 percent rate the extra deductions save Kestrel $56,000 of tax, against a contingent liability of $160,000.
The capped allocation is recommended. It gives Kestrel what the economics support without exposing it to a large contingent payment for deductions worth about a third of that amount.
References
Orrisch v. Commissioner, 55 T.C. 395 (1970).
Partner's Distributive Share, 26 C.F.R. § 1.704-1 (2024).
Partner's Distributive Share, 26 U.S.C. § 704 (2018).
What the ACC 661 Topic 3 instructions ask for
ACC-661 Topic 3 asks students to evaluate a special allocation in a partnership agreement. Many papers approve allocations the partners agreed to. The assignment rewards tests that quote the agreement's capital account, liquidation and qualified income offset clauses, roll capital accounts forward year by year and apply the alternate economic effect test. Students should mark where an allocation would create an unrestorable deficit, consider substantiality and gain chargebacks, reallocate the failed portion by the partners' interests and compare a capped allocation with a deficit restoration obligation.
How the ACC-661 Topic 3 example is put together
Two partners each contribute $200,000, and the partnership buys $400,000 of equipment depreciated at $100,000 a year, straight-line for simplicity and with illustrative figures throughout. The agreement allocates 90 percent of depreciation to the investor partner, maintains capital accounts under the section 704(b) regulations, liquidates by positive capital accounts and contains a qualified income offset but no deficit restoration obligation. The test rolls both capital accounts forward. The investor's falls from $200,000 to $110,000 and then $20,000, and a third year's $90,000 would push it $70,000 below zero, which the alternate economic effect test does not allow. Only $20,000 of that year's allocation, and none of the fourth year's, stands. The remaining $160,000 is reallocated, and the test prices the deficit restoration obligation the investor would need to keep it.
Where the marks sit in the ACC 661 Topic 3 rubric
Faculty grading the validity test reward the agreement's words over intent. Excellent tests roll both capital accounts and stop the allocation at zero. Credit goes to explaining why the value-equals-basis presumption keeps a chargeback from defeating the allocation. The rubric values reallocating to the partner who bears the burden. The highest level prices a deficit restoration obligation against the tax it would save. Tests that accept the full 90 percent without a capital account roll, or treat the qualified income offset as a restoration obligation, usually lose marks.
Common ACC 661 Topic 3 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Allocation answers lose the most by declaring the arrangement valid because the agreement says so. A paper that recites the three economic effect requirements and never rolls a capital account cannot see year three coming, and on these facts year three decides the question. Treating the qualified income offset as though it were a deficit restoration obligation lets the investor's balance fall below zero with nothing behind it. Papers that find the allocation fails and stop, without reallocating the $160,000, leave the returns incomplete. Substantiality is often skipped once economic effect is found, which leaves half the test undone. A recommendation offering the investor a restoration obligation without stating that it is a real promise to pay presents a tax benefit as free, when it is a liability of up to $160,000 if the equipment ends worthless.
Get an ACC-661 Topic 3 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-661 Topic 3 instructions, your rubric and the operating agreement terms or allocation facts in your case. We write a custom example to them, with the agreement's provisions tested against each requirement, capital accounts rolled forward, any failed allocation reallocated and the planning alternatives priced, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free, and it is written for coursework, not advice.
More ACC 661 papers and MS in Accounting samples
- ACC 661 Topic 1: Pass-through Character Schedule
- ACC 661 Topic 2: Built-in Gain Method Comparison
- ACC 661 Topic 4: Liability Share Basis Analysis
- ACC 661 Topic 5: Excess Distribution DQ Post
- ACC 661 Topic 6: Regime Divergence Analysis
- ACC 661 Topic 7: Passive Investor Loss Projection
- ACC 661 Topic 8: Owner-differentiated Structure Memo
- ACC 660 Topic 3: Functional Currency Translation Worksheet
- ACC 658 Topic 3: Modified Accrual Recognition Worksheet
- ACC 657 Topic 3: Rule Baseline Benchmark
ACC 661 Topic 3 questions, answered
What does a qualified income offset do?
It is an agreement provision that, if a partner's capital account unexpectedly goes negative through certain adjustments or distributions, allocates income and gain to that partner as quickly as possible to eliminate the deficit. Together with capital account maintenance and liquidation by positive balances, it lets an agreement satisfy the alternate economic effect test without a deficit restoration obligation, but only for allocations that do not create or increase a deficit.
Does a gain chargeback make the depreciation allocation transitory?
Not by itself. For the substantiality tests, the regulations presume that property is worth its adjusted tax basis or book value, so a later gain that might reverse the depreciation is not treated as strongly likely to occur. The allocation therefore stands or falls on economic effect in the years examined, and the example states that presumption rather than assuming the chargeback defeats it.
Why not simply give the investor a deficit restoration obligation?
Because it is a genuine promise to contribute cash on liquidation to cover the deficit. If the equipment ends worthless, the investor pays, and the operating partner receives what the investor's deductions took from the shared capital. That exposure is exactly what makes the allocation respected: the partner who takes the deductions bears the loss. The example prices it as a $160,000 exposure, not a formality.
Where can I find a free ACC 661 Topic 3 sample paper?
The full test sits above, with the agreement's words, economic effect first, the capital account roll, where the allocation fails, substantiality, reallocation and the planning choice. Give us your agreement's clauses for a free worked test.
Why does only $20,000 stand in year three in ACC 661 Topic 3?
The investor's capital account is $20,000 entering the year, and with no restoration obligation any allocation beyond that would create a deficit.