| Course | ACC 661 Flow-Through Entities and Planning |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 6 |
| Paper type | Regime divergence analysis |
| Length | About 1,000 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 661 Topic 6
Where the S Corporation and Partnership Rules Part Ways for One Medical Practice: A Building, a Preferred Return and a Working Owner's Pay
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
ACC-661: Flow-Through Entities and Planning
Topic 6 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Where the S Corporation and Partnership Rules Part Ways for One Medical Practice: A Building, a Preferred Return and a Working Owner's Pay
The Owners' Plans
Two physicians are forming Lakeview Family Medicine. Dr. Alan Brooks, near retirement, will contribute $300,000; Dr. Kim Soto, early in practice, will contribute $100,000 and will work full time running the clinic. The practice will buy its building for $500,000, projected to be worth $900,000 in about ten years when Dr. Brooks retires and, under the owners' plan, takes the building as part of the retirement payout. Dr. Brooks wants a preferred return on the larger capital contribution. Dr. Soto needs to be paid for running the practice.
Each of these plans meets a rule that differs between an S corporation and a partnership. The analysis takes them in the order the plans raise them.
Divergence One: Distributing the Building
In an S corporation, distributing appreciated property to a shareholder is treated as if the corporation sold it at fair value: the corporation recognizes the gain (Taxability of Corporation on Distribution, 2018). Distributing a building worth $900,000 with a basis of $500,000 would produce $400,000 of gain, less any depreciation recapture differences ignored here. Because an S corporation's income passes through pro rata, Dr. Soto, who stays, would report half of it, $200,000, on a building Dr. Soto does not receive.
In a partnership, a distribution of property generally produces no gain to the partnership or the partner (Extent of Recognition of Gain or Loss on Distribution, 2018). In a liquidating distribution, the building would take a basis equal to Dr. Brooks's outside basis in the partnership, so the appreciation is preserved and taxed only when Dr. Brooks sells the building (Basis of Distributed Property Other Than Money, 2018). Dr. Soto reports nothing. On this point the partnership is decisively better.
Divergence Two: The Preferred Return
Dr. Brooks wants a 6 percent preferred return on the $200,000 by which Dr. Brooks's capital exceeds Dr. Soto's, about $12,000 a year, paid before profits are split. A partnership agreement can grant that routinely, as a priority allocation and distribution of income to one partner.
An S corporation cannot. Its shares are limited to a single class, and every outstanding share must carry identical rights to distribution and liquidation proceeds (S Corporation Defined, 2018). A governing provision that gives one shareholder's shares a priority return creates a second class of stock and would terminate the election (S Corporation Defined, 2024). Dr. Brooks's preference could be approximated with a separate loan to the corporation at interest, but the preference as the owners describe it does not fit an S corporation.
Divergence Three: Pay for the Working Owner
In an S corporation, Dr. Soto would be an employee paid wages subject to payroll taxes, and the corporation must pay reasonable compensation for the services before making distributions. Distributions beyond reasonable pay are not subject to employment tax. In a partnership, Dr. Soto would receive a guaranteed payment for services (Transactions Between Partner and Partnership, 2018), and a general partner's guaranteed payments and share of ordinary business income are both subject to self-employment tax (Definitions, 2018).
The case estimates that, once the practice is established, the S corporation structure would save about $11,000 a year in employment tax on Dr. Soto's income, because profits above a reasonable salary would pass through without payroll tax. On this point the S corporation is better.
Combining the Results
No single entity wins on all three points. The partnership handles the building and the preferred return; the S corporation handles the working owner's pay. The recommended structure uses both.
The medical practice should operate as an S corporation owned by the two physicians in proportion to their shares of the practice, paying Dr. Soto a reasonable salary. The building should be held by a separate LLC taxed as a partnership, owned by the two physicians and leasing the building to the practice at market rent. Dr. Brooks's larger capital goes into the building LLC, where a preferred return can be written into the operating agreement. When Dr. Brooks retires, the LLC can distribute the building without gain to either owner, and the practice continues untouched.
What the Two-Entity Structure Must Get Right
The structure works only if the two entities deal with each other as unrelated parties would. The lease should be in writing, at a rent supported by a broker's opinion of market rent for comparable medical office space, and reviewed whenever it renews. Rent set too high would move practice profits into the building LLC, where they would escape the reasonable compensation test; rent set too low would understate the building's return and blur Dr. Brooks's preferred return.
Financing also favors the split. If the building LLC borrows to buy the building, each member's share of the mortgage is included in outside basis, which supports depreciation deductions in the early years. Had the building been bought inside the S corporation with the same loan, the physicians would have had no basis from the loan at all. Finally, the owners should expect the net rent to be treated as nonpassive income to them because they materially participate in the practice that pays it, so rental income cannot be used to absorb passive losses from other investments.
The Rejected Alternatives, Priced
A single S corporation would cost Dr. Soto tax on $200,000 of gain at retirement, about $40,000 at a 20 percent capital gains rate, and would deny Dr. Brooks the preferred return. A single partnership would cost about $11,000 a year of self-employment tax on Dr. Soto's income, or about $110,000 over the ten years before Dr. Brooks retires, before any reduction for the deduction allowed for half of that tax. The two-entity structure avoids both costs at the price of a second tax return, a lease between related parties that must be kept at market terms, and slightly more complicated bookkeeping, which together cost far less than either rejected alternative.
References
Basis of Distributed Property Other Than Money, 26 U.S.C. § 732 (2018).
Definitions, 26 U.S.C. § 1402 (2018).
Extent of Recognition of Gain or Loss on Distribution, 26 U.S.C. § 731 (2018).
S Corporation Defined, 26 C.F.R. § 1.1361-1 (2024).
S Corporation Defined, 26 U.S.C. § 1361 (2018).
Taxability of Corporation on Distribution, 26 U.S.C. § 311 (2018).
Transactions Between Partner and Partnership, 26 U.S.C. § 707 (2018).
What the ACC 661 Topic 6 instructions ask for
The Topic 6 instructions in ACC-661 ask students to compare S corporation and partnership treatment for a real business. Weak submissions list differences in textbook order. Credit here goes to analyses that begin with what the owners intend and work each divergence they make decisive: distributing appreciated property, granting a preferred return and paying a working owner. Students should compute the gain and who reports it, explain the single-class-of-stock rule, compare wages with guaranteed payments and recommend a structure, pricing the alternatives rejected.
How this ACC 661 Topic 6 example is built
The owners' plans come before the rules in the finished analysis, and all its figures are illustrative. The building will cost $500,000 and is projected at $900,000 when the older owner retires and takes it. Held in an S corporation, that distribution triggers section 311(b): the corporation recognizes $400,000 of gain as if it sold the building, and $200,000 passes through to the owner who stays. Held in a partnership, section 731 generally recognizes no gain to either the partnership or the retiring partner, and the building carries its basis out with him. The preferred return the older owner wants on his larger capital is routine in a partnership agreement and a second-class-of-stock risk under section 1361. Pay for the working owner, wages in one regime and guaranteed payments under section 707(c) in the other, is compared last.
Where the marks sit in the ACC 661 Topic 6 rubric
Faculty grading the divergence analysis reward rules tied to plans. Excellent analyses show the staying owner taxed on a building the retiring owner receives. Credit goes to recognizing a preferred return as a second-class-of-stock problem. The rubric values weighing employment tax savings against the partnership's advantages. The highest level combines an S corporation practice with a partnership building and sets market-rent terms. Analyses that pick one entity without pricing its costs, or that treat the preferred return as a simple distribution, usually lose marks.
ACC 661 Topic 6 help: mistakes that cost marks
Comparisons on this topic lose credit when they list every difference between the regimes and apply none of them. A table showing that S corporations allocate pro rata and partnerships allocate by agreement is accurate and tells these owners nothing until it meets the preferred return. Papers that treat a building distribution from an S corporation as tax-free, on partnership reasoning, miss section 311(b) and the $200,000 it leaves with the remaining owner. The reverse error, taxing the partnership distribution as a sale, applies corporate logic where section 731 governs. Stating a payroll saving with an invented rate or salary offers a number with nothing behind it. A recommendation that chooses one entity for everything, without considering the split structure, overlooks an arrangement commonly used for an operating business that owns its own real estate.
Get an ACC-661 Topic 6 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-661 Topic 6 instructions, your rubric and the owners' facts and plans from your case. We write a custom example to them, with each point where the two regimes diverge applied to those plans, the consequences priced from the case's figures and a structure recommended against its alternatives, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More ACC 661 papers and MS in Accounting samples
- ACC 661 Topic 1: Pass-through Character Schedule
- ACC 661 Topic 2: Built-in Gain Method Comparison
- ACC 661 Topic 3: Special Allocation Validity Test
- ACC 661 Topic 4: Liability Share Basis Analysis
- ACC 661 Topic 5: Excess Distribution DQ Post
- ACC 661 Topic 7: Passive Investor Loss Projection
- ACC 661 Topic 8: Owner-differentiated Structure Memo
- ACC 660 Topic 6: Operating Segment Determination Report
- ACC 658 Topic 6: Net Asset Classification Worksheet
- ACC 657 Topic 6: Model Drift Monitoring Plan
ACC 661 Topic 6 questions, answered
Why does an S corporation recognize gain when it distributes property?
Because section 311(b) applies to S corporations through the corporate rules that govern their distributions: a corporation distributing appreciated property recognizes gain as if it had sold the property at fair market value. In an S corporation that gain passes through to all shareholders under section 1366, pro rata, so owners who receive nothing still report part of it. Partnership distributions are generally governed by section 731 instead.
Does a preferred return always create a second class of stock?
The rule looks at whether outstanding shares confer identical rights to distribution and liquidation proceeds, and shares may differ in voting rights without breaking it. A preferred return that gives one shareholder a priority to distributions generally creates a second class, which would end the election. Some arrangements outside the governing provisions are treated differently, so the example states the general rule and notes that the details reach beyond the case.
Is the split structure a recommendation for any practice?
No. It follows from these owners' facts: a building likely to appreciate, an owner who wants to take it out and a working owner whose pay the case estimates. Different facts, such as no real estate or owners who never plan to separate, can make a single entity simpler and cheaper. The example is coursework analysis on illustrative figures, and an actual structure needs a qualified adviser.
Where can I find a free ACC 661 Topic 6 sample paper?
The complete analysis appears above: the owners' plans, the building, the preferred return, pay for the working owner, combining the results, what the two-entity structure must get right and the rejected alternatives priced. Describe your owners' plans for a free worked analysis.
Why hold the building in a partnership in ACC 661 Topic 6?
A partnership can distribute it to the retiring owner without gain, while an S corporation would recognize $400,000 of gain and pass half to the owner who stays.