| Course | ACC 661 Flow-Through Entities and Planning |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 8 |
| Paper type | Owner-differentiated structure memo |
| Length | About 840 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 661 Topic 8
Memorandum
To: Erin Walsh, Victor Lang and Sam Okafor, Harborlight Software
From: [Author Name], tax planning
Date: [Date]
Re: Choice of entity for Harborlight Software
Recommendation
Harborlight Software should be organized as a limited liability company taxed as a partnership. That form meets Victor's and Sam's needs fully and most of Erin's. The owner who gives something up is Erin, who would save about $12,000 a year in payroll tax from year three under an S corporation. The reasons follow, owner by owner.
Victor Lang, the Investor
Victor will contribute $450,000 and wants an 8 percent preferred return, about $36,000 a year, paid before other owners share profits. Victor also expects Harborlight to lose money in its first year and wants to use that loss against passive rental income from other investments.
The rules that decide whether these needs are met are the allocation and class-of-stock rules. A partnership agreement can grant a preferred return and can allocate losses to Victor in proportion to Victor's capital, provided the allocations have substantial economic effect (Partner's Distributive Share, 2018). Because Victor will not work in the business, Victor's share of losses is passive and can offset passive rental income (Passive Activity Losses and Credits Limited, 2018).
Erin Walsh, the Founder
Erin will contribute $50,000 and work full time as chief executive. Erin needs to be paid for that work and, over time, to share in the growth Erin creates. The decisive rules are those governing pay. In a partnership, Erin's pay is a guaranteed payment for services, deductible by the partnership and taxable to Erin (Transactions Between Partner and Partnership, 2018), and it is subject to self-employment tax along with Erin's share of business income. In an S corporation, Erin would draw a reasonable salary subject to payroll tax, and profits beyond it would pass through without employment tax.
Sam Okafor, the Key Hire
Sam joins in year two as head of engineering in exchange for a 10 percent share of future profits, with no capital contribution. Sam needs that interest without owing tax on receipt. In a partnership, a profits interest received for services, one that would give Sam nothing if the partnership liquidated immediately, is generally not taxed when received or when it vests, provided the conditions of the revenue procedures are met (Rev. Proc. 93-27, 1993; Rev. Proc. 2001-43, 2001). In a corporation, stock received for services is compensation, taxed at its value when it vests unless an election is made to be taxed earlier (Property Transferred in Connection With Performance of Services, 2018).
The Comparison
Each form is scored against each owner's needs.
Table 1
Entity Forms Against Owner Needs
| Owner and need | LLC taxed as a partnership | S corporation | C corporation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Victor: preferred return | Permitted in the agreement | Creates a second class of stock; not permitted | Permitted through preferred stock |
| Victor: first-year losses against passive income | Allocated to Victor; passive | Pro rata only; Victor bears a share, not all | Losses stay in the corporation |
| Erin: pay | Guaranteed payment, self-employment tax | Salary with payroll tax; profits free of employment tax | Salary; profits taxed twice when paid out |
| Sam: equity for services | Profits interest, generally untaxed on receipt | Stock taxed as pay on vesting | Stock taxed as pay on vesting |
Why Not an S Corporation
An S corporation may have only a single class of stock, with identical distribution and liquidation rights on every share (S Corporation Defined, 2018). Victor's preferred return would violate that requirement or would have to be restructured as a loan, which Victor has declined. Losses would pass through pro rata by shares, so Victor could not take the full first-year loss even though Victor provided nearly all the capital. Sam's equity would be taxed as pay. The S corporation's one advantage belongs to Erin.
What Erin Gives Up
The case estimates that from year three, when Harborlight is profitable, an S corporation would save Erin about $12,000 a year in employment tax, because profits above a reasonable salary would not bear payroll tax. Under the partnership, Erin's guaranteed payment and share of business income are subject to self-employment tax. Over years three through seven that difference totals about $60,000. The owners could compensate Erin in the agreement, for example by a slightly larger profit share once Victor's preferred return has been paid, and should discuss that directly.
The C Corporation Option
A C corporation would allow a preferred stock for Victor, but its losses would stay inside the corporation as carryforwards, unusable by Victor against rental income. Profits paid out later would be taxed twice, and Sam's stock would be taxed as pay. It fails every owner's main need except Victor's preference.
When to Reopen the Choice
The recommendation depends on Victor's preferred return. Once it has been paid off and Victor no longer needs special allocations, the main reasons for partnership treatment weaken, and Erin's payroll tax saving becomes the largest remaining difference. At that point the owners should revisit the choice, including whether converting to an S corporation, or electing S status for a newly formed entity, makes sense.
References
Partner's Distributive Share, 26 U.S.C. § 704 (2018).
Passive Activity Losses and Credits Limited, 26 U.S.C. § 469 (2018).
Property Transferred in Connection With Performance of Services, 26 U.S.C. § 83 (2018).
Rev. Proc. 2001-43, 2001-2 C.B. 191 (2001).
Rev. Proc. 93-27, 1993-2 C.B. 343 (1993).
S Corporation Defined, 26 U.S.C. § 1361 (2018).
Transactions Between Partner and Partnership, 26 U.S.C. § 707 (2018).
What the ACC 661 Topic 8 instructions ask for
The Topic 8 instructions in ACC-661 ask students to recommend an entity for owners with different goals. Weak submissions compare entity forms in general. The assignment rewards memos that profile each owner's needs, identify the rule that decides each one and score the entity forms against every owner. Students should state the recommendation and who gives something up, price that owner's loss, explain the tax treatment of a profits interest, reject the forms that fail and name the event that should reopen the choice.
Inside the ACC 661 Topic 8 example
Each owner's position gets a page before any entity is compared; figures throughout are illustrative. The investor contributes $450,000, wants an 8 percent preferred return and expects to use first-year losses against his passive rental income. The founder contributes $50,000 and works full time. The key hire joins in year two for a 10 percent share of future profits. An LLC taxed as a partnership serves the investor and the key hire: the agreement can grant the preference and allocate losses, and a profits interest for services is generally not taxed on receipt under Rev. Proc. 93-27. An S corporation would put the preference at odds with section 1361, share losses pro rata and tax the hire's stock as pay. It would, however, save the founder payroll tax the case estimates at $12,000 a year from year three.
Reading the ACC 661 Topic 8 rubric
Faculty grading the structure memo reward owners analyzed before entities. Excellent memos cite the rule that meets or blocks each need in a comparison table. Credit goes to treating a profits interest for services as generally untaxed on receipt. The rubric values pricing the founder's lost payroll tax saving honestly. The highest level names when the choice should be revisited and labels the memo as coursework. Memos that recommend an S corporation without addressing the preferred return, or that ignore the key hire's tax on receiving equity, tend to earn partial credit.
Common ACC 661 Topic 8 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Treating the three owners as one is where structure memos fail most often. A recommendation built on the founder's payroll saving alone, because it is the easiest figure to compute, ignores the investor's preference and the key hire's equity, which decide the case. Papers that grant the investor a preferred return inside an S corporation without noting the one-class requirement recommend a structure that may not survive its first distribution. Treating the key hire's profits interest as taxable on receipt, or as automatically tax-free without conditions, misstates the guidance in either direction. A memo that never says which owner gives something up hides the trade-off the recommendation turns on. Rejecting the C corporation without mentioning trapped early losses leaves the third alternative dismissed rather than priced.
Get an ACC-661 Topic 8 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-661 Topic 8 instructions, your rubric and each owner's facts and goals. We write a custom example to them, with every owner's needs set out, the entity choices compared against each with citations, the least-served owner's cost priced and a trigger for revisiting stated, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free, as coursework, not advice.
More ACC 661 papers and MS in Accounting samples
- ACC 661 Topic 1: Pass-through Character Schedule
- ACC 661 Topic 2: Built-in Gain Method Comparison
- ACC 661 Topic 3: Special Allocation Validity Test
- ACC 661 Topic 4: Liability Share Basis Analysis
- ACC 661 Topic 5: Excess Distribution DQ Post
- ACC 661 Topic 6: Regime Divergence Analysis
- ACC 661 Topic 7: Passive Investor Loss Projection
- ACC 660 Topic 8: Credit Loss Disclosure Critique
- ACC 658 Topic 8: Board Liquidity Briefing
- ACC 657 Topic 8: Champion Model Defense Memo
ACC 661 Topic 8 questions, answered
What is a profits interest?
A partnership interest that entitles the holder to a share of future profits and appreciation but nothing of the existing value if the partnership liquidated immediately. Under Rev. Proc. 93-27 its receipt for services is generally not treated as a taxable event, subject to exceptions such as an interest in a predictable income stream or one disposed of soon after. A capital interest received for services is generally compensation at its value.
Why not choose the S corporation and handle the preference another way?
Some owners try, for example by paying the investor a fee or making him a lender instead of an owner. Each alternative changes what he holds: a fee is taxable to him and deductible by the company, and a loan earns interest rather than a share of profit. The memo considers the loan version and rejects it because the investor wants the early losses, which a lender does not receive.
Can the entity be changed later?
Often, though never without consequences. An LLC taxed as a partnership can in many cases elect to be taxed as a corporation and then make an S election if every eligibility condition is met, but the preference and special allocations would have to be unwound first. The memo treats a later change as possible and costly, and ties its timing to the investor's preference being repaid.
Where can I find a free ACC 661 Topic 8 sample paper?
The memo is here in full: the recommendation, the investor, the founder, the key hire, the comparison, why not an S corporation, what the founder gives up, the C corporation option and when to reopen the choice. Tell us your owners' goals for a free worked memo.
What does the founder give up in ACC 661 Topic 8?
About $12,000 a year of payroll tax an S corporation would save from year three, roughly $60,000 over years three through seven.