ACC 663 Topic 8 contested recommendation letter example

Personal Financial Advisory Services Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This ACC 663 Topic 8 sample paper answers a client who wants to withdraw a $300,000 inherited IRA this year to pay off a $210,000 mortgage. It belongs to GCU ACC 663, Personal Financial Advisory Services, the course listed as ACC-663 in the Grand Canyon University MS in Accounting. At an assumed 32 percent, one withdrawal costs about $96,000 and leaves $204,000, short of the mortgage. Five yearly withdrawals at 24 percent cost about $72,000, though carrying the loan costs about $14,800 of interest. The letter keeps its recommendation, answers the client's preference for certainty, offers a middle route and asks for a signed choice.

CourseACC 663 Personal Financial Advisory Services
TopicTopic 8
Paper typeContested recommendation letter
LengthAbout 790 words, 1 pages
FormatMemo with APA 7 references
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMS in Accounting
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for ACC 663 Topic 8

1

Memorandum

To: Carmen Wilder

From: [Author Name], CPA

Date: [Date]

Re: Your plan to withdraw the inherited IRA this year

 

Your Goal, as You Put It

You told us you want to reach retirement owing nothing, and that you would rather pay off the $210,000 mortgage now with the $300,000 IRA you inherited from your father than carry the debt another day. You said certainty matters more to you than tax. That goal is sound, and we share it. Our disagreement is only about the route, and this letter explains ours before asking you to choose.

Two Routes Side by Side

Both routes pay off the mortgage and empty the IRA. The table compares them over five years, with your regular $1,600 monthly mortgage payment continuing until the loan is paid and saved afterward. All rates are assumptions for federal tax only.

Table 1

Two Routes Compared

Withdraw all $300,000 this yearWithdraw $60,000 a year for five years
Assumed federal rate on the withdrawals32 percent blended24 percent
Total federal tax$96,000$72,000
Mortgage interest paid, at 3.25 percentNone after payoffAbout $14,800
Cash on hand right after the payoffAbout $6,000 short; savings neededReserve kept intact throughout
Cash built up by the end of year fiveAbout $90,000About $99,200
Debt-freeThis yearEnd of year four

Why One Large Withdrawal Costs More

Every dollar you withdraw from the IRA is added to your salary and taxed as ordinary income. Our tax system taxes income in layers, at higher rates as income rises. Taking $300,000 in one year pushes much of it into higher layers, so we assume an average rate of 32 percent on the added income: about $96,000 of federal tax, leaving $204,000. That is $6,000 less than the mortgage, so you would need to use savings to finish paying it, and you would have no cash reserve left. Spreading the withdrawals keeps each year's added income in a lower layer, assumed at 24 percent, for $72,000 of tax in total.

Spreading is allowed. Most adult children who inherit an IRA must empty it within ten years of the parent's death, but may take the money at any pace within that period (Internal Revenue Service, 2024).

The Honest Arithmetic

Spreading saves about $24,000 of tax, but it means carrying the mortgage for about four more years, which costs about $14,800 of interest. The net difference by year five is roughly $9,200 in your favor, not $24,000. The larger reason we recommend spreading is the reserve. Under the one-year route, you would be debt-free but also without cash, and any surprise, a roof, a medical bill, a gap in work, would have to be borrowed. Under the spread, you keep your savings intact the whole time and become debt-free at the end of year four.

These figures rest on assumptions that could change. If your salary rises, each year's withdrawal could fall into a higher layer and narrow the tax saving. If tax rates change in later years, the spread could cost more or less than shown. State income tax, which we excluded, would add to both routes, and more to the one-year route. We will update the figures each year before the withdrawal is made.

Your Objection

You told us that tax matters less to you than the certainty of owing nothing. We take that seriously. People often value being free of debt for reasons the numbers do not capture, and that is a legitimate preference, not an error (Shefrin & Thaler, 1988). But we would point out that the one-year route trades one uncertainty for another: you would owe nothing, but you would also have nothing set aside. Our recommendation is the spread, because it reaches your goal within four years while keeping the cushion that protects it (Billingsley et al., 2017).

A Middle Route

If carrying the full mortgage for four years is what troubles you, there is a middle route. Withdraw about $146,000 this year, which at an assumed blended rate of 28 percent leaves about $105,120, enough to cut the mortgage in half at once. Withdraw the remaining $154,000 over the next four years at an assumed 24 percent. Total federal tax would be about $77,840, more than the spread but well below the one-year route, your monthly interest would fall by half immediately, and your reserve would stay intact.

Your Choice

Please tell us which route you choose: the one-year withdrawal, the five-year spread or the middle route. Whatever you decide, we will carry it out with you and keep working on the rest of your plan. Because this is a significant decision and you may choose differently from our recommendation, we ask you to confirm your choice by signing and returning the enclosed page.

References

Billingsley, R., Gitman, L. J., & Joehnk, M. D. (2017). Personal financial planning (14th ed.). Cengage Learning.

Internal Revenue Service. (2024). Distributions from individual retirement arrangements (IRAs) (Publication 590-B). U.S. Department of the Treasury.

Shefrin, H. M., & Thaler, R. H. (1988). The behavioral life-cycle hypothesis. Economic Inquiry, 26(4), 609-643. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1465-7295.1988.tb01520.x

The ACC-663 Topic 8 assignment instructions

The Topic 8 instructions in ACC-663 ask students to maintain a recommendation a client disputes. Weak submissions either give in or repeat the advice more forcefully. The assignment rewards letters that restate the client's goal fairly, compare both routes in a table with every rate labeled and state tax named as excluded, and explain bracket effects in plain words. Students should apply the ten-year rule for inherited IRAs, answer the client's reason directly, offer a middle route and ask the client to confirm the decision in writing.

How this ACC 663 Topic 8 example is built

The letter opens by restating the client's goal, owing nothing by retirement, and shares it. A table compares withdrawing all $300,000 this year, about $96,000 of federal tax at an assumed 32 percent that leaves $204,000 against a $210,000 mortgage, with $60,000 a year for five years at an assumed 24 percent, about $72,000 in total. It counts the roughly $14,800 of interest the spread costs, so the net gain is about $9,200, and rests the case on keeping a reserve. It notes that most adult children must empty an inherited IRA within ten years, offers a middle route that halves the mortgage in the first year for about $77,840 of total tax, and asks the client to sign a page confirming the route chosen, stating that the engagement continues whatever the client decides.

Where the marks sit in the ACC 663 Topic 8 rubric

Faculty grading the contested letter reward disagreement handled with respect. Excellent letters show that the client's own route does not clear the mortgage. Credit goes to counting the interest the adviser's route costs, not only its tax saving. The rubric values labeled rates, excluded state tax named and the ten-year window applied. The highest level offers a middle route and records the client's decision in writing. Letters that adopt the client's route without comment, or that never show the client's route in figures, usually land in a middle band.

ACC 663 Topic 8 help before you submit

Letters that simply adopt the client's preference once the client objects score lowest, since the topic asks whether the adviser can hold a reasoned position and still respect the client's authority to decide. The opposite failure is a letter that restates the recommendation more forcefully without answering the client's reason, which treats the goal as an error. Pricing only the adviser's route leaves the client unable to compare, and here the client's own plan does not clear the mortgage. Rates without labels, or state tax left unmentioned, make figures look more certain than they are. Papers that ignore the inherited IRA's ten-year window miss that spreading is allowed, and a letter with no signed record of the decision leaves the file unable to show that the client understood the cost of the route chosen.

Get an ACC-663 Topic 8 example written to your instructions

Send the ACC-663 Topic 8 instructions, the rubric and the client scenario, including the objection your section's case raises. We write a custom example to them, with the client's goal restated fairly, both routes priced on labeled assumptions, the recommendation defended and her decision documented, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free; it is coursework, never financial advice.

More ACC 663 papers and MS in Accounting samples

ACC 663 Topic 8 questions, answered

Should the adviser give in if the client insists?

Not on the analysis. The decision is hers, and the letter says so, but the adviser's professional duty is to give an objective recommendation and explain its basis, not to adopt whatever the client prefers. The letter keeps the recommendation, offers a middle route she might accept, and records the choice she makes, which respects her authority without abandoning the advice.

Why does one large withdrawal cost more tax?

Because income tax brackets are progressive. Adding $300,000 to one year's income pushes much of it into higher brackets, while spreading the same amount over five years keeps more of it in lower ones. The example uses assumed rates of 32 and 24 percent to show the effect, labeled as illustrations, since actual brackets depend on the year and her other income.

Must an inherited IRA be emptied within ten years?

For most adult children who inherit an IRA from a parent who died after 2019, yes: the account generally has to be fully distributed by the end of the tenth year after the death, and annual withdrawals may also be required in some cases. Certain beneficiaries, such as a surviving spouse, follow different rules. The example states the general rule and flags that the details depend on the facts.

Where can I find a free ACC 663 Topic 8 sample paper?

The whole letter is above: the client's goal, two routes side by side, why one large withdrawal costs more, the honest arithmetic, the objection, a middle route and the client's choice. Share your client's decision for a free worked letter.

Why does the one-year route fall short in ACC 663 Topic 8?

About $96,000 of federal tax at an assumed 32 percent leaves $204,000, which is $6,000 less than the $210,000 mortgage and leaves no reserve.