| Course | ACC 669 Corporate Taxation |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 1 |
| Paper type | Separate taxpayer analysis memo |
| Length | About 800 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 669 Topic 1
Memorandum
To: Leah Carver, President, Carver Design Studio, Inc.
From: [Author Name], CPA
Date: [Date]
Re: How this year's corporate income and your personal withdrawals are taxed
The Premise
Carver Design Studio, Inc. is a taxpayer separate from you, with its own return, its own income and its own tax. A corporation formed for business purposes and carrying on business is taxed as a distinct entity, even when one person owns all of it (Moline Properties, Inc. v. Commissioner, 1943). You told us you had assumed the corporation's money and yours were effectively the same, and three conclusions below follow from the fact that they are not.
The Diverted Fees
Two clients paid $20,000 of design fees by checks that you deposited into your personal account. The question is who earned the fees. The contracts are in the corporation's name, the invoices were issued on its letterhead and the work was done by its employees, including you acting as its president. The corporation earned the fees, and they are its gross income, wherever the checks were deposited.
Including the $20,000, the corporation's taxable income for the year is $150,000.
Depositing the checks personally did not move the income to you; it created a second event. The corporation earned $20,000 and, in the same moment, let its shareholder take that cash. The first event is taxed on the corporation's return and the second on yours, which is why the same $20,000 appears twice in the table below. If the fees had been left out of the corporate return, the understatement would carry penalties and interest as well as the tax.
The Vacation, at the Corporate Level
The corporation paid $12,000 for your family's vacation in Hawaii, and it was recorded as travel expense. A corporation may deduct only ordinary and necessary expenses paid in carrying on its business (Trade or Business Expenses, 2018). No client meetings, training or other business activity took place during the trip, so it served no business purpose, and the corporation may not deduct it. The $150,000 of taxable income above already excludes the $12,000 deduction.
Corporate Tax
A corporation pays a flat 21 percent federal tax on its taxable income (Tax Imposed, 2018). On $150,000, the corporation owes $31,500. There is no lower rate for smaller amounts of corporate income.
The Same Items, at Your Level
The $20,000 of fees you kept and the $12,000 vacation are, from your side, amounts the corporation transferred to you as its shareholder. They were not wages, because the corporation ran no payroll for them and withheld no tax, and they were not loans, because there is no note, interest or repayment plan. Transfers of corporate property to a shareholder in that capacity are distributions (Distributions of Property, 2018), and they are treated as such even though the corporation never declared them. Together they total $32,000.
Table 1
The Same Two Items on Two Returns
| Item | Corporation | You |
|---|---|---|
| Diverted fees, $20,000 | Gross income | Dividend |
| Vacation, $12,000 | Not deductible | Dividend |
| Taxable income | $150,000 | |
| Tax | $31,500 at 21 percent | Tax on $32,000 of dividends at your rate |
Whether a distribution counts as a dividend is measured against the earnings and profits the corporation has built up (Dividend Defined, 2018). Whether a payment is a dividend depends on that computation, not on what anyone called it. The corporation's current earnings and profits start from taxable income of $150,000, reduced by the $31,500 of federal income tax, which the corporation cannot deduct but has paid. That gives about $118,500. Because $118,500 exceeds the $32,000 distributed, the full $32,000 is a dividend to you, taxed at qualified dividend rates on your personal return.
Retained Profit Is Taxed Twice
Profit the corporation keeps is taxed once now, at 21 percent, and again when it is eventually paid to you as a dividend. Of each $100 the corporation earns, $21 goes to corporate tax and $79 remains; if that $79 is later distributed and taxed to you at an assumed 15 percent qualified dividend rate, you keep about $67. Salary for services you actually perform is different: the corporation can deduct a reasonable salary, so it is taxed only once, on your return, subject to payroll taxes. We will discuss the balance between salary and distributions at our next meeting.
Keeping the Two Apart
From now on, every client payment should be deposited to the corporation's account, and every personal expense paid from your own account. The corporation should keep its own bank and card accounts, its own invoices and contracts, a record of board decisions on salary and any dividends, and written loan documents if it ever lends to you or you to it. Your personal accounts should show only your salary, any declared dividends and your own spending. Records kept this way support the corporation's separate status and make each year's tax results predictable.
References
Distributions of Property, 26 U.S.C. § 301 (2018).
Dividend Defined, 26 U.S.C. § 316 (2018).
Moline Properties, Inc. v. Commissioner, 319 U.S. 436 (1943).
Tax Imposed, 26 U.S.C. § 11 (2018).
Trade or Business Expenses, 26 U.S.C. § 162 (2018).
The ACC-669 Topic 1 assignment instructions
In Topic 1 of ACC-669, students work from the principle that a corporation is a taxpayer separate from its owner. Many papers merge the two. The assignment rewards memos that state the premise with authority, decide who earned diverted income, test a personal expense paid by the corporation under section 162, and compute corporate tax at 21 percent. Students should characterize the owner's receipts as distributions, compute earnings and profits before calling them dividends, show retained profit taxed twice and list the records that keep the two taxpayers apart.
How the ACC-669 Topic 1 example is put together
Written to the client, the memo works one year. The corporation's contracts are in its own name, so $20,000 of fees the owner deposited personally remain its income, and taxable income is $150,000 with those fees included and a $12,000 family vacation denied under section 162 as serving no business purpose. Section 11 applies 21 percent, for $31,500 of corporate tax. On the owner's side, the fees and the vacation are $32,000 of constructive distributions. Current earnings and profits of about $118,500 exceed them, so sections 301 and 316 make the whole $32,000 a dividend. Retained profit is shown taxed once now and again when distributed, and Moline Properties supplies the premise. A closing paragraph lists the accounts and records the corporation should keep apart from the owner's, from bank accounts and invoices to board minutes on salary and written loan documents.
Where the marks sit in the ACC 669 Topic 1 rubric
Faculty grading the separate taxpayer memo reward one premise applied three times. Excellent memos decide who earned the fees from the contracts and the work, not from where the checks went. Credit goes to denying the vacation deduction and treating the payment as a distribution rather than wages. The rubric values an earnings and profits figure that supports the dividend conclusion. The highest level shows the second layer of tax on retained profit and lists the records to keep apart. Memos that treat the corporation as the owner's pocket usually lose marks.
ACC 669 Topic 1 help before you submit
Papers that treat the corporation as an extension of its owner lose marks on all three facts at once, since each conclusion depends on the separate-taxpayer premise. Reporting the diverted fees only on the owner's return skips the corporate income they first were and understates the corporation's tax. Deducting the vacation because the corporation paid it confuses who paid with why it was paid. Calling the $32,000 a dividend without an earnings and profits figure reaches the right label by assumption, and markers look for the computation. Papers that recast the payments as salary need facts showing an intent to compensate. Retained profit described as untaxed misses the corporate layer entirely, and a memo that ends without telling the client how to keep the two taxpayers apart leaves the same problem to recur next year.
Get an ACC-669 Topic 1 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-669 Topic 1 instructions, your rubric and the fact pattern your section assigned. We write a custom example to them, with the separate-taxpayer premise stated, income placed with the entity that earned it, earnings and profits computed before any dividend label and both layers of tax shown, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More ACC 669 papers and MS in Accounting samples
- ACC 669 Topic 2: Section 351 Transfer Analysis
- ACC 669 Topic 3: Book-tax Income Reconciliation
- ACC 669 Topic 4: Earnings and Profits Schedule
- ACC 669 Topic 5: Cash Route Comparison Dq Post
- ACC 669 Topic 6: Redemption Attribution Memo
- ACC 669 Topic 7: Two-level Liquidation Computation
- ACC 669 Topic 8: Reorganization Structure Memo
- ACC 663 Topic 1: Advisory Engagement Letter
- ACC 661 Topic 1: Pass-through Character Schedule
- ACC 660 Topic 1: Dual-framework Impairment Comparison
ACC 669 Topic 1 questions, answered
What does Moline Properties stand for?
The Supreme Court held that a corporation formed for a business purpose, or carrying on business activity, is a separate taxable entity, even when one person owns and controls it. Its owner cannot disregard it when that would be convenient for tax. The memo cites the case for that premise only, which is the point every later conclusion depends on.
What is a constructive dividend?
A benefit a corporation confers on a shareholder without declaring a dividend, such as paying a personal expense or letting corporate receipts go to the owner. The label the parties use does not control. The payment is measured, tested against earnings and profits, and taxed as a dividend to the extent they cover it, while the corporation gets no deduction for it.
Why not treat the payments as salary?
Salary would give the corporation a deduction and give her wages, but that reading needs facts: an intent to compensate, amounts reasonable for services, and payroll reporting. None appear in this fact pattern, so the memo rejects the salary alternative and says why. Where an assignment supplies those facts, the analysis changes, and a custom example follows the facts given.
Where can I find a free ACC 669 Topic 1 sample paper?
The whole memo is above: the premise, the diverted fees, the vacation at the corporate level, corporate tax, the same items at the owner's level, retained profit taxed twice and keeping the two apart. Share your corporation's facts for a free worked memo.
Why is the full $32,000 a dividend in ACC 669 Topic 1?
Current earnings and profits, taxable income of $150,000 less $31,500 of tax, are about $118,500, which exceeds the $32,000 distributed.