| Course | ACC 669 Corporate Taxation |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 2 |
| Paper type | Section 351 transfer analysis |
| Length | About 1,010 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 669 Topic 2
Three Founders, One Section 351 Transfer: Control, a Mortgage That Exceeds Basis and a $280,000 Gain That Now Sits Twice
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
ACC-669: Corporate Taxation
Topic 2 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Three Founders, One Section 351 Transfer: Control, a Mortgage That Exceeds Basis and a $280,000 Gain That Now Sits Twice
The Contributions
Three founders form Tidewater Cold Storage, Inc., which issues a single class of voting common stock. Each contribution is listed with its value, its basis, any liability attached and the stock received.
Table 1
Contributions and Stock Issued
| Founder | Contribution | Fair value | Adjusted basis | Liability assumed | Stock received |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hollis Grant | Warehouse building | $500,000 | $180,000 | $220,000 | $280,000 |
| Amara Singh | Cash | $200,000 | $200,000 | None | $200,000 |
| Theo Marsh | Organizing services | $0 | None | $40,000 | |
| Total | $520,000 |
Control
Section 351 lets founders move property into a corporation for its stock without recognizing gain or loss, but only if, right after the exchange, the people who transferred property together control the corporation (Transfer to Corporation Controlled by Transferor, 2018). For this test, control requires 80 percent of the combined voting power and 80 percent of the shares in every other class (Definitions Relating to Corporate Reorganizations, 2018).
Services are not property for this purpose, so stock issued for services does not count toward the transferors' control. The property transferors are Hollis and Amara, who together receive $480,000 of the $520,000 of stock issued, about 92.3 percent of the single class of voting stock. They are in control, and section 351 applies to both. Theo, who contributed only services, is not a transferor of property and is outside the section.
Hollis Grant: The Building and Its Mortgage
Hollis realizes a gain equal to the amount realized, $280,000 of stock plus $220,000 of mortgage relief, less the $180,000 basis, or $320,000. Section 351 defers realized gain unless the transferor receives boot. The corporation's assumption of a liability is generally not treated as boot (Assumption of Liability, 2018), with two exceptions that must be checked in order.
The first applies if the principal purpose of the assumption was to avoid tax or was not a bona fide business purpose, in which case the whole liability becomes boot. Hollis placed the mortgage eleven years ago to buy the building, and it has been paid down on schedule since. The liability arose in the ordinary course of acquiring the property it now travels with, and there is no avoidance purpose. The first exception does not apply.
The second applies when the liabilities assumed exceed the total adjusted basis of the property transferred. Here the $220,000 mortgage exceeds the $180,000 basis by $40,000, and that excess is recognized as gain regardless of purpose (Assumption of Liability, 2018). Hollis recognizes $40,000 of gain, characterized by the nature of the building in Hollis's hands.
Amara Singh: Cash
Amara transfers $200,000 of cash for $200,000 of stock. No gain or loss is realized, and Amara's stock basis is $200,000.
Theo Marsh: Stock for Services
Theo receives $40,000 of stock for organizing the corporation, which is compensation for services. Theo has $40,000 of ordinary income, as property received for services is taxable at its value when it vests (Property Transferred in Connection With Performance of Services, 2018), and takes a $40,000 cost basis in the shares. The corporation treats the $40,000 as an organizational expenditure; it may deduct up to $5,000 in its first year, reduced when total organizational costs exceed $50,000, and amortize the rest over 180 months (Organizational Expenditures, 2018).
Basis Schedules
A transferor's stock basis equals the basis of the property transferred, increased by gain recognized and decreased by liabilities the corporation assumed (Basis to Distributees, 2018). Hollis's basis is $180,000 plus $40,000 less $220,000, or zero. The corporation's basis in property received in a section 351 transfer is the transferor's basis increased by the gain the transferor recognized (Basis to Corporations, 2018). The corporation's basis in the building is $180,000 plus $40,000, or $220,000.
Table 2
Basis After the Transfer
| Holder | Asset | Basis | Fair value |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hollis Grant | Tidewater stock | $0 | $280,000 |
| Amara Singh | Tidewater stock | $200,000 | $200,000 |
| Theo Marsh | Tidewater stock | $40,000 | $40,000 |
| Tidewater Cold Storage | Building | $220,000 | $500,000 |
| Tidewater Cold Storage | Cash | $200,000 | $200,000 |
Holding Periods and the Timing of the Transfers
Two further consequences follow from the basis rules. Because Hollis's shares take their basis from the building, Hollis's holding period in the shares includes the eleven years Hollis held the building, so a later sale of the shares would produce long-term gain from the first day. The corporation's holding period in the building likewise includes Hollis's. Amara's holding period starts on the day of the exchange, and so does Theo's, because Theo's shares were received as compensation.
Timing matters for control. The transfers need not be simultaneous, but they must be part of one prearranged plan carried out with reasonable speed. If Amara's cash had arrived months later under a separate agreement, Hollis alone would have held about 88 percent of the stock issued at that point, which still passes, but a founder whose transfer stands alone below 80 percent would lose the protection. The founders should sign one subscription agreement covering all three contributions.
Theo also illustrates a trap. Had Theo contributed a nominal amount of property alongside the services, hoping to be counted as a transferor, the stock issued for that property would be disregarded if its value were small relative to the stock received for services. A founder whose contribution is mainly services should not expect a token transfer to change the result.
The Deferred Gain, Now in Two Places
Of Hollis's $320,000 realized gain, $40,000 was recognized and $280,000 was deferred. The deferral did not make the gain disappear; it duplicated it. The building's value of $500,000 exceeds the corporation's $220,000 basis by $280,000, which the corporation will recognize if it sells the building. Hollis's shares, worth $280,000 with a zero basis, carry the same $280,000 of built-in gain, which Hollis will recognize on selling the shares.
This is the cost of the corporate form. If both the building and the shares were sold, the same economic gain would be taxed twice, once to the corporation and once to Hollis. The founders should consider this before deciding whether the building belongs in the corporation at all, or whether Hollis should keep it and lease it to the corporation instead.
References
Assumption of Liability, 26 U.S.C. § 357 (2018).
Basis to Corporations, 26 U.S.C. § 362 (2018).
Basis to Distributees, 26 U.S.C. § 358 (2018).
Definitions Relating to Corporate Reorganizations, 26 U.S.C. § 368 (2018).
Organizational Expenditures, 26 U.S.C. § 248 (2018).
Property Transferred in Connection With Performance of Services, 26 U.S.C. § 83 (2018).
Transfer to Corporation Controlled by Transferor, 26 U.S.C. § 351 (2018).
What the ACC 669 Topic 2 instructions ask for
The Topic 2 instructions in ACC-669 ask students to analyze a corporate formation under section 351. Weak submissions treat every founder alike. The assignment rewards analyses that table each contribution, test control under section 368(c) while excluding stock issued for services, and work each property transfer through realized gain, boot and liability rules. Students should check section 357(b) before 357(c), treat the services founder's stock as ordinary income, build stock and asset basis schedules under sections 358 and 362 and show the deferred gain duplicated.
Inside the ACC 669 Topic 2 example
The finished analysis starts from three transfers with illustrative figures. The first founder contributes a building worth $500,000 with a $180,000 adjusted basis and a $220,000 mortgage the corporation assumes, receiving stock worth $280,000. The second contributes $200,000 of cash for stock of equal value. The third receives $40,000 of stock for organizing services. Control is tested under section 368(c): the two property transferors hold $480,000 of the $520,000 of a single class of voting stock, about 92 percent, so section 351 applies to them, while the third founder has $40,000 of ordinary income. Because the mortgage exceeds the building's basis by $40,000, section 357(c) makes that excess gain. The first founder's stock basis under section 358 comes to zero, and the corporation's basis in the building under section 362 is $220,000, the carryover basis plus the gain recognized.
Reading the ACC 669 Topic 2 rubric
Faculty grading the section 351 analysis reward control tested on the right stock. Excellent analyses exclude the services founder from the control count. Credit goes to checking the avoidance rule before applying the excess-liability rule. The rubric values basis schedules that reach zero stock basis and a $220,000 building basis. The highest level shows the $280,000 of deferred gain sitting in both the building and the shares. Analyses that treat the mortgage assumption as boot in full tend to earn partial credit.
ACC 669 Topic 2 help before you submit
Where most versions of this analysis lose credit is the mortgage. Papers that treat the assumed liability as irrelevant because no cash changed hands miss section 357(c) and report no gain, and those that treat the whole $220,000 as boot overstate it by applying section 357(b) with no avoidance purpose in the facts. Counting the services founder's shares toward control reverses the rule, and in closer facts that error decides whether section 351 applies at all. A first founder given a $180,000 stock basis has ignored that liabilities assumed reduce it. The corporation's building basis left at $180,000 drops the gain recognized from the carryover. Papers that stop at the founders never show the corporate side, and an analysis that states conclusions without naming sections 351, 357, 358 and 362 leaves correct figures unsupported.
Get an ACC-669 Topic 2 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-669 Topic 2 instructions, the rubric and the formation facts in your case. A custom example is written to them, with control tested, liabilities checked under both parts of section 357, recognized gain isolated, and basis carried to each shareholder and to the corporation, returned in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.
More ACC 669 papers and MS in Accounting samples
- ACC 669 Topic 1: Separate Taxpayer Analysis Memo
- ACC 669 Topic 3: Book-tax Income Reconciliation
- ACC 669 Topic 4: Earnings and Profits Schedule
- ACC 669 Topic 5: Cash Route Comparison Dq Post
- ACC 669 Topic 6: Redemption Attribution Memo
- ACC 669 Topic 7: Two-level Liquidation Computation
- ACC 669 Topic 8: Reorganization Structure Memo
- ACC 663 Topic 2: Client Discovery Record
- ACC 661 Topic 2: Built-in Gain Method Comparison
- ACC 660 Topic 2: Exchange Gain Placement Analysis
ACC 669 Topic 2 questions, answered
Why does a mortgage in excess of basis create gain?
Because the founder is relieved of a $220,000 debt while having only $180,000 of basis in the property that carried it. Without section 357(c), stock basis would have to go negative to absorb the difference, which the rules do not allow. Taxing the $40,000 excess brings basis to zero instead, and the corporation adds that gain to its basis in the building.
Does stock received for services count toward control?
Not as stock held by a property transferor. Services are not property for section 351, so a founder who contributes only work is outside the transferor group, has ordinary income equal to the stock's value, and takes that amount as basis. The shares still count as outstanding stock when the 80 percent test is measured, which is why the example checks the percentage including them.
Could the founders have avoided the section 357(c) gain?
Possibly, on different facts. Contributing enough additional cash or property to lift the first founder's total basis above the mortgage, or reducing the debt before the transfer, would change the result, and each has costs of its own. The example mentions them as alternatives outside the fact pattern; choosing among them for a real business is work for a qualified adviser.
Where can I find a free ACC 669 Topic 2 sample paper?
Everything is above: the contributions, control, the building and its mortgage, the cash founder, stock for services, basis schedules, holding periods and timing, and the deferred gain in two places. Send your formation facts for a free worked analysis.
Why does the building founder recognize $40,000 in ACC 669 Topic 2?
The $220,000 mortgage the corporation assumes exceeds the building's $180,000 basis by $40,000, and section 357(c) makes that excess gain.