| Course | ACC 669 Corporate Taxation |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 5 |
| Paper type | Cash route comparison discussion post |
| Length | About 410 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Discussion post, APA 7 citations |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 669 Topic 5
Topic 5 DQ 1: Initial Post and Reply
Salary, Dividend or Retention: On These Facts the Routes Differ Less in Rate Than in What the Code Will Let Each Payment Be Called
Initial Post
My claim: for this owner, the salary and dividend routes end up close in after-tax cash. The real constraint is what the Code will allow each payment to be called.
Facts: the corporation has $100,000 of profit before any salary to its one owner, Tanya Reyes, who also runs it. I assume a 32 percent individual rate on wages and a 15 percent rate on qualified dividends, for this post only.
Salary. Paid as salary, the $100,000 is deductible, the corporation owes no income tax, and Tanya keeps $68,000 after income tax. But the deduction is limited to a reasonable allowance for services actually rendered (Trade or Business Expenses, 2018). If Tanya's duties would command $70,000 in the market, the other $30,000 is at risk of being recharacterized as a dividend and its deduction denied.
Dividend. Paid as a dividend, the profit is first taxed to the corporation: $21,000 at 21 percent. Current earnings and profits are the $100,000 less that tax, $79,000. Only then can the word dividend be used: the $79,000 distributed is fully covered by earnings and profits, so all of it is a dividend (Dividend Defined, 2018), and Tanya keeps $67,150. The gap is $850 in favor of salary, and employment taxes on the wages, which dividends do not bear, would more than erase it.
Retention. Keeping the profit inside the corporation defers the second layer of tax, since only the 21 percent is paid now. It cannot be done indefinitely without a reason: the accumulated earnings tax applies to earnings retained beyond the reasonable needs of the business to avoid shareholder tax (Imposition of Accumulated Earnings Tax, 2018).
Recommendation: pay Tanya a salary the duties support, documented against market data, and distribute the balance as dividends or retain it for identified business needs. An all-salary plan would invite a reasonableness challenge; an all-dividend plan would forgo a legitimate deduction.
Reply to Omar
Omar, you suggested Tanya borrow the $79,000 from the corporation instead, so nothing is taxed now. A real loan is not income, but the Code will ask whether it is one: a note, a market interest rate, a repayment schedule and actual payments. Without those, the advance is a distribution, and a dividend to the extent of earnings and profits. Would Tanya actually repay it?
References
Dividend Defined, 26 U.S.C. § 316 (2018).
Imposition of Accumulated Earnings Tax, 26 U.S.C. § 531 (2018).
Trade or Business Expenses, 26 U.S.C. § 162 (2018).
Reading the GCU ACC 669 Topic 5 instructions
ACC-669 Topic 5 asks students to compare ways of getting cash from a closely held corporation. Many posts compare rates only. Strong posts state a claim, give the facts with assumed rates labeled, compute the owner's net under each route and derive earnings and profits before calling a payment a dividend. Students should name the reasonable compensation limit on salary, explain what retention defers and the accumulated earnings tax that stops it, recommend a mix and reply to a classmate's loan idea by testing whether it is a real loan.
How the ACC-669 Topic 5 example is put together
The post's claim comes first: on these facts the routes differ less in rate than in what the Code will allow each payment to be called. A 32 percent wage rate and a 15 percent qualified dividend rate are assumed for the post. Paid as salary, the $100,000 is deductible, the corporation owes nothing and the owner keeps $68,000. Paid as a dividend, it first bears $21,000 of corporate tax. Current earnings and profits of $79,000 cover the $79,000 distributed, so all of it is a dividend and the owner keeps $67,150. Employment taxes on wages would erase the $850 gap. Retention defers the second layer until section 531 applies, and a reply takes up a classmate's shareholder loan idea by asking whether a note, interest and repayment exist. The recommendation pays a salary the owner's duties support and distributes or retains the balance.
ACC 669 Topic 5 rubric: what Excellent looks like
GCU's rubric for this discussion rewards labels the facts can carry. Excellent posts compute earnings and profits of $79,000 first and only then name the payment. Credit goes to naming the reasonable allowance limit on salary. The rubric values labeling individual rates as assumptions and citing the accumulated earnings tax on retention. The strongest replies ask whether a proposed loan has a note, interest and repayment. Posts that rank the routes by rate alone, or that treat retention as tax-free, usually land in a middle band.
ACC 669 Topic 5 help: mistakes that cost marks
Rate-only comparisons are where this discussion tends to shed credit, since a post ranking the routes by percentage never asks which label the facts can carry. Calling the $79,000 a dividend without deriving current earnings and profits reaches the right answer by assumption, and graders in many sections look for the figure itself. Posts that pick salary for its deduction and ignore the reasonableness limit leave any excess exposed to recharacterization as a constructive dividend, with the deduction lost. Stating an individual wage or dividend rate as current law, rather than as a labeled assumption, invites a correction the argument never needed. Treating retention as tax-free forgets the corporate layer already paid and the accumulated earnings tax standing behind it. Replies that accept a classmate's loan without asking about a note or interest waste the exchange.
Get an ACC-669 Topic 5 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-669 Topic 5 discussion prompt, the participation rubric and any figures the prompt supplies. A custom example is written to them, with each route priced on labeled assumptions, earnings and profits derived before any dividend label, the limiting provisions cited and a reply to a classmate, ready in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free, as coursework and never tax advice.
More ACC 669 papers and MS in Accounting samples
- ACC 669 Topic 1: Separate Taxpayer Analysis Memo
- ACC 669 Topic 2: Section 351 Transfer Analysis
- ACC 669 Topic 3: Book-tax Income Reconciliation
- ACC 669 Topic 4: Earnings and Profits Schedule
- ACC 669 Topic 6: Redemption Attribution Memo
- ACC 669 Topic 7: Two-level Liquidation Computation
- ACC 669 Topic 8: Reorganization Structure Memo
- ACC 663 Topic 5: Competing Goals Dq Post
- ACC 661 Topic 5: Excess Distribution DQ Post
- ACC 660 Topic 5: Unobservable Input DQ Post
ACC 669 Topic 5 questions, answered
Why are the individual rates labeled as assumptions?
Because an individual's rate depends on bracket, filing status and year, and a post that states one as law invites correction on a point the prompt never raised. Only the corporate figure is fixed by statute, the flat 21 percent of section 11, and the post cites it without hedging. Labeling the other two lets a reader substitute her own figures and see whether the ranking between salary and dividend survives.
When does a shareholder loan stay a loan?
When the facts show real debt: a signed instrument, interest the corporation actually charges, repayments made on schedule and a borrower able to repay. Courts weigh factors like these rather than the label the parties chose. An advance that fails them is treated as a distribution and tested against earnings and profits, and a loan charging too little interest brings section 7872 into the analysis.
Does retaining the profit avoid the second tax?
It postpones it. Whatever stays inside has already paid the 21 percent corporate tax, and the shareholder layer arrives when the earnings are distributed, paid out in a redemption, or reflected in the price of the shares when they are sold. Retention beyond the reasonable needs of the business can also draw the accumulated earnings tax, so the post accepts retention only where a stated purpose supports it.
Where can I find a free ACC 669 Topic 5 sample paper?
This page holds the full post and a reply to Omar, covering the claim, the facts, salary, the dividend, retention and a recommendation. Send us the question from your course and a sample post will be written at no cost to you.
Why is the dividend route close to salary in ACC 669 Topic 5?
After 21 percent corporate tax and a 15 percent dividend rate the owner keeps $67,150, only $850 less than salary, before employment taxes on wages.