| Course | ACC 669 Corporate Taxation |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 6 |
| Paper type | Redemption attribution memo |
| Length | About 860 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 669 Topic 6
Memorandum
To: Gene Albright, Founder, Albright Millwork, Inc.
From: [Author Name], CPA
Date: [Date]
Re: Your proposed partial redemption and a complete redemption alternative
The Facts and the Share Table
Albright Millwork, Inc. has 1,000 shares of one class. You own 600 and your child, Casey Albright, who runs the company, owns 400. The shares are worth about $1,000 each, your basis is $200 a share, and the corporation's earnings and profits are $500,000, of which $450,000 is accumulated and $50,000 current. You have proposed that the corporation redeem 300 of your shares for $300,000 so you can step back from the business. The table shows ownership before and after each proposal, with direct and constructive ownership in separate columns.
Table 1
Direct and Constructive Ownership
| Your direct shares | Shares outstanding | Direct percentage | Casey's shares attributed to you | Constructive percentage | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before any redemption | 600 | 1,000 | 60.0% | 400 | 100% |
| After redeeming 300 | 300 | 700 | 42.9% | 400 | 100% |
| After redeeming all 600 | 0 | 400 | 0% | Waived | 0% |
The Partial Redemption Fails
A redemption is treated as a sale of stock, producing capital gain, only if it meets one of the tests in section 302(b); otherwise it is a distribution taxed under the dividend rules (Distributions in Redemption of Stock, 2018). The test you would expect to meet is the substantially disproportionate redemption: after the redemption you must own less than 50 percent of the voting stock and less than 80 percent of your former percentage.
On your own shares alone, the proposal passes. You would fall from 60 percent to about 42.9 percent, under 50 percent and under 48 percent, which is four-fifths of 60.
But the tests are applied after attribution. An individual is treated as owning the stock owned by the individual's children, parents and spouse (Constructive Ownership of Stock, 2018). Casey's 400 shares are attributed to you. Counting them, you own all 1,000 shares before the redemption and all 700 after it: 100 percent both times. Your interest has not been reduced at all, and the substantially disproportionate test fails.
Not Essentially Equivalent to a Dividend
The remaining test asks whether the redemption is not essentially equivalent to a dividend. The Supreme Court has held that a redemption that leaves a shareholder's proportionate interest unchanged, after attribution, is essentially equivalent to a dividend, and that a business purpose for the redemption does not change that result (United States v. Davis, 1970). Your stepping back from the business is a genuine reason, but after attribution your interest is unchanged at 100 percent. The test fails.
The Tax on the Partial Redemption
Because no test is met, the $300,000 is a distribution. Its dividend portion is capped by the corporation's earnings and profits (Dividend Defined, 2018), and $500,000 is available, so the whole $300,000 is a dividend (Distributions of Property, 2018). Your $60,000 basis in the redeemed shares is not recovered; it shifts to your remaining 300 shares.
The Replacement: A Complete Redemption With a Waiver
A redemption of all your shares is a complete termination of your interest and is treated as a sale. Attribution from Casey would normally defeat that too, since you would still be treated as owning Casey's 400 shares. But family attribution can be waived for a complete termination if you meet the following conditions (Distributions in Redemption of Stock, 2018):
Immediately after the redemption, you hold no interest in the corporation, including as an officer, director or employee, other than as a creditor.
You do not acquire any such interest, other than by inheritance, for ten years after the redemption.
You file an agreement with your return for the year of the redemption promising to notify the IRS if you acquire an interest, and to keep the records needed to verify this (Termination of Shareholder's Interest, 2024).
The ten-year lookback is also met. You acquired none of your shares from a related person in the past ten years, and Casey bought Casey's 400 shares when the company was formed fifteen years ago, not from you.
Redeeming all 600 shares for $600,000 against your $120,000 basis produces $480,000 of long-term capital gain.
The Two Proposals Compared
The complete redemption delivers twice the cash, recovers your basis and is taxed as capital gain, at the price of leaving the company entirely for ten years.
Table 2
Partial Versus Complete Redemption
| Partial redemption, 300 shares | Complete redemption, 600 shares | |
|---|---|---|
| Cash received | $300,000 | $600,000 |
| Treatment | Dividend | Sale of stock |
| Taxable amount | $300,000 dividend | $480,000 capital gain |
| Basis recovered | None; shifts to remaining shares | $120,000 |
| Your role afterward | Unrestricted | No officer, director or employee role for ten years |
Conditions You Must Keep
If you choose the complete redemption, you must leave the board and any management role at closing. You may consult for Casey only as an independent adviser in a way that does not amount to an employee or officer role, and we recommend avoiding any formal arrangement. If the corporation pays you over time, you may hold its note as a creditor, but the note should not be subordinated or tied to the company's earnings. Any return to the company within ten years would reopen the redemption and could convert the gain to a dividend.
References
Constructive Ownership of Stock, 26 U.S.C. § 318 (2018).
Distributions in Redemption of Stock, 26 U.S.C. § 302 (2018).
Distributions of Property, 26 U.S.C. § 301 (2018).
Dividend Defined, 26 U.S.C. § 316 (2018).
Termination of Shareholder's Interest, 26 C.F.R. § 1.302-4 (2024).
United States v. Davis, 397 U.S. 301 (1970).
Reading the GCU ACC 669 Topic 6 instructions
The Topic 6 instructions in ACC-669 ask students to determine whether a stock redemption is a sale or a dividend. Weak submissions test direct ownership only. The assignment rewards memos that show ownership before and after with direct and constructive columns, test the substantially disproportionate rule with and without attribution and apply the dividend equivalence test under Davis. Students should compute the dividend within earnings and profits, build a complete termination with each waiver condition and the ten-year lookback, compare the proposals and list what the founder must keep doing for ten years after closing.
How this ACC 669 Topic 6 example is built
The memo opens with a share table before and after each proposal, direct and constructive ownership in separate columns. The corporation has 1,000 shares worth $1,000 each; the founder owns 600 with a $200 basis per share and the founder's child owns 400. Earnings and profits are $500,000. On direct ownership the proposed 300-share redemption drops the founder from 60 to about 42.9 percent, under 50 percent and under 48 percent. Section 318 then attributes the child's 400 shares, leaving 100 percent before and after, so both tests fail and the $300,000 is a dividend. Redeeming all 600 shares for $600,000 with the family attribution waiver yields $480,000 of capital gain, and the memo sets out each waiver condition, checks the ten-year lookback and lists the roles the founder must give up.
Reading the ACC 669 Topic 6 rubric
Faculty grading the redemption memo reward attribution applied before any conclusion. Excellent memos pass the partial redemption on direct shares and then fail it after attribution. Credit goes to citing Davis for the point that business purpose does not rescue it. The rubric values shifting the redeemed shares' basis rather than losing it. The highest level sets out every waiver condition and the lookback, then compares the two proposals. Memos that stop at direct ownership, or that recommend the complete redemption without the waiver conditions, usually lose marks with graders.
ACC 669 Topic 6 help: mistakes that cost marks
Most of the credit on this memo turns on attribution. Papers that test the partial redemption on direct ownership alone find a sale where section 318 makes it a dividend, and every later figure inherits the error. Applying attribution but skipping the earnings and profits figure calls the $300,000 a dividend without showing the computation that bounds it. Treating the redeemed shares' $60,000 basis as lost, instead of shifting it to the founder's remaining stock, overstates the eventual tax. A complete termination recommended without each waiver condition is exposed the first time the founder rejoins the board or the payroll. Business purpose offered to save the partial buyback runs into Davis, and memos that never set the two proposals side by side leave the recommendation undefended.
Get an ACC-669 Topic 6 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-669 Topic 6 instructions, the rubric and the shareholder table from your case. We write a custom example to them, with ownership shown before and after attribution, each section 302 test applied in turn, earnings and profits computed wherever dividend treatment results and every waiver condition listed, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More ACC 669 papers and MS in Accounting samples
- ACC 669 Topic 1: Separate Taxpayer Analysis Memo
- ACC 669 Topic 2: Section 351 Transfer Analysis
- ACC 669 Topic 3: Book-tax Income Reconciliation
- ACC 669 Topic 4: Earnings and Profits Schedule
- ACC 669 Topic 5: Cash Route Comparison Dq Post
- ACC 669 Topic 7: Two-level Liquidation Computation
- ACC 669 Topic 8: Reorganization Structure Memo
- ACC 663 Topic 6: Coverage Needs Calculation
- ACC 661 Topic 6: Regime Divergence Analysis
- ACC 660 Topic 6: Operating Segment Determination Report
ACC 669 Topic 6 questions, answered
What does section 318 attribute between family members?
Stock owned by a spouse, children, grandchildren and parents is treated as owned by the individual, so a father is treated as holding his son's shares. Siblings are not on the list, and stock attributed from one family member cannot be attributed onward to another. Entities carry their own attribution rules. The memo applies only the family rule, since that is the one these facts raise.
Why does complete termination need a waiver at all?
Because attribution follows the founder out of the corporation. Even after every one of his own shares is redeemed, section 318 would treat him as owning his son's 400, and his interest would not have terminated. Section 302(c)(2) lets him waive family attribution for this purpose, provided he keeps no interest other than as a creditor, acquires none for ten years and files the required agreement.
Is sale treatment always the better result?
For an individual it usually is, because exchange treatment recovers basis and produces capital gain, while a dividend is taxed with no basis offset. A corporate shareholder can see it the other way, since a dividend may qualify for the dividends-received deduction, although provisions such as section 1059 then cut into that benefit on redemptions. The memo concerns an individual founder and says so.
Where can I find a free ACC 669 Topic 6 sample paper?
The complete memo appears above: the facts and share table, why the partial redemption fails, dividend equivalence, the tax on it, the complete redemption with a waiver, the comparison and the conditions to keep. Describe your family corporation for a free worked memo.
Why is the partial redemption a dividend in ACC 669 Topic 6?
The child's 400 shares are attributed to the founder, who therefore owns 100 percent before and after, so the redemption changes nothing and fails every test.