ACC 669 Topic 8 reorganization structure memo example

Corporate Taxation Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This ACC 669 Topic 8 sample paper recommends how to sell a $10,000,000 company whose founder has a $1,000,000 stock basis. It belongs to GCU ACC 669, Corporate Taxation, the course listed as ACC-669 in the Grand Canyon University MS in Accounting. An asset purchase triggers $6,000,000 of corporate gain and $945,000 of tax after a $1,500,000 carryforward, then $8,055,000 of gain on liquidation. A cash stock sale taxes $9,000,000 with no step-up. A forward triangular merger for 60 percent stock and $4,000,000 of cash limits recognized gain to the boot, defers $5,000,000 and is tested for qualification, Clark and section 382.

CourseACC 669 Corporate Taxation
TopicTopic 8
Paper typeReorganization structure memo
LengthAbout 900 words, 1 pages
FormatMemo with APA 7 references
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMS in Accounting
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for ACC 669 Topic 8

1

Memorandum

To: Ray Ferreira, Founder and Sole Shareholder, Ferreira Controls, Inc.

From: [Author Name], CPA

Date: [Date]

Re: Structuring the sale of Ferreira Controls to Allmark Industrial

 

Recommendation

We recommend that Allmark Industrial acquire Ferreira Controls by merging it into an Allmark subsidiary, with you receiving $6,000,000 of Allmark voting stock and $4,000,000 of cash. You would recognize $4,000,000 of gain now and defer $5,000,000, and the corporate-level tax an asset sale would trigger would not arise. The reasons follow, alternative by alternative.

The Facts

All figures are illustrative. Ferreira Controls is worth $10,000,000. Your basis in its stock is $1,000,000. The corporation's basis in its assets is $4,000,000, and it has a $1,500,000 net operating loss carryforward. Allmark is a public company worth about $190,000,000 before the deal.

Three Structures Priced

Asset purchase. Ferreira Controls sells its assets to Allmark for $10,000,000 and recognizes $6,000,000 of gain. The loss carryforward offsets $1,500,000 of it, well within the 80 percent of taxable income that post-2017 losses may offset, leaving $4,500,000 taxed at 21 percent, $945,000. The corporation then liquidates, distributing $9,055,000, and you recognize $8,055,000 of capital gain. Allmark takes a $10,000,000 basis in the assets.

Table 1

Three Structures Compared

Asset purchaseStock purchase for cashMerger, 60 percent stock
Corporate tax$945,000$0$0
Your gain recognized now$8,055,000$9,000,000$4,000,000
Your gain deferred$0$0$5,000,000
Allmark's basis in the assets$10,000,000$4,000,000$4,000,000

Stock purchase for cash. You sell your shares to Allmark for $10,000,000 and recognize $9,000,000 of capital gain. The corporation pays no tax, but Allmark gets no step-up: the assets keep their $4,000,000 basis, and the loss carryforward becomes subject to the annual limit discussed below.

Merger for stock and cash. You receive $6,000,000 of Allmark stock and $4,000,000 of cash. Your realized gain is $9,000,000, but in a reorganization, gain is recognized only up to the cash and other boot received (Receipt of Additional Consideration, 2018), so you recognize $4,000,000. Your basis in the Allmark shares starts from your old basis, rises by the gain you recognize and falls by the cash you take: $1,000,000 (Basis to Distributees, 2018). The $5,000,000 difference between that basis and the shares' value is deferred until you sell them. The target's assets keep their $4,000,000 basis in Allmark's hands (Basis to Corporations, 2018).

Qualifying as a Reorganization

The merger must meet four requirements. It must be a statutory merger under state law (Definitions Relating to Corporate Reorganizations, 2018). It must preserve continuity of interest, meaning a substantial part of the consideration must be acquirer stock; 60 percent stock comfortably exceeds the 40 percent the regulations treat as sufficient (Purpose and Scope of Exception of Reorganization Exchanges, 2024). It must preserve continuity of business enterprise, which Allmark meets by continuing Ferreira's controls business. And it must have a business purpose, which Allmark's plan to integrate Ferreira's product line into its own supplies.

Why a Forward Triangular Merger

Allmark wants to hold Ferreira's business in a subsidiary, not merge it into the parent. Two triangular structures are available. In a reverse triangular merger, Allmark's subsidiary merges into Ferreira Controls, which survives, but that structure requires the acquirer to obtain control, at least 80 percent, in exchange for voting stock. With 40 percent of the consideration in cash, it fails. In a forward triangular merger, Ferreira Controls merges into the Allmark subsidiary, using Allmark stock, and the 80 percent voting stock requirement does not apply (Definitions Relating to Corporate Reorganizations, 2018). The forward structure accommodates the cash.

Character of the Boot

Whether your $4,000,000 of recognized gain is capital gain or a dividend is tested by treating you as if you had received only Allmark stock and Allmark had then redeemed shares equal to the cash (Commissioner v. Clark, 1989). You would have held $10,000,000 of stock in a company worth $200,000,000, 5 percent. After a hypothetical $4,000,000 redemption, you would hold $6,000,000 of $196,000,000, about 3.1 percent. That is below both 50 percent and 80 percent of your former 5 percent, so the hypothetical redemption is substantially disproportionate, and the $4,000,000 is capital gain.

Limits

Section 382. The merger is an ownership change for Ferreira Controls, so Allmark's use of the $1,500,000 carryforward is limited each year to the value of the loss corporation times the long-term tax-exempt rate (Limitation on Net Operating Loss Carryforwards and Certain Built-In Losses Following Ownership Change, 2018). At an assumed rate of 3.5 percent, the limit is about $350,000 a year, so the carryforward would be used over roughly five years rather than at once.

Step transactions. If the merger were one step in a prearranged plan, for example an agreement for Allmark to redeem your new shares for cash soon after closing, the steps could be combined and the continuity of interest test reapplied to the result. You should have no agreement or understanding to dispose of the Allmark shares back to Allmark or a related party.

What Would Change the Recommendation

Two changes would favor a different structure. If you needed all of the proceeds in cash now, the stock sale would be simpler and the deferral would lose its value to you. If Allmark placed a high value on a stepped-up basis, for example because much of Ferreira's value lay in depreciable equipment or amortizable intangibles, it might pay enough more for an asset purchase to cover the corporate tax, and that offer should be priced before closing.

References

Basis to Corporations, 26 U.S.C. § 362 (2018).

Basis to Distributees, 26 U.S.C. § 358 (2018).

Commissioner v. Clark, 489 U.S. 726 (1989).

Definitions Relating to Corporate Reorganizations, 26 U.S.C. § 368 (2018).

Limitation on Net Operating Loss Carryforwards and Certain Built-In Losses Following Ownership Change, 26 U.S.C. § 382 (2018).

Purpose and Scope of Exception of Reorganization Exchanges, 26 C.F.R. § 1.368-1 (2024).

Receipt of Additional Consideration, 26 U.S.C. § 356 (2018).

The ACC-669 Topic 8 assignment instructions

The Topic 8 instructions in ACC-669 ask students to recommend a structure for selling a corporation. Weak submissions call a merger tax-free without testing it. The assignment rewards memos that state facts once, price an asset purchase, a stock purchase and a merger with corporate tax, the seller's gain and the buyer's basis, and test the merger's qualification. Students should explain the choice of triangular form, characterize the boot under Clark, address section 382 and step transactions and say what change in the facts would flip the recommendation.

How the ACC-669 Topic 8 example is put together

The memo fixes its facts once: a target worth $10,000,000, a $1,000,000 stock basis, $4,000,000 of inside asset basis and a $1,500,000 loss carryforward. A taxable asset purchase triggers $6,000,000 of corporate gain, and after the full carryforward, $945,000 of tax at 21 percent, before the founder is taxed on $8,055,000 in liquidation. A stock purchase for cash taxes $9,000,000 and gives the buyer no step-up. In the recommended forward triangular merger the founder receives $6,000,000 of acquirer voting stock and $4,000,000 of cash. Section 356 caps recognized gain at the $4,000,000 of boot, section 358 leaves $1,000,000 of basis in the new shares, and $5,000,000 of gain waits there. The memo then tests continuity of interest, business enterprise and purpose, explains the forward triangular form, characterizes the boot under Clark and limits the carryforward under section 382.

Where the marks sit in the ACC 669 Topic 8 rubric

Faculty grading the reorganization memo reward qualification tested, not assumed. Excellent memos state the 60 percent stock proportion behind continuity of interest. Credit goes to rejecting the reverse triangular form because the cash would break its control requirement. The rubric values the hypothetical redemption Clark uses to characterize the boot. The highest level limits the carryforward under section 382 and names what would flip the recommendation. Memos that price only the recommended structure, or ignore section 382, usually land in a middle band.

Common ACC 669 Topic 8 mistakes, and how to avoid them

A merger recommended because it is tax-free, with no test of whether it qualifies, is the weakest paper this topic produces. Continuity of interest asserted without the stock proportion leaves the central requirement unexamined, and a reverse triangular form chosen alongside 40 percent cash fails a condition the writer could have checked. Papers that call the $4,000,000 of boot a dividend, or capital gain, without the hypothetical redemption Clark applies reach a character by assumption, and skip the earnings and profits limit a dividend result would bring in. Carrying the $1,500,000 loss forward with no section 382 limit overstates what the buyer acquires. Taxable alternatives dismissed without figures give the reader no reason to reject them. Memos silent on what would overturn the recommendation present a conditional answer as a settled one.

Get an ACC-669 Topic 8 example written to your instructions

Send the ACC-669 Topic 8 instructions, the rubric and the transaction facts in your case. We write a custom example to them, with each structure priced on the same figures, qualification tested requirement by requirement, boot characterized, the limiting provisions answered directly and the rejected routes addressed, returned in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free, and it is coursework rather than tax advice.

More ACC 669 papers and MS in Accounting samples

ACC 669 Topic 8 questions, answered

What is continuity of interest?

A requirement, developed by the courts and now set out in the section 368 regulations, that the target's shareholders keep a substantial proprietary stake in the combined business through acquirer stock. If most of the consideration is cash, the transaction looks like a sale and does not qualify. The regulations' examples indicate a stock proportion that suffices, and the memo stays well above it rather than near the line.

Why use a subsidiary instead of merging the target into the acquirer?

A forward triangular merger under section 368(a)(2)(D) keeps the target's business and liabilities in a separate corporation, which acquirers usually prefer, while the founder still receives acquirer stock. Because the acquirer owns all of that subsidiary, the two form an affiliated group and can file a consolidated return under section 1501, although the consolidated return regulations have their own rules for losses a new member brings in.

What does the step transaction doctrine threaten here?

It lets the IRS and the courts treat formally separate steps as one transaction when they are parts of a single plan. If the acquirer had agreed to redeem the founder's new shares soon after closing, the stock he received would count as cash for continuity purposes and the merger could fail to qualify. The memo states that no such arrangement exists and names that fact as one its conclusion depends on.

Where can I find a free ACC 669 Topic 8 sample paper?

All of the memo is on this page: the recommendation, the facts, three structures priced, qualification, why a forward triangular merger, the character of the boot, limits and what would change the recommendation. Tell us about your deal for a free worked memo.

How much gain is recognized in the merger in ACC 669 Topic 8?

Only the $4,000,000 of cash boot, since section 356 limits recognition to boot, leaving $5,000,000 deferred in the Allmark shares.