| Course | ACC 670 Advanced Financial Statement Analysis |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 6 |
| Paper type | Distress model miss analysis |
| Length | About 970 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 670 Topic 6
Why the Z-Score Never Crossed 1.81: A Retailer's Asset Turnover Held Up the Score While Its Liquidity Drained Away
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
ACC-670: Advanced Financial Statement Analysis
Topic 6 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Why the Z-Score Never Crossed 1.81: A Retailer's Asset Turnover Held Up the Score While Its Liquidity Drained Away
The Model
The original Z-score combines five ratios with fixed weights: 1.2 times working capital to total assets, 1.4 times retained earnings to total assets, 3.3 times earnings before interest and taxes to total assets, 0.6 times the market value of equity to total liabilities, and 1.0 times sales to total assets. Scores above 2.99 fall in the safe zone, scores below 1.81 in the distress zone, and scores between in a gray zone. The weights were estimated on a sample of publicly traded manufacturers (Altman, 1968).
Brookline Home Stores, a composite home furnishings retailer, filed for bankruptcy protection early in its fourth year of this analysis. Its Z-score in the three years before the filing never entered the distress zone. This analysis explains why and what the statements showed that the score did not.
Three Years of Scores
Each ratio is shown with its weighted contribution, so the reader can see which term held the score up.
Table 1
Z-Score Components, Three Years Before the Filing
| Ratio | Weight | Year 1 | Contribution | Year 2 | Contribution | Year 3 | Contribution |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Working capital / total assets | 1.2 | 0.10 | 0.12 | 0.08 | 0.10 | 0.05 | 0.06 |
| Retained earnings / total assets | 1.4 | 0.05 | 0.07 | -0.02 | -0.03 | -0.10 | -0.14 |
| EBIT / total assets | 3.3 | 0.06 | 0.20 | 0.03 | 0.10 | 0.01 | 0.03 |
| Market value of equity / total liabilities | 0.6 | 0.35 | 0.21 | 0.30 | 0.18 | 0.25 | 0.15 |
| Sales / total assets | 1.0 | 2.00 | 2.00 | 1.95 | 1.95 | 1.90 | 1.90 |
| Z-score | 2.6 | 2.3 | 2.0 |
The Asset Turnover Effect
In year three, the sales-to-total-assets term contributed 1.9 of the final 2.0. The other four terms together contributed about 0.1: retained earnings had turned negative after two years of losses, operating profit was close to zero, and working capital and market value had both shrunk. Without the turnover term, the company looked like what it was.
Retailers turn their assets over much faster than manufacturers, because inventory is bought and sold within months and stores are often leased rather than owned. A turnover of 1.9 is ordinary for a retailer and would be high for a manufacturer. The original model, estimated on manufacturers, gives that term a weight that lifts every retailer's score, healthy or failing.
The Non-Manufacturer Check
Altman later proposed a variant for non-manufacturers that drops the sales-to-assets term and reweights the others, using book equity to total liabilities in place of market value; scores below 1.1 fall in the distress zone (Altman et al., 2019). It is used here as a check, not a replacement.
On that variant, Brookline scored 1.64 in year one, in the gray zone, and 0.92 in year two and 0.17 in year three, both in the distress zone. Removing the term that retail business models inflate moved the warning two years earlier.
Liquidity Read Directly
The statements showed the decline in liquidity plainly. Comparable-store sales fell in each of the three years, by 3, 6 and 9 percent. Days of payables fell from 52 to 31, which means suppliers were demanding faster payment, often a sign they had lost confidence in the retailer's credit. The revolving credit line, with a $600 million limit, went from about a third drawn at the end of year one to almost fully drawn by the third quarter of year three. Cash on hand at quarter ends fell from $140 million to $35 million over the same period.
None of these appear in the Z-score. Vendor terms and credit line usage are the variables that decide whether a retailer can buy inventory for the next season, and a retailer that cannot buy inventory fails quickly regardless of its asset turnover (Penman, 2013).
What the Statements Showed That No Ratio Captured
The liquidity note disclosed that the credit line's borrowing base depended on the value of inventory, and that the lender had reduced advance rates in year three. The subsequent events note in the year-three annual report described negotiations with the lender to amend a covenant. Neither is a ratio, and both were in the filing months before the bankruptcy.
Using a Model Outside Its Sample
The miss is not a flaw in the model's arithmetic. It is a consequence of applying weights estimated on one kind of company to another. Every weight in a discriminant model reflects the average relationships in its estimation sample, and a firm whose ratios sit far from that sample's typical values can be scored in ways the model was never tested on. Asset turnover is the clearest case for retailers, but it is not the only one: service companies with few tangible assets and asset-heavy utilities also sit outside the original sample.
Three practices follow for anyone using a score of this kind. First, check which term drives the score and whether that term reflects the business model rather than its health. Second, use a variant estimated on comparable firms where one exists, and report both results. Third, never let a gray-zone score stand in for a liquidity review. A score summarizes the balance sheet and income statement on one date; a retailer's survival depends on the next few months of cash, credit and supplier terms, which the score does not measure.
The Score Report as It Should Have Been Written
Brookline Home Stores, year three: Z-score 2.0, gray zone. Caution: the original model was estimated on manufacturers, and 1.9 of this score comes from the sales-to-assets term, which is high for all retailers. On the non-manufacturer variant, the score is 0.17, in the distress zone, and has been in that zone for two years. Liquidity evidence is consistent with distress: comparable sales down three years, supplier payment terms shortened from 52 to 31 days, the revolving credit line nearly fully drawn and advance rates reduced. The score alone should not be relied on for this company.
References
Altman, E. I. (1968). Financial ratios, discriminant analysis and the prediction of corporate bankruptcy. The Journal of Finance, 23(4), 589-609. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6261.1968.tb00843.x
Altman, E. I., Hotchkiss, E., & Wang, W. (2019). Corporate financial distress, restructuring, and bankruptcy (4th ed.). Wiley.
Penman, S. H. (2013). Financial statement analysis and security valuation (5th ed.). McGraw-Hill.
ACC 670 Topic 6 instructions, in plain terms
The Topic 6 instructions in ACC-670 ask students to evaluate a bankruptcy prediction model against an actual failure. Weak submissions report the score. The assignment rewards analyses that state the model, its zones and its estimation sample, show each ratio's weighted contribution across several years and identify the term that holds the score up. Students should rerun the result with a variant suited to the company, read liquidity directly from vendor terms, credit lines and cash, note what no ratio captured and rewrite the score report as it should have read.
How this ACC 670 Topic 6 example is built
Scores come first in the finished analysis, computed from the retailer's illustrative statements for the three years before the filing: 2.6, 2.3 and 2.0, gray zone each time and never below the 1.81 line the original model uses for distress. The decomposition explains why. The sales-to-total-assets term supplied 1.9 of the final 2.0, because retailers turn assets quickly, while retained earnings had gone negative and operating profit sat near zero. The model was built on manufacturers, and a variant Altman later proposed for non-manufacturers drops that term. The analysis then reads what preceded the failure: comparable sales down three years running, payables days cut from 52 to 31 as vendors tightened terms, and the revolving credit line drawn from a third of its limit to almost all of it. It closes on what an honest score report would have said.
ACC 670 Topic 6 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Faculty grading the model miss analysis reward the score decomposed by term. Excellent analyses show asset turnover supplying almost all of a failing retailer's score. Credit goes to using the non-manufacturer variant as a check rather than a replacement. The rubric values liquidity evidence such as vendor terms and credit line usage. The highest level explains what applying a model outside its sample means and drafts an honest score report. Analyses that blame the model without breaking the score into its terms usually land in a middle band.
Common ACC 670 Topic 6 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Presenting a Z-score as a prediction is the deduction this topic sees most often, because a score measures resemblance to past failures and nothing more. A paper reporting three gray-zone scores and concluding the retailer was moderately safe has read the number and ignored the model's origin. Leaving out the ratio contributions hides that one term carried the score, which is the finding the exercise is built around. Some papers swap in a different model and declare the problem solved, when the better answer shows what both models see and miss. Liquidity is where the warning actually appeared, and analyses that never read vendor terms or credit line usage leave the most useful evidence untouched. Conclusions written with hindsight, as though the failure was obvious, also lose credit; the point is what a careful reader could have said then.
Get an ACC-670 Topic 6 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-670 Topic 6 instructions, the rubric in your classroom and the company or distress case your section assigned. The custom example is written to those criteria, with the model stated, scores decomposed by ratio, its blind spots explained, liquidity read directly and the score reported with its limits, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More ACC 670 papers and MS in Accounting samples
- ACC 670 Topic 1: Accrual Persistence Analysis
- ACC 670 Topic 2: Reserve Estimate Trend Review
- ACC 670 Topic 3: Revenue Recognition Signal Analysis
- ACC 670 Topic 4: Adjusted Net Debt Restatement
- ACC 670 Topic 5: Quiet Disclosure Change Dq Post
- ACC 670 Topic 7: Segment Disaggregation Analysis
- ACC 670 Topic 8: Earnings Quality Judgment Memo
- ACC 669 Topic 6: Redemption Attribution Memo
- ACC 663 Topic 6: Coverage Needs Calculation
- ACC 661 Topic 6: Regime Divergence Analysis
- ACC 653 Topic 6: Value Chain Linkage Analysis
ACC 670 Topic 6 questions, answered
What does the Altman Z-score measure?
A weighted combination of five ratios covering working capital, retained earnings, operating profit, market value of equity against liabilities, and sales against total assets. Altman estimated the weights by comparing manufacturers that failed with ones that did not, and the resulting score places a company in a distress, gray or safe zone. It measures resemblance to those historical failures, which is useful and different from a probability of failing.
Why did the model miss this retailer?
Mainly because of the sales-to-assets term. Apparel retailers turn their assets over much faster than the manufacturers the weights were estimated on, so that ratio lifts the score regardless of profitability. Here it supplied almost the whole final score while the other four terms sat near zero. The model also reads annual figures, so tightening vendor terms or a nearly exhausted credit line register only once they reach a year-end balance sheet.
Are newer distress models better?
Some suit particular settings better, including variants for non-manufacturers and models that combine market data with accounting data. None removes the basic limitation that a model learns from past failures and can miss one with a new cause. The strongest papers run a recognized model, show its contributions and its blind spots, and put the liquidity evidence beside it rather than trading one score for another.
Where can I find a free ACC 670 Topic 6 sample paper?
The complete analysis appears above: the model, three years of scores, the asset turnover effect, the non-manufacturer check, liquidity read directly, using a model outside its sample, what no ratio captured and the score report as it should have been written. Share your company's statements for a free worked analysis.
Why did the Z-score miss the failure in ACC 670 Topic 6?
The sales-to-assets term, high for any retailer, supplied 1.9 of the 2.0 score, masking negative retained earnings and near-zero profit.