| Course | ACC 680 Auditing and Data Analytics Core |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 2 |
| Paper type | Benford screen risk memo |
| Length | About 830 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 680 Topic 2
Memorandum
To: Engagement Partner, Audit of Crestview Property Services
From: [Author Name], audit senior
Date: [Date]
Re: Results of the digit analysis of vendor payments and the planned response
Why Benford's Law Applies to This File
Benford's law describes the frequency of leading digits in many naturally occurring sets of numbers: a first digit of 1 appears about 30 percent of the time, and 9 under 5 percent. It applies when amounts arise from ordinary economic activity, span several orders of magnitude and are not assigned or constrained by a fixed price list (Nigrini, 2012). The vendor payment file meets those conditions. The 38,000 payments for the year are for services, supplies and repairs from about 1,900 vendors, with no assigned numbers or standard prices, and they span five orders of magnitude.
Table 1
Payments by Order of Magnitude
| Payment size | Count |
|---|---|
| $10 to $99 | 3,900 |
| $100 to $999 | 14,800 |
| $1,000 to $9,999 | 15,600 |
| $10,000 to $99,999 | 3,300 |
| $100,000 and above | 400 |
| Total | 38,000 |
Tests Run and Thresholds Set in Advance
Two tests were run: first-digit and first-two-digit frequencies. Conformity was measured by the mean absolute deviation between observed and expected proportions, using published thresholds fixed before the results were seen: for the first-digit test, below 0.006 indicates close conformity; for the first-two-digit test, above 0.0022 indicates nonconformity (Nigrini, 2012).
Results
First-digit frequencies conform closely, with a mean absolute deviation of 0.004. The first-two-digit test does not, with a deviation of 0.0024, and almost all of the departure comes from two prefixes.
Table 2
Observed and Expected Counts Around the Spike
| First two digits | Observed | Expected | Observed share | Expected share |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 47 | 352 | 347 | 0.93% | 0.91% |
| 48 | 612 | 340 | 1.61% | 0.90% |
| 49 | 718 | 333 | 1.89% | 0.88% |
| 50 | 301 | 327 | 0.79% | 0.86% |
Reading the Results
Payments beginning 48 and 49 make up 3.5 percent of the file, against about 1.8 percent expected: 1,330 payments where about 674 would be normal. Payments beginning 50 fall slightly below expectation. Of the 1,330, 1,010 fall between $4,800 and $4,999, just beneath the $5,000 level at which company policy requires a second approval. Of those 1,010, 740 are coded to facilities maintenance.
What the Pattern Does and Does Not Show
Nonconformity shows that the data depart from an expected pattern. It does not show that anything is wrong, and it cannot distinguish fraud from a legitimate habit. Vendors who know the approval threshold may price routine jobs just below it to speed payment, and a maintenance contract with a standard call-out fee near $4,900 would produce the same spike honestly. The screen identifies where to look, not what will be found.
Why the Screen Was Worth Running
Digit analysis is inexpensive once the payment file has been extracted and reconciled, and it looks at every payment, not a sample. Its value lies in directing attention. Without it, facilities maintenance would have been tested with a small selection of the account's payments, drawn across the full range of amounts, and a concentration of payments just under $5,000 could easily have gone unnoticed. The screen does not replace substantive testing; it changes which items are tested and why. The payment file used for the screen was reconciled to disbursements in the general ledger, in count and total, before the tests were run, so the pattern cannot be an artifact of an incomplete extract. The screen also covered vendors in every department, and the concentration appears in only one of them, which strengthens the case that it reflects a specific practice rather than a quirk of the company's pricing across the board.
The Risk
The pattern points to one account and one assertion: occurrence of facilities maintenance expense. The specific risk is that invoices were split to stay below the approval level, or that fabricated invoices were kept below it to avoid a second reviewer. Either would be a fraud risk that auditing standards require the auditor to respond to (American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, 2002). The risk is rated significant for that account and assertion, and the assessment is documented alongside the other risks identified in planning (American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, 2021).
Planned Response
First, every payment between $4,800 and $4,999 coded to facilities maintenance, all 740, will be examined against the work order system: a work order approved before the work, a completion sign-off by the property manager and a location that matches one of the company's buildings. Payments with no work order will be followed up with the vendor.
Second, a split-invoice test will search the full file for payments to the same vendor on the same day, or within three days, whose combined amount exceeds $5,000. Each group found will be examined to see whether it represents one job divided into parts.
Third, the vendors receiving the most payments in the band will be compared with the approved vendor master for address, bank account and tax identification number matches to employee records.
The first procedure produces direct evidence on occurrence for the flagged payments; the second tests whether the approval control was circumvented; the third tests for fictitious vendors. Results will be reported to you before the risk is closed.
References
American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. (2002). Consideration of fraud in a financial statement audit (Statement on Auditing Standards No. 99). AICPA.
American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. (2021). Understanding the entity and its environment and assessing the risks of material misstatement (Statement on Auditing Standards No. 145). AICPA.
Nigrini, M. J. (2012). Benford's law: Applications for forensic accounting, auditing, and fraud detection. Wiley.
What the ACC 680 Topic 2 instructions ask for
The Topic 2 instructions in ACC-680 ask students to apply Benford's law in an audit. Weak submissions treat nonconformity as evidence of fraud. The assignment rewards memos that show why the population suits the test, fix conformity thresholds before seeing results and present observed and expected frequencies. Students should explain what nonconformity can and cannot show, link the pattern to a specific account, assertion and control threshold, rate the risk and plan procedures that would produce direct evidence.
How the ACC-680 Topic 2 example is put together
The finished memo first shows why Benford's law could apply here: vendor payment amounts arise naturally and span several orders of magnitude, with no assigned numbers or fixed prices in the file. The illustrative results follow. First-digit frequencies sit close to expectation. The first-two-digit test does not: payments beginning 48 and 49 make up 3.5 percent of the file against about 1.8 percent expected: 1,330 payments where 674 would be normal. Of those, 1,010 fall between $4,800 and $4,999, just beneath the $5,000 level that requires a second approval, mostly coded to facilities maintenance. The memo treats this as a pointer. It names the risk, occurrence of maintenance expense through split or fabricated invoices, and plans the response: every payment in that band examined against work orders, plus a test for same-vendor payments on one day summing past $5,000.
ACC 680 Topic 2 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Faculty grading the Benford memo reward conditions shown before results. Excellent memos report orders of magnitude and the absence of assigned prices. Credit goes to thresholds fixed in advance and to naming the approval level behind the spike. The rubric values stating that the pattern points to a risk rather than proving one. The highest level plans a full examination of the band, a split-invoice test and a vendor check. Memos that conclude fraud from digit frequencies, or that set the conformity threshold after seeing the results, tend to earn partial credit.
ACC 680 Topic 2 help: mistakes that cost marks
The usual deduction on Benford work falls on a nonconforming result reported as a misstatement, because the screen shows only that the data departs from an expected pattern. Running the test without first showing the population suits it costs credit before any result is read; invoice numbers, capped reimbursements and small files do not follow the law. A first-digit test alone would have missed this case, and memos that stop there hide the concentration the two-digit test reveals. Leaving the conformity threshold unstated until after the results allows any outcome to be called significant. Papers that find the approval limit and then assess risk across the whole expense cycle spread effort over accounts the pattern never touched. A memo naming a risk with no planned response loses the rest, since the screen is worth only the testing it directs.
Get an ACC-680 Topic 2 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-680 Topic 2 instructions, the rubric and the data or client case your section provided. We write a custom example to them, with the population's suitability shown, tests and thresholds fixed in advance, results tabled against expectation, the screen's limits stated and the pattern pinned to one assertion with a response, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one costs nothing.
More ACC 680 papers and MS in Accounting samples
- ACC 680 Topic 1: Analytic Assertion Coverage Map
- ACC 680 Topic 3: Journal Entry Testing Workpaper
- ACC 680 Topic 4: Exception Triage Log
- ACC 680 Topic 5: Full Population Testing Dq Post
- ACC 680 Topic 6: Analytic Evidence Working Paper
- ACC 680 Topic 7: Substantive Analytic Simulation
- ACC 680 Topic 8: Review Note Response Memo
- ACC 670 Topic 2: Reserve Estimate Trend Review
- ACC 669 Topic 2: Section 351 Transfer Analysis
- ACC 663 Topic 2: Client Discovery Record
- ACC 653 Topic 2: Target Cost Gap Analysis
ACC 680 Topic 2 questions, answered
What is Benford's law?
An observation that in many naturally occurring sets of numbers the leading digit is 1 about 30 percent of the time, 2 about 18 percent, and so on down to 9 at under 5 percent. Financial data often follows it when amounts arise from many transactions and span several orders of magnitude. Mark Nigrini's work brought it into auditing as a way to find parts of a file that depart from the expected pattern.
When does Benford's law not apply?
When numbers are assigned rather than generated, such as invoice or check numbers; when amounts are set by policy or price lists; when a minimum or maximum constrains them, as with reimbursement caps; and when the file is too small for frequencies to settle. A population dominated by a few fixed amounts, such as monthly rent, will also depart from the pattern for reasons unrelated to error or fraud.
Why test the first two digits as well?
Because the first-digit test groups every amount beginning with 4 together, from $4 to $49,999, and a concentration in one narrow range can disappear inside that group. The first-two-digit test separates 48 from 41 and 42, which is where an approval-limit pattern shows up. Here the first-digit results looked ordinary while the two-digit test found the bunching the memo is built on.
Where can I find a free ACC 680 Topic 2 sample paper?
Everything is above: why the law applies, the tests and thresholds, the results, reading them, what the pattern shows, why the screen was worth running, the risk and the planned response. Send your payment file's profile and approval thresholds for a free worked memo.
What does the spike point to in ACC 680 Topic 2?
Payments just under the $5,000 second-approval level, mostly facilities maintenance, suggesting split or fabricated invoices kept below the threshold.