| Course | ACC 680 Auditing and Data Analytics Core |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 8 |
| Paper type | Review note response memo |
| Length | About 810 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 680 Topic 8
Memorandum
To: Engagement Partner, Audit of Westbrook Outdoor Supply
From: [Author Name], audit senior
Date: [Date]
Re: Responses to your review notes on working paper I-6
Summary
Note 1, reliability of the selling price file: defended. Note 2, the cost-layer test that found no exceptions: defended. Note 3, latest prices applied to a discontinued line: conceded; the analytic was rerun, and the proposed write-down rises from $760,000 to $840,000. The proposed adjustment against the client's recorded reserve of $610,000 is now $230,000.
The Analytic in Brief
Working paper I-6 compares cost with net realizable value for all 48,000 inventory items at year end. Inventory measured at cost under first-in, first-out must be written down to net realizable value whenever the price the goods will fetch, after the costs of finishing and selling them, is lower than their cost (Financial Accounting Standards Board, 2015). The analytic used each item's latest selling price less a 6 percent cost to sell, flagged 1,900 items with net realizable value below cost, and proposed a write-down of $760,000 against the client's recorded reserve of $610,000.
Note 1: Is the Price File Reliable?
Note restated: the analytic depends on the selling price file, and the working paper does not show that the prices are accurate.
Evidence on file: the price file was extracted from the point-of-sale system's price master on January 6 and reconciled in item count to the inventory listing. To test accuracy, 40 items were selected across price ranges and product lines, and each price was agreed to a customer invoice dated in January, after year end. All 40 agreed within one cent. Post-year-end invoices are the right source because net realizable value is measured at the balance sheet date using the best evidence of the price at which the goods will actually be sold, and prices charged shortly after year end provide that evidence (Arens et al., 2020).
Judgment: the price file is reliable for the purpose. No change. A cross-reference to the price testing, now at I-6.1, has been added to the working paper.
Note 2: What Would an Exception Have Looked Like?
Note restated: the cost-layer test found no exceptions; how do we know the test could have found one?
This is the right question behind any clean result. The cost-layer test compares each item's recorded cost with the cost of its most recent purchase layers, to detect items carried at an outdated cost. An exception is defined as a recorded unit cost that differs by more than 2 percent from the weighted cost of the layers still on hand.
Evidence on file: before the test was run on the year-end data, it was run on a trial file containing one item whose cost had been deliberately altered by 5 percent. The test flagged that item and no others. The trial run and its output are now attached at I-6.2. A test that demonstrably catches a planted error, and then finds none in the real data, supports the conclusion that no exceptions exist rather than that the test could not see them (American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, 2017).
Judgment: the test had the power to fail. No change.
Note 3: Why Latest Prices for a Discontinued Line?
Note restated: the client plans to discontinue its camping furniture line; latest selling prices will not be achieved on that inventory.
Evidence on file: the working paper applied the latest selling price to all items, including 620 items in the camping furniture line. Management's board minutes from November record the decision to discontinue the line and to clear remaining stock through outlet channels. Clearance sales in January, found in the invoice file, averaged 58 percent of the previous list price.
Judgment: conceded. The assumption that latest prices apply was reasonable for continuing lines and not for a line being cleared. The analytic was rerun with the 620 camping furniture items priced at 58 percent of their latest selling price, less the same 6 percent cost to sell. The number of flagged items rose to 2,140, and the proposed write-down rose by $80,000 to $840,000. The rerun, with its parameters and date, is documented at I-6.3, and the original run is retained.
Proposed Adjustment
The proposed write-down of $840,000 against the recorded reserve of $610,000 gives a proposed adjustment of $230,000, increasing the reserve and cost of sales. This is below performance materiality of $400,000 and above the clearly trivial threshold of $20,000, so it is carried to the summary of misstatements for discussion with management. The evidence supporting the analytic, including the price testing and the trial run, meets the standard for sufficient appropriate evidence for the valuation assertion (American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, 2020).
Working papers revised: I-6 updated for the rerun and cross-references; I-6.1 added, price testing; I-6.2 added, cost-layer trial run; I-6.3 added, rerun for the discontinued line.
References
American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. (2017). Guide to audit data analytics. AICPA.
American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. (2020). Audit evidence (Statement on Auditing Standards No. 142). AICPA.
Arens, A. A., Elder, R. J., Beasley, M. S., & Hogan, C. E. (2020). Auditing and assurance services: An integrated approach (17th ed.). Pearson.
Financial Accounting Standards Board. (2015). Inventory (Topic 330): Simplifying the measurement of inventory (Accounting Standards Update No. 2015-11). FASB.
What the ACC 680 Topic 8 instructions ask for
The Topic 8 instructions in ACC-680 ask students to respond to review notes on analytic work. Weak submissions defend every point. The assignment rewards memos that summarize each outcome first and answer each note in the same parts: the note restated, the evidence on file, the judgment and any change made. Students should show that a clean test could have failed, concede a flawed assumption and document the rerun, restate the proposed adjustment against materiality and list the working papers revised.
Inside the ACC 680 Topic 8 example
The finished memo restates each review note in one sentence and answers it, every figure illustrative. The analytic compared cost with net realizable value for all 48,000 inventory items, using the latest selling price less costs to sell, flagged 1,900 items and proposed a write-down of $760,000 against the client's recorded reserve of $610,000. The first note asks whether the price file was reliable; the memo cites 40 prices agreed to post-year-end invoices, all within a cent. The second asks what an exception would have looked like in the cost-layer test that found none; the memo shows the definition and a known item the test flagged in a trial run. The third asks why latest prices were applied to a line the client plans to discontinue. The memo concedes, reruns with clearance prices, and the write-down rises to $840,000.
ACC 680 Topic 8 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Faculty grading the response memo reward evidence over assertion. Excellent memos answer a clean result with a trial run that shows the test could fail. Credit goes to explaining why post-year-end invoices are the right price evidence. The rubric values conceding the discontinued line and documenting the rerun. The highest level restates the adjustment at $230,000 against materiality and lists every revised paper. Memos that defend all three notes regardless of the evidence, or concede without rerunning the analytic, tend to earn partial credit.
Common ACC 680 Topic 8 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Response memos lose the most when every note is treated as an attack to be repelled, because a reviewer's challenge that is right and goes unconceded leaves the conclusion wrong. A memo that answers the price-file note by asserting the data was fine, without citing the testing, replaces evidence with confidence. A clean result is the note most often answered badly: saying the test found no exceptions repeats the question instead of showing that the test could have found one. Conceding the discontinuation point and leaving the $760,000 write-down unchanged makes the concession decorative. Papers that revise the analytic and never carry the new figure to the proposed adjustment and materiality stop one step short of a conclusion. Tone costs credit in either direction: defensiveness reads as weak judgment, and conceding points the evidence already answers reads as having none.
Get an ACC-680 Topic 8 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-680 Topic 8 instructions, your classroom rubric and the review notes or engagement case your section assigned. We write a custom example to them, with each note restated and answered from evidence on file, points conceded where the reviewer is right, the analytic rerun where needed and the adjustment carried to materiality, returned in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More ACC 680 papers and MS in Accounting samples
- ACC 680 Topic 1: Analytic Assertion Coverage Map
- ACC 680 Topic 2: Benford Screen Risk Memo
- ACC 680 Topic 3: Journal Entry Testing Workpaper
- ACC 680 Topic 4: Exception Triage Log
- ACC 680 Topic 5: Full Population Testing Dq Post
- ACC 680 Topic 6: Analytic Evidence Working Paper
- ACC 680 Topic 7: Substantive Analytic Simulation
- ACC 670 Topic 8: Earnings Quality Judgment Memo
- ACC 669 Topic 8: Reorganization Structure Memo
- ACC 663 Topic 8: Contested Recommendation Letter
- ACC 653 Topic 8: Costing System Fitness Review
ACC 680 Topic 8 questions, answered
Should a response memo ever concede a point?
Yes, whenever the reviewer is right. The purpose of review is a better-supported conclusion, not a won argument, and a concession backed by a rerun and a revised figure strengthens the file. Each concession should change something: the analytic, the adjustment or the working papers. A concession with no consequence suggests the preparer agreed without understanding what the note required.
What is a reviewer asking about a test with no exceptions?
Whether the test could have found an exception at all. A procedure that is defined too loosely, or run on the wrong field, will always return nothing, and a clean result from it is not evidence. Showing the exception definition and a trial run in which the test flagged a known item demonstrates that its silence on the real population means something.
Why did discontinuation change the write-down?
Because net realizable value is the price the inventory is expected to fetch, less costs to sell, and a product line being discontinued will usually be cleared at lower prices than its recent sales achieved. Using the latest selling price assumes normal demand continues. Replacing it with expected clearance prices for that line raised the write-down by $80,000, which the memo carries through to the proposed adjustment.
Where can I find a free ACC 680 Topic 8 sample paper?
The memo is here in its entirety: the summary, the analytic in brief, the three notes with their responses and the proposed adjustment. Share your review notes for a free worked memo.
Why does the write-down rise in ACC 680 Topic 8?
The discontinued camping line was repriced at clearance levels of 58 percent of list, adding $80,000 to the write-down, now $840,000.