| Course | ACC 681 Tax Core |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 5 |
| Paper type | Deciding fact discussion post |
| Length | About 430 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Discussion post, APA 7 citations |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 681 Topic 5
Topic 5 DQ 1: Initial Post and Reply
Find the Regime, Then the One Fact That Moves the Answer: A $200,000 Gain on Land Contributed From a Homebuilder's Inventory
Initial Post
My method for a timed fact pattern: identify the tax regime that owns the item first, because no rule can be applied until you know whose rules they are, and then look for the one fact that changes the answer. Most facts in these patterns are there to be ignored.
Here is a pattern. Two members own an LLC that made no classification election, so it is a partnership. The character of partnership gain is determined at the partnership level (Income and Credits of Partner, 2018), which means neither member's personal situation decides it. The LLC sells a parcel for $500,000. One member, a homebuilder, contributed it 26 months ago from lot inventory, when it was worth $380,000 and had a $300,000 basis. The other member is an investor.
The pattern gives five facts: the 26-month holding period, the members' tax brackets, the identity of the buyer, the state where the LLC was formed, and the fact that the parcel was contributed from the homebuilder's inventory. Four of them do not move the answer. The brackets affect how much tax each member pays, not the character. The buyer is unrelated. The state of formation has no federal effect. And the holding period, as it turns out, does not matter either.
The fifth fact decides it. Gain on property that was an inventory item in the contributing partner's hands is ordinary income if the partnership disposes of it within five years of the contribution (Character of Gain or Loss on Contributed Unrealized Receivables, Inventory Items, and Capital Loss Property, 2018). The parcel was lot inventory to the homebuilder and was sold after 26 months, so the whole $200,000 gain is ordinary. Allocation then follows the built-in gain rule: the $80,000 that accrued before contribution goes to the homebuilder (Partner's Distributive Share, 2018), and the remaining $120,000 is split equally, $60,000 each. The homebuilder reports $140,000 of ordinary income and the investor $60,000.
The course reading on partnership contributions works a similar pattern with receivables.
Reply to Chris
Chris, you reported the gain as long-term capital gain because the LLC's holding period includes the homebuilder's time holding the parcel, which puts it well over a year. You are right that the holding period tacks. But the five-year rule for contributed inventory fixes the character as ordinary regardless of holding period, so the tacked period never comes into play. Would your answer change if the sale had come in year six?
References
Character of Gain or Loss on Contributed Unrealized Receivables, Inventory Items, and Capital Loss Property, 26 U.S.C. § 724 (2018).
Income and Credits of Partner, 26 U.S.C. § 702 (2018).
Partner's Distributive Share, 26 U.S.C. § 704 (2018).
Reading the GCU ACC 681 Topic 5 instructions
ACC-681 Topic 5 asks students to discuss a method for working timed tax fact patterns. Many posts offer general time-management advice. Posts that score well state a method, apply it to a real fact pattern, classify the entity first and show which facts do and do not change the answer. Students should apply the rule the deciding fact triggers with the arithmetic shown, allocate the result correctly among the owners, point to the course reading and reply to a classmate by testing the classmate's answer against the deciding fact.
How this ACC 681 Topic 5 example is built
The post's first sentence gives the method, and the rest shows it working on a timed-style fact pattern. Two members own an LLC that made no election, so it is a partnership. It sells a parcel for $500,000 that one member, a homebuilder, contributed from lot inventory 26 months earlier, when it was worth $380,000 and had a $300,000 basis. Five facts are given; four of them, the holding period, the members' brackets, the buyer and the state of formation, do not move the answer. The fifth does: section 724(b) makes gain on contributed inventory ordinary if the partnership disposes of it within five years. The whole $200,000 is ordinary, $80,000 of built-in gain goes to the homebuilder under section 704(c), and the remaining $120,000 splits equally. A reply takes up a classmate who reported long-term capital gain from the tacked holding period.
Reading the ACC 681 Topic 5 rubric
GCU's rubric for this discussion rewards a method shown working. Excellent posts classify the LLC before applying any partnership rule. Credit goes to striking the distracting holding period. The rubric values characterizing the whole partnership gain, not just the contributor's share. The strongest replies concede that the holding period tacks and show why it never mattered. Posts that give study tips without a worked problem, or that tax only the contributor's share as ordinary, usually land in a middle band.
ACC 681 Topic 5 help: mistakes that cost marks
Time-management advice is the answer this prompt draws most, reading faster or budgeting minutes, and with no tax problem attached it shows nothing about whether the method works. A method stated and never applied cannot be checked. Posts that do work the land sale often reach capital gain through the holding period, the distracting fact the pattern was built around, and those that notice the homebuilder's inventory sometimes tax only the homebuilder's share as ordinary, missing that section 724(b) characterizes the partnership's whole gain. Skipping classification leaves the post applying partnership rules to an entity it never identified. An allocation that ignores section 704(c) gives the investor half of a built-in gain the investor never had. Replies are weakest when they endorse a classmate's answer without testing it against the deciding fact.
Get an ACC-681 Topic 5 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-681 Topic 5 discussion question as your classroom shows it, the participation rubric and any fact pattern attached. We write a custom example to those, with a method stated, applied to a worked pattern, the deciding fact isolated and a reply that tests a classmate's answer, ready in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More ACC 681 papers and MS in Accounting samples
- ACC 681 Topic 1: Research Trail Memo
- ACC 681 Topic 2: Worthless Stock Loss Computation
- ACC 681 Topic 3: Conversion Carryover Analysis
- ACC 681 Topic 4: Basis Provenance Schedule
- ACC 681 Topic 6: Examination Path Comparison
- ACC 681 Topic 7: Related Sale Simulation Answer
- ACC 681 Topic 8: Termination Defense Memo
- ACC 680 Topic 5: Full Population Testing Dq Post
- ACC 670 Topic 5: Quiet Disclosure Change Dq Post
- ACC 669 Topic 5: Cash Route Comparison Dq Post
- ACC 653 Topic 5: Structural Cost Driver DQ Post
ACC 681 Topic 5 questions, answered
What does section 724(b) do?
It keeps a partner from converting ordinary income into capital gain by contributing inventory to a partnership. If property was an inventory item in the contributing partner's hands, any gain or loss the partnership recognizes on disposing of it within five years of the contribution is ordinary. Related rules in section 724 do similar work for unrealized receivables and for capital loss property.
Why does the investor member's gain turn ordinary too?
Because character is fixed at the partnership level and flows to every partner with the item. Section 724(b) characterizes the partnership's gain on the parcel, not only the homebuilder's slice of it, so the $60,000 allocated to the investor arrives ordinary as well. Her own investment intent would matter only if she had sold property of her own.
Is this method just advice about exam technique?
It is a claim about how tax rules are built. Most provisions apply only inside one regime, so a timed answer that starts with the rule risks applying one that does not govern. Identifying the regime, then scanning the facts for the single element its rule turns on, is faster because it discards most of the pattern early, and the post demonstrates that rather than asserting it.
Where can I find a free ACC 681 Topic 5 sample paper?
This page presents the opening post and a response to Chris, covering the method, classification, the five facts, the deciding rule, the allocation and the reading. Share your own discussion question and we will write a free sample post around it.
Why is the whole gain ordinary in ACC 681 Topic 5?
The parcel was inventory to the contributing homebuilder and was sold within five years, so section 724(b) makes the partnership's entire $200,000 gain ordinary.