| Course | ACC 681 Tax Core |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 8 |
| Paper type | Termination defense memo |
| Length | About 790 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 681 Topic 8
Memorandum
To: Board of Directors, Pinecrest Cabinetry, Inc.
From: [Author Name], CPA
Date: [Date]
Re: Status of the S election after the April 1 share transfer
Position
Our position has three parts. The S election terminated when shares were transferred to Tamarack Holdings LLC. It terminated on April 1, the date of the transfer, not on January 1 as the examiner's report assumes. And the corporation should request relief for an inadvertent termination, which, if granted, would treat the corporation as an S corporation throughout. Each part answers one of the two challenges now before the board.
The Other Adviser: Was the LLC an Eligible Shareholder?
An adviser to one shareholder argues that the election never terminated, because Tamarack Holdings LLC is a disregarded entity and its owner, an individual, is therefore the real shareholder. That argument works for a single-member LLC, and it fails here on the member count.
A domestic LLC that files no classification election is disregarded only if it has a single owner. With two or more members, it is classified by default as a partnership (Classification of Certain Business Entities, 2024). Tamarack has two members, the transferring shareholder and a sibling, and it has filed no election. It is a partnership for federal tax purposes.
An S corporation may not have a partnership as a shareholder (S Corporation Defined, 2018). When Tamarack acquired the shares on April 1, Pinecrest ceased to meet the definition of a small business corporation, and its election terminated (Election, Revocation, Termination, 2018).
The Examiner: When Did It Terminate?
The examiner's report treats the corporation as a C corporation for the entire year, beginning January 1. That is incorrect. A termination caused by ceasing to be a small business corporation is effective on the date the corporation ceases to qualify (Election, Revocation, Termination, 2018). Pinecrest qualified until April 1. The year is therefore divided into two short years: an S short year from January 1 through March 31, 90 days, and a C short year from April 1 through December 31, 275 days.
Allocating the Year's Income
Pinecrest's taxable income for the full year is $730,000. By default, income is allocated between the two short years in proportion to their days. The S short year receives 90/365 of it, $180,000, which passes through to the shareholders. The C short year receives $550,000, taxed at 21 percent, for $115,500 of corporate tax. The corporation may instead elect, with the consent of all shareholders during the year, to close its books on March 31 and allocate actual results to each period. Pinecrest earned only $120,000 through March 31, because its busiest months follow the spring building season, so a closing of the books would place $610,000 in the C year and produce $128,100 of tax, $12,600 more than the pro rata method. We recommend against that election.
Table 1
Short-Year Allocation
| Pro rata allocation | Closing of the books | |
|---|---|---|
| S short year, January 1 to March 31 | $180,000 | $120,000 |
| C short year, April 1 to December 31 | $550,000 | $610,000 |
| Corporate tax at 21 percent | $115,500 | $128,100 |
Relief for an Inadvertent Termination
The Code allows the IRS to treat a corporation as continuing to be an S corporation if the termination was inadvertent, the corporation takes steps to correct it within a reasonable time after discovery, and the corporation and its shareholders agree to any adjustments the IRS requires (Election, Revocation, Termination, 2018). Each condition can be met.
Inadvertent: the transferring shareholder formed Tamarack for estate planning on the advice of a family attorney, who did not know the corporation was an S corporation, and no one intended to end the election. Correction: on discovering the problem in November, Tamarack returned the shares to the original shareholder, restoring eligibility. Agreement: all shareholders are prepared to report their shares of the corporation's income for the entire year as S corporation income. A private letter ruling request should be filed promptly, with affidavits from the shareholder and the attorney.
If relief is granted, the short-year computation above becomes unnecessary and no corporate tax is due. If relief is denied, the April 1 termination and pro rata allocation stand, and the examiner's January 1 position should still be contested.
If Relief Is Denied
A corporation whose election has terminated generally may not elect S status again for five tax years without the IRS's consent. If relief were denied, Pinecrest would remain a C corporation until at least the fifth year after the termination, unless the IRS consented to an earlier election, which it may do when the termination was not within the control of the corporation or its majority shareholders. The relief request should therefore be treated as the priority, and the board should adopt a policy requiring legal review of any share transfer.
References
Classification of Certain Business Entities, 26 C.F.R. § 301.7701-3 (2024).
Election, Revocation, Termination, 26 U.S.C. § 1362 (2018).
S Corporation Defined, 26 U.S.C. § 1361 (2018).
What the ACC 681 Topic 8 instructions ask for
The Topic 8 instructions in ACC-681 ask students to defend a position on an S election termination. Weak submissions accept one side's view. The assignment rewards memos that state a position, classify the shareholder entity from the regulations, apply the shareholder rules and fix the effective date of termination. Students should split the year into short years, compare pro rata allocation with closing the books, set out the conditions for inadvertent termination relief with the corrective steps taken and note the bar on re-electing.
Inside the ACC 681 Topic 8 example
The finished memo takes the classification question first, since both challenges depend on it. A two-member LLC that filed no classification election defaults to partnership status, and section 1361(b)(1)(B) admits no partnership as a shareholder, so the other adviser's view that the LLC is disregarded fails on its member count. Under section 1362(d)(2) the termination took effect on the transfer date, April 1, not on January 1 as the examiner's report assumes. Section 1362(e) splits the year: a 90-day S short year and a 275-day C short year. With illustrative taxable income of $730,000, the pro rata allocation puts $180,000 in the S year and $550,000 in the C year, where 21 percent produces $115,500 of tax. Closing the books would shift income into the C year and cost $12,600 more, so the memo rejects that election.
Reading the ACC 681 Topic 8 rubric
Faculty grading the termination memo reward each challenge answered by its deciding provision. Excellent memos count the LLC's members before calling it disregarded. Credit goes to the April 1 effective date and the short-year split. The rubric values comparing both allocation methods in figures and recommending the cheaper one. The highest level builds the relief request on inadvertence, correction and shareholder consent. Memos that accept the January 1 date, or call a two-member LLC disregarded, usually land in a middle band.
ACC 681 Topic 8 help: mistakes that cost marks
A defense that picks one side loses before it starts: agreeing with the other adviser denies a termination the shareholder rules make certain, and accepting the examiner's report surrenders an S short year the Code grants. Papers that cite section 1362(d)(2) for the split have the right result and the wrong provision, since the division of the year comes from section 1362(e), a distinction this topic assesses. Treating a two-member LLC as disregarded without counting its members misreads the classification default. A closing of the books elected without comparing it to proration costs the corporation $12,600 on these facts. Memos that stop at the termination and never raise section 1362(f) leave the most useful remedy unused. The five-year bar on a new election is often left out, though a client planning to re-elect next year needs it most.
Get an ACC-681 Topic 8 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-681 Topic 8 instructions, your rubric and the fact pattern and challenge your section assigned. We write a custom example to them, with the position stated first, each challenge answered by the provision that governs it, the computations compared, relief routes set out and every citation made precise, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free; it is coursework, never tax advice.
More ACC 681 papers and MS in Accounting samples
- ACC 681 Topic 1: Research Trail Memo
- ACC 681 Topic 2: Worthless Stock Loss Computation
- ACC 681 Topic 3: Conversion Carryover Analysis
- ACC 681 Topic 4: Basis Provenance Schedule
- ACC 681 Topic 5: Deciding Fact Dq Post
- ACC 681 Topic 6: Examination Path Comparison
- ACC 681 Topic 7: Related Sale Simulation Answer
- ACC 680 Topic 8: Review Note Response Memo
- ACC 670 Topic 8: Earnings Quality Judgment Memo
- ACC 669 Topic 8: Reorganization Structure Memo
- ACC 653 Topic 8: Costing System Fitness Review
ACC 681 Topic 8 questions, answered
Why can a partnership not hold S corporation stock?
Section 1361(b)(1)(B) limits S corporation shareholders to individuals, estates and certain trusts and exempt organizations, and a partnership is none of them. A single-member LLC owned by an individual is different: as a disregarded entity it is treated as the individual for this purpose, so the stock is treated as hers. That is why the LLC's second member decides this case.
What does inadvertent termination relief require?
Under section 1362(f), the IRS must determine that the termination was inadvertent, the corporation must take steps within a reasonable period after discovery to restore eligibility, and the corporation and its shareholders must agree to any adjustments the IRS requires. Relief is generally sought through a letter ruling request. If granted, the corporation is treated as continuing to be an S corporation for the period the IRS specifies.
Can the corporation simply elect S status again next year?
Not without consent. Section 1362(g) bars a new election for five taxable years after a termination unless the IRS consents to an earlier one. That bar is a large part of why the memo pursues relief under section 1362(f) instead of treating the lost months as a one-year cost. The example is coursework on a composite company and is not tax advice.
Where can I find a free ACC 681 Topic 8 sample paper?
The memo is available on this page in full: the position, the other adviser's argument, the examiner's date, the income allocation, relief and what happens if relief is denied. Share your client's facts for a free worked memo.
Why is the pro rata method better in ACC 681 Topic 8?
Only $120,000 was earned by March 31, so closing the books would put $610,000 in the C year and cost $12,600 more tax than the pro rata split.