| Course | ACC 683 TCP Discipline Capstone |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 2 |
| Paper type | Revocation break-even analysis |
| Length | About 980 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 683 Topic 2
Should the Brewery Revoke Its S Election? Cents per Dollar, Five Years of Retained Income, a Year-Six Sale and a 26.6 Percent Break-Even
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
ACC-683: TCP Discipline Capstone
Topic 2 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Should the Brewery Revoke Its S Election? Cents per Dollar, Five Years of Retained Income, a Year-Six Sale and a 26.6 Percent Break-Even
The Question and the Assumptions
Three siblings own Tall Pines Brewing, Inc., an S corporation. A friend who owns a C corporation has told them that the 21 percent corporate rate would let them keep more money in the business to fund expansion, and they have asked whether to revoke the S election. The case supplies the assumptions: each sibling's rate on ordinary income is 40 percent, federal and state combined; the rate on capital gains and qualified dividends is 25 percent; the brewery will retain $1,200,000 of income each year for five years to fund expansion; and the siblings plan to sell the brewery's assets in year six, when they are expected to have appreciated by $8,000,000, and liquidate.
Pass One: One Dollar Under Each Regime
In an S corporation, income passes through to the shareholders whether or not it is distributed (Pass-Thru of Items to Shareholders, 2018). A dollar earned costs 40 cents of tax now, and nothing more when it is later distributed. In a C corporation, a dollar earned costs 21 cents of corporate tax now (Tax Imposed, 2018). The remaining 79 cents is taxed again when it reaches the siblings, as a dividend or on liquidation, at 25 percent: 19.75 cents. The C route costs 40.75 cents in total, three-quarters of a cent more than the S route, but it defers 19.75 cents of it until distribution.
Pass Two: Five Years of Retained Income
On $1,200,000 retained each year, the S route costs $480,000 of tax a year and the C route $252,000. Revoking keeps $228,000 a year more in the business to fund expansion. That is what the friend saw. What the friend did not mention is that the extra cash is not a saving but a postponement: over five years, the C route defers $1,185,000 of shareholder-level tax that will fall due when the retained earnings reach the siblings.
What the Retained Dollar Buys
In practice, an S corporation that retains income still has to distribute enough cash for its owners to pay the tax on it, because they are taxed whether or not they receive anything. On $1,200,000 of income, the siblings owe $480,000, so the brewery distributes that much and reinvests $720,000. As a C corporation, it pays $252,000 of corporate tax and reinvests $948,000. The $228,000 difference is real cash for expansion each year, which is why the friend's argument is attractive to a growing business.
Pass Three: The Year-Six Sale
The sale reverses the picture. In an S corporation, the $8,000,000 of appreciation passes through once and is taxed at 25 percent, $2,000,000. In a C corporation, the corporation pays 21 percent on the gain, $1,680,000, and the siblings then pay 25 percent on the remaining $6,320,000 when they receive it in liquidation (Gain or Loss to Shareholders in Corporate Liquidations, 2018), $1,580,000. The C route costs $3,260,000 on the sale, $1,260,000 more than the S route.
Table 1
Tax Under Each Route
| S corporation | C corporation | |
|---|---|---|
| Tax on five years of retained income, paid as earned | $2,400,000 | $1,260,000 |
| Shareholder tax on the retained income when distributed | $0 | $1,185,000 |
| Tax on the year-six sale | $2,000,000 | $3,260,000 |
| Total, undiscounted | $4,400,000 | $5,705,000 |
Pass Four: The Discount Rate at Which They Meet
Across the whole plan, the C route costs $1,305,000 more, undiscounted. Its only advantage is timing: $228,000 a year of lower tax for five years, against $2,445,000 more tax in year six. Discounting both, the two routes are equal at a discount rate of about 26.6 percent. The C route wins only if the siblings can earn more than 26.6 percent a year, after tax, on the cash it keeps in the business. The brewery's expansion plan projects a return well below that, so on the case's own numbers the S election should stay.
Risks of Revoking
Two further risks weigh against revocation. A C corporation that retains earnings beyond the reasonable needs of its business to avoid shareholder tax is subject to the accumulated earnings tax (Imposition of Accumulated Earnings Tax, 2018); a documented expansion plan would support retention for five years, but the risk grows if plans change. And once an S election is revoked, the corporation generally cannot elect S status again for five years without the IRS's consent (Election, Revocation, Termination, 2018). If the siblings revoked and then changed their minds, a re-election would also bring the built-in gains tax on appreciation that accrued during the C years, so the sale in year six would be taxed at the corporate level anyway.
How Sensitive Is the Answer?
The conclusion depends mainly on the year-six sale. If the siblings instead planned to hold the brewery indefinitely and never distribute the retained earnings, the second layer of tax would be deferred without limit, and the C route would win. If they sold their shares rather than the brewery's assets, the buyer would inherit the corporation's low asset basis and would pay less for it, so much of the corporate-level tax would reappear as a lower price. A lower appreciation figure narrows the gap but does not close it: at $4,000,000 of appreciation, the C route still costs about $675,000 more undiscounted. The answer changes only if the sale disappears from the plan.
Recommendation
Keep the S election. The friend's point is real for a business that will retain earnings indefinitely and never sell, but the siblings plan to sell in year six, and the second layer of tax on the sale outweighs five years of deferral at any plausible discount rate. If the expansion needs more cash than the S route leaves, the siblings should consider financing the shortfall with debt, or limiting distributions to the amounts needed for tax, rather than changing the entity's tax status.
References
Election, Revocation, Termination, 26 U.S.C. § 1362 (2018).
Gain or Loss to Shareholders in Corporate Liquidations, 26 U.S.C. § 331 (2018).
Imposition of Accumulated Earnings Tax, 26 U.S.C. § 531 (2018).
Pass-Thru of Items to Shareholders, 26 U.S.C. § 1366 (2018).
Tax Imposed, 26 U.S.C. § 11 (2018).
ACC 683 Topic 2 instructions, in plain terms
The Topic 2 instructions in ACC-683 ask students to evaluate revoking an S election. Weak submissions compare the 21 percent rate with individual rates and stop. The assignment rewards analyses that state the assumptions, work one dollar under each regime now and on distribution, apply the rates to retained income and to a planned sale, and discount the difference to a break-even rate. Students should address the accumulated earnings tax and the waiting period for re-election, test how sensitive the answer is to the planned sale and make a clear recommendation.
How the ACC-683 Topic 2 example is put together
The finished analysis reduces the choice to cents per dollar before it uses the brewery's numbers. Those numbers are illustrative, and so are the siblings' assumed rates of 40 percent on ordinary income and 25 percent on capital gain and dividends. Retained in an S corporation, a dollar of income costs 40 cents now. In a C corporation it costs 21 cents now under section 11(b) and 19.75 cents more when the remaining 79 cents reaches the siblings. On $1,200,000 retained each year, revoking keeps $228,000 a year in the business. The asset sale planned for year six works the other way: $8,000,000 of appreciation taxed once costs $2,000,000, and taxed twice $3,260,000. Across the whole plan the C route costs $1,305,000 more, and it wins only above a 26.6 percent discount rate.
Reading the ACC 683 Topic 2 rubric
Faculty grading the break-even analysis reward the second layer of tax kept in view. Excellent analyses show that revoking postpones the shareholder-level tax rather than removing it. Credit goes to adding the year-six sale, where double taxation dominates. The rubric values a discount rate at which the routes meet. The highest level tests sensitivity to the sale and names the re-election bar and accumulated earnings tax. Analyses that stop at 21 percent against 40 percent, or ignore the tax distributions an S corporation must make, usually land in a middle band.
Common ACC 683 Topic 2 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Most lost credit comes from comparing 21 percent with 40 percent and stopping, as the friend did, which ignores the tax waiting when C earnings leave the corporation. A paper that adds the dividend layer but omits the asset sale has priced the retention years and skipped the event the siblings are planning toward. Treating the $228,000 annual difference as a permanent saving rather than a deferral overstates the case for revoking by the whole second layer. Analyses that never discount leave the comparison to intuition, while many sections reward finding the rate at which the answer flips. Papers recommending revocation without the wait before re-electing present as reversible a choice that is close to permanent. Stating the siblings' rates as law, instead of as case assumptions, invites an accuracy deduction.
Get an ACC-683 Topic 2 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-683 Topic 2 instructions, the rubric and the owners' facts and assumed rates from your case. A custom example is written to them, with the entity choice priced per dollar and in total, retention and exit both modeled, the break-even rate found and the rejected route's risks stated, returned in 24 to 48 hours. First one free, and coursework only, not tax advice.
More ACC 683 papers and MS in Accounting samples
- ACC 683 Topic 1: Engagement Framing Memo
- ACC 683 Topic 3: Lot Sale Character Memo
- ACC 683 Topic 4: Settlement Allocation Authority Memo
- ACC 683 Topic 5: Substantiation Dq Post
- ACC 683 Topic 6: Installment Plan Stress Test
- ACC 683 Topic 7: Sale Structure Client Letter
- ACC 683 Topic 8: Plan-to-return Reconciliation
- ACC 682 Topic 2: Backlog Extraction Workpaper
- ACC 653 Topic 2: Target Cost Gap Analysis
- ACC 681 Topic 2: Worthless Stock Loss Computation
- ACC 656 Topic 2: Acquisition Date Fair Value Schedule
ACC 683 Topic 2 questions, answered
Why is the 21 percent rate not the whole comparison?
Because a C corporation's income is taxed again when it reaches the owners, as a dividend or on liquidation. At the case's assumed 25 percent shareholder rate, the 79 cents left after corporate tax loses another 19.75 cents, so the combined cost of 40.75 cents slightly exceeds the S corporation's 40. The corporate rate buys time, and the analysis measures what that time is worth to these owners.
What does revoking the election involve?
Under section 1362(d)(1), shareholders holding more than half the shares can consent to a revocation, with timing rules that decide which year it first affects. Once revoked, a new S election generally cannot be made for five years without IRS consent under section 1362(g). A revocation made for a few years of retention is therefore closer to permanent than it sounds, and the analysis treats it that way.
Could the siblings avoid the second layer by never distributing?
Only for a while, and not cheaply. Earnings kept beyond the business's reasonable needs can attract the accumulated earnings tax, and an asset sale followed by liquidation brings the second layer due regardless. Holding shares until death can reset their basis under section 1014, but the corporation's own gain on selling its assets would remain. The example weighs these routes as coursework on composite facts, never as tax advice.
Where can I find a free ACC 683 Topic 2 sample paper?
Everything is above: the question and assumptions, one dollar under each regime, what the retained dollar buys, five years of retained income, the year-six sale, the break-even rate, sensitivity, risks and the recommendation. Send your owners' plan for a free worked analysis.
Why keep the S election in ACC 683 Topic 2?
The year-six sale would be taxed twice in a C corporation, costing $1,260,000 more, which outweighs five years of $228,000 of deferral at any plausible return.