ACC 683 Topic 3 lot sale character memo example

TCP Discipline Capstone Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This ACC 683 Topic 3 sample paper decides whether $425,000 of gain on five farm lots is capital gain or dealer income. It was prepared for GCU ACC 683, TCP Discipline Capstone, catalog code ACC-683, in the Grand Canyon University MS in Accounting program. A retired couple platted 14 lots, graded a gravel road and listed with a broker, who sold five at $95,000 against a $10,000 basis each. The memo states the ordinary reading at full strength, weighs the factors from the case law and applies section 1237, testing the road against its improvement rule. It reports capital gain and compares one-at-a-time sales with a $760,000 bulk offer.

CourseACC 683 TCP Discipline Capstone
TopicTopic 3
Paper typeLot sale character memo
LengthAbout 870 words, 1 pages
FormatMemo with APA 7 references
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMS in Accounting
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for ACC 683 Topic 3

1

Memorandum

To: Harold and June Tate

From: [Author Name], CPA

Date: [Date]

Re: How the gain on your lot sales should be reported

 

The Question

Is the $425,000 gain on the five lots you have sold capital gain from the sale of an investment, or ordinary income from a real estate business? The answer decides which return we file. As capital gain, it is reported on Schedule D at long-term capital gain rates. As ordinary income, it is reported on Schedule C, taxed at ordinary rates and subject to self-employment tax as well. At your income level the difference is well over $100,000 of tax.

The Facts in Date Order

Courts examine the taxpayer's purpose in holding the property at the time of sale, so the facts are set out in the order they happened. You bought the 40 acres thirty-four years ago and farmed them for thirty years. You retired four years ago and stopped farming. Three years ago you had the land surveyed and platted into 14 residential lots and graded a gravel access road so the lots could be reached. You listed the lots with a local broker, who has handled all marketing, showings and negotiations. Over the past two years the broker sold five lots at $95,000 each. Your basis in each lot, including a share of the survey and road costs, is about $10,000, so each sale produced about $85,000 of gain.

The Factors

Property held primarily for sale to customers in the ordinary course of a trade or business is not a capital asset (Capital Asset Defined, 2018), and primarily means of first importance (Malat v. Riddell, 1966). Courts weigh a set of factors to decide it (Biedenharn Realty Co. v. United States, 1976). Each is taken in turn.

Table 1

Factors and Their Direction

FactorFactsLeans toward
Frequency and continuity of salesFive sales over two years, steadyOrdinary
ImprovementsPlatting and a graded gravel access roadOrdinary, modestly
Selling effortA broker did everything; you did not advertise or negotiateCapital
Purpose of acquisition and holdingBought and held thirty years as a farmCapital
Other real estate activityNone; you have never bought land to resellCapital
Time devotedMinimal; you meet the broker quarterlyCapital

The Ordinary-Income Reading at Full Strength

The strongest case against you is this. Once you platted the land and built a road, you changed its purpose from farming to selling lots, and you have been selling steadily ever since. Frequent, continuous sales of subdivided land with improvements are the classic marks of a dealer, and a court looking only at the last three years could find that the lots were held primarily for sale to customers. The fact that a broker did the selling does not help much, since a dealer can act through agents.

Section 1237

Congress addressed exactly this situation for individuals who subdivide land they have held as an investment. Under section 1237, an individual is not treated as a dealer merely because of subdividing a tract and selling lots, if the tract was not previously held primarily for sale, no substantial improvement was made that substantially increased the value of the lots, and the individual holds no other real property for sale (Real Property Subdivided for Sale, 2018).

The road is the one condition that needs testing. For land held at least ten years, a road necessary to make the lots marketable at the prevailing local price is not treated as a substantial improvement, provided you elect not to adjust the lots' basis or deduct the road's cost. You have held the land for thirty-four years, the lots could not be sold without access, and the gravel road is basic rather than a paved subdivision street. The condition is met if the election is made, and your basis figures will be revised to exclude the road cost.

Position

We will report the $425,000 as long-term capital gain. The factors on balance favor capital treatment: you acquired and held the land as a farm, did nothing to sell it yourselves and have no other real estate activity. Section 1237 then answers the ordinary-income reading directly, because it was written to protect sellers in your position from being treated as dealers for subdividing. One rule within it applies from the year the sixth lot is sold: gain on each lot sold that year and later is ordinary to the extent of 5 percent of its selling price, about $4,750 a lot, reduced by selling expenses.

Planning the Nine Remaining Lots

You have a bulk offer of $760,000 for the remaining nine lots from an unrelated builder. Selling them one at a time at $95,000 would bring $855,000 before a 6 percent commission, $803,700 net, but over perhaps four more years, with the 5 percent ordinary portion applying to each, continued exposure to the dealer argument and your own time. The bulk sale brings less money but sooner, as a single sale of the remaining investment that looks nothing like a dealer's business, and no commission if the builder deals directly. The difference, about $44,000 before tax, is the price of certainty, and the decision is yours; we recommend discussing it before the next lot is listed.

References

Biedenharn Realty Co. v. United States, 526 F.2d 409 (5th Cir. 1976).

Capital Asset Defined, 26 U.S.C. § 1221 (2018).

Malat v. Riddell, 383 U.S. 569 (1966).

Real Property Subdivided for Sale, 26 U.S.C. § 1237 (2018).

ACC 683 Topic 3 instructions, in plain terms

ACC-683 Topic 3 asks students to determine the character of gain on subdivided land. Many papers list factors without weighing them. The assignment rewards memos that state the question and the two returns it could produce, set out the facts in date order and weigh each factor from the case law in a table. Students should state the ordinary-income argument at full strength, apply section 1237 including its improvement condition, take a position that answers the losing argument and plan the remaining sales.

How the ACC-683 Topic 3 example is put together

The finished memo sets out the facts each side depends on, amounts illustrative. The couple farmed the land for thirty years, retired, had it platted into 14 lots, graded a gravel access road and listed the lots with a broker, who sold five over two years at $95,000 against a $10,000 basis per lot, $425,000 of gain in all. The ordinary reading draws on the platting, the road and the steady sales, the marks of land held primarily for sale to customers under section 1221(a)(1). The capital reading draws on the decades of holding, the broker doing all the selling and section 1237, which keeps subdivision alone from making an individual a dealer if no substantial improvement was made. The memo reports capital gain, and says what would reverse it.

ACC 683 Topic 3 rubric: what Excellent looks like

Faculty grading the character memo reward the losing argument stated fairly. Excellent memos weigh frequency and improvements against selling effort and holding purpose. Credit goes to testing the road under the ten-year rule and the required election. The rubric values noting the 5 percent ordinary portion once the sixth lot sells. The highest level compares one-at-a-time sales with the bulk offer on money, time and risk, leaving the choice with the clients. Memos that call the gain capital without addressing dealer factors, or miss the road's effect under section 1237, tend to earn partial credit.

Common ACC 683 Topic 3 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Deciding the character from one fact sinks more of these memos than anything else, whether that fact is thirty years of farming or the platting map. Papers reporting capital gain without ever stating the ordinary-income case have asserted a position rather than defended it. The reverse error treats any subdivision as a business and adds self-employment tax to $425,000 without testing section 1237. Applying that provision without asking whether the road was a substantial improvement assumes the one condition the facts leave open. Memos that settle the five sold lots and say nothing of the nine still listed produce a correct return and no advice, the gap a capstone is designed to expose. The planning section costs marks too when it recommends the bulk sale without setting its price against the after-tax result of selling lot by lot.

Get an ACC-683 Topic 3 example written to your instructions

Send your ACC-683 Topic 3 instructions, the rubric and the transaction facts your section provided. We write a custom example to them, with both treatments argued at full strength, the governing factors and provisions applied, a filing position chosen and the client's next transactions planned around it, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free, as coursework, not tax advice.

More ACC 683 papers and MS in Accounting samples

ACC 683 Topic 3 questions, answered

What does 'primarily for sale' mean?

In Malat v. Riddell the Supreme Court read 'primarily' in this setting as meaning of first importance, or principally, so land held for investment is not ordinary property merely because a sale was one possible purpose. Lower courts then apply factors such as the frequency of sales, improvements and selling effort. No single factor decides the question, which is why the memo weighs them against each other.

Does section 1237 settle the question?

Only where its conditions are met. It applies to an individual who has not otherwise held the tract for sale, has held it long enough, and made no substantial improvement that substantially increased its value. If those hold, subdividing the tract and activity incident to selling it do not by themselves make the owner a dealer. The road is the open condition here, so the memo addresses it directly.

Why does the position on five lots affect the other nine?

Because each further sale adds to the frequency and continuity that point toward a business, and from the year a sixth lot sells section 1237 itself makes part of each price ordinary income. The return position and the plan for the remaining land are therefore one decision, taken together. The couple and their figures are composites; this is coursework, never tax advice.

Where can I find a free ACC 683 Topic 3 sample paper?

The full memo sits above, with the question, the facts in date order, the factors, the ordinary-income reading, section 1237, the position and planning for the nine remaining lots. Give us your client's land history for a free worked memo.

How does section 1237 help in ACC 683 Topic 3?

It keeps an individual from being treated as a dealer merely for subdividing long-held land, if no substantial improvement was made; a necessary road on land held ten years qualifies.