| Course | ACC 683 TCP Discipline Capstone |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 7 |
| Paper type | Sale structure client letter |
| Length | About 780 words, 1 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 683 Topic 7
Memorandum
To: Elena Brooks, Founder, Brooks Precision Molding, Inc.
From: [Author Name], CPA
Date: [Date]
Re: Your two offers for the company
Our Recommendation
At the same $6,000,000 price, selling your shares would leave you about $4,625,000 after federal tax, and selling the company's assets about $3,995,000. We recommend pursuing the share sale, and if the other buyer insists on buying assets, asking a higher price to make up the difference.
Why the Same Price Gives Different Results
When a buyer purchases the company's assets, the company itself sells them and pays tax on its gain before any money reaches you, and you then pay tax again when the company pays the proceeds out to you. When a buyer purchases your shares, you sell them directly and are taxed only once.
The Two Routes Side by Side
The figures below assume the full $6,000,000 is paid at closing and that your own gain is taxed at 25 percent, the rate we have assumed for your situation.
Table 1
Share Sale and Asset Sale at $6,000,000
| Share sale | Asset sale | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $6,000,000 | $6,000,000 |
| Tax paid inside the company | $0 | $840,000 |
| Cash reaching you | $6,000,000 | $5,160,000 |
| Your own tax | $1,375,000 | $1,165,000 |
| What you keep | $4,625,000 | $3,995,000 |
The Price That Would Match
An asset buyer usually prefers to buy assets because it can deduct their cost over time, which is worth real money to it. That is a reason for the buyer to pay more, not for you to take less. For an asset sale to leave you the same amount as the share sale, the asset buyer would have to pay about $7,063,000, roughly $1,063,000 more than the share buyer. If the asset buyer's offer rises toward that figure, the choice becomes closer and may depend on other terms, such as how much of the price is paid at closing.
Keep in mind that a buyer of shares takes on the company's history, including any tax or legal exposure from past years, while an asset buyer generally does not. Share buyers often ask for a lower price or a larger escrow for that reason, so compare the offers on their full terms, not the headline price alone.
What to Do Before You Sign a Letter of Intent
1. Find the records of how you first acquired your shares when you started the company: the subscription agreement, the amount you paid and the date. If the shares qualify as small business stock, a large part of your gain on a share sale could be excluded from tax altogether, which would widen the gap in favor of the share sale considerably.
2. Ask your corporate attorney to confirm that the share buyer will take the company as it is, including its contracts and any past liabilities, and what protections the buyer will ask you to give in return.
3. Do not agree to any allocation of price, payment schedule or noncompete payment in a letter of intent before we have reviewed it, since each can change the figures above.
Assumptions and Limits
This letter assumes the company is a C corporation, that it has no losses or credits that would reduce its tax on an asset sale, that its assets have a combined tax basis of about $2,000,000, that your shares have a basis of $500,000, and that federal tax on your gain is 25 percent. It does not address state taxes, which may differ between the routes, or the effect of any payment spread over time. Professional standards for written tax advice expect those assumptions to be spelled out, so you can see exactly which facts would change the answer (Requirements for Written Advice, 2024).
Appendix: Computation and Citations
Share sale: amount realized $6,000,000 less basis $500,000 gives $5,500,000 of gain (Determination of Amount of and Recognition of Gain or Loss, 2018); tax at 25 percent is $1,375,000; you keep $4,625,000.
Asset sale: corporate gain is $6,000,000 less the assets' basis of $2,000,000, or $4,000,000, taxed at 21 percent (Tax Imposed, 2018), $840,000. The company distributes $5,160,000 in liquidation, which is treated as full payment for your shares (Gain or Loss to Shareholders in Corporate Liquidations, 2018). Your gain is $4,660,000, taxed at 25 percent, $1,165,000; you keep $3,995,000.
Matching price: for you to keep $4,625,000, the company must distribute $6,000,000, so the price less 21 percent of the price in excess of $2,000,000 must equal $6,000,000, which gives about $7,063,000.
Small business stock: gain on qualified small business stock held more than five years may be partly or fully excluded (Partial Exclusion for Gain From Certain Small Business Stock, 2018). Qualification depends on facts at the time the shares were issued, which is why the records in action 1 matter.
References
Determination of Amount of and Recognition of Gain or Loss, 26 U.S.C. § 1001 (2018).
Gain or Loss to Shareholders in Corporate Liquidations, 26 U.S.C. § 331 (2018).
Partial Exclusion for Gain From Certain Small Business Stock, 26 U.S.C. § 1202 (2018).
Requirements for Written Advice, 31 C.F.R. § 10.37 (2024).
Tax Imposed, 26 U.S.C. § 11 (2018).
Reading the GCU ACC 683 Topic 7 instructions
ACC-683 Topic 7 asks students to write tax advice for a nonspecialist client. Many papers read like research memos. The assignment rewards letters that open with the recommendation and the number behind it, explain the difference in plain words without section numbers, and show both routes in a short table. Students should convert the gap into a price the other buyer would have to pay, list concrete actions including records bearing on small business stock, state assumptions and limits as Circular 230 expects and move citations to an appendix.
How the ACC-683 Topic 7 example is put together
The letter opens with the recommendation and the one number behind it. At equal prices, selling the founder's shares leaves about $4,625,000 after federal tax and selling the company's assets about $3,995,000, on the case's assumed 25 percent rate on the founder's gain. The second paragraph explains the gap in two sentences: an asset sale is taxed first inside the corporation at 21 percent and again when the proceeds are paid out, while a share sale is taxed once. A short table shows both routes. The letter then gives a negotiating figure, about $7,063,000 for the asset buyer to match, and lists three things to do before signing any letter of intent. Code sections appear only in the appendix, where a reviewer can check the computation and the citations without the founder having to read them.
ACC 683 Topic 7 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Faculty grading the client letter reward a decision before an explanation. Excellent letters keep section numbers out of the body. Credit goes to the matching price the asset buyer would have to pay. The rubric values raising small business stock as an open question with records to find. The highest level states assumptions so the advice can be revised and puts computations and citations in an appendix. Letters that open with the history of the offers, or state the assumed rate as law, usually land in a middle band.
ACC 683 Topic 7 help before you submit
Letters lose marks fastest when they read as papers, opening with the history of the two offers and reaching the recommendation on the third page. Section numbers in the body, or terms such as double taxation left undefined, give the founder vocabulary instead of a decision. Stopping at the $630,000 difference, without the asset price that would erase it, leaves the founder unable to answer the second buyer. Some letters present the assumed 25 percent rate as the law, which a reviewer treats as an accuracy error. Leaving section 1202 out, even as an open question, can understate the case for a share sale. Advice with no assumptions paragraph cannot be revised cleanly when the client's facts turn out different, and a reviewer will ask for one.
Get an ACC-683 Topic 7 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-683 Topic 7 instructions, the rubric and the client facts or earlier analysis your section assigned. A custom example is written to them, with the recommendation first, the reasoning in plain terms, a figure the client can use, an action list and the technical support placed where a reviewer finds it, in 24 to 48 hours. First one free; coursework only.
More ACC 683 papers and MS in Accounting samples
- ACC 683 Topic 1: Engagement Framing Memo
- ACC 683 Topic 2: Revocation Break-even Analysis
- ACC 683 Topic 3: Lot Sale Character Memo
- ACC 683 Topic 4: Settlement Allocation Authority Memo
- ACC 683 Topic 5: Substantiation Dq Post
- ACC 683 Topic 6: Installment Plan Stress Test
- ACC 683 Topic 8: Plan-to-return Reconciliation
- ACC 682 Topic 7: Breakage Estimate Workpaper
- ACC 653 Topic 7: Transfer Pricing Policy Memo
- ACC 681 Topic 7: Related Sale Simulation Answer
- ACC 656 Topic 7: Consolidated Statement Preparation
ACC 683 Topic 7 questions, answered
Why would a buyer prefer to buy assets?
Because buying assets gives the buyer a cost basis in them, so equipment can be depreciated again and purchased goodwill amortized under section 197, while buying shares leaves the corporation's old basis in place. That future deduction has value to the buyer, which is why an asset offer can sometimes be raised. The letter converts the tax gap into a price so the founder can test whether the buyer will pay for it.
What is section 1202, and why is it only flagged?
It can exclude part or all of the gain on qualified small business stock held long enough, if a series of conditions is met, including how and when the shares were issued and what the company does. The letter cannot confirm those facts yet, so it asks the founder for the records that would. If her shares qualify, the stock sale becomes more favorable still, and the letter would be revised.
Why does the letter keep citations out of the body?
Because the founder has to decide and act, and the reasoning she needs is short: one route is taxed twice, the other once. Citations matter to whoever reviews the work, so they sit in an appendix where they can be checked. Keeping them there is a register choice this topic grades. The letter is coursework for a composite client, not tax advice.
Where can I find a free ACC 683 Topic 7 sample paper?
Every part is above: the recommendation, why the same price differs, the two routes, the matching price, actions before signing, assumptions and limits, and the appendix. Send us your two offers for a free worked letter.
What asset price would match the share sale in ACC 683 Topic 7?
About $7,063,000, the price at which corporate tax and the founder's tax on liquidation still leave $4,625,000.