ACC 683 Topic 8 plan-to-return reconciliation example

TCP Discipline Capstone Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This ACC 683 Topic 8 sample paper reconciles a like-kind exchange plan with the return that followed. It belongs to GCU ACC 683, TCP Discipline Capstone, the course listed as ACC-683 in the Grand Canyon University MS in Accounting. An LLC owned by two cousins exchanged a warehouse with a $700,000 basis, sold for a net $1,500,000, planning to defer all $800,000 of gain. The replacement closed at $1,440,000, and $60,000 was released for a roof deposit. That boot makes $60,000 recognized under section 1031(b), basis stays $700,000 and $740,000 remains deferred, reported as unrecaptured section 1250 gain, $30,000 per partner.

CourseACC 683 TCP Discipline Capstone
TopicTopic 8
Paper typePlan-to-return reconciliation
LengthAbout 980 words, 2 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMS in Accounting
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for ACC 683 Topic 8

1

Plan Versus Return for a Like-Kind Exchange: How a $60,000 Roof Deposit Turned a Fully Deferred Gain Into $60,000 Recognized

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

ACC-683: TCP Discipline Capstone

Topic 8 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states where the plan and the return part ways and why. The LLC, partners and figures are illustrative composites; the statutes, regulation and instructions are real.
2

Plan Versus Return for a Like-Kind Exchange: How a $60,000 Roof Deposit Turned a Fully Deferred Gain Into $60,000 Recognized

The Claim and the Documents

Last year's tax plan for Crestwood Holdings LLC, owned equally by two cousins and taxed as a partnership, said the LLC would exchange its warehouse for replacement property and defer the entire $800,000 gain. This reconciliation tests that claim against what happened, using five documents: the qualified intermediary agreement, the closing statements for the sale and the purchase, the identification letter sent to the intermediary and the draft Form 8824. The plan is in the first column, the return in the second, and the third records which gives way.

Title and Timing

The same taxpayer must transfer the relinquished property and receive the replacement property. The LLC held title to the warehouse and took title to the replacement building; neither cousin took title personally. The identification letter named the replacement building 31 days after the sale closed, within the 45-day limit, and the purchase closed on day 104, within the 180-day limit (Treatment of Deferred Exchanges, 2024). The sale proceeds went directly to the intermediary. On title and timing, plan and return agree.

Closing Costs and the Roof Deposit

The sale's closing statement shows a gross price of $1,590,000, with a broker's commission and title and escrow fees of $90,000 paid from the proceeds, leaving net proceeds of $1,500,000 delivered to the intermediary. Transaction costs of this kind reduce the amount realized and do not create taxable boot.

The purchase's closing statement shows a replacement price of $1,440,000, paid from exchange funds. The remaining $60,000 did not go into the replacement property. At the partners' request, the intermediary released it to the LLC, which used it for a deposit on a new roof for another building. Cash received from exchange funds is boot, whatever it is spent on. The plan assumed the whole $1,500,000 would be reinvested; it was not.

Could the $60,000 Be Treated Differently?

Two arguments were considered and rejected. The first is that the deposit was spent on real property, so it should count as reinvested. It was spent on a roof for a different building the LLC already owned, not on the replacement property, and money received does not stop being boot because it is later spent on the taxpayer's business. Had the $60,000 been paid at closing toward improvements to the replacement building under the purchase contract, it would have been part of the replacement cost, not boot.

The second is that boot received can be offset by boot given. Cash paid by the taxpayer at the replacement closing, or liabilities assumed on the replacement property, can offset liabilities relieved on the relinquished property. Neither applies here: the warehouse had no mortgage, and the LLC paid nothing into the replacement closing. The $60,000 stands as boot.

The Gain

Realized gain is the amount realized, $1,500,000, less the warehouse's adjusted basis, $700,000: $800,000. In an exchange that otherwise qualifies, any money the taxpayer receives is taxed as gain, capped at the gain realized (Exchange of Real Property Held for Productive Use or Investment, 2018). The LLC recognizes $60,000, not zero, and reports it on Form 8824 (Internal Revenue Service, 2024). The replacement building's basis is the warehouse's basis, increased by gain recognized and decreased by money received: $700,000. The building cost $1,440,000, so $740,000 of gain remains deferred in its basis.

Table 1

Plan and Return Side by Side

PlanReturnWhich gives way
Amount realized$1,500,000$1,500,000Agree
Replacement costAt least $1,500,000$1,440,000Plan
Cash received from exchange fundsNone$60,000Plan
Gain recognized$0$60,000Plan
Gain deferred$800,000$740,000Plan
Replacement basis$700,000$700,000Agree

Character of the Recognized Gain

The warehouse was depreciated on a straight-line basis for twelve years, and the depreciation taken, about $420,000, far exceeds the $60,000 recognized. Because straight-line depreciation on real property is not recaptured as ordinary income (Gain From Dispositions of Certain Depreciable Realty, 2018), the gain is section 1231 gain (Property Used in the Trade or Business and Involuntary Conversions, 2018). But gain on real property attributable to prior depreciation is taxed to individuals at a maximum 25 percent rate as unrecaptured section 1250 gain, and here all $60,000 is attributable to depreciation. Each partner's Schedule K-1 reports $30,000 of section 1231 gain, all of it unrecaptured section 1250 gain.

Reporting on Form 8824

The draft Form 8824 has been corrected. It now reports the $60,000 of cash received, the $800,000 of realized gain, the $60,000 recognized and the $740,000 deferred, with the replacement basis of $700,000. The recognized gain flows to Form 4797 as section 1231 gain and from there to the partners' Schedules K-1, with the unrecaptured section 1250 amount shown separately so each partner's return applies the correct rate.

The Partners

The $60,000 of recognized gain raises each cousin's outside basis by $30,000. The roof deposit was spent by the LLC, not distributed, so it does not reduce outside basis. Each cousin's estimated tax payments for the year should be increased to cover about $7,500 of federal tax on the $30,000 at the 25 percent rate, which the plan had not anticipated.

Revising the Plan and What Would Have Kept It Whole

The plan is revised in writing to show the recognized gain, the reduced deferral and the estimated payment change, and the revision is sent to both cousins with this reconciliation. The exchange would have stayed whole if the roof deposit had been paid from the LLC's operating funds or a short-term loan rather than from exchange funds, or if the LLC had acquired replacement property costing at least $1,500,000. Any future exchange plan should state, in the instructions to the intermediary, that no funds may be released to the LLC before the replacement closes, and the tax adviser should review the purchase closing statement before it is signed.

References

Exchange of Real Property Held for Productive Use or Investment, 26 U.S.C. § 1031 (2018).

Gain From Dispositions of Certain Depreciable Realty, 26 U.S.C. § 1250 (2018).

Internal Revenue Service. (2024). Instructions for Form 8824: Like-kind exchanges. U.S. Department of the Treasury.

Property Used in the Trade or Business and Involuntary Conversions, 26 U.S.C. § 1231 (2018).

Treatment of Deferred Exchanges, 26 C.F.R. § 1.1031(k)-1 (2024).

Reading the GCU ACC 683 Topic 8 instructions

The Topic 8 instructions in ACC-683 ask students to reconcile a tax plan with the return actually filed. Weak submissions report the plan's figures. The assignment rewards reconciliations that test the plan against the source documents, checking title and timing, separating closing costs that create no boot from cash that does, and computing realized, recognized and deferred gain and replacement basis. Students should determine the character of recognized gain, carry it to the partners, adjust estimated payments and record, in a revised written plan, what would have kept the exchange whole.

Inside the ACC 683 Topic 8 example

The finished reconciliation lays the two documents side by side, with every amount a composite. The plan said an LLC owned by two cousins would exchange a warehouse with a $700,000 adjusted basis, sold for a net $1,500,000, for replacement property costing at least as much, and defer the whole $800,000 gain under section 1031. The replacement closed at $1,440,000, and the intermediary released $60,000 to the LLC for a roof deposit. Section 1031(b) recognizes gain up to the boot received, so the return reports $60,000 on Form 8824, not zero. The replacement's basis stays $700,000 under section 1031(d), and $740,000 remains deferred. Because depreciation already taken exceeds the recognized amount, the partners receive it as section 1231 gain that is all unrecaptured section 1250 gain, $30,000 each.

Where the marks sit in the ACC 683 Topic 8 rubric

Faculty grading the reconciliation reward documents tested against the plan. Excellent reconciliations confirm the same taxpayer on both deeds and the identification and closing deadlines. Credit goes to treating the roof deposit as boot although it was spent on property. The rubric values identifying the recognized amount as depreciation-related gain taxed at the 25 percent maximum rate. The highest level corrects Form 8824, adjusts each partner's estimates and writes the instruction that would have prevented the release. Reconciliations that keep the plan's zero gain, or treat closing costs as boot, usually lose marks.

ACC 683 Topic 8 help before you submit

Reconciliations that trust the plan and file zero gain lose the most, because the return then repeats the planning memo's error under the partnership's signature. Papers that find the $60,000 and treat the whole exchange as failed overreact, since section 1031(b) recognizes gain only to the extent of boot. Calling the commission boot along with the deposit overstates the gain. A replacement basis set at the $1,440,000 purchase price ignores section 1031(d) and would overstate depreciation for years. Credit also goes when the gain stops at the partnership and never reaches the K-1s or the partners' outside basis. The subtler omission is leaving the plan uncorrected, so the cousins keep a document saying one thing while their return says another, the very mismatch a capstone reconciliation exists to remove.

Get an ACC-683 Topic 8 example written to your instructions

Send the ACC-683 Topic 8 instructions, your rubric and the plan, closing documents or return drafts in your case. We write a custom example to them, with each planning claim tested against the filing, differences traced, both documents corrected and the effect carried to every owner, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free; coursework support, not tax advice.

More ACC 683 papers and MS in Accounting samples

ACC 683 Topic 8 questions, answered

Why does $60,000 of cash not ruin the whole exchange?

Section 1031(b) provides that when an exchange would qualify except that money or other property is also received, gain is recognized, but not beyond the amount of that money and the value of the other property. The exchange remains an exchange, and the rest of the gain stays deferred. The reconciliation therefore reports $60,000 and keeps the $740,000 deferral the plan was built to protect.

Could the roof deposit have come from exchange funds without boot?

Not as it was handled. Money spent on costs of the exchange itself, such as commissions and title charges, generally reduces the amount realized. A deposit on future repairs is not a transaction cost, and releasing it to the LLC put cash in the exchanger's hands. The alternatives were paying it from the LLC's own funds or acquiring replacement property that used the full proceeds.

Does a like-kind exchange still work for equipment?

Not since the 2017 tax act, which limited section 1031 to real property not held primarily for sale, so equipment, vehicles and other personal property no longer qualify. The warehouse is real property held for rental and investment, which is why the exchange works here. The reconciliation is coursework built on composite documents, never tax advice.

Where can I find a free ACC 683 Topic 8 sample paper?

The reconciliation is on this page in full: the claim and documents, title and timing, closing costs and the deposit, other treatments considered, the gain, character, Form 8824, the partners and the revised plan. Share your exchange documents for a free worked reconciliation.

Why is $60,000 recognized in ACC 683 Topic 8?

The intermediary released $60,000 of exchange funds to the LLC, and money received in an exchange is taxed as gain up to the gain realized.