| Course | ACC 685 BAR Discipline Capstone |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 2 |
| Paper type | Retirement obligation sensitivity schedule |
| Length | About 960 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Accounting |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 685 Topic 2
A $1.30 Million Retirement Obligation for a Solar Array, Built One Assumption at a Time, and What One Point on the Discount Rate Does to It
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
ACC-685: BAR Discipline Capstone
Topic 2 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
A $1.30 Million Retirement Obligation for a Solar Array, Built One Assumption at a Time, and What One Point on the Discount Rate Does to It
The Obligation
Brightfield Solar LLC, a composite power producer, built a 40-megawatt solar array on land leased for 25 years. The ground lease requires Brightfield, at the end of the lease, to remove the panels, racking and inverters and to restore the land to a condition suitable for farming, to the landowner's reasonable satisfaction. That is a legal obligation arising from a contract, created when the array was built, so a liability for it is recognized at fair value when incurred, with the same amount added to the carrying amount of the array (Financial Accounting Standards Board, 2001). Because no market exists for transferring such obligations, fair value is estimated by an expected present value technique, taking one assumption at a time.
Restoration Scenarios
What restoration will require at the end of the lease is uncertain, because the landowner's satisfaction clause could be read narrowly or broadly. Three outcomes were costed in current prices.
Table 1
Restoration Scenarios
| Scenario | Cost today | Weight | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Panel removal only | $2.40 million | 50% | Contractor estimate |
| Removal with regrading | $3.40 million | 30% | Contractor estimate |
| Full soil restoration | $5.00 million | 20% | Engineering quote |
| Expected cost today | $3.22 million |
Reading the Scenarios
Removal only is weighted at 50 percent because the lease's restoration standard has been interpreted narrowly in two neighboring decommissionings. Regrading, at 30 percent, reflects the landowner's stated interest in returning the land to crops. Full soil restoration, at 20 percent, covers the possibility that soil testing at lease end shows compaction or contamination requiring remediation. The weighted expected cost today is about $3.22 million.
Why an Expected Value
The most likely outcome, removal only at $2.4 million, would give a smaller liability, and some preparers use it. The expected present value technique instead weights every plausible outcome by its probability, because a single most likely figure ignores the cost of the less likely but more expensive outcomes that a buyer of the obligation would price in (Financial Accounting Standards Board, 2000). When the range of outcomes is wide and skewed toward higher costs, as it is here, the difference is material: the most likely outcome alone would understate the liability by about a quarter. The weights are judgments, so they are documented with their basis, and the sensitivity table shows what changing them does.
Inflation
The costs are stated in today's prices, but they will be incurred in 25 years. They are inflated at 2.5 percent a year, consistent with long-run forecasts of construction cost inflation published by an industry cost index and with the Federal Reserve's longer-run inflation objective plus a small allowance for labor costs. The expected cost at lease end becomes about $5.97 million.
Market Risk Premium
A contractor taking on this obligation today would not accept the expected cost alone; it would demand compensation for bearing the risk that the outcome is worse than expected. Fair value therefore includes a market risk premium, the amount a market participant would require (Financial Accounting Standards Board, 2006). Informed by contractors' quoted margins for fixed-price decommissioning contracts, the premium is set at 5 percent of the inflated cost, bringing the undiscounted amount to about $6.27 million.
Discounting
The cash flows are discounted at a credit-adjusted risk-free rate: a 25-year Treasury yield of 4.3 percent plus Brightfield's credit spread of 2.2 percentage points, from the pricing of its most recent term loan, for 6.5 percent. Discounting $6.27 million over 25 years at 6.5 percent gives a liability of about $1.30 million.
Entries
At recognition: debit the solar array for the asset retirement cost of $1.30 million and credit the asset retirement obligation. In the first year: debit accretion expense and credit the obligation for about $84,395, 6.5 percent of the opening balance, and debit depreciation expense and credit accumulated depreciation for about $51,935, one twenty-fifth of the asset retirement cost. Accretion grows each year as the liability grows, reaching the full $6.27 million at lease end.
Sensitivity
Each input was varied alone, with the others held at their measured values.
Table 2
Sensitivity of the Liability
| Change to one input | Liability |
|---|---|
| As measured | $1.30 million |
| Discount rate 5.5 percent | $1.64 million |
| Discount rate 7.5 percent | $1.03 million |
| Inflation 2.0 percent | $1.15 million |
| Inflation 3.0 percent | $1.47 million |
| Full restoration weighted 40 percent, removal only 30 | $1.51 million |
| No market risk premium | $1.24 million |
Reading the Sensitivity
The discount rate matters most: one point either way moves the liability between about $1.03 million and $1.64 million. Inflation matters nearly as much, because it compounds over the same 25 years. The scenario weights and the risk premium matter less. Later changes are handled layer by layer: an upward revision in the estimated cash flows is measured at the credit-adjusted rate current when the revision is made, while a downward revision is measured at the rate used for the layer it reduces. The rate used at recognition therefore stays attached to this original layer for the life of the obligation.
Disclosure
The notes will describe the obligation and the asset it relates to, explain how fair value was measured, and present a reconciliation of the obligation from the beginning to the end of each year, showing liabilities incurred, accretion, revisions in estimated cash flows and any amounts settled. In the first year the reconciliation will show the $1.30 million incurred and about $84,400 of accretion. Because the measurement rests on unobservable inputs, the notes should also name the most significant of them, the discount rate and the inflation assumption, so a reader can judge how much the reported figure depends on them. The estimate will be reviewed each year against updated contractor quotes and the landowner's position on restoration.
References
Financial Accounting Standards Board. (2000). Using cash flow information and present value in accounting measurements (Statement of Financial Accounting Concepts No. 7). FASB.
Financial Accounting Standards Board. (2001). Accounting for asset retirement obligations (Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 143). FASB.
Financial Accounting Standards Board. (2006). Fair value measurements (Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 157). FASB.
ACC 685 Topic 2 instructions, in plain terms
The Topic 2 instructions in ACC-685 ask students to measure an asset retirement obligation. Weak submissions discount a single cost estimate at the company's borrowing rate. The assignment rewards schedules that identify the legal obligation, weight restoration scenarios with their cost basis, inflate them, add a market risk premium and discount at a credit-adjusted risk-free rate built from its parts. Students should record the liability, asset retirement cost, accretion and depreciation, vary each input alone, and explain how later revisions are measured and what the notes must disclose each year.
How this ACC 685 Topic 2 example is built
The finished schedule builds the obligation in four steps, every figure illustrative. Three restoration scenarios in current prices come first: panel removal only at $2.4 million, removal with regrading at $3.4 million and full soil restoration at $5.0 million, weighted 50, 30 and 20 percent for an expected $3.22 million. Inflation of 2.5 percent a year over 25 years and a 5 percent market risk premium lift that to $6.27 million at lease end. Discounting at the company's 6.5 percent credit-adjusted risk-free rate gives $1.30 million, recognized as a liability and added to the solar array's carrying amount. First-year accretion is $84,400. A sensitivity table closes the schedule: one point either way on the discount rate moves the liability between $1.03 million and $1.64 million.
ACC 685 Topic 2 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Faculty grading the obligation schedule reward one assumption per block, each with its source and support. Excellent schedules weight scenarios rather than using the most likely outcome. Credit goes to a market risk premium explained from a contractor's view. The rubric values a credit-adjusted rate built from a Treasury yield and the company's spread. The highest level varies each input alone and explains layered revisions. Schedules that discount today's cost without inflation, or use a risk-free rate with no credit adjustment, tend to earn partial credit. The entries for recognition, accretion and depreciation are expected in full.
ACC 685 Topic 2 help before you submit
Schedules that report $1.30 million and stop lose the most, because the figure is only as good as three assumptions nobody has been shown. Measuring from the most likely scenario alone understates the obligation by about a third of a million dollars on these facts, and many sections score that as a mismeasurement, not a shortcut. Discounting at the rate on one of the producer's loans, or at a risk-free rate with no credit adjustment, uses a rate the guidance does not. Papers that forget to add the asset retirement cost to the array record an expense where the standard records an asset. Leaving accretion out of first-year income misstates operating results. Sensitivity shown for the discount rate alone hides that the scenario weights move the answer by a similar amount.
Get an ACC-685 Topic 2 example written to your instructions
Send your ACC-685 Topic 2 instructions, the rubric and the estimate or obligation facts your section supplied. We write a custom example to them, with the obligation's source identified, scenarios weighted, each assumption supported, the measurement computed, the entries recorded and sensitivity shown input by input, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More ACC 685 papers and MS in Accounting samples
- ACC 685 Topic 1: Hosting Arrangement Characterization Memo
- ACC 685 Topic 3: Principal Agent Presentation Analysis
- ACC 685 Topic 4: Going Concern Note Draft
- ACC 685 Topic 5: Lease-adjusted Debt Multiple Dq Post
- ACC 685 Topic 6: Supplier Comparability Review
- ACC 685 Topic 7: Failed Sale-leaseback Position Memo
- ACC 685 Topic 8: Earnout Integration Report
- ACC 653 Topic 2: Target Cost Gap Analysis
- ACC 683 Topic 2: Revocation Break-even Analysis
- ACC 656 Topic 2: Acquisition Date Fair Value Schedule
- ACC 682 Topic 2: Backlog Extraction Workpaper
ACC 685 Topic 2 questions, answered
Why is the obligation measured with expected cash flows?
Because fair value reflects the range of outcomes a market participant would consider, not just the single likeliest one. When no market exists for settling the obligation, ASC 410-20 generally relies on an expected present value technique, weighting possible cash flows by probability. Where outcomes are skewed toward a costly tail, as full restoration is here, the expected amount sits above the most likely one.
What happens when the estimate changes later?
Revisions change the liability and the asset retirement cost together. An upward revision is treated as a new layer, measured at the credit-adjusted risk-free rate current when it arises, while a downward revision is applied at the rates of the existing layers. The schedule records the original layer's rate so that a later engineering estimate can be processed correctly and a reviewer can follow it.
Is accretion interest expense?
No. Accretion increases the liability each period toward its settlement amount, and the guidance classifies it as an operating item in the income statement rather than as interest cost. Depreciation of the capitalized asset retirement cost runs separately over the asset's useful life. The schedule shows both lines because readers see them in different places and should know they come from one estimate.
Where can I find a free ACC 685 Topic 2 sample paper?
Everything is above: the obligation, restoration scenarios, reading them, why an expected value, inflation, the risk premium, discounting, entries, sensitivity and disclosure. Send your obligation's facts for a free worked schedule.
What moves the liability most in ACC 685 Topic 2?
The discount rate; one point either way moves it between about $1.03 million and $1.64 million, with inflation close behind.